Supreme Court of California Results from the petition conference of 9/19/2018

Transcription

1 Results from the petition conference of 9/19/2018 The following list reflects cases on which the court acted at the most recent conference. Set out first are those on which the court (1) acted concerning a petition for rehearing and/or a request for modification of opinion (or elected to modify on its own motion); (2) acted on a petition for transfer; (3) granted a petition for review or a request to answer a question of state law; (4) issued an order to show cause or alternative writ in an original writ matter; (5) acted on a motion for publication or depublication (or elected to do so on its own motion); (6) dismissed a matter that had been held in light of a final lead case; (7) transferred for reconsideration a matter that had been held in light of a final lead case; (8) acted on the merits of a Commission on Judicial Performance disciplinary matter; (9) acted on a State Bar disciplinary matter; (10) referred to the State Bar a public accusation against any attorney; (11) acted on a clemency matter; and (12) acted on any matter as to which a dissenting justice wishes to be noted. After reporting the disposition of these matters, all matters that were denied by the court are listed in alphabetical order. Notes: The Results column below shows only abbreviated descriptions of action taken. For the full and official result, review the matter on Supreme Court s docket through the Appellate Courts Information page. Any person or entity also may register for a Supreme Court notification to receive prompt alerts about any official action in any individual matter that is pending before the court. Title Case # CA # Action Type Result NATIONWIDE BIWEEKLY ADMINISTRATION v. S.C. S A Petition for Review & Pub/Depub Granted (PEOPLE) GUERRERO, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review GRANTED and Held JACKSON v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S A Petition for Review & Stay GRANTED and Held ROUSSEAUX, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review GRANTED and Held GUTIERREZ v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> MARTIN v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> MOLINA v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> PRECIADO v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> PRECIADO v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> SOTOMAYOR v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S G Petition for Review G&T 4/3 <alternative writ> AGUILAR, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold BROWN, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/2 Transferred after hold BURRELL, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/4 Transferred after hold CISNEROS, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/6 Transferred after hold COSTA, PEOPLE v. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold DAZO, PEOPLE v. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold DONLEY, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold

2 Results from the petition conference DORVAL, PEOPLE v. S D Grant - dismissal/lead case 4/1 Transferred after hold DUNN, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold EDWARDS, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/3 Transferred after hold FISHER, PEOPLE v. S E Grant - dismissal/lead case 4/2 Transferred after hold GARDEA, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold GRAYSON, PEOPLE v. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold GUIHER, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold HALL, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/6 Transferred after hold HERNANDEZ (JUSTIN) ON H.C. S D Grant - dismissal/lead case 4/1 Transferred after hold HERNANDEZ, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/3 Transferred after hold HOLDER, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold JONES, PEOPLE v. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold KAPPLER, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/4 Transferred after hold KELM, PEOPLE v. S D Grant - dismissal/lead case 4/1 Transferred after hold MCGHEE, PEOPLE v. S E Grant - dismissal/lead case 4/2 Transferred after hold NORMAN, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold QUAIR, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold QUINTERO, PEOPLE v. S H Grant - dismissal/lead case 6 Transferred after hold RUBIO, PEOPLE v. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold RUFF, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold STUBBS, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/1 Transferred after hold TAPIA, PEOPLE v. S F Grant - dismissal/lead case 5 Transferred after hold TUCKER, PEOPLE v. S B Grant - dismissal/lead case 2/8 Transferred after hold WILDE (DAVID SACHIO) ON H.C. S C Grant - dismissal/lead case 3 Transferred after hold 2

3 Results from the petition conference BARTZ v. PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION (SOUTHERN S B Petition for Review & Stay Denied (review & stay) CALIFORNIA EDISON) Chin, J., was recused and did not participate KUHLMANN v. ETHICON ENDO-SURGERY S A Publication request Denied Chin, J., was recused and did not participate MEDVEI v. MORGAN STANLEY SMITH BARNEY S B Petition for Review Denied (MEDVEI) Chin, J., was recused and did not participate MCDANIELS (ROBERT) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied Corrigan, J., was recused and did not participate ACCUSATION OF PANZER S Accusation against an attorney Denied ALFARO (JOHN C.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied ALLEN, PEOPLE v. S D Petition for Review Denied BATLINER, PEOPLE v. S D Petition for Review Denied BEAVER, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied BENHOFF, PEOPLE v. S D Petition for Review Denied BLACKMON, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied BRADFORD v. W.C.A.B. (LOS ANGELES COUNTY S B Petition for Review Denied OFFICE OF EDUCATION) BREITBARD (NEIL) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied BROWN (VICTOR SHAWN) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied BUSTAMANTE, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied BUTLER, PEOPLE v. S D Petition for Review Denied C. (JOSEPH) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied CALLOWAY (LAMAR) ON H.C. S B Petition for Review Denied CARDER, PEOPLE v. S F Petition for Review Denied CASONTOS, PEOPLE v. S F Petition for Review Denied CODY ON DISCIPLINE S State Bar - discipline Denied 3

4 Results from the petition conference COWELL, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied COYLE v. HISTORIC MISSION INN CORPORATION S E Petition for Review Denied DAVIS (JIM DALE) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied DAVIS, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied DAVIS, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied DAWKINS, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied DEMACEDO, PEOPLE v. S H Petition for Review Denied DEVLIN (PAUL F.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied DEXTER (SAMUEL L.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied EDELBACHER (PETER T.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied EVERETT (DANIEL), IN RE S Mandate/Prohibition petition Denied (writ & stay) FAGUNDES v. JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. S C Petition for Review Denied FISK, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied FLOYD, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied FRANCO (MARIA ANTONIA) ON H.C. S F Petition for Review Denied FREEMAN (TRAVON LEON) ON H.C. S B Petition for Review Denied GOMEZ (GENO) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied GOMEZ (RONALD) ON H.C. S B Petition for Review Denied GONZALEZ (GABRIEL) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied GONZALEZ (JOSE ALBERTO) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied GRIFFIN, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied HARROD (JESSE) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied HENDRIX, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied HERNANDEZ, PEOPLE v. S D Petition for Review Denied 4

5 Results from the petition conference HERZER v. S.C. (REDSTONE) S B Petition for Review Denied HOLLAND, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied HUI v. HUANG S B Petition for Review Denied HUTCHINS (RICHARD HUGH) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied IN RE A.L. S H Petition for Review Denied IN RE A.S. S E Petition for Review Denied IN RE D.A. S B Petition for Review Denied IN RE MELANIE K. S B Petition for Review & Stay Denied (review & stay) JOHNSON (THOMAS) ON H.C. S A Petition for Review Denied JONES, PEOPLE v. S F Petition for Review Denied KIM v. KIM S B Petition for Review Denied KIM, PEOPLE v. S H Petition for Review Denied KROLIKOWSKI v. SAN DIEGO CITY EMPLOYEES' S D Petition for Review & Pub/Depub Denied (review & depub.) RETIREMENT SYSTEM LEE (WEBSTER) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied L E-WILLIAMS (ROBERT L.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied LEPPAN v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S E Petition for Review & Stay Denied (review & stay) LI v. CHIU S A Publication request Denied LONG BEACH COUNCIL OF CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES, S B Publication request Denied LOCAL 6108 v. LONG BEACH COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT LOPEZ, PEOPLE v. S H Petition for Review Denied LOS ANGELES, COUNTY OF v. S.C. (MONDAY) S B Petition for Review & Stay Denied (review & stay) LOUIE v. S.C. (AMAZON.COM) S A Petition for Review Denied MACK, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied 5

6 Results from the petition conference MAGEE (RUCHELL CINQUE) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied MAGEE (RUCHELL CINQUE) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied MARTINEZ-COSTA, PEOPLE v. S C nd Petition for Review Denied MCCARTHY (JAMES TIMOTHY) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied MCKNIGHT (TERRENCE A.) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied MCVEY, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERN S B Petition for Review & Pub/Depub Denied (review & depub.) CALIFORNIA v. WINOGRAD (AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, & MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, LOCAL 1902, AFL/CIO) MONDRAGON, PEOPLE v. S E Petition for Review Denied MOORE v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S A Petition for Review Denied MULLICANE (MICHAEL STEWART) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied MURPHY, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied MUSTAFAA, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied NEWELL v. ABOUELMAGD S G Petition for Review Denied NOGUEDA, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied PENSION & BENEFIT INSURANCE SERVICES v. S G Petition for Review Denied PATTINSON PLUMMER v. KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITALS S A Publication request Denied PRESTON v. GREYHOUND LINES S C Petition for Review Denied RODRIGUEZ (RAUL) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied S.C. (VENICE SUITES), PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied SAAVEDRA, PEOPLE v. S F Petition for Review Denied SALARY, PEOPLE v. S G Petition for Review Denied 6

7 Results from the petition conference SALAZAR, PEOPLE v. S H Petition for Review Denied SIMS (NATHAN) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied SKIFF v. S.C. (PEOPLE) S B Petition for Review & Stay Denied (review & stay) SMITH (FRANKLIN) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied SNOWDEN, PEOPLE v. S C Petition for Review Denied SOLANO (CARLOS) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied SOTO, PEOPLE v. S F Petition for Review Denied STEVENS, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied SUARES, PEOPLE v. S B Petition for Review Denied THAI (HIEU HO TRONG) ON H.C. S Habeas Corpus petition Denied THAO v. COUNTY OF FRESNO S F Publication request Denied THOMAS (HORACE) ON H.C. S H Petition for Review Denied TORRICELLAS v. MCCLELLAND S D Petition for Review Denied VEGA v. CARMAX AUTO SUPERSTORES CALIF. ORNIA, S B Petition for Review Denied LLC WANG v. HSBC BANK USA, N.A. S Petition for Review Denied WASHINGTON v. CA 2/7 (PEOPLE) S Mandate/Prohibition petition Denied WILSON, PEOPLE v. S G Petition for Review Denied WILSON, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied WITTROCK, PEOPLE v. S A Petition for Review Denied 7