Council Chambers, City Hall June 7, th Street North Wednesday St. Petersburg, Florida 33701

Transcription

1 CITY OF ST. PETERSBURG DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEVELOPMENT REVIEW SERVICES DIVISION ENVIRONMENTAL DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION ACTION TAKEN AGENDA/MINUTES Council Chambers, City Hall June 7, th Street North Wednesday 2:00 P.M. First Alternate: Calvin Samuel Se cond Alternate: John McQueen Third Alternate: Thomas Whiteman Commission Members: Charles S. Canerday, Chair - P David Punzak, Vice-Chair - A Valarie Nussbaum - P Diane M. Friel - P Lynn Cravey - P Wendy Giffin A William E. Klein - P Alternates: 1. Thomas Whiteman Jr. - P 2. Calvin B. Samuel - A 3. John McQueen - P A = Absent P = Present City Staff Present: John Hixenbaugh, Zoning Official Al Galbraith, Assistant City Attorney Philip Lazzara, Deputy Zoning Official Rob Gerdes, Planner II Candee Smith, Planning Technician Mona Graham, Planning Technician Lynn Moore, Administrative Assistant I. OPENING REMARKS OF CHAIR AND SWEARING IN OF WITNESSES II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF May 3, 2006 Minutes approved as written by unanimous vote of the Commission IV. EXECUTIVE ACTION AGENDA ITEM #1 CASE NO G-2 N/A Approval of a one-year extension from November 4, 2006 to November 4, 2007 to satisfy the conditions for approval of a vacation of 15 th Street South between Central Avenue and 1 st Avenue South.

2 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 2 of 16 Pilgram Hall LLC 9741 International Court North St. Petersburg, Florida Grady Pridgen 9741 International Court North St. Petersburg, Florida Central Avenue 24/31/16/14544/000/0420; 24/31/16/14544/000/0470; 24/31/16/77220/000/0010; 24/31/16/77220/000/0140 On File CBD-4 PRESENTATIONS: John Hixenbaugh made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Jim King, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to approve the one-year extension for Ordinance 926-V from November 4, 2006 to November 4, Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Whiteman, Canerday ACTION TAKEN ON (G-2) 1) Motion to approve the one-year extension for Ordinance 926-V from November 4, 2006 to November 4, 2006, approved by a vote of 7-0. AGENDA ITEM #2 CASE NO H-68 Carillon Property Owners 1 Approval of a one-year extension from June 6, 2006 to June 6, 2007 for the construction of a 5-story, 100,000 SF MOL office building at the Catalina Marketing corporate headquarters in Carillon Business Park. Catalina Marketing International 200 Carillon Parkway St. Petersburg, Florida Stephen C. Chumbris Trenam Kemker 200 Central Avenue, Suite Carillon Parkway 12/30/16/13463/005/0010; 12/30/16/13463/005/0020 Lots 1 And 2, Block 5, Carillon Phase II IB-P

3 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 3 of 16 PRESENTATIONS: John Hixenbaugh made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Steve Chumbris, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to approve the one-year extension from June 6, 2006 to June 6, 2007, subject to the condition to the Staff report. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Whiteman, Canerday ACTION TAKEN ON (H-68) 1) Motion to approve the one-year extension from June 6, 2006 to June 6, 2007, subject to the condition of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 7-0. AGENDA ITEM #3 CASE NO E-1 Downtown REQUEST Approval of a one-year extension from March 31, 2006 to March 31, 2007 for the University Village Shopping Center (Publix) mixed-use development. Mark Stroud Osprey Real Estate Services 360 Central Avenue, Suite 1570 Northeast corner of 4 th Street South and 4 th Avenue South 19/31/17/93450/000/0010; 19/31/17/93450/000/0020; 19/31/17/93450/000/0030; 19/31/17/93450/000/0040 On File CBD-1, CBD-2 PRESENTATIONS: John Hixenbaugh made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Mark Stroud, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to approve the one-year extension from March 31, 2006 to March 31, 2007, subject to the condition of the Staff report. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Whiteman, Canerday ACTION TAKEN ON (E-1) 1) Motion to approve the one-year extension from March 31, 2006 to March 31, 2007, subject to the condition of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 7-0.

4 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 4 of 16 V. PUBLIC HEARING CASE AGENDA AGENDA ITEM #4 CASE NO L-5 Childs Park, Central Oak Park Withdrawn by the Applicant Approval of a vacation of 7 th Avenue South (abutting the Pinellas Trail) between 43 rd and 46 th Streets South. APPLICANT LEGAL DESCRIPTION Malluch Properties, LLC 3431 Edmonson Court Sarasota, Florida Peter Sprague/Ron Molter th Avenue South St. Petersburg, Florida th Avenue South 27/31/16/29754/003/0010; 27/31/16/29754/003/0011; 27/31/16/29754/003/0012; 27/31/16/30537/001/0010 On File IG AGENDA ITEM #5 CASE NO F-7 Bartlett Park Approval of a vacation of a 16 foot wide alley running northsouth from 13 th Avenue South to 12 th Avenue South, west of 5 th Street South. Chris H. Caloto th Avenue South Christopher Kelly th Avenue South St. Petersburg, Florida Alley east of th Avenue South/ th Avenue South 30/31/17/23958/000/0490; 30/31/17/35460/000/0060; 30/31/17/77400/000/0471; 30/31/17/77400/000/0480; 30/31/17/77400/000/0481 On File RM-10

5 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 5 of 16 PRESENTATIONS: John Hixenbaugh made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Chris Kelly, representing the applicant, spoke about the reasons to vacate the existing alley. Tod Reinert, th Avenue South, spoke in opposition to the project and turned in a petition of people against this vacation. Tom Tito, th Avenue South, spoke in support of the Chris Kelly spoke in rebuttal. Tod Reinert spoke in rebuttal. MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to approve the alley vacation, subject to the conditions of the Staff report. Yes Cravey, Klein, Whiteman, Punzak, Canerday No Friel, Nussbaum ACTION TAKEN ON (F-7) 1) Motion to approve the alley vacation, subject to the conditions of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 5-2. AGENDA ITEM #6 CASE NO E-2, E-4 Downtown Deferred by the Applicant Approval of a partial vacation of Bayshore Drive, north of 2 nd Avenue Northeast, to accommodate parking for the Museum of Fine Arts. The applicant is dedicating additional land for Beach Drive in exchange for the portion of Bayshore Drive to be vacated. John Schloder Museum of Fine Arts Inc. 255 Beach Drive Northeast Mariela Gomez WilsonMiller, Inc Channelside Drive, Suite 400n Tampa, Florida Beach Drive Northeast 19/31/17/74466/000/0020 On File CBD-3

6 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 6 of 16 AGENDA ITEM #7 CASE NO E-2, E-4 Downtown Deferred by the Applicant ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Approval of a site plan modification for a phased 58,856 SF MOL expansion of the Museum of Fine Arts with variances for 1) setbacks, 2) structure width, 3) landscaping and 4) signage. John Schloder Museum of Fine Arts, Inc. 255 Beach Drive Northeast Mariela Gomez WilsonMiller, Inc Channelside Drive, Suite 400n Tampa, Florida Mariela Gomez WilsonMiller, Inc Channelside Drive, Suite 400n Tampa, Florida Beach Drive Northeast 19/31/17/74466/000/0020 On File CBD-3 AGENDA ITEM #8 CASE NO E-12 Historic Old Northeast, Crescent Heights, Crescent Lake, 4 th Street Business Approval of a Special Exception and related site plan to reconstruct an existing gas station with a 4,230 SF MOL convenience store and café, gas pumps, and a car wash. Special Exceptions are required for parking in a residential zone and the car wash. The applicant is requesting variances for 1) setbacks, 2) dumpster location, and 3) wall height. Panther Petroleum, Inc. f/k/a Hallmark Stations, Inc Executive Drive Clearwater, Florida R. Donald Mastry Trenam Kemker 200 Central Avenue, Suite 1600

7 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 7 of 16 ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Tim Bauer Progressive Development Group 5205 South Lois Avenue Tampa, Florida th Street North 18/31/17/60390/000/0010; 18/31/17/60390/000/0050; 18/31/17/60390/000/0440; 18/31/17/60390/000/0450 On File CG, RM 12/15 PRESENTATIONS: John Hixenbaugh made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Don Mastry, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. Nicole Durkin, the registered opponent, spoke of concerns with noise, car wash, 24 hours, traffic, etc. Peter Hooper, nd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Theresa Deeb, 1801 Park Street North, spoke in opposition to the Catherine Martin, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Brian Johnson, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Douglas Haan, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Julia Brazier, th Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Lorene Kipp, rd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Scott Miller, nd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Steve Shrago, nd Street North, spoke in opposition to the Connie Russell, nd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Celine Kapiolani, nd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Ken Durkin, st Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Michael Harris, nd Avenue North, spoke in support of the Anne-Marie Stephenson, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in support of the Robert Hart, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Terri Fritzel, st Avenue North, spoke n opposition to the Robin Reed, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Brett Alexander, st Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Kelly Marlin, st Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Christine Wheeler, nd Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the Jerry Marrone, st Avenue North, spoke in opposition to the William Tapp, th Avenue Northeast, spoke in support of the

8 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 8 of 16 David Hood, 1968 Iowa Avenue Northeast, spoke in support of the Peter Laskowski, 3200 Bayou Placido Boulevard Northeast, supports the project but did not want to speak. Linda Dobbs, 2296 Coffee Pot Boulevard Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Robert Dobbs, 2296 Coffee Pot Boulevard Northeast, spoke in opposition to the Don Mastry, the representative for the applicant and Nicole Durkin, the opponent cross-examined Tom Whalen, Transportation Planner, on traffic issues and Staff on outdoor eating area. John Hixenbaugh spoke in rebuttal and added conditions for approval. Don Mastry spoke in rebuttal. Nicole Durkin spoke in rebuttal. 1 st MOTION: Commissioner McQueen moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to allow the opposition to speak for 10 minutes after the applicant. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday Voting Conflict - Whiteman 2 nd MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the variance for setbacks, as amended. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday Voting Conflict - Whiteman 3 rd MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the variance for dumpster enclosure. Yes Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday No Friel Voting Conflict - Whiteman 4 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the variance for wall height. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday Voting Conflict - Whiteman 5 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the Special Exception for a car wash. Yes Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday No Friel Voting Conflict - Whiteman

9 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 9 of 16 6 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the Special Exception for parking in a residential zone. Yes Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Canerday No Friel Voting Conflict - Whiteman 7 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to delete Special Conditions 6 and 14 and add Special Conditions 19, 20, and 21. Added Special Conditions: 19 states, The car wash operation shall be limited to the hours of 10:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m. 20 states, The driveway along 4 th Street North shall be constructed with a channelized island to permit right-in/right-out only vehicular movement. 21 states, The applicant shall dedicate a sidewalk easement along 4 th Street North so that the sidewalk is within the easement, Yes Klein, Cravey, McQueen, Canerday No Friel, Nussbaum Voting Conflict - Whiteman 8 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Cravey seconded a motion to approve the site plan, subject to the amended conditions of the Staff report. Yes Klein, Cravey, McQueen, Canerday No Friel, Nussbaum Voting Conflict - Whiteman ACTION TAKEN ON (E-12) 1) Motion to approve the to allow the opposition to speak for 10 minutes after the applicant, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the variance for setbacks, as amended, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the variance for dumpster location, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the variance for wall height, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the Special Exception for a car wash, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the Special Exception for parking in a residential zone, approved by a vote of ) Motion to delete Special Conditions 6 and 14 and add Special Conditions 19, 20, and 21, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the site plan, subject to the amended conditions of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 4-2. AGENDA ITEM #9 CASE NO J-16 Ponce de Leon Approval of a Special Exception and related site plan to construct a crematory for an existing funeral home with variances for 1) parking and 2) landscaping.

10 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 10 of 16 ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Richard E. Sorenson Funeral Home & Richard E. Sorenson th Avenue North St. Petersburg, Florida R. Donald Mastry Trenam Kemker 200 Central Avenue, Suite 1600 Brian Triske Phil Graham & Company 436 2nd Street North th Avenue North/ th Avenue North 11/31/16/53012/000/0010 Lot 1, Lowell Manor Partial Replat GO PRESENTATIONS: Philip Lazzara made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Don Mastry, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. 1 st MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Nussbaum seconded a motion to approve the variance for parking. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, Canerday Voting Conflict McQueen, Whiteman 2 nd MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Nussbaum seconded a motion to approve the variance for landscaping. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, Canerday Voting Conflict McQueen, Whiteman 3 rd MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Nussbaum seconded a motion to approve the Special Exception. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, Canerday Voting Conflict McQueen, Whiteman 4 th MOTION: Commissioner Klein moved and Commissioner Nussbaum seconded a motion to approve the site plan, subject to the conditions of the Staff report.

11 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 11 of 16 Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, Canerday Voting Conflict McQueen, Whiteman ACTION TAKEN ON (J-16) 1) Motion to approve the variance for parking, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the variance for landscaping, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the Special Exception, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the site plan, subject to the conditions of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 5-0. AGENDA ITEM #10 CASE NO I-11 Highland Oaks ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Approval of a Special Exception and related site plan to construct a 3-story, 12,307 SF MOL bank and offices with a drive-thru facility. David Goodwin City of St. Petersburg P.O. Box 2842 St. Petersburg, Florida Tony Bower 200 South Orange Avenue Orlando, Florida Robert Reid Wedding Architects 4112 Cypress Street Tampa, Florida th Avenue South 25/31/16/56988/000/0010; 25/31/16/56988/000/0030; 25/31/16/56988/000/0031; 25/31/16/56988/000/0040; 25/31/16/56988/000/0080; 25/31/16/79722/000/0040; 26/31/16/28278/000/0010; 26/31/16/28278/000/0020; 26/31/16/28278/000/0260 On File ROR-1 PRESENTATIONS: Rob Gerdes made a presentation based on the Staff Report. Goliath Davis introduced the Tony Bower, representing the applicant, agreed with Staff recommendations. Mayor Baker spoke about the 1 st MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Klein seconded a motion to approve the Special Exception.

12 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 12 of 16 Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Whiteman, Canerday 2 nd MOTION: Commissioner Whiteman moved and Commissioner Nussbaum seconded a motion to approve the site plan, subject to the conditions of the Staff report. Yes Friel, Cravey, Klein, Nussbaum, McQueen, Whiteman, Canerday ACTION TAKEN ON (I-11) 1) Motion to approve the Special Exception, approved by a vote of ) Motion to approve the site plan, subject to the conditions of the Staff report, approved by a vote of 7-0.

13 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 13 of 16 VI. Notice is hereby given that the following application(s) has been filed with the City of St. Petersburg Development Review Services. It is the intent of the Development Review Services Department to approve the application(s) on May 25, 2006 at 12:00 noon since no appeal was filed. AGENDA ITEM #1 CASE NO F-25 Bayou Highlands Approval of a lot refacing to re-orient to two (2) lots that face 45 th Avenue South to face Myrtle Way South. The applicant also proposes to shift a lot line of an existing lot to make the lot wider. Lot width variances are required for all three (3) lots. Charles Cushing & Lynne Randall 716 Myrtle Way South St. Petersburg, Florida Charles Cushing & Lynne Randall 716 Myrtle Way South St. Petersburg, Florida Myrtle Way South 06/32/17/48078/037/0010 Lots 1, 14 & 15, Block 37, Lake Maggiore Park Revised RS-75 AGENDA ITEM #2 CASE NO F-7 Bartlett Park Approval of a lot line adjustment to split one (1) lot into two (2) lots with variances to 1) lot width and 2) lot area. The applicant intends to construct a new single-family home on land north of th Avenue South. Joe Daniele Titan Development Group, LLC Turnbury Oak Drive Odessa, Florida Nathan Lemons th Street North St. Petersburg, Florida th Avenue South 30/31/17/12708/000/0390 Lot 39, Buena Vista RM-10

14 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 14 of 16 AGENDA ITEM #3 CASE NO K-1 Central Oak Park Approval of a lot line adjustment to shift a lot line east of rd Avenue South with variances for 1) lot width, 2) lot area, and 3) setbacks. The applicant intends to construct a new singlefamily home. Laverne Conolly-Iverson Chimney Hill Court Tampa, Florida Nathan Lemons/Dan Mondello th Street North St. Petersburg, Florida rd Avenue South 22/31/16/96228/004/0110 Lots 11 And 12, Block 4, West Central Avenue Resubdivision RS-75 AGENDA ITEM #4 CASE NO B-30 Mangrove Bayou Approval of a lot line adjustment to shift the lot line between two (2) existing lots Joseph Murphy 5733 Bayou Grande Boulevard Northeast St. Petersburg, Florida Thomas R. Tipps rd Avenue Northeast St. Petersburg, Florida Bayou Grande Boulevard Northeast 33/30/17/81216/003/0090 Lots 9 & 10, Block 3, Bayou Grande RS-75

15 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 15 of 16 AGENDA ITEM #5 CASE NO F-8 Historic Uptown, Historic Old Northeast, 4 th Street Business ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: LEGAL DESCRIPTION ZONING Approval of a site plan to construct a 24-space parking lot with variances for 1) impervious surface ratio, 2) green yard, 3) gross floor area, and 4) parking. Lynn Vlaming 4940 Camellia Way South St. Petersburg, Florida Laura Bamond st Avenue North, Suite 128 St. Petersburg, Florida Earl Henry Astech Engineering nd Street North Pinellas Park, Florida th Avenue North & th Street North 18/31/17/37548/000/0210; 18/31/17/37548/000/0240; 18/31/17/37548/000/0241; 18/31/17/37548/000/0220 Lots 21, 22, 23, & 24, Harvey's Subdivision ROR-1

16 EDC Action Taken Agenda / Minutes for June 7, 2006 Page 16 of 16 VI. Notice is hereby given that the following application(s) has been filed with the City of St. Petersburg Development Review Services. It is the intent of the Development Review Services Department to approve the application(s) on June 2, 2006 at 12:00 noon since no appeal was filed. AGENDA ITEM #6 CASE NO F-50 Gateway NBRHD & Crime Watch ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Approval of a site plan to construct a 47-room hotel with variances for 1) green yard and 2) setbacks. Dhruvanjali Inc th Avenue North St. Petersburg, Florida Ben Aubin 1536 Commercial Park Drive Lakeland, Florida Joe Demidovich, P.E Commercial Park Drive Lakeland, Florida Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street North 19/30/17/90342/000/0010 Tract A, Texaco Bay Bridge Addition CP