The Sub-national Dimension of the EU

Transcription

1 The Sub-national Dimension of the EU

2 .

3 Carlo Panara The Sub-national Dimension of the EU A Legal Study of Multilevel Governance

4 Carlo Panara School of Law Liverpool John Moores University Liverpool United Kingdom ISBN ISBN (ebook) DOI / Library of Congress Control Number: Springer Cham Heidelberg New York Dordrecht London Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved by the Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. Printed on acid-free paper Springer International Publishing AG Switzerland is part of Springer Science+Business Media (

5 Ad Alessandra Maria, Ali, mia figlia, Carlo, il tuo pap a

6 .

7 Foreword I would like to express my gratitude to Prof. Dr. Martin Nettesheim for a very valuable discussion on this project and for hosting me so wonderfully at Tübingen University during its execution. I am also indebted to the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for supporting this research with a Fellowship for Experienced Researchers and to Springer, particularly in the person of Dr. Brigitte Reschke, for publishing this monograph. I would also like to thank Erin O Leary, research assistant at Liverpool John Moores University, for her precious help during the initial stage of the research and my friend Dr. Michael Varney, from Hull University, for revising the final manuscript. Finally and most importantly, I would like to declare my unconditional love and gratitude to my parents in Italy for all they have done and still do for me. Tübingen, Germany October 2014 Carlo Panara vii

8 .

9 Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears; I come to bury Caesar, not to praise him. The evil that men do lives after them; The good is oft interred with their bones; So let it be with Caesar. [From Mark Anthony s speech in Julius Caesar, Act 3, Scene 2 by William Shakespeare] ix

10 ThiS is a FM Blank Page

11 List of Principal Abbreviations AER AG BGBl BOE BVerfGE B-VG CALRE CARCE CdR CDU CEMR CFI CFSP CJEU CoR CUP EC ECHR ECI ECJ ECR EEC EMK EP ERDF EU EULG Assembly of European Regions Advocate General Bundesgesetzblatt (Germany) Boletín Oficial del Estado (Spain) Entscheidungen des Bundesverfassungsgericht (Germany) Bundes-Verfassungsgesetz (Austria) Conference of European Regional Legislative Assemblies Conferencia para Asuntos Relacionados con las Comunidades Europeas (Spain) Comité des régions Christlich Demokratische Union Deutschlands Council of European Municipalities and Regions Court of First Instance Common Foreign and Security Policy Court of Justice of the European Union Committee of the Regions Cambridge University Press European Community European Convention on Human Rights European Citizens Initiative European Court of Justice European Court Reports European Economic Community Europaministerkonferenz European Parliament European Regional Development Fund European Union Gesetz über die Beteiligung des Landtags in Angelegenheiten der Europäischen Union xi

12 xii EUV EUZBLG EWS FAG GC GG LEP LJMU MBO MEP MLG MoU MP OJ OUP P REGLEG Rn Rz SMN SPD TEC TEU TFEU TUEL UKRep VfSlg List of Principal Abbreviations Vertrag über die Europäische Union Gesetz über die Zusammenarbeit von Bund und Ländern in Angelegenheiten der Europäischen Union (Germany) Early Warning System Finanzausgleichsgesetz (Germany) General Court Grundgesetz (Germany) Local enterprise partnership Liverpool John Moores University Merseyside Brussels Office Member of the European Parliament Multilevel governance Memorandum of Understanding (UK) Member of Parliament Official Journal of the European Union Oxford University Press Pourvoi Conference of European Regions with Legislative Power Randnummer Randzahl (or Randziffer) Subsidiarity Monitoring Network Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands Treaty establishing the European Community Treaty on the European Union Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union Testo Unico degli Enti Locali (Italy) United Kingdom Permanent Representation to the European Union Sammlung der Erkentnisse und wichtigsten Beschlüsse des Verfassungsgerichtshofes (Austria)

13 Contents 1 Introduction: A Legal Study of Multilevel Governance... 1 A. Why a Legal Study of Multilevel Governance? B. Overview of the Work... 4 C. A Required Post-Scriptum on the Heterogeneity of the Sub-national Level... 5 References The Sub-national Dimension of the EU A. Introduction B. Beyond the Masters of the Treaties Dogma C. Sub-national Participation in Lawmaking in the Council and Through the Committee of the Regions (CoR) D. The Implementation of EU Law and Policy by the Sub-national Authorities Beyond the Doctrine of the Exclusive Responsibility of the Member States for the Fulfilment of EU Obligations: The Role of the Sub-national Authorities State Liability and Financial Liability of the Sub-national Authorities in Case of Failure to Comply with Obligations Stemming from the EU Protecting Local and Regional Self-government from Surreptitious Re-centralisation : Constitutional Limitations and Constraints Surrounding the EU-Related Substitution Powers of the State The Defence of the Sub-state Authorities in Infraction Proceedings E. The Challenge of Union Acts by the Sub-national Authorities Direct Challenge of Union Acts: The State Centric Jurisprudence oftheecj xiii

14 xiv Contents 2. The Way Out of the Conundrum: The Judicial Defence of the Rights of the Sub-state Authorities at EU Level Through the National Government F. Concluding Remarks References Multilevel Governance in the EU A. Introduction B. Content and Constitutional Foundation of Multilevel Governance The Emergence of Multilevel Governance in the EU The White Papers Approach to Multilevel Governance Towards a Legal Notion of Multilevel Governance: A) EU Primary Law Towards a Legal Notion of Multilevel Governance: B) EU Secondary Law Towards a Legal Notion of Multilevel Governance: C) Article 4(2) TEU and the Constitutional Identity of the Member States Towards a Legal Notion of Multilevel Governance: D) The Role of the CJEU for the Definition and Enforcement of Multilevel Governance C. The Making Phase of EU Law and Policy The Notion of Legitimacy Used in This Study Legitimacy in the Making Phase of EU Law and Policy Partnership and Loyal Cooperation The Role of the Domestic Courts for the Definition and Enforcement of Multilevel Governance D. Concluding Remarks References The Principle of Subsidiarity A. Introduction B. The Principle of Subsidiarity in the EU The Origin of Subsidiarity in the EU The Court of Justice s Approach to Subsidiarity The Proportionality Test C. Comparative Analysis Germany: The Long and Winding Road to the Judicial Enforcement of Subsidiarity Lessons from the German Pattern Italy: From Subsidiarity to Loyal Cooperation (i) Subsidiarity in Administration (ii) Subsidiarity in Legislation (iii) The Relationship Between Subsidiarity and Loyal Cooperation Lessons from the Italian Pattern

15 Contents xv D. The Enforcement of Subsidiarity in the Post-Lisbon Era The Shift Towards a Procedural Approach to Subsidiarity The Role of the Sub-national Authorities in the Enforcement of Subsidiarity After the Lisbon Treaty (i) The Early Warning Mechanism (ii) The Right to Challenge Union Acts (iii) Committee of the Regions E. Concluding Remarks: Subsidiarity Between Justiciability and Cooperation References The Regional Responsibility for European Integration: Baden-Württemberg (Germany), Lombardia (Italy), Merseyside (UK) A. Introduction: Regional Responsibility for European Integration B. Case Study 1: A Multilevel Constitutional Approach to Integration in the EU: Land Baden-Württemberg C. Case Study 2: Integration in the EU Through the Involvement of the System-Lombardia in the EU Decision-Making D. Case Study 3: Integration in the EU and Region Building Liverpool City Region and the Merseyside Brussels Office (MBO) E. Concluding Remarks References The Constitutional Dimension of Multilevel Governance in the EU A. The EU Polycentric System of Governance B. Multilevel Governance in the EU Constitutional Space C. Multilevel Governance Beyond Soft Law D. The Multilevel Constitutional Foundation of Multilevel Governance E. Multilevel Governance v Federalism and Regionalism F. Multilevel Governance and European Constitutionalism G. Multilevel Governance and Democracy H. Concluding Remarks References Summary Thoughts and Agenda for Future Research A B C D E F G

16 xvi Contents H References Appendix: Charter for Multilevel Governance in Europe Preamble Title 1: Fundamental Principles Title 2: Implementation and Delivery