FINAL SUMMARY OF DECISIONS

Transcription

1 BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO AS THE DULY CONSTITUTED ELECTORAL BOARD FOR THE HEARING AND PASSING UPON OBJECTIONS TO NOMINATION PAPERS OF CANDIS FOR THE MARCH 20, 2012 GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION IN THE CITY OF CHICAGO FINAL SUMMARY OF DECISIONS 12-EB-SS-01 (rel SS-02, 03) Josip "Joe" Trutin Edgar Diaz State Senate 1 Objection Sustained 01/04/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 12-EB-SS-02 (rel SS-01, 03) Elizabeth Diaz Castillo Edgar Diaz State Senate 1 Objection Moot 01/04/2012 Objector defaulted, objection dismissed 12-EB-SS-03 (rel SS-01, 02) Elizabeth Diaz Castillo Edgar Diaz State Senate 1 Objection Moot 01/04/2012 Objector defaulted, objection dismissed 12-EB-SS-04 Midge Kimberly Larry D Carddieth State Senate 3 Candidate Withdrew 12-EB-SS-05 Sandra Ramsey Annazette R Collins State Senate 5 Objection Overruled candidate meets residency requirements, candidate s nomination papers declared valid 1

2 12-EB-SS-06 Tonya White Patricia Van Pelt Watkins State Senate 5 Objection Overruled 12-EB-SS-07 Gary Crossman Raul Montes, Jr State Senate 12 Objection Overruled 12-EB-RGA-01 Wayne Grzywacz Josip "Joe" Trutin Representative 2 Objection Overruled statement of candidacy in substantial compliance, 01/20/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-RGA-02 (rel RGA-03) Moises Moreno & Stephanie Kennedy Lani Wong Representative 2 Objection Sustained 01/04/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 12-EB-RGA-03 (rel RGA-02) Wayne Grzywacz Lani Wong Representative 2 Objection Moot 01/10/2012 Objection involved in related case, candidate s nomination papers declared invalid 12-EB-RGA-04 Elias Espindola Edward J Acevedo Representative 12-EB-RGA-05 Wallace Davis, III & Ruben Calderon & Carlos Ayala Denise Gordils Garcia Representative 12-EB-RGA-06 Denise Garcia Luis Arroyo Representative 2 Objector Overruled 3 Objection Sustained 3 Objection Withdrawn 01/20/2012 Objector defaulted, sufficient valid signatures, candidate s nomination papers declared valid 01/04/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 01/04/2012 Objection withdrawn 2

3 12-EB-RGA-07 (rel RGA-08) Dori Collins John Hu Representative 5 Objection Moot 01/20/2012 Candidate withdrew 12-EB-RGA-08 (rel RGA-07) Jonese Burnett John Hu Representative 5 Objection Moot 01/20/2012 Candidate withdrew 12-EB-RGA-09 Rita M Hardy Dori Collins Representative 12-EB-RGA-10 Carmela Wimberly Vetress M Boyce Representative 12-EB-RGA-11 Carol Aguila Gregory A Bedell Representative 12-EB-RGA-12 Jose Luis Garcia, Jr Rudy Lozano Representative 12-EB-RGA-13 Terrence Austin Anna Goral Representative 5 Objection Overruled 10 Objection Sustained 15 Objection Sustained 21 Objection Overruled 23 Objection Sustained 01/13/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/13/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 01/10/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 01/04/2012 Objection defaulted, 12-EB-RGA-14 Kevin Wunder & David Miranda Elizabeth "Lisa" Hernandez Representative 24 Objection Dismissed 01/04/2012 Objectors lacked standing, objection dismissed 3

4 12-EB-RGA-15 Lori Lelis Neftalie Gonzalez Representative 12-EB-RGA-16 Norman Shropshear Kenny Johnson Representative 12-EB-RGA-17 Norman Shropshear LaConyer Davis Representative 12-EB-RGA-18 Rory Perry Preston Brown, Jr Representative 12-EB-RGA-19 Casimir J Kmak Michael E Mayden Representative 12-EB-RGA-20 Donald Tucker Bobby Joe Johnson Representative 12-EB-RGA-21 Antoinette Puccio- Johnson Deborah L Mell Representative 12-EB-RGA-22 Donald Winter Rosemary E Mulligan Representative 24 Objection Overruled 26 Objector Withdrew 26 Candidate Withdrew 27 Objection Overruled 28 Objection Sustained 32 Objection Overruled 40 Objection Overruled 55 Candidate Withdrew 01/10/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/13/2012 Objector withdrew 01/10/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/04/2012 Sufficient number of signatures, candidate s nomination papers declared valid 01/13/2012 Sufficient number of signatures, candidate s nomination papers declared valid 01/13/2012 Candidate withdrew 4

5 12-EB-RGA-23 Kenneth A Klinicki Ralph P Vara Representative 12-EB-WC-01 Juan Elias Jesse Ruben Juarez Ward 12-EB-WC-02 Juan Elias Anne Shaw Ward 78 Objection Sustained 1 Objection Overruled 1 Objection Overruled 01/13/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 01/10/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/10/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-WC-03 Mirlinda Vula Feierstein Martin "Marty" Phelan Ward 2 Objective Overruled 01/13/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-WC-04 Dale A Charletta Theresa Stroud-Johnson Ward 4 Objection Sustained 01/10/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 12-EB-WC-05 Dale A Charletta Patrick D John Ward 4 Objector Withdrawn 01/10/2012 Objector withdrew 12-EB-WC-06 Dale A Charletta Erick M Wallace Ward 4 Objector Withdrawn 01/10/2012 Objector withdrew 12-EB-WC-07 Anne Marie Miles Leslie A Hairston Ward 5 Objector Withdrawn 01/10/2012 Objector withdrew 5

6 12-EB-WC-08 Angela Caldwell Roderick Sawyer Ward 12-EB-WC-09 Jerold Rodish William H Balasa Ward 12-EB-WC-10 Jerold Rodish Mary Estella Rymus Ward 6 Objection Overruled 10 Objection Overruled 10 Objector Withdrew 01/10/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/04/2012 Objector withdrew 12-EB-WC-11 (rel WC-12) Jerold Rodish Thomas E Malesh Ward 10 Objection Overruled 01/04/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-WC-12 (rel WDC-11) Anthony Navarro Thomas E Malesh Ward 10 Objector Withdrew 01/04/2012 Objector withdrew 12-EB-WC-13 Carl Segvich Richard A Catezone, Jr Ward 12-EB-WC-14 Rosalba Guzman Sergio Bocanegra Ward 11 Objection Sustained 12 Objection Overruled 01/04/2012 Candidate s did not file Statement of Candidacy, nomination papers declared invalid 01/13/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-WC-15 (rel WC-16) Janette Maldonado Toni L Foulkes Ward 15 Candidate Withdrew 6

7 12-EB-WC-16 (rel WC-15) Charles M Hughes Toni L Foulkes Ward 15 Candidate Withdrew 12-EB-WC-17 Leola Chambers Fred McGee Ward 15 Candidate Withdrew 12-EB-WC-18 Cort D Chubko Rosa Pritchett Ward 15 Objection Overruled 01/04/2012 Nomination papers in substantial compliance 12-EB-WC-19 Antoine Members Curtis Lacy Ward 17 Objection Overruled 01/04/2012 Objection overruled, 12-EB-WC-20 Mae E Amos Vernita McClinton- Farmer Ward 21 Objection Sustained 12-EB-WC-21 Bruce E Crosby Howard B Brookins, Jr Ward 12-EB-WC-22 Marsha Kozlowski John Robert Boyle Ward 21 Objection Overruled 23 Objection Sustained 01/23/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 12-EB-WC-23 Larry G Nelson Wallace E Mickey- Johnson Ward 24 Objection Overruled in Part, Dismissed in Part 01/10/2012 Use of nickname not improper; objections do not fully state nature of objections 7

8 12-EB-WC-24 (rel WC-25) Larry G Nelson Darren Tillis Ward 24 Candidate Withdrew 12-EB-WC-25 (rel WC-24) Linda F Hooper Darren Tillis Ward 24 Candidate Withdrew 12-EB-WC-26 (rel WC-27) Larry G Nelson Marcel Walton-El Ward 24 Candidate Defaulted 01/04/2012 Candidate defaulted 12-EB-WC-27 (rel WC-26) Linda F Hooper Marcel A Walton-El Ward 24 Candidate Defaulted 01/04/2012 Candidate defaulted 12-EB-WC-28 Larry G Nelson Ronnie C McKenzie Ward 24 Objection Sustained 01/17/2012 Candidate defaulted 12-EB-WC-29 Eileen Jackson Carmelita P Earls Ward 28 Objection Sustained 01/20/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 12-EB-WC-30 Carmelita P Earls Jason C Ervin Ward 12-EB-WC-31 John J Curry Stephen F Boulton Ward 28 Objection Overruled 32 Objection Sustained 1/20/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 8

9 12-EB-WC-32 Gregory Eidukas Scott Campbell Ward 33 Objection Overruled 01/04/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 12-EB-WC-33 Miguel Sotomayor & Roger P Klich Rey Colon Ward 35 Candidate Defaulted 01/04/2012 Candidate defaulted 12-EB-WC-34 Kathleen Tompkins Tom Caravette Ward 12-EB-WC-35 William C "Bill" Miceli Jason Para Ward 12-EB-WC-36 William J Kelly Tom Smithburg Ward 12-EB-WC-37 Chris Cleveland Kent Griffiths Ward 12-EB-WC-38 Jim Ginderske Nathan Benjamin Myers Ward 12-EB-WC-39 Kurt Fujio Suzanne Devane Ward 12-EB-CON-1 Evans G. Hernandez & Ricardo Rosario Hector Concepcion Representative U.S. Congress 12-EB-CON-2 Evans G. Hernandez Jorge Zavala Representative & Ricardo Rosario U.S. Congress 12-EB-CON-3 Timothy C. Wolfe Susanne Atanus Representative U.S. Congress 38 Objection Overruled 39 Objection Overruled 42 Objection Overruled 43 Objection Overruled 49 Objection Sustained 49 Objection Overruled 4 Objection Sustained 4 Objection Sustained 9 Objection Sustained 01/13/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/04/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 01/20/2012 Nominating petition in substantial compliance 01/13/2012 Sufficient valid signatures, 01/23/2012 Insufficient valid signatures 9

10 12-EB-DEL-1 James Fernandez Willie L. Fleming Delegate to the Democratic Party National Nominating Convention (Obama) 7 Objection Dismissed 01/25/2012 Objections dismissed 10