ex United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization Executive Board Hundred and fifty-fifth Session 155 EX/47 PARIS, 2 August 1998 Original: French Item 9.2 of the provisional agenda REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL ON THE FOLLOW-UP TO THE ADOPTION OF THE STATUTES OF THE INTERNATIONAL BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: ELECTION OF MEMBER STATES CANDIDATES FOR THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL COMMITTEE SUMMARY In accordance with 154 EX/Decision 8.4, paragraphs 4(b) and 5, adopted by the Executive Board at its 154th session, the Director- General submits to the Executive Board the list of Member States which have put themselves forward as candidates for the Intergovernmental Committee established by Article 11 of the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee (IBC). On the basis of the candidatures submitted, it is for the Executive Board to elect the 36 members of the Intergovernmental Committee. Decision required: paragraph 9.
155 EX/47 I. INTRODUCTION 1. The Executive Board, by 154 EX/Decision 8.4, paragraph 3, adopted on 7 May 1998, approved the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee of UNESCO (IBC). Under Article 11 of these Statutes: An Intergovernmental Committee, hereafter referred to as the Intergovernmental Committee, is hereby established within the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). 2. This Intergovernmental Committee is to be composed of 36 representatives of the Member States of UNESCO elected by the General Conference. However, the interim provision in paragraph 4 stipulates that The Executive Board, at its 155th session, as an interim measure, shall elect the first members of the Intergovernmental Committee to hold office until the next succeeding General Conference. When electing these members, the Executive Board shall take into account cultural diversity, balanced geographical representation and the need to ensure appropriate rotation. 3. In compliance with this provision, the Member States of UNESCO were invited, if they so wished, to submit their candidature for the Intergovernmental Committee before 26 June 1998. By 10 July 1998, the following 24 Member States had informed the Secretariat that they intended to put themselves forward as candidates for the Intergovernmental Committee: Australia, Azerbaijan, Bangladesh, Belgium, Canada, Chile, Côte d Ivoire, Egypt, Finland, Germany, Indonesia, Israel, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, Peru, Poland, Republic of Korea, Russian Federation, South Africa, Spain, Tunisia, United Kingdom and Venezuela. In addition, some states informed the Secretariat that the matter was under study in their respective countries. II. PROCEDURES FOR THE ELECTION OF THE MEMBERS OF THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL COMMITTEE 4. The Director-General reminds the Executive Board of the terms of the IBC Statutes which lay down the principle of balanced geographical representation within the Intergovernmental Committee. In this respect, the expression balanced geographical representation may be understood in two ways: (a) (b) either to distribute the 36 seats equally among the electoral groups I, II, III, IV, V(a) and V(b); or to distribute the 36 seats among the electoral groups according to the number of states making up these groups. 5. In this context, the Director-General reminds the Executive Board that the General Conference, at its 28th session, decided on a method for the distribution of seats among the electoral groups within the Organization s intergovernmental committees and councils (28 C/Resolution 22). Accordingly, since the Intergovernmental Committee, like the Intergovernmental Council of the General Information Programme (PGI) and the Intergovernmental Council of the International Hydrological Programme (IHP), is composed of 36 members, the Executive Board may wish to refer to the distribution of seats within those bodies for the purpose of determining the distribution of seats within the Intergovernmental Committee.
155 EX/47 - page 2 6. In the light of the two options set out above, the distribution of seats might be as follows: Option 1: Elections based on six seats per Group Group I Western Europe (26) Group II Eastern Europe (24) Group III Latin America and the Caribbean (33) 6 Group IV Asia and the Pacific (39) 6 Group V(a) Africa (47) 6 Group V(b) Arab States (17) 6 6 6 Option 2: Election in accordance with 28 C/Resolution 22 (same distribution as for PGI and IHP) Group I Western Europe (26) Group II Eastern Europe (24) Group III Latin America and the Caribbean (33) 7 Group IV Asia and the Pacific (39) 4 Group V Africa and the Arab States (64) 6 7 12 7. The ballot papers will be prepared on the basis of the list of candidates drawn up by the Secretariat, having regard to the Executive Board s decision concerning the distribution of seats among the electoral groups. 8. The election will be held in plenary meeting and will take place in accordance with the Rules of Procedure of the Executive Board. III. DECISION 9. In view of the foregoing, the Executive Board may wish to adopt the following decision: The Executive Board, 1. Considering the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee of UNESCO (IBC), 2. Having examined the list of Member States which have put themselves forward as candidates for the Intergovernmental Committee established by Article 11 of these Statutes,
155 EX/47 - page 3 3. Decides that, for the purposes of the election to this Intergovernmental Committee, the distribution of seats among the electoral groups will be as follows: 4. Decides that the following states are elected members of the Intergovernmental Committee until the 30th session of the General Conference:
ex United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization Executive Board Hundred and fifty-fifth Session 155 EX/47 Add. PARIS, 16 September 1998 Original: French Item 9.2 of the provisional agenda REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL ON THE FOLLOW-UP TO THE ADOPTION OF THE STATUTES OF THE INTERNATIONAL BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: ELECTION OF MEMBER STATES CANDIDATES FOR THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL COMMITTEE SUMMARY In document 155 EX/47 the Director-General has submitted to the Executive Board the list, as at 10 July 1998, of Member States which have put themselves forward as candidates for the Intergovernmental Committee established by Article 11 of the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee (IBC). This addendum informs the Executive Board of all the candidatures of Member States received by 4 September 1998.
155 EX/47 Add. 1. Recapitulation of candidatures received Group I Belgium Canada Finland France Germany Greece Israel Italy Netherlands Norway Spain Switzerland Turkey United Kingdom Group II Azerbaijan Belarus Hungary Lithuania Poland Russian Federation Group IV Australia Bangladesh China India Indonesia Japan Republic of Korea Group V Benin Côte d Ivoire Egypt Lebanon Morocco South Africa Syrian Arab Republic Tunisia Group III Chile Cuba Dominican Republic Ecuador Jamaica Peru Venezuela 2. On 29 July 1998, pursuant to Article 3 of the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee (IBC), the Director-General appointed the 36 members of the Committee, the composition of which is given in the Annex. 3. In accordance with the interim provision set out in Article 6 of the Statutes of IBC, 18 members of IBC, whose term of office will expire at the 30th session of the General Conference, have been designated by lots drawn on 24 July 1998 in the presence of the representatives of the Chairpersons of Electoral Groups I and III. The term of office of each of the members of IBC is specified in the Annex.
ANNEX COMPOSITION OF THE INTERNATIONAL BIOETHICS COMMITTEE OF UNESCO (IBC) 155 EX/47 Add. Annex Name Country Term of office 1. ANDORNO Dr (Mr) Roberto Luis Argentina 1998-2001 Professor of Civil Law 2. BEDJAOUI (Mr) Mohammed Algeria 1998-2001 Judge at the International Court of Justice (The Hague) 3. BOMPIANI Professor (Mr) Adriano Italy 1998-1999 Professor of Gynaecology 4. CANÇADO TRINIDADE Professor (Mr) Antonio A. Brazil 1998-2001 Professor of International Law 5. CRUZ-COKE Professor (Mr) Ricardo Chile 1998-1999 Professor of Medicine 6. ESTEVEZ Professor (Mr) Edmundo Ecuador 1998-1999 Director of the Biomedicine Centre of the Central University of Ecuador 7. FADEN Professor (Ms) Ruth United States 1998-1999 Director of the Institute of Bioethics of Johns Hopkins University 8. FATES Professor (Mr) Ismail Libyan Arab 1998-1999 Professor of Cell Biology Jamahiriya 9. GALJAARD Professor (Mr) Hans Netherlands 1998-2001 Chairman of Clinical Genetics 10. GROS ESPIELL Professor (Mr) Héctor Uruguay 1998-2001 Professor of International Law 11. HAMDAN Dr (Mr) Mohammad Jordan 1998-2001 Minister of Education and Higher Education 12. IDA Professor (Mr) Ryuichi Japan 1998-1999 Professor of International Law 13. JEAN (Ms) Michèle Canada 1998-2001 Special Adviser for Health Matters to the Minister of Foreign Affairs 14. KILAMA Professor (Mr) W. United Republic of 1998-1999 Co-ordinator of the African Malaria Tanzania Vaccine Testing Network 15. KIRBY Justice (Mr) Michael Australia 1998-2001 Justice of the High Court of Australia
155 EX/47 Add. Annex - page 2 Name Country Term of office 16. MCINTYRE Professor (Ms) Sally United Kingdom 1998-2001 Director of the Medical Research Council 17. NOMBELA CANO Professor (Mr) D. Cesar Spain 1998-1999 President Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas 18. ÖZTÜRK Professor (Mr) Mehmet Turkey 1998-2001 Professor of Molecular Biology and Genetics 19. PAK Professor (Ms) Un-jung Republic of Korea 1998-1999 Professor of Law 20. PALOTIE Professor (Ms) Leena Finland 1998-1999 Professor of Molecular Biology 21. PETROV Academician (Mr) Rem V. Russian Federation 1998-2001 Vice-President of the Academy of Sciences 22. POGNON (Ms) Elisabeth Benin 1998-2001 Magistrate, Former President of the Constitutional Court of Benin 23. QUESTIAUX (Ms) Nicole France 1998-1999 Member of the Comité consultatif national d éthique des sciences de la vie et de la santé 24. REICH Professor (Mr) Jens Germany 1998-2001 Professor of Genetics 25. REVEL Professor (Mr) Michel Israel 1998-2001 Professor of Molecular Genetics 26. ROBINSON (Mr) Patrick Jamaica 1998-2001 Deputy Solicitor-General 27. ROUCOUNAS Professor (Mr) Emmanuel Greece 1998-1999 Professor of International Law 28. ROUSHDY EL-KADY Professor (Mr) Hamed Egypt 1998-1999 Secretary of the Egyptian National Committee for Bioethics 29. RUMBALL Professor (Ms) Sylvia New Zealand 1998-1999 Science Education and Policy Unit 30. SACHS Justice (Mr) Albie South Africa 1998-1999 Judge of the Constitutional Court of South Africa 31. SWAMINATHAN Dr (Mr) Monkombu Sambasivan India 1998-1999 President of the Swaminathan Research Foundation
155 EX/47 Add Annex - page 3 Name Country Term of office 32. TADJUDIN Professor (Mr) Muhammad Kamil Indonesia 1998-2001 Professor of Biology 33. TANO BOUAH Professor (Ms) Yolande Evelyne Côte d Ivoire 1998-2001 Professor of Law 34. TIKK Professor (Mr) Arvo Estonia 1998-1999 Chairman of the Estonian Council of Bioethics 35. YANG Professor (Mr) Huanming China 1998-2001 Chinese Academy of Science 36. ZAREMBA Professor (Mr) Jacek Poland 1998-1999 Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology
ex United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization Executive Board Hundred and fifty-fifth Session 155 EX/47 Add. 2 PARIS, 13 October 1998 Original: French Item 9.2 of the provisional agenda REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL ON THE FOLLOW-UP TO THE ADOPTION OF THE STATUTES OF THE INTERNATIONAL BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: ELECTION OF MEMBER STATES CANDIDATES FOR THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL COMMITTEE SUMMARY In documents 155 EX/47 and 155 EX/47 Add. the Director-General has submitted to the Executive Board the list, as at 4 September 1998, of Member States which have put themselves forward as candidates for the Intergovernmental Committee established by Article 11 of the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee (IBC). This addendum informs the Executive Board of further candidatures that have been received since then. Since the distribution of document 155 EX/47 Add., the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (Group V) and Mexico (Group III) have put themselves forward as candidates for election to the Intergovernmental Committee established by Article 11 of the Statutes of the International Bioethics Committee (IBC). As at 25 September 1998, 44 candidatures had therefore been received.