Ex officio No. 415/2016 REPORT WITH RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE OMBUDSPERSON OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO. Related to
|
|
- Alyson Cross
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Ex officio No. 415/2016 REPORT WITH RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE OMBUDSPERSON OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO Related to Lack of access to Court building in the Northern part of Mitrovica, namely denial of the right of access to justice To: Mr Nehat Idrizi Chair of the Kosovo Judicial Council Mr Blerim Isufaj President of the Kosovo Prosecutorial Council Mr Ali Kutllovci Acting President of the Basic Court in Mitrovica Mr Shyqyri Syla Chief prosecutor in the Basic Prosecution Office in Mitrovica Prishtina, 8 August 2016
2 PURPOSE OF REPORT The purpose of this report is to draw the attention of responsible authorities whether the Court in the Northern part of Mitrovica is providing access to justice, and whether this access is in conformity with the standard of equal treatment of citizens before Constitution. Through this report, the Ombudsperson is aiming at drawing the attention of relevant/competent institutions on the negative consequences from the non-application of Law, violation of fundamental human rights for access to justice, and to recommend a possible solution. SUMMARY OF FACTS Since February 2008, namely, immediately following the proclamation of the independence of the Republic of Kosovo, judicial system in Mitrovica has been facing essential problems in its functioning. Judicial system started its work from 1 September 1999 till 20 February Thus, for more than eight years, this system has almost ceased functioning completely, making it impossible to the citizens of the region to exercise basic rights for access to justice, a right which is guaranteed by International instruments on human rights, directly applicable in Kosovo and with Constitution of Kosovo. There has been no access for judges and local public prosecutors and the supporting staff to the Court building, located in the Northern part of Mitrovica, since after the events of February and March Ever since their official appointment, on 9 December 2008, this Court Complex has been administered by the staff of the European Union Rule of Law Mission (EULEX), which is currently comprised of judges, prosecutors and local staff (Kosovo Albanians and Kosovo Serbs), and international 2 supporting staff. Considerable damages were caused to the Court building in the Northern part of Mitrovica and there has been no access to the Court building in the north, with 2500 case files of civilian procedure and 1700 case files of criminal procedures left un-adjudicated, with no possibility to be proceeded 3 ever. 1 See OSCE report, January 2011, relating to Judicial system in Mitrovica 2 Ibid, p 3 Document from Basic Court of Mitrovica, GJA.no.209/2016,
3 Currently, Basic Court in Mitrovica is working in the building of former Municipal Court of Vushtrri. Last year, the branch in Vushtrri of BCM, was located into a new building. Lack of space for work in BCM makes working difficult, as some judges are working in one office. In addition, the entire working staff is facing difficult working conditions due to the lack of spaces. EULEX is located in the Court building in the north. Expenditures required for maintenance of the building in the north are paid, while access is not allowed. Almost, the majority of cases of prosecution which remained in a building in the North of Mitrovica have been prescribed, due to objective reasons of the inability to access the north. BPM, is now functioning in the building of the former Court building in Vushtrri, their working conditions are difficult, due to the working space. There is lack of prosecutors. After being located in a new building of the branch of Vushtrri of BCM, Prosecution office now has two (2) more offices, but they are insufficient for work. LEGAL ANALYSIS The blocking of cases in the Northern part and incomplete functioning of the judicial system in Mitrovica for more than eight years constitute a serious violation of human rights guaranteed by the European Convention on Human Rights: right for access to justice, right to liberty and right to a fair trial within a reasonable time. This report shall be focused on the right to access to justice which is a fundamental right and a source of the realisation of human rights. Right for access to justice The access to justice, not only is a right on its own, but is also a strengthening and enabling remedy in the realisation of the exercise of other rights. Right to access to Court is a fundamental human right, which means that no one shall be hindered or prohibited to address a court to seek protection of his/her rights, and prohibitions shall not be made by the Constitution, Law or whatever other act, neither shall be made by individual rulings of some court or other authority. 4 Right for access to justice is a right set forth and protected by European Convention on Human Rights and Freedoms 5 (hereinafter ECHR): and it includes fundamental human 4 A commentary of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, p ECHR is part of our legal system of Constitution in conformity with Article 22 of the Constitution of Kosovo generally acceptable rules of the international law become part of the legal order, they have
4 rights, such as right to a fair trial in conformity with Article 6 of ECHR 6, Right to an effective remedy in conformity with Article 13 of ECHR. 7 Access to justice through Courts, "the right of access to a court" according to ECHR, means that courts should be accessible. Access may include the willingness of Courts with relevant jurisdiction, availability of interpretation, access to information and access to court decisions. Part of this right may also include the geographic distance of a court, thus, if applicants are made unable to attend regular legal proceedings due to geographic distance. 8 Taking into account the elements by which a right for access to justice is characterised which is required through courts, it may be established that in the case of the Court of Mitrovica, this right has been generally violated, and in particular: 1) Denial of access to information; 2) Access to court decisions, and 3) Unwillingness of the court with jurisdiction to act. International and European law on Human Rights forces countries to guarantee the right of every individual to visit and have access to courts or to receive a judicial protection relating a criminal, civil, administrative issue or even to ascertain that the right of an individual has been violated. In this way, having information that over 2500 civilian cases and over 1700 criminal cases have been left un-adjudicated, this has not only discriminated a part of the citizens of Kosovo (North Municipalities), but it also constitutes a burden, and loss of credibility and reliability on the judicial system of the Republic of Kosovo. Making it unable to exercise the right to access justice, namely the courts, constitutes a fundamental and the most important violation, as access to other rights is enabled only through it (through judicial paths to the judgment on the merits). In this case, the citizens of Mitrovica are made unable to protect themselves against violation of their rights, to rectify civilian errors/violations, to retain responsible executive power and to defend themselves in criminal proceedings. Right to a fair trial and timely resolution of disputes, right to appropriate damages, and general application of principles of efficiency and effectiveness in the provision of justice priority over the domestic law, i.e. over the law in the Republic of Kosovo, which belong to a national domestic law, and as such, these rules (principles) are not subject to the assessment of constitutionality. 6 Article 6 ECHR Right to a fair trial: Everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law, which shall decide not only relating to disputes relating to the rights and obligations of their civilian nature, but also on the foundation of any criminal charges. 7 Article 13 ECHR: Right to an effective remedy: Everyone whose rights and freedoms as set forth in this Convention are violated shall have an effective remedy before a national authority notwithstanding that the violation has been committed by persons acting in an official capacity. 8 Handbook access to justice
5 which are foreseen in the International and European law are violated at the moment when the exercise of the right of access to justice is denied. 9 Application in practice of the right for access to courts is seen in the case Golder v. United Kingdom 10, where a prisoner tried to sue the guardian for defamation according to the civilian procedure, which was not accepted by the national court, therefore ECtHR decided that the rejection of a trial of such an indictment by the court was a violation of the prisoner s right for access to court. According to par. 36 of the judgment right for access right to court is interpreted as follows: A part of the right to a trial or access to justice is the right to submit with the Court or a Tribunal, whatever type of submission, upon which, the court shall act relating to the rights and civilian obligations. Right to the court or the right to access justice, includes the right to initiate proceedings in civilian issues with the competent court. The right to access a court where ECtHR ascertained that the inability of a party s indictment to be heard effectively by a court relating to a civilian dispute has been treated by the Court also in the case of Immobiliare Saffi v. Italy, 11 where it was established that this constitutes violation of the right to access a court, and subsequently is in conflict with the principle of the democratic state and the state law. ECtHR in the case of Brandstetter v. Austria, 12 decided that the right of indicted party for equal access to a court was violated, since the appeal of the Prosecution office made with the court was not submitted to the indicted party, and subsequently the latter was not provided with possibility to respond to the claim of the appeal of the prosecution office. Right to equal access to a court is a standard of the right to a fair trial and means that each party in the judicial proceedings should be provided with reasonable environment and time to present explanations on the case, in order that it should not be seen in the eyes of others that one party was unreasonably limited against his/her opponent. 13 Access to justice according to the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo The Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo foresees the right of access to justice, where Article sets forth that The judicial power is unique, independent, fair, apolitical and impartial and ensures equal access to the courts, based on Article the access to court is a constitutional right guaranteed. This constitutional right is documented also by 9 Handbook on European law relating to access to justice 10. Case of Golder v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 4451/70) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 21 February Case of, Immobiliare Saffi v. Italy, Application No /93, 28 July 1999, Judgement. 12. Case of, Brandstetter v. Austria, 28 August 1991, Judgment, Series A. No. 21, f. 28, par Case of, Bulut v. Austria, 13
6 Article 7 of the Law on Courts according to which it sets forth that Every person has the right to address the courts to protect and enforce his or her legal rights. Every person has the right to pursue legal remedies against judicial and administrative decisions that infringe on his or her rights or interests, in the manner provided by Law. The Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo sets forth that every person has the right to access courts; this access should be equal to all citizens of the Republic of Kosovo without discrimination. The access to the court in accordance with the Constitution means that every person without discrimination and in an equal manner has the right to address courts for the realisation of his/her constitutional and legal rights and obligations. The access to courts includes the right that every person may address the courts and should have not only physical access, but also access it through letters and other legal remedies. Right of access to justice in general and the right for access to courts in particular constitutes a very important element, taking into account that courts provide judicial protection of rights 14 against unlawful practices and enable the enactment and rule of law. The rule of law can be guaranteed only through a functional court and functional judicial system. Violation of the right to access a court exists in cases: a) when courts refuse to accept a party on basis of locus standi, considering that the issue of the party cannot access the court; b) when the right for access to courts is limited by the procedure or different limitations; and c) when final court decisions are not implemented by relevant institutions. 15 Denial of access to courts constitutes violation of human rights set forth under ECHR and Constitution, violation of this right makes persons unable to submit issues to the Constitutional Court, in conformity with Article 113 par. 7 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo and Article 47 of the Law on Constitutional Court which sets forth that: 1.Every individual is entitled to request from the Constitutional Court legal protection when he considers that his/her individual rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution are violated by a public authority. 2. The individual may submit the referral in question only after he/she has exhausted all the legal remedies provided by the law. With the inability to submit issues to the Court, persons are also made unable to exhaust legal remedies, which is a condition for the submission of an issue to the Constitutional Court, and in this way, persons are denied one more constitutional right. 14 Article 54 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo; Judicial Protection of Rights: Everyone enjoys the right of judicial protection if any right guaranteed by this Constitution or by law has been violated or denied and has the right to an effective legal remedy if found that such right has been violated. 15 A commentary of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, p.489
7 FINDINGS OF THE OMBUDSPERSON The Ombudsperson finds that: Lack of a judicial system, completely functional in the north of Kosovo, constitutes a great obstacle for individual s rights to access justice. In the concrete case of the citizens of the Republic of Kosovo in general, and the inhabitants of that region that fall under the territorial competence of that court, they have constantly been denied the right for access to justice, since 20 February 2008, and to date. The denial for more than eight years of the access to the Court in the north of Mitrovica constitutes a violation of: (1) The right to a fair trial, which is protected by Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and by Article 102 par. 2 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo. (2) Upon violation of the right to access a court, it also violates the right for a legal effective remedy set forth and protected by Article 13 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and by Article 32 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo. 16 (3) Right to a fair trial and within a reasonable time by an independent court established by law, which is set forth and protected by Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). (4) Right of judicial protection of rights set forth by Article 54 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo. 17 (5) Right to protection of property and possessions set forth and protected by Article 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights - ECHR (Additional protocol Paris, 20.III.1952), namely by Article 46 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo. (6) Irregular functioning of judicial system and the denial of the right of access to court causes serious consequences also to the rule of law, strengthening of the public order and protection of the region from unlawful 18 practices. (7) Legal prescriptions: Criminal offenses for which, based on the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kosovo, prescriptions are foreseen, as a result of lack of access to court 16 Violation of the right for access to a court causes also a violation of the right to have an effective remedy, because with the violation of the right for access to a court, the submission of documents to court is made unable, submissions such as appeals and other legal remedies. 17 Article 54 of KCC foresees: Everyone enjoys the right of judicial protection if any right guaranteed by this Constitution or by law has been violated or denied and has the right to an effective legal remedy if found that such right has been violated. 18 Denial of the access to a court and to justice bodies makes not only state bodies but also persons unable to realise their legal obligations and report on a crime.
8 and irregular functioning of judicial bodies occur after the expiry of the legal limitation foreseen. 19 RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE OMBUDSPERSON Based on these findings, and in conformity with Article 135, par. 3 of Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, and Article 16, par. 8 of Law no. 05/L-019 on Ombudsperson, the Ombudsperson recommends the: 1) Kosovo Judicial Council should functionalise the judicial system in the region of Mitrovica, in at the shortest time possible, enabling access to civilian and criminal case files, which have been blocked since 2008, and hence proceed with the subsequent ones. 2) The Court in the Northern part of Mitrovica should take all measures required, to remove all physical and administrative obstacles for access to documents, and should cooperate, at the appropriate level, with the other part of branches of the Court of Mitrovica. In conformity with Article 132, paragraph 3 of Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo ( Every organ, institution or other authority exercising legitimate power of the Republic of Kosovo is bound to respond to the requests of the Ombudsperson and shall submit all requested documentation and information in conformity with the law ) and Article 28 of Law no. 05/L-019 on Ombudsperson ( Authorities to which the Ombudsperson has addressed recommendation, request or proposal for undertaking concrete actions, must respond within thirty (30) days. The answer should contain written reasoning regarding actions undertaken about the issue in question ), will you kindly inform us on actions to be undertaken about this issue. Sincerely, Hilmi Jashari Ombudsperson 19 Prescription is presented in those cases where criminal offenses have shorter statutory limitation than eight (8) years, mainly criminal offences containing punishments with fewer years of imprisonment, criminal offenses containing fines and minor offenses.
The Mitrovicë/Mitrovica Justice System: Status update and continuing human rights concerns
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe MISSION IN KOSOVO The Mitrovicë/Mitrovica Justice System: Status update and continuing human rights concerns LSMS Issue 1 January 2011 Introduction
More informationThe Importance of Implementation of Constitutional Principles in Criminal Procedure 1
EUROPEAN ACADEMIC RESEARCH Vol. II, Issue 7/ October 2014 ISSN 2286-4822 www.euacademic.org Impact Factor: 3.1 (UIF) DRJI Value: 5.9 (B+) The Importance of Implementation of Constitutional Principles 1
More informationRepublika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo-Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo-Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 03/L-121 ON THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Pursuant to
More informationTHE IMPACT OF PRECEDENT IN THE LEGAL SYSTEM OF KOSOVO
THE IMPACT OF PRECEDENT IN THE LEGAL SYSTEM OF KOSOVO M.Sc. Nehat Idrizi-PhD Judge at the Basic Court in Prishtina and PhD candidate at UET in Tirana Abstract It is known that there are two systems of
More informationIssues concerning the role of professional associates and the initiation of proceedings in inheritance cases
Department of Human Rights and Communities Legal System Monitoring Section Issues concerning the role of professional associates and the initiation of proceedings in inheritance cases Issue 9 November
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
REPUHLlKA E KOSO\'ES - PEflYIiJlllKA I(OCOBO - REPUBLIC OF KOS()\'O GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHlI CYlI: CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 10 November 2016 Ref. NO.:RKt002/16 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
RLpl 111.1K\ I KOSO\ U,. PEl I) 1>.1111".\I';()LOBO. R.pl HI 1('01- KOSO\ () GJYKA TA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHI1 CYll CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 2 June 2016 Ref. no.:rk94s/16 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
More informationThe resolution of criminal case through temporary suspension of proceedings: Kosovo Context
International Journal of Development and Sustainability ISSN: 2186-8662 www.isdsnet.com/ijds Volume 5 Number 10 (2016): Pages 508-517 ISDS Article ID: IJDS17013001 The resolution of criminal case through
More informationThe Mitrovicë/Mitrovica Justice System: status update and continuing human rights concerns
Department of Human Rights and Communities Legal System Monitoring Section The Mitrovicë/Mitrovica Justice System: status update and continuing human rights concerns Issue 1 February 2010 Introduction
More informationRepublika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 05/L-021 ON THE PROTECTION FROM DISCRIMINATION Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Based on Article 65 (1) of
More informationLAW ON THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF MONTENEGRO
Pursuant to Article 82, paragraph 1, Item 2 of the Constitution of Montenegro and Amendment IV, paragraph 1 to the Constitution of Montenegro, the 25 th Parliament of Montenegro, at its sitting of the
More informationEquality of Arms, Albanian Case and the European Court of Human Rights
Doi:10.5901/ajis.2015.v4n3p181 Abstract Equality of Arms, Albanian Case and the European Court of Human Rights PhD Candidate Emira Kazazi Albtelecom Sh.A Prof. Assoc. Dr Ervis Çela Faculty of Law, University
More informationPurposes of the Law. Information of Public Importance. Public Authority Body. Legal Presumptions of Justified Interest
LAW ON FREE ACCESS TO INFORMATION OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE I Basic Provisions Purposes of the Law Article 1 This Law regulates the rights to access information of public importance held by public authority
More informationThe Right of Access to Court
Abstract The Right of Access to Court Sokol Mëngjesi PhD Faculty of Law, University of Tirana Klodjan Skënderaj PhD Faculty of Law, University of Tirana Every person has the right to address the court
More informationOFFICIAL GAZETTE OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVA / No. 33 / 2 SEPTEMBER 2013, PRISTINA
OFFICIAL GAZETTE OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVA / No. 33 / 2 SEPTEMBER 2013, PRISTINA LAW NO. 04/L-213 ON INTERNATIONAL LEGAL COOPERATION IN CRIMINAL MATTERS Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Based on Article
More informationSERBIA DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA. As submitted by the Ministry of Justice of Serbia on 12 October 2018
Strasbourg, 12 October 2018 Opinion No. 921 / 2018 CDL-REF(2018)053 Eng.Only EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW (VENICE COMMISSION) SERBIA DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC
More informationDRAFT AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL AND CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODES OF ALBANIA
Strasbourg, 22 April 2014 Opinion No. 754 / 2014 Engl. only EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW (VENICE COMMISSION) DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL AND CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODES OF ALBANIA This
More informationCOMPETENCE AND COOPERATION OF THE PUBLIC PROSECUTION OFFICE WITH THE MINISTRY OF INTERIOR OF THE REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA
COMPETENCE AND COOPERATION OF THE PUBLIC PROSECUTION OFFICE WITH THE MINISTRY OF INTERIOR OF THE REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA Sonja Aleksova Faculty of Law at University "Goce Delchev"-Stip, Macedonia, sonja_2010@live.com
More informationThe deadlines of Statutory Limitation of Criminal Prosecution according to the Criminal Code of Kosovo
EUROPEAN ACADEMIC RESEARCH Vol. VI, Issue 12/ March 2019 ISSN 2286-4822 www.euacademic.org Impact Factor: 3.4546 (UIF) DRJI Value: 5.9 (B+) The deadlines of Statutory Limitation of Criminal Prosecution
More informationWritten evidence to the Justice Committee. Scottish Human Rights Commission. November 2017
Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Repeal) (Scotland) Bill Introduction Written evidence to the Justice Committee Scottish Human Rights Commission November 2017 1. The Scottish
More informationACCESS TO JUSTICE FOR CHILDREN: CROATIA
ACCESS TO JUSTICE FOR CHILDREN: CROATIA This report was produced by White & Case LLP in February 2014 but may have been subsequently edited by Child Rights International Network (CRIN). CRIN takes full
More informationCase No. KI 46/17. Applicant
REPUBLIKA E KOSOvEs - PEnYBJII1KA J{OCOBO - REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHHCY,lJ; CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Pristina, on 4 December 2017 Ref. No.: RK 1161/17 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY III
More informationCOURT OF APPEALS. B. J., (aka xxx ), born on xxx in xxx, Kosovo xxx, father s name xxx, mothers name xxx;
COURT OF APPEALS Case number: PAKR 161/16 Date: 15 September 2016 Basic Court of Mitrovica: P. no. 122/2014 The Court of Appeals, in the Panel composed of EULEX Judge Hajnalka Veronika Karpati, as presiding
More informationRepublic of Kosova Kosovo Prosecutorial Council
Republic of Kosova Kosovo Prosecutorial Council Based on Article 4 of the Law on Kosovo Prosecutorial Council, Articles 27 and 28 of the Law on State Prosecutor and the Plan on Implementation of the Law
More informationON LIABILITY OF LEGAL PERSONS FOR CRIMINAL OFFENCES LAW ON LIABILITY OF LEGAL PERSONS FOR CRIMINAL OFFENCES CHAPTER I GENERAL PROVISIONS
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 04/L-030 ON LIABILITY OF LEGAL PERSONS FOR CRIMINAL OFFENCES Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Based on Article
More informationL A W ON PUBLIC PROSECUTOR S OFFICE. Chapter One PRINCIPLES. Public Prosecutor s Office. Article 1
L A W ON PUBLIC PROSECUTOR S OFFICE Chapter One PRINCIPLES Public Prosecutor s Office Article 1 Public prosecutor s office is an autonomous state authority that shall prosecute perpetrators of criminal
More informationANNUAL COURT MONITORING REPORT
ANNUAL COURT MONITORING REPORT 2013 Table of Content 03 04 05 09 12 12 13 14 14 15 15 INTRODUCTION METHODOLOGY 1. Judiciary in 2013 difficulties during reform 2. Procedural violations 3. Minor offences
More informationLaw on the Protector of Human Rights and Freedoms of Montenegro
I. GENERAL PROVISIONS Law on the Protector of Human Rights and Freedoms of Montenegro Article 1 This law shall regulate the competency, authorizations and manner of working and procedure of the Protector
More informationTHE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT ACT (ZUstS)
THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT ACT (ZUstS) (Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, No. 64/07-official consolidated text and No. 109/12) I. GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1 (1) The Constitutional Court is
More informationSUPREME COURT. Prishtinë/Priština. Case number: PA II 11/2016 (P No. 938/13 Basic Court of Mitrovicë/Mitrovica) (PAKR No. 445/15 Court of Appeals)
SUPREME COURT Prishtinë/Priština Case number: PA II 11/2016 (P No. 938/13 Basic Court of Mitrovicë/Mitrovica) (PAKR No. 445/15 Court of Appeals) Date: 3 July 2017 IN THE NAME OF PEOPLE The Supreme Court
More informationTORTURE 1. NOTION OF TORTURE
Franciska Zhitia Ymeri Saranda Bogaj Sheremeti 1. NOTION OF TORTURE TORTURE Torture is an inhumane, demining and degrading act undertaken by an official person, an action done on purpose with the aim of
More informationON TRADEMARKS LAW ON TRADEMARKS CHAPTER I GENERAL PROVISIONS
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 04/L-026 ON TRADEMARKS Assembly of Republic of Kosovo; Based on article 65 (1) of Constitution of the Republic
More information*Please note that this translation is missing the following amendments to the Act: JUVENILE COURTS ACT. (Official Gazette no. 111/1997) PART ONE
Please note that the translation provided below is only provisional translation and therefore does NOT represent an official document of Republic of Croatia. It confers no rights and imposes no obligations
More information6. (amended, SG No. 102/2009, effective ) person with whom he/she is in a collateral relationship up to the fourth degree included;
Protection Against Domestic Violence Act (Title amended, SG No. 102/2009, effective 22.12.2009) Promulgated, State Gazette No. 27/29.03.2005, amended, SG No. 82/10.10.2006, amended and supplemented, SG
More informationAcronyms: - Case management system. - Council of Europe. Procedural Criminal Code of Kosovo. - Criminal Code of Kosovo
Acronyms: CMS CE PCCK CCK JCLK MP MPP DP DPP RP PPRK SPRK KJC MIA MJ - Case management system - Council of Europe Procedural Criminal Code of Kosovo - Criminal Code of Kosovo - Juvenile Criminal Law of
More informationCriminal Procedure Code No. 301/2005 Coll.
Criminal Procedure Code No. 301/2005 Coll. P A R T F I V E L E G A L R E L A T I O N S W I T H A B R O A D CHAPTER ONE BASIC PROVISIONS Section 477 Definitions For the purposes of this Chapter: a) an international
More informationRepublika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 04/L-209 ON AMNESTY Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Based on Article 65 (1 and 15) of the Constitution of
More informationALTERNATIVES TO CUSTODY FOR YOUNG OFFENDERS
ALTERNATIVES TO CUSTODY FOR YOUNG OFFENDERS NATIONAL REPORT ON JUVENILE JUSTICE TRENDS Latvia Ilona Kronberga Latvia Ilona Kronberga with the contribution of Sanita Sīle, Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
More informationACT ON THE RESPONSIBILITY OF LEGAL PERSONS FOR THE CRIMINAL OFFENCES
Please note that the translation provided below is only provisional translation and therefore does NOT represent an official document of the Republic of Croatia. It confers no rights and imposes no obligations
More informationAJJL Journal ISSN
THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM IN KOSOVO Dr. Sc. Hashim Çollaku Myrvete Çollaku According to scientist of democracy Thomas Carothers, The advancers of rule of law consider to take rule of law as an institutional
More informationCase No. KISS/18. Applicant. Jovan Jovanovic
REPUBLIKA E KOSOVES - PEIlYliJ1l1KA KOCOBO - REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHH CY.21: CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 11June 2018 Ref. No.: RK 1275/18 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY In Case
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
REPUBI.JKA E KOSOVES - PEnYD./lHKA KOCOBO - REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHII CY.l1: CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 8 May 2018 Ref.no.: RK 1230/18 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY III Case
More informationConference of European Constitutional Courts XIIth Congress
Conference of European Constitutional Courts XIIth Congress The relations between the Constitutional Courts and the other national courts, including the interference in this area of the action of the European
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
REPUBUKA E KOSOVES - PEUYBJIHKA KOCOBO - REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHH CYLI: CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 10 April 2018 Ref. No.: RK1209/18 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY III Case
More informationCOURT OF APPEALS PRISTINA. Basic Court: Pristina, PKR 955/13 Original: English
COURT OF APPEALS PRISTINA Case number: PAKR 397/14 Date: 24 March 2015 Basic Court: Pristina, PKR 955/13 Original: English The Court of Appeals, in a Panel composed of EULEX Court of Appeals judge Hajnalka
More informationEuropean Convention on Human Rights
European Convention on Human Rights as amended by Protocols Nos. 11 and 14 Council of Europe Treaty Series, No. 5 Note on the text The text of the Convention is presented as amended by the provisions of
More informationHuman rights an introduction
Human rights an introduction Moral or legal force? From the Universal Declaration to the European Convention Alison Riley What are human rights? Do you regularly watch the news? Do you sometimes read a
More informationAd Hoc Query on refusal of exit at border crossing points and on duration of stay. Requested by SI EMN NCP on 5 th August 2011
Ad Hoc Query on refusal of exit at border crossing points and on duration of stay Requested by SI EMN NCP on 5 th August 2011 Compilation produced on 11 th November 2011 Responses from Austria, Bulgaria,
More informationLAW ON THE COURT OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA
Strasbourg, 6 December 2000 Restricted CDL (2000) 106 Eng.Only EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW (VENICE COMMISSION) LAW ON THE COURT OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA 2 GENERAL
More informationJUDGMENT. Case No. KO 108/13. Applicants. Albulena Haxhiu and 12 other deputies of the Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo
Pristina, 9 September 2013 Ref.no.:AGJ471/13 JUDGMENT in Case No. KO 108/13 Applicants Albulena Haxhiu and 12 other deputies of the Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo Constitutional review of the Law,
More informationProposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, XXX COM(2013) 822/2 Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on procedural safeguards for children suspected or accused in criminal proceedings
More informationLimitation periods in claims for wrongful conviction, temporary arrest or detention. Magdalena Makieła 1
Limitation periods in claims for wrongful conviction, temporary arrest or detention by Magdalena Makieła 1 There is no justice system capable of avoiding errors, but there must be one to compensate them.
More informationACCOUNTABILITY FOR HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS ACT ( Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia No. 58/2003)
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS ACT ( Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia No. 58/2003) I GENERAL PROVISIONS Subject of the Law Article 1 This Law shall regulate and/or determine: - types
More informationFIFTH SECTION. CASE OF MIHELJ v. SLOVENIA. (Application no /07) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG. 15 January 2015 FINAL 15/04/2015
FIFTH SECTION CASE OF MIHELJ v. SLOVENIA (Application no. 14204/07) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 15 January 2015 FINAL 15/04/2015 This judgment has become final under Article 44 2 of the Convention. It may be subject
More informationSUPREME COURT. Case number: Plm. Kzz. 178/2016 (PKR. No 1046/2013 Basic Court of Prishtinë/Priština) (PAKR 216/2015 Court of Appeals)
SUPREME COURT Case number: Plm. Kzz. 178/2016 (PKR. No 1046/2013 Basic Court of Prishtinë/Priština) (PAKR 216/2015 Court of Appeals) Date: 19 December 2016 IN THE NAME OF PEOPLE The Supreme Court of Kosovo,
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
Prishtina, 01.08. 2016 Ref. no.: RK 970/16 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY in Case No. KI122/15 Applicant Tarkett LLC Constitutional review of Judgment No. AC-I.-14-0169-A0001 of the Appellate Panel of the
More informationTHE CONSTITUTIONAL ACT ON THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA I. GENERAL PROVISIONS. Article 1
THE CONSTITUTIONAL ACT ON THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA Published in Narodne novine, no. 49/02 of May 3, 2002 I. GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1 This Constitutional Act regulates conditions
More informationCROATIAN PARLIAMENT. Pursuant to Article 88 of the Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, I hereby pass a DECISION
88 11 October 2001 Law on Associations CROATIAN PARLIAMENT Pursuant to Article 88 of the Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, I hereby pass a DECISION ON THE PROCLAMATION OF THE LAW ON ASSOCIATIONS
More informationFair trial based on penal legislation of Kosovo
Fair trial based on penal legislation of Kosovo Abstract PhD (C) Mirvete Uka University Hasan Pristina, Kosovo Fair trial is the main principle or as is often said principle above principles on penal procedure.
More informationOpinions adopted by the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention at its seventy-ninth session, August 2017
Advance Edited Version Distr.: General 2 October 2017 Original: English Human Rights Council Working Group on Arbitrary Detention Opinions adopted by the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention at its seventy-ninth
More informationTITLE II CONCEPT OF A TRADEMARK AND REGISTRATION PROHIBITIONS
SPAIN Trademark Act Law No. 17/2001 of December 7, 2001 (Consolidated Text Including the Amendments Made by Law 20/2003, of July 7, 2003, on Legal Protection of Industrial Designs) TABLE OF CONTENTS TITLE
More informationReferring to Article 110 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo and the Law on Kosovo Prosecutorial Council (Nr.03/L-244)
Referring to Article 110 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo and the Law on Kosovo Prosecutorial Council (Nr.03/L-244) Recalling internationally recognized human rights standards and fundamental
More informationChapter 16: Right to Review the Legality of Any Deprivation of Liberty
481 Chapter 16: Right to Review the Legality of Any Deprivation of Liberty General Commentary The provisions of Chapter 16 apply not only to any deprivation of liberty whatsoever but also to deprivation
More informationBASIC COURT OF PRISHTINË/PRIŠTINA. C. no. 2147/09
BASIC COURT OF PRISHTINË/PRIŠTINA C. no. 2147/09 THE BASIC COURT OF PRISHTINË/PRIŠTINA, through EULEX Judge Franciska Fiser, acting upon decision of EULEX Judge delegated by the President of the Assembly
More informationGuaranteeing the Judgment of Civil Cases Within a Reasonable Time as a Requirement of the Right to a Fair Trial in Albania
Guaranteeing the Judgment of Civil Cases Within a Reasonable Time as a Requirement of the Right to a Fair Trial in Albania Msc. Beslinda Rrugia University Aleksdandër Moisiu Durrës rrugiab@gmail.com Msc.
More informationGeneral Principles of Administrative Law
General Principles of Administrative Law 7 Administrative Procedure and Individual Rights Univ.-Prof. Dr. Ulrich Stelkens Chair for Public Law, German and European Administrative Law 7 Administrative Procedure
More informationON PROTECTION AGAINST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE LAW ON PROTECTION AGAINST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CHAPTER I GENERAL PROVISIONS. Article 1 Purpose of the Law
OFFICIAL GAZETTE OF THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVA / PRISTINA: YEAR V / No. 76 / 10 AUGUST 2010 Law No.03/L 182 ON PROTECTION AGAINST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE Assembly of Republic of Kosovo, Pursuant to Article 65 (1)
More informationCOUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS FIRST SECTION. CASE OF KUTIĆ v. CROATIA. (Application no /99) JUDGMENT
CONSEIL DE L EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS FIRST SECTION CASE OF KUTIĆ v. CROATIA (Application no. 48778/99) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 1 March
More informationImmigration Act 2014 Article 8 ECHR
Immigration Enforcement Immigration Act 2014 Article 8 ECHR Presented by Criminality Policy Team 2) Aims and Objectives Aim to explain the new Article 8 provisions in the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum
More informationADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES, CODE PROCEDURAT ADMINISTRATIVE, KOD
Project funded by the European Union ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES, CODE PROCEDURAT ADMINISTRATIVE, KOD DISCLAIMER Please note that the translation provided below is only provisional translation and therefore
More informationCOUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 19 March /08 PI 14
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 19 March 2008 7728/08 PI 14 WORKING DOCUMT from: Presidency to: Working Party on Intellectual Property (Patents) No. prev. doc. : 7001/08 PI 10 Subject : European
More informationCODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 1. According to Article 201 from the Law amending the Code of Criminal Procedure ( Official Gazette of the
CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 1 According to Article 201 from the Law amending the Code of Criminal Procedure ( Official Gazette of the Republic of Macedonia, No. 74/2004), the Legislative Committee of the
More informationRULE ON LICENSING OF ENERGY ACTIVITIES IN KOSOVO
Rule ERO/No. 07/2017 RULE ON LICENSING OF ENERGY ACTIVITIES IN KOSOVO Prishtina, 31 March 2017 Address: Str. Dervish Rozhaja nr. 12, 10000 Prishtina, Kosovo Tel: 038 247 615 ext. 101, Fax: 038 247 620,
More information(Notices) NOTICES FROM EUROPEAN UNION INSTITUTIONS, BODIES, OFFICES AND AGENCIES EUROPEAN COMMISSION
C 277 I/4 EN Official Journal of the European Union 7.8.2018 IV (Notices) NOTICES FROM EUROPEAN UNION INSTITUTIONS, BODIES, OFFICES AND AGENCIES EUROPEAN COMMISSION Guidance Note Questions and Answers:
More informationTHE LAND ADJUDICATION ACT, Arrangement of Sections PART II. OFFICERS 4. Appointment and general powers of officers PART III
THE LAND ADJUDICATION ACT, 2000 Arrangement of Sections Section PART I PRELIMINARY AND APPLICATION 1. Short title and commencement 2. Interpretation 3. Minister to declare adjudication area PART II OFFICERS
More informationWELSH LANGUAGE MEASURE 2007
A Measure approved by the National Assembly for Wales to provide that the Welsh language, being the native language of Wales, shall be an official language in Wales; to give to the people of Wales the
More informationEuropean Convention on Human Rights
European Convention on Human Rights European Convention on Human Rights as amended by Protocols Nos. 11 and 14 supplemented by Protocols Nos. 1, 4, 6, 7, 12 and 13 The text of the Convention is presented
More informationREPIlRJ.lKA E KOSO\'f.'i - I'En T>.,lllh:" "oeoro - REl'tTRI.Jr OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHM CY.U CONSTITUTIONAL COURT.
.. " REPIlRJ.lKA E KOSO\'f.'i - I'En T>.,lllh:" "oeoro - REl'tTRI.Jr OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHM CY.U CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Pristine, 15 May 2012 Ref. No.: AK 234 /12 Case K038/12 Assessment of
More informationCOURT OF APPEALS PRISTINA. Basic Court: Gjilan, PKR 56/13 Original: English
COURT OF APPEALS PRISTINA Case number: PAKR 259/14 Date: 22 May 2015 Basic Court: Gjilan, PKR 56/13 Original: English The Court of Appeals, in a Panel composed of EULEX Court of Appeals judge Hajnalka
More informationLAW ON AMENDING AND SUPPLEMENTING THE LAW NO. 03/L-223 ON THE KOSOVO. Based on Article 65 (1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo, Article 1
Law No. 05/L-033 ON AMENDING AND SUPPLEMENTING THE LAW NO. 03/L-223 ON THE KOSOVO JUDICIAL COUNCIL Assembly of Republic of Kosovo; Based on Article 65 (1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo,
More informationRepublika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly
Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosovo - Republic of Kosovo Kuvendi - Skupština - Assembly Law No. 05/L-103 ON AMENDING AND SUPPLEMENTING THE LAWS RELATED TO THE MANDATE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION RULE OF LAW
More informationSTATE ENTERPRISE LABOUR RELATIONS ACT, B.E (2000)
Unofficial Translation* STATE ENTERPRISE LABOUR RELATIONS ACT, B.E. 2543 (2000) BHUMIBOL ADULYADEJ, REX. Given on the 23rd Day of March B.E. 2543; Being the 55th Year of the Present Reign. His Majesty
More informationPOLAND ACT ON THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR S OFFICE
Strasbourg, 29 September 2017 Opinion No. 892 / 2017 Engl. only EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW (VENICE COMMISSION) POLAND ACT ON THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR S OFFICE This document will not be
More informationIndustrial Design Rights Law. (Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law No ) ( ), ( ), Chapter I. Title, Effective Date and Definition
Pyidaungsu Hluttaw enacted this Law. Industrial Design Rights Law (Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law No ) ( ), ( ), 2017 Chapter I Title, Effective Date and Definition 1. This Law shall be called the Industrial Design
More informationUniversal Periodic Review of Bosnia and Herzegovina Stakeholder s submission
Universal Periodic Review of Bosnia and Herzegovina Stakeholder s submission Constitutional order Bosnia and Herzegovina has made firm pledges to the effect that the attainment of full respect for human
More informationRESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY
REPUBUKA E Kosovi:'s ~ PErrY6JIl1KA KOCOHO ~ RF.PUlU.IC OF KOSOVO GJYKATA KUSHTETUESE YCTABHlf CY.lI. CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Prishtina, on 11 June 2018 Ref. No.: RK.268/.8 RESOLUTION ON INADMISSIBILITY in
More informationThe Law on Gender Equality in Kosovo
UNITED NATIONS United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo UNMIK Mission d Administration NATIONS UNIES Intérimaire des Nations Unies au Kosovo PROVISIONAL INSTITUTIONS OF SELF GOVERNMENT Law
More informationLAW ON PERMANENT AND TEMPORARY RESIDENCE OF CITIZENS OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA. Official Gazette of BiH, no. 32/01
The translation of BiH legislation has no legal force and should be used solely for informational purposes. Only legislation published in the Official Gazettes in BiH is legally binding Pursuant to Article
More informationTRADING ON NATIONAL ROAD OR IN BUILDING RESTRICTION AREA
CHAPTER 15 TRADING ON NATIONAL ROAD OR IN BUILDING RESTRICTION AREA 15.1 OVERVIEW 2 15.2 AUTHORITY OF THE SANRAL 2 15.3 RESTRICTIONS PLACED ON THE SANRAL 4 15.4 POLICIES AND PROCEDURES IN RESPECT OF ILLEGAL
More informationAd-Hoc Query on Revoking Citizenship on Account of Involvement in Acts of Terrorism or Other Serious Crimes
Ad-Hoc Query on Revoking Citizenship on Account of Involvement in Acts of Terrorism or Other Serious Crimes Requested by FI EMN NCP on 26 st August 2014 Compilation produced on 25 th of September 2014
More informationGuidance on Immigration Bail for Judges of the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber)
Tribunals Judiciary Judge Clements, President of the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Presidential Guidance Note No 1 of 2018 Guidance on Immigration Bail for Judges of the First-tier
More informationThe Scope and the Challenges of the Access of Children to Justice in Macedonian Legislation and Practice
The Scope and the Challenges of the Access of Children to Justice in Macedonian Legislation and Practice Aleksandra Deanoska, PhD, Associate Professor Faculty of Law Iustinianus Primus, Criminal Law Department,
More informationCRIMINAL CODE OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA (KZ-1) GENERAL PART. Chapter One FUNDAMENTAL PROVISIONS. Imposition of Criminal Liability Article 1
CRIMINAL CODE OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA (KZ-1) GENERAL PART Chapter One FUNDAMENTAL PROVISIONS Imposition of Criminal Liability Article 1 (1) Criminal liability in the Republic of Slovenia may be imposed
More informationSubversive Activities Prevention Act
Subversive Activities Prevention Act (Act No. 240 of July 21, 1952) Table of Contents Chapter I General Provisions (Articles 1 to 4) Chapter II Control on Subversive Organizations (Articles 5 to 10) Chapter
More informationD E C I S I O N HELD:
THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT No: U-I-284/94 Date: February the 4 th, 1999 D E C I S I O N Following the procedure for verification of constitutionality, based on the initiative of
More informationCOUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
CONSEIL DE L EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COURT (CHAMBER) CASE OF ISGRÒ v. ITALY (Application no. 11339/85) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 19 February
More informationHaving deliberated, makes the following findings and recommendations:
OPINION Date of adoption: 26 November 2010 Case No. 02/08 Nexhmedin SPAHIU against UNMIK The Human Rights Advisory Panel sitting on 26 November 2010 with the following members present: Mr Marek NOWICKI,
More informationBylaws. Grain and General Services Union (ILWU Canada)
Bylaws Grain and General Services Union (ILWU Canada) as approved by the members of the Union effective January 1, 2010 and as amended by delegates to GSU s 2014 Biennial Policy Convention effective March
More informationAttachment 1 to Submission of the National Whistleblowers Center to the UN Universal Periodic Review
Attachment 1 to Submission of the National Whistleblowers Center to the UN Universal Periodic Review 1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth
More informationPractice Guide for the application of the new Brussels II Regulation.
EN Practice Guide for the application of the new Brussels II Regulation www.europa.eu.int/civiljustice Introduc tion The European Union s area of freedom, security and justice helps people in their daily
More information