MAHARASHTRA POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

Transcription

1 MAHARASHTRA POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Minutes of 2 nd sitting of 8 th Consent Appraisal Committee Meeting of 2012 held on at 3.30 P.M. at Conference Hall, MPC Board, Kalpataru Point, 4 th Floor, Sion Circle, Sion (E), Mumbai 22.. The Consent Appraisal Committee meeting of the Board held on Following members of the Consent Appraisal Committee were present: 1. Shri. J. S. Sahni, Chairman Chairman, MPC Board, Mumbai. 2. Shri. Rajeev Kumar Mital, Member Secretary Member Secretary, MPC Board, Mumbai 3. Shri.P.P.Nandusekar Member Technical Advisor( Env), MIDC, Mumbai 4. Shri. Rakesh Kumar, Special Invitee Scientist & Head, NEERI, Mumbai The Secretary, Home (Transport) Dept., Mantralaya, Mumbai, Member could not attend the meeting. Leave of absence was granted to him. Chairman of the committee welcomed the members of the committee and allowed proceeding of the meeting to start. The minutes of the 1 st sitting of 8 th Consent Appraisal Committee (CAC) meeting of 2012 held on circulated under Board s letter No. MPCB/AS (tech)/cac/b dated were confirmed. The meeting thereafter deliberated on the remaining and fresh agenda items placed before the committee and following decisions were taken. Agenda No. Name of Industry Resubmitted Agenda 1 M/s. Chandrapur Ferro Alloy Plant, S No. 498/2, 499, 500 & 503/3, Mul Road, Chandrapur Decision on grant of consent for expansion Consent granted upto Remarks/Discussion (1) --- The case was deferred and it was decided to put up the case in next CAC alongwith the letter dtd submitted by industry for review of forfeiture of BG. 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

2 2 M/s. Dighi Port Ltd., Stone Crusher and RMC Plant, G No. 71, A/p- Dighi, Tal-p Shrivardhan, Dist Raigad Refusal --- It was decided to refuse the renewal of consent to operate due to non-provision of APC system. 3 M/s. Avantha Power and Infrastructure Ltd., Unit- Bhigwan, 105, Pune Solapur Highway, Tal- Indpaur, Dist Pune 4 Manadhana Dyeing ( Unit-II), (Division of Mandhana Industries Ltd), C-3, MIDC Tarapur, Boisar, Dist- Thane. 1st Operate of consent to operate shall be issued with the following conditions: 1. Industry shall stop discharge of effluent from power plant into Bori Nallah by and submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards the compliance of the same. 2. Industry shall install opacity & CAAQMS by and submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards the compliance of the same. 3. Industry shall provide adequate land for disposal of effluent by and submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards the compliance of the same. 4. Industry shall submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs for O & M of pollution control system so as to achieve consented standards. --- Revert back. JD(WPC) to study the issue considering all aspect of the scheme about treatment & disposal of effluent at outlet of CETP. Emphasis also to be given on whether to permit LSI/MSI in MIDC area where CETP exists, including impact on CETP scheme. 1 M/s. Maharashtra State Power Generation Co. Ltd., Nashik Thermal Power Station, Ekhlare, Tal & Dist Nashik Fresh Agenda (Expansion) Industry was called for presentation before CAC as the site location is not confirming with the RRZ policy distance criteria. Representatives of company made presentation before the Committee. Representatives informed that they are replacing the 2x 140 MW 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

3 2 M/s. Bajaj Auto Ltd., Plot No. A-1, MIDC Chakan, Mahalunge, Tal- Khed, Dist Pune 1 st Operate with amalgamation project which was set in 70 s with their proposed coal based supercritical thermal project of 1x660 MW for which they have applied for EC to MoEF. They also assured that there will be no increase in pollution load as all pollution control systems are based on advanced technology. Committee cleared to the representatives that the EC under the provisions of EIA notification, 2006 and RRZ policy of 2009 are two separate issues. It was decided industry shall get the assessment done on no increase in pollution load especially w.r.t. Particulate matter, SO 2 & NOx & Zero discharge from NEERI and then based on the report from NEERI, if necessary, the case shall be referred to RRZ committee with presumption that no RRZ clearance is required as they are carrying out modernization and expansion with no increase in pollution load It was decided to grant 1 st consent operate for expansion & amalgamation of existing consents. 3 M/s. Tetra Pak India Pvt. Ltd., B-53, MIDC Chakan, Phase-2, Vill- Vasuli, Tal- Khed, Dist Pune 4 M/s. Kalyani Thermal System Ltd., E-84, MIDC Ranjangaon, Tal- Shirur, Dist Pune 5 M/s. Ideal Energy Project Ltd., Borgaon, Lambat Nr Bela, Khusapar, Kinala, Tal- Umred, Dist Nagpur 1st operate 1st operate (Expansion) and amalgamation not approved 1st Operate st Consent to operate shall be granted without CAAQMS condition as fuel used is CNG & with the condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 5 lakhs for O & M of pollution control system so as to achieve consented standards Consent to 1 st operate for expansion shall be issued with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 5 lakhs for O & M of pollution control system so as to achieve consented standards ---- It was decided to issue SCN for refusal towards non-compliance of consent conditions and EC condition (STP not provided) 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

4 6 M/s. Grace Industries Ltd., A- 23, MIDC Indl. Area, Tadali Growth Centre, Chandrapur Not approved 1 st Operate ---- It was decided to call report from concerned RO on compliance of C to E & EC conditions within seven days and put up in next CAC meeting. 7 Clarient Chemicals (I) Ltd, Plot No.113/114, MIDC Dhatav, Tq- Roha, Dist- Raigad. change in product Mix ---- It was decided to issue SCN for refusal. 8 Century Rayon, P.B. No. 22, Murbad Road, Shahad, Ulhasnagar, Dist- Thane 9 Majalgaon SSK Ltd. (Distillery Div) Sundarnagar, Talegaon, Tq- Majalgaon, Dist- Beed. consent consent to operate shall be issued with condition that applicant shall submit locational clearance by and BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards compliance of the same of consent to operate shall be issued with extension of BG upto consent period. 10 Solapur Municipal Corporation, Indrabhuvan, Punyashlok Appasaheb Ward Path, Solapur. 11 Vasai Virar Minicipal Coporation, S. No. 30 A-31 and 32, Vill- Gokhiware, Dist- Thane. of Authorisation of Authorisation It was decided to forfeit existing BG of Rs. 5 lakhs towards non compliance of authorization condition and renew the authorisation with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 10 Lakhs towards capping of existing landfill site and provision of SLF by It was decided to renew the authorization with the condition that applicant shall submit BG of RS. 5 lakhs towards provision of SLF by M/s. Skoda Auto India Pvt. Ltd., A-1/1, MIDC, Shendra, Aurangabad and 1st operate for expansion of consent to operate and 1 st operate for expansion after obtaining additional consent fees. 13 M/s. Mahindra Vehicle Mfg. Ltd., A-1, Chakan Indl. Area, Phase- IV, Tal- Khed, Dist Pune with Expansion It was decided to grant renewal with expansion with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 10/- Lakhs towards O & M of pollution control system so as to 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

5 achieve consented standards. 14 M/s. Ordinance Factory, Varangaon, Tal- Bhusawal, Dist Jalgaon consent to operate -- It was decided not to amend consent for discharge of treated effluent into river as per industry s request. 15 Croda Chemicals (I) Pvt. Ltd. Plot No. 1/1 (part), TTC MIDC, Kopar Khairane, Navi Mumbai 16 Goodyear South Asia Tyres Pvt. Ltd. H-18, MIDC Waluj, Aurangabad It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards O & M of pollution control system so as to achieve consented standards and encash BG of Rs. 2 lakhs It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate for CI- Rs /- Crs. 17 Samsonite South Asia Pvt. Ltd, Gut. No , At-Gonde Dumala, Tal- Igatpuri, Dist- Nashik 18 Polygenta Technologies Ltd, Gat No. 265,266, Vill- Avankhed, Tal- Dindori, Dist- Nashik of consent to operate shall be issued in RED category after obtaining additional consent fees or by restricting the validity period and with the condition of providing STP by and submission of BG of Rs. 5 lakhs towards compliance of the same The case was withdrawn. 19 M/s. Cummins India Ltd., S no.3 to 7,31(1), 32,33,37,38,41,42 & 43, Kothrud, Pune -- It was decided to issue SCN for refusal of consent for not submitting additional consent fees, justification for increase in CI and increase in effluent qty. 20 M/s. Zamil Steel Building (I) Pvt. Ltd., B-32/2, MIDC Ranjangaon, Pune It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate and existing BG of Rs. 5 lakhs for O & M shall be extended upto the M/s. Tata Motors Ltd., Chinchwad Works, Pune It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate with condition to complete STP before as per earlier consent condition & extension BG upto nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

6 22 M/s. Ratnagiri Gas & Power Pvt. Ltd., LNG Terminal, G No. 1036,1037,1039,1040, A/p- Anjanvel, Guhagar, Tal- Guhagar, Dist Ratnagiri M/s. Sona Alloys Pvt. Ltd., C-1, MIDC Lonand, Tal- Khandala, Dist Satara It was decided to resubmit the case after examining compliance of earlier consent condition. 24 M/s. Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd., Aircrat Division, Ojhar Township, Nashik 25 M/s. Supermax Personal Care Pvt. LTd., ( Plant-I), Wagle Indl. Est. PO LBS Marg, Thane It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate after obtaining additional consent fees towards difference in the CI and with condition to submit BG of Rs lakhs towards submission of Environment Statement and Water Cess by It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate. 26 M/s. Jindal Saw Ltd., A-59-60, MIDC Malegaon, Sinnar, Dist Nashik --- Revert to CAC after getting full details regarding installation of ARP. 27 M/s. Lloyd Steel Industries Ltd., Oxygen Plant, Lloydsnagar, Bhugaon Link Road, Tal & Dist Wardha 28 M/s. Tata Motors Ltd., Passenger Ca Unit, Sect 15 & 15 A, PCNTDA, Chikhali, Tal- Haveli, Dist Pune and amalgamation not approved It was decided to grant only plain renewal for the oxygen plant. For amalgamation of other consents, revert back to CAC in next meeting after getting details about other valid consents & compliance of the industry It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 10 lakhs towards O & M of pollution control system so as to achieve consented standards. 29 M/s. Adani Power Maharashtra Pvt. LTd., A-1, Vill- Tiroda, Dist Gondia 30 M/s. Reliance Cementation Pvt. Ltd., J-2, MIDC Butibori, Nagpur consent to operate -- It was decided to call monitoring results from SRO and resubmit in next CAC meeting. --- It was decided to grant amendment in consent to operate for consent condition no. 3(i), 3(ii) & 5(iii) with deletion of DG set conditions. 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

7 31 M/s. Ultratech Cement Ltd., Po- Awarapur, Tal- Korpana, Dist Chandrapur 32 Sharad SSK Ltd, Shamrao Patil ( Yadravakar ) Nagar, Narande, Tal- Hatkangale, Dist- Kolhapur. 33 M/s. Asian Paint Ltd, Plot No. A-1, MIDC Khandala, Phase-I, Tal- Khandala, Dist- Satara consent to operate & 1 st operate 1st Operate Regarding CAAQMS, HOD shall put up separate note for the CAC meeting on and amendment to be approved subsequently. --- It was decided to grant amendment in consent to operate by substituting 3x 23 MW with 2x 23 MW & 1x 25 MW It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate (sugar) and 1 st operate (co-gen) Consent to 1 st operate for phase-1 shall be issued with EPA standards. 34 M/s. Khed Economic Infrastructry Pvt. Ltd. Khed City, Muntiproduct SEZ, Tq- Khed &Sirrur, Dist- Pune 35 Udgiri Sugar and Power Ltd ( Sugar Unit), Sr. No. 586,87/88, A/p. Bamani, Tal- Khanapur, Dist- Sangli. 1st Operate ( Part) 1st Operate It was decided to grant part 1 st consent to operate to the SEZ with the condition that Individual industrial unit in SEZ shall obtain separate consent to establish and operate and shall provide their own treatment and disposal arrangement till common infrastructure facility comes up It was decided to grant consent to 1st operate with condition that industry shall submit performance BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards O & M of pollution control system and BG of Rs. 2/- lakhs towards providing necessary arrangements to cover the effluent collection system and to avoid the ingress of bagasse and other materials within six months, as per Board s circular dated Review Items 1 Issue of disposal of spent acid of metal plating indsutries located in the jurisdiction of Regional Office, Nagpur. It was decided to issue directions to the metal plating industries that either they should make provision for a common ARP or should have individual ARP by and shall submit BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs for CAC cases, Rs. 3/- lakhs for CC cases & Rs. 2/- lakhs for other general cases towards the compliance of the same. 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

8 2 Submission of material balance and process flow and Water balance for Sugar, Co- Generation and Distillery. Item was not discussed. Agenda No. Name of Industry Decision on grant of consent Consent granted upto Remarks/Discussion (1) Fresh Agenda Part -II 1 M/s Hikal Ltd, Plot No T-21, MIDC Taloja, Dist-Raigad 2 M/s Wockhardt Ltd. (Bio Tech Park)Plot No. H-14/2, MIDC Waluj, Dist. Aurangabad 3 M/s. Bayer CropScience Ltd, Kolshet Road, Thane. 4 M/s Essel Infraprojects Ltd. (Resort), Plot bearing CTS No. 1917, 1923, 1925 & 1940 of village Gorai, Borivali (West), Mumbai. with C to E Cancellation of Consent Consent to It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate with consent to establish for installation of Briquette Fired Boiler by replacing Oil Fired Boiler with revised EPA standards and condition that industry shall submit the Bank Guarantee of Rs. 5 Lakh towards the compliance of the same. --- Revert to CAC after examining EC(of existing unit) condition w.r.t. fuel consumption for Boiler. --- It was decided to cancel the consent granted to industry which is valid upto as per industry s request with the following conditions: 1. The project proponent is responsible for carrying out any remedial measures, if required in future at their own cost. 2. The consent fees paid up to shall not be refunded. 3. The proponent shall settle any dues viz. cess payment, JVS analysis charges, if any. 4. The project proponent shall submit a copy of report of third party about safe closer of the site to the Board and responsible for implementations of suggestions, if any. 5. The proponent shall submit a BG. of Rs. 10/- Lakhs towards above compliances. Commission It was decided to grant -ing of the amendment in Consent to unit or for expanded Built Up area 37, Sq. Mtrs to proposed resort after receipt of 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

9 additional consent fee. 5 M/s Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd., village Gotahivli & Talavali, Navi-Mumbai 6 M/s Indiabulls Properties Pvt. Ltd.., Plot No. 612, 613 Lower Parel Division, Elphinstone Mills, Senapati Bapat Marg, Mumbai M/s Indiabulls Properties Pvt. Ltd.., C.S. No. 841 of Lower Parel Division(G-South Ward), Senapati Bapat Marg, Eilphinstone (W), Mumbai M/s Nirlon Ltd. CTS No. 257/1, 257/B, 257/C, 257/D, 257/E, 257/F, 557, 558, 559, 571, 586/3, part of 257E Village Goregaon (E) and Pahadi Taluka Borivali, Mumbai 1st Operate (In part ) 1st Operate (In part ) 1st Operate (In part ) Commission -ing of the unit or 5 yrs whichever is earlier It was decided to grant consent to establish subject to the condition that applicant shall not take any effective steps before obtaining Environmental Clearance as per EIA notification, 2006 and CRZ clearance as per CRZ notification, 2011 and submit BG of RS. 5 lakhs towards the compliance of above It was decided to grant part consent to 1 st Operate with standard conditions of IT park for total construction area of sq mtrs and with following conditions: 5. Project Proponent shall submit an affidavit within 15 days in the prescribed format regarding the part of the built up area / building for which application for Consent to 1st operate is made is included in the Environmental Clearance accorded. 6. Industry shall submit the BG of Rs. 10 Lakhs towards O & M of STP and MSW processing plant It was decided to grant part consent to 1 st Operate with standard conditions of IT park for total construction area of sq mtrs and with following conditions: 1. Project Proponent shall submit an affidavit within 15 days in the prescribed format regarding the part of the built up area / building for which application for Consent to 1st operate is made is included in the Environmental Clearance accorded. 2. Industry shall submit the BG of Rs. 10 Lakhs towards O & M of STP and MSW processing plant. --- Committee noted that Environmental Clearance expired on and C to E on Hence, it was decided to resubmit the case in next CAC after examining the case with respect to Board s circular of 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

10 validity period of consent to establish. 9 M/s. Shree Chatrapati Shahu SSK Ltd.Tal Kagal, Dist Kolhapur 10 M/s. Malegaon SSK Ltd. (Sugar+ CoGen amalgamation)a/p Shivnagar, Tal - Baramati, Dist Pune 11 M/s. Malegaon SSK Ltd. (Distillery Unit) A/P Shivnagar, Tal - Baramati, Dist Pune 12 M/s. Baramati Agro Ltd. (Co- Gen Unit), Vilage Shetfal Gade, Tal Indapur, Dist Pune Consent to of consent with amalgamation Commissioni ng of the unit or 5 yrs whichever is earlier It was decided to grant amendment in consent to establish(expansion) to include Co-Generation plant with following conditions: 1. Applicant shall not take any effective steps before obtaining Environmental Clearance as per EIA notification, Applicant shall submit performance BG of Rs. 5/- lakhs towards O & M of pollution control system and BG of Rs. 2/- lakhs towards providing necessary arrangements to cover the effluent collection system and to avoid the ingress of bagasse and other materials within six months, as per Board s circular dated Revert back in next meeting with 1. Action taken against industry for not meeting the JVS standards. 2. Query raised by SRO vide letter dated and its reply It was decided to grant renewal of consent with following conditions: 1. Industry shall provide 11 acres of Compost yard by and submit BG of Rs. 5 Lakhs towards the compliance of the same. 2. Industry shall submit BG of Rs. 2 Lakhs for continuous compliance of CREP Norms It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate to only 20 MW Co-Generation as Environmental Clearance & C to O is granted to only 20 MW. 13 M/s. Lokmangal Agro Distillery Gat No Subhash Nagar, AP - Bibidarphal, Tal North Solapur, Dist Solapur The existing BG of Rs. 5 Lakhs obtained for CREP compliance shall be released and renewal of consent to operate shall be issued with the condition that 1. Industry shall submit BG of Rs. 2 Lakhs towards continuous compliance of CREP Norms as per consistence approach. 2. Industry shall submit BG of Rs. 2 Lakhs towards submission of 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

11 14 M/s. Mumbai Municipal Corporation of Grater Mumbai ( STP)(MCGM) Mahapalika Marg, Fort, Mumbai Nashik Muicipal Corporatio, Rajiv Gandhi Bhavan, Sharanpur Road, Nashik. Environment Statement within one month It was decided to grant renewal of consent to operate with condition that applicant shall submit BG of Rs. 5 Lakhs for O & M of STP so as to achieve consented standards It was decided to grant renewal of consent after obtaining requisite consent fee. Review Items 1 The review of CAC cases as per CAC calendar ( Dec ) those not applied for renewal of consent. 2 Vitthal Corporation Ltd., (Textile Division), Vitthalnagar, Mhaisgaon-Tadwale (M), Tal - Madha, Dist - Solapur 3 Vitthalrao Shinde SSK Ltd., (Expansion), A/p - Gangamainagar, Tal - Madha, Dist- Solapur - ( Expansion ) -- Commissioni ng of the unit or 5 yrs whichever is earlier It was decided that concerned HOD shall put up file to issue Show Cause Notice for revocation of consent to the industries who have not applied for renewal of consent to operate, with time period of 15 days to reply. HOD has confirmed that it is a separate unit and it is under purview of MS, hence the case was withdrawn. It was decided to grant consent to establish for expansion with condition that industry shall submit BG of Rs. 5 Lakhs towards compliance and provision of pollution control devices. 4 The Saswad Mali Sugar Factory Ltd., (Co-generation) Malinagar, Tal - Malshiras, Dist - Solapur Commissioni ng of the unit or 5 yrs whichever is earlier It was decided to grant consent to establish to Co-gen plant with condition that industry shall submit the Bank Guarantee of Rs. 5 Lakhs towards provision of pollution control devices. General points: 1. Next CAC meeting dates alongwith the review items to be discussed were scheduled as below, in addition to the normal agenda: Sr.no. Meeting dates Review Topics Pendency till 31 st December, 2012 plus fresh cases, review of water balance of sugar, power plant, pharma, textile, etc. sectors, Compliance of BG, review of CAAQMS note put up by JD(APC) All cases due for renewal upto , Hospital cases, Compliance of Envt. Statement and Cess conditions. 2 nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated

12 Review of compliance of circular regarding validity of C to E, Review of cases pending upto February Review of specific conditions compliance for all cases and renewal cases pendency upto All C to E cases which are not converted to C to O Committee observed that the compliance time recommended by HOD is in months, which does not clarify whether it is from the date of meeting or date of issuance of consent. Hence it was decided that general circular shall be issued by AST that the time period for compliance will be recommended with specific date such as 6 months from today , 4 months from today , etc. 3. In continuation to the general point number 1 of minutes of CAC meeting held on , agendas to be placed before CAC meeting shall also include draft of SCN for refusal for the cases where it is recommended to issue SCN for refusal. 4. Regarding circular for validity of consent to establish for a period upto commissioning of unit or 5 years whichever is earlier the validity shall be considered from the date of consent issued such as date of consent maximum validity for C to E In case of C to E, 5 years period shall be calculated from the date of original consent and not from the date of amendment issued. 5. Sr. Law Officer shall examine the issue whether demolition is covered in effective steps under provisions of EIA notification, nd sitting of 8 th CAC meeting of 2012 dated