Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document 289 Filed 09/18/12 Page 1 of 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Transcription

1 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document 289 Filed 09/18/12 Page 1 of 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, v. Plaintiff, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and ERIC H. HOLDER, JR., in his official capacity as Attorney General, Case No. 1:12-cv-203 (CKK-BMK-JDB) Defendants, and JAMES DUBOSE, et al., Defendant-Intervenors. SOUTH CAROLINA S NOTICE OF FILING FINAL EXHIBIT LIST Plaintiff, the State of South Carolina, hereby electronically files its Final Exhibit List, pursuant to the Court s September 10, 2012 Order Amending the Court s August 28, 2012 Order (Doc. 251). The Final Exhibit List is attached hereto.

2 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document 289 Filed 09/18/12 Page 2 of 3 Respectfully submitted, Hon. Alan Wilson ATTORNEY GENERAL OF SOUTH CAROLINA Bryan Stirling DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL Rembert Dennis Building Room Assembly Street Columbia, SC (803) s/h. Christopher Bartolomucci Paul D. Clement (DC Bar No ) H. Christopher Bartolomucci (DC Bar No ) Stephen V. Potenza (admitted pro hac vice) Jeffrey M. Harris (admitted pro hac vice) Brian J. Field (DC Bar No ) D. Zachary Hudson (admitted pro hac vice) Michael H. McGinley (DC Bar No ) BANCROFT PLLC 1919 M Street, N.W., Suite 470 Washington, D.C (202) Karl S. Bowers, Jr. (admitted pro hac vice) WOMBLE CARLYLE SANDRIDGE & RICE 1727 Hampton Street Columbia, SC (803) Date: September 18, 2012 H. Christopher Coates (admitted pro hac vice) LAW OFFICE OF H. CHRISTOPHER COATES 934 Compass Point Charleston, SC (843) Counsel for the State of South Carolina

3 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document 289 Filed 09/18/12 Page 3 of 3 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on September 18, 2012, I filed the foregoing notice with the Court s electronic filing system, which will provide notice to all counsel of record. /s/ H. Christopher Bartolomucci H. Christopher Bartolomucci (D.C. Bar No )

4 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 1 of 13 1 Act R54 n/a JA-US SC_ , 2, 3, 17, 21- JA-US SC_ , 23, 26, 28, 2 Legislative History of H.3418 n/a JA_ JA_001025; SC_ SC_ JA-DI JA- (with gaps) DI (excerpts) 3 Legislative History of H.3003 n/a JA_ JA_ Legislative History of S.1 n/a JA_ JA_ Legislative History of S.334 n/a JA_ JA_ SC_ SC_ (with gaps) SC_ SC_ ; SC_ ; SC_ SC_ , 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 20, 21, 22, 23, 39, 40, 41, 45, 51, 53, 55, 56, 58, 60, 62, 63, 64, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 88, 90, 104, 106, 107, 110, , 131, 133, 136, 139, 140, 141, 144, 151, 152, 155, 156, 162, 163, 168, 170, 172, 175, 178, 180, 182, 188, 190, 191, 193, 195, 196, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 215, 218, 219, 230, 234, 235, , 132, , 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 12, 13, 14, 15, 30 2, 3, 5, 18, 20, 28, 29, 30 30, 33, Def- 7, 10

5 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 2 of 13 6 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 1/20/10 JA_ SC_ JA_002461; SC_ JA-US JA-US (excerpts) 7 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 1/26/10 JA_ JA_002535; JA-US JA-US (excerpts) 8 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 1/27/10 JA_ JA_003031; JA-US JA-US (excerpts) 9 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 1/28/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/2/10 JA_ JA_003254; JA-US JA-US Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/3/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 5/11/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 5/12/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 6/15/10 JA_ JA_004417; JA-US JA-US (excerpts) 15 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 6/16/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 10/27/10 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Committee 3/26/09 JA_ JA_001925; JA-US JA-US (excerpts) SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ SC_ S&CTR S&CTR , , , , Def-

6 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 3 of Transcript of Senate Committee 4/2/09 JA_ S&CTR , JA_001952; S&CTR JA-US JA-US (excerpts) 19 Transcript of Senate Committee 4/16/09 JA_ JA_002080; JA-US JA-US (excerpts) SC_ SC_ , Transcript of Senate Committee 5/7/09 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Committee 5/12/09 JA_ SC_ JA_ SC_ Transcript of Senate Committee 5/14/09 JA-SC JA-SC 0140 S&CTR S&CTR Transcript from Conference Committee 5/19/10 JA_ S&CTR , , 97 JA_ S&CTR Transcript from Conference Committee 5/26/10 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript from Conference Committee 6/2/10 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript from Conference Committee 6/3/10 JA-SC JA-SC 0187 SC_ SC_ Transcript of House Legislative Session 1/18/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of House Legislative Session 1/25/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of House Legislative Session 1/26/11 JA_ SC1-# v , 32 JA_ Transcript of House Legislative Session 1/27/11 JA_ SC1-# v Def- 31 Transcript of House Legislative Session 4/6/11 JA_ JA_ Transcript of House Legislative Session 4/26/11 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/8/11 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/9/11 JA_ JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/10/11 JA_ JA_ SC1-# v SC1-# v S&CTR S&CTR S&CTR S&CTR S&CTR S&CTR

7 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 4 of 13 Def- 36 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/15/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/16/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/17/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/22/11 JA_ S&CTR JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/23/11 JA_ SC1: JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 2/24/11 JA_ SC1: JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 4/13/11 JA_ SC1: JA_ Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 4/14/11 The State hereby withdraws the designation of this exhibit 44 Transcript of Senate Legislative Session 5/11/11 JA_ SC1: JA_ Transcript of Senate Committee 1/6/11 JA_ S&CTR , , 130 JA_ S&CTR Transcript of Senate Committee 2/1/11 JA_ S&CTR , , 160 JA_ S&CTR Building Confidence in U.S. Elections, Report of the Commission on Federal 9/2005 JA-SC JA-SC 0300 SC_ SC_ Election Reform 48 Revitalizing our Nation s Election System 11/6/01 JA-SC JA-SC 0430 SC_ SC_ Declaration of M.V. Hood III and 6/19/12 JA_ exhibits JA_ Supplemental Declaration of M.V. Hood 7/28/12 JA_ , 32, 34 7, 8 III and exhibits JA_ Rebuttal Declaration of M.V. Hood III 8/3/12 JA_ , 9, 12 and exhibits JA_ Declaration of Scott Eugene Buchanan, 8/6/12 JA_ , 21 Ph.D. and exhibits JA_ Declaration of Orville Vernon Burton and exhibits 6/19/12 JA_ JA_ Supplemental Report of Orville Vernon Burton and exhibits 7/26/12 JA_ JA_ , 21

8 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 5 of Declaration of Charles Stewart III, Ph.D. 6/26/12 JA_ and exhibits JA_ Rebuttal Declaration of Charles Stewart 8/6/12 JA_ , 35 III, Ph.D. and exhibits JA_ Declaration of Theodore Arrington, 6/19/12 JA_ Ph.D. and exhibits JA_ Curriculum Vitae of Theodore 6/19/12 JA_ Arrington, Ph.D. JA_ Supplemental Declaration of Theodore 7/28/12 JA_ S. Arrington Ph.D. and exhibits JA_ Def- 60 Rebuttal Declaration of Theodore S. Arrington, Ph.D. and exhibits 61 Declaration of Andrew D. Martin, Ph.D. and exhibits 62 Supplemental Report of Andrew D. Martin, Ph.D. and exhibits 63 Declaration of Kevin M. Quinn, Ph.D. and exhibits 64 Rebuttal Declaration of Kevin M. Quinn, Ph.D. and exhibits 65 M.V. Hood III and Charles S. Bullock III, An Empirical Assessment of the Georgia Voter Identification Statute 66 Kenyda Bailey Georgia Registration Material 8/6/12 JA_ JA_ /19/12 JA_ JA_ /28/12 JA_ JA_ /18/12 JA_ JA_ /6/12 JA_ JA_ Mar JA-US JA-US ; JA-SC JA-SC /3/12 JA-SC 0465 SCNAACP Voter Registration Card of Delores Freelon 68 Attention SC Voters, SC Progressive Network Press Release 69 On May 28, 2011, Gov. Haley signed the nation s most restrictive voter photo ID law, SC Progressive Network Press Release 70 South Carolina just passed the nation s most restrictive voter photo ID law, SC Progressive Network Press Release n/a JA-SC 0466; JA-DI n/a JA-SC 0467; JA-DI n/a JA-SC 0468; JA-DI n/a JA-SC 0469; JA-DI ACLU_ ACLU_ ACLU_

9 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 6 of from B. Bursey to Ronald and 7/13/11 JA-SC ACLU_ Mary Bain JA-SC 0471; ACLU_ JA-DI JA- DI Karen Rutherford, "Making it Harder for 5/18/12 JA-SC Poor People, Black People and College JA-SC 0473; Students to Vote," ACLU JA-DI JA- DI Declaration of Mozelle Hughes 4/19/12 JA-SC 0474; ACLU_ JA-DI Declaration of Willie Blair 5/16/11 JA-SC 0475 USA_ Declaration of Raymond Rutherford 5/16/11 JA-SC 0476 USA_ Declaration of Thelma Hodge 4/11/12 JA-SC 0477 ACLU_ Declaration of Cathline Jennings 4/13/12 JA-SC 0478; ACLU_ JA-DI Declaration of Donna Suggs Dubose 3/2/12 JA-SC 0479 ACLU_ Voter Registration and Election SC_ Commission Handbook SC_ State Election Commission's Absentee Voting in South Carolina Poster (web version) 81 State Election Commission's Newspaper Advertisement Publicizing Act R54 Requirements 82 State Election Commission's Poster Publicizing Act R54 Requirements 6/1/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0631; JA-DI JA- DI /13/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0633 SC_ SC_ , 21 12/13/11 JA-SC 0634 SC_ /13/11 JA-SC 0635 SC_ Def- 83 State Election Commission's Handout Publicizing Act R54 Requirements 12/13/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0637 SC_ SC_ , State Election Commission's Internet Advertisement Publicizing Act R54 Requirements 12/13/11 JA-SC 0638 SC_ , State Election Commission's "Voting in South Carolina Poster" 12/13/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0640 SC_ SC_ State Election Commission's provisional ballot under Act R54 JA-SC JA-SC 0643 USA_ USA_ , 7

10 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 7 of 13 Def- 87 Procedure for Issuing Photo Voter 4/26/12 JA-SC USA_ , 22 3 Registration Cards JA-SC 0646; JA-US JA-US USA_ Photo ID Voter Education Plan JA-SC JA-SC 0663; JA-DI JA- DI 02340; JA-US JA-US USA_ USA_ , 26, 27 3, 20, Voter Education Postcard JA-SC JA-SC 0665; USA_ USA_ ; ; 506 JA-DI JA- SC_ DI 02342; SC_ JA-DI JA- DI 03469; JA-US JA-US Poll Manager's Handbook Supplement JA-SC 0666 USA_ , South Carolina Attorney General's Opinion Interpreting Act R54's Reasonable Impediment Exception 92 Letter from Marci Andino to Sonny Jones re: administrative preclearance 8/16/11 JA-SC JA-SC /29/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0707 SC_ SC_ USA_ USA_ , 22, 23 3, 5 5, 6, 7 93 Press Release, State Election Commission Calls for Investigation into Allegations of Voter Fraud 94 from State Budget and Control Board to the State Election Commission approving the Election Commission's request to "carry forward" funds for implementing Act R54 1/11/12 JA-SC 0708 SC_ /1/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0718; JA DI 03450; JA- US JA- US SC_ SC_ Letter from Marci Andino to Sonny Jones re: "inactive" status 10/25/11 JA-SC USA_ JA-SC 0720; USA_ JA-DI JA- DI 02345; JA-US JA-US

11 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 8 of Letter from Marci Andino to Sonny 1/10/12 JA-SC SC_ Jones re: creation of list under Section 8 JA-SC 0723; SC_ ; of Act R54 JA-US SC_ South Carolina Election Commission Poll Managers Handbook 98 South Carolina Notary Public Reference Manual 99 Reasonable Impediment / Religious Objection Procedures JA-US /1/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0785; JA-US JA-US SC_ SC_ SC_ (2010 version of document) 2010 JA-SC JA-SC 0828; JA-US JA-US ; JA-DI JA- DI /13/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0832; JA DI JA DI 03473; JA- US JA- US SC_ SC_ Voter Education Postcard 8/14/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0835; JA DI JA DI 03469; JA- US JA- US SC_ SC_ Resolving Issues with Identification, State Election Commission, Poll Manager Training Document 102 Letter from Marci Andino to Kevin Shwedo regarding methodology for comparing the State's voter registration list with the DMV ID list 9/10/08 JA-SC JA-SC 0837; JA-DI JA- DI SC_ SC_ /22/11 JA-SC 0838 SC_ , Def- 103 United States Citizen's Checklist for First Time Issuance of Driver's License, Beginner's Permit, and Identification Card JA-SC SC_ JA-SC 0840; SC_ ; JA-DI JA- SC_ DI SC_

12 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 9 of South Carolina Department of Motor 5/17/12 JA-SC Vehicles, Office Locations, Hours and JA-SC 0862; Wait Times JA-DI JA- 105 State Law Enforcement Division, Investigative Report regarding alleged election fraud in Dillon County DI /13/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0864 SC_ SC_ Def- 106 State Law Enforcement Division, Investigative Report regarding alleged election fraud in Marion County 12/7/11 JA-SC JA-SC 0866 SC_ SC_ Conviction documents in Richland v. Campbell 2/29/08 JA-SC JA-SC 0869 SC_ SC_ Indictment in Richland v. Campbell 6/12/07 JA-SC JA-SC 0877 SC_ SC_ Letter from Alan Wilson to William 1/19/12 JA-SC 0878 SC_ Nettles discussing potential voter fraud in South Carolina 110 Defendant-Intervenors' Responses and Objections to South Carolina's Requests for Admissions 7/31/12 JA-SC JA-SC United States' Responses to the State of South Carolina's Requests for Admissions 112 United States' Objections and Responses to South Carolina's First Set of Interrogatories to the United States 7/31/12 JA-SC JA-SC /16/12 JA-SC JA-SC United States' Objections and Responses to South Carolina's First Set of Interrogatories to the United States and Defendant-Intervenors 5/16/12 JA-SC JA-SC Defendant-Intervenors' Responses and Objections to South Carolina's First Set of Interrogatories to Defendant- Intervenors 5/9/12 JA-SC JA-SC 0965

13 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 10 of Defendant-Intervenors' Responses and 5/9/12 JA-SC Objections to South Carolina's First Set JA-SC 0980 of Interrogatories to the United States and Defendant-Intervenors Def- 116 Defendant-Intervenors' Supplemental Responses to South Carolina's First Set of Interrogatories to Defendant- Intervenors 5/16/12 JA-SC JA-SC Letter from Adam Harris providing supplemental reponse of Kenyda Bailey to South Carolina's Interrogatory to Defendant-Intervenors No. 7 7/19/12 JA-SC JA-SC South Carolina's Responses to Defendant-Intervenors' First Set of Interrogatories 119 South Carolina's Supplemental Response to Defendant-Intervenors' Interrogatory No Letter from Department of Justice denying preclearance of Act R Letter from Department of Justice preclearing Sections 1 and 3 of Act R54 and requesting more information on the remaining Sections of Act R54 5/16/12 JA-SC JA-SC 1024; JA-DI JA- DI 01922; JA-US JA-US /8/12 JA-SC JA-SC /23/11 JA-SC JA-SC 1035; JA-US JA-US /29/11 JA-SC JA-SC 1040 USA_ USA_ USA_ USA_ , Letter from Gerald Malloy to the Department of Justice 12/20/11 JA-SC JA-SC 1044 USA_ USA_ ; USA_ USA_

14 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 11 of Letter from Gerald Malloy to the 8/25/11 JA-SC USA_ Department of Justice JA-SC 1058; USA_ JA-DI JA- DI Letter from John C. Land III 7/11/11 JA-SC JA-SC from Heather Anderson and attachments 126 Village of Arlington Heights et al. v. Metropolitan Housing Development Corp. 127 William Crawford et al. v. Marion County Election Bd. 1/22/10 JA-SC JA-SC 1066; JA-DI JA- DI 02002; JA-US JA-US /11/77 JA-SC JA-SC /28/08 JA-SC JA-SC United States v. Charleston County 3/6/03 JA-SC JA-SC United States v. Ike Brown 6/29/07 JA-SC JA-SC Glover v. South Carolina Democratic 9/30/04 JA-SC Party, No. 4:04-CV-2171, 2004 WL JA-SC (D.S.C. Sept. 30, 2004) USA_ USA_ SC_ SC_ Def- 131 Reaves v. South Carolina Democratic Party, No. 04:04-CV-2047, 2007 WL (D.S.C. Mar. 21, 2007) 3/21/07 JA-SC JA-SC Dawn Hinshaw, Eastover mayor guilty; chief cleared: Campbell sentenced to 18 months for forgery, misconduct, Columbia State, Mar. 1, 2008, Section b. 3/1/08 JA-SC JA-SC Scott Dodd & Ted Mellnik, Voters Found on Both N.C., S.C. Rolls: Miscount, Fraud Possible as Elections Officials Not Cross-Checking Lists, Charlotte Observer, Oct. 24, 2004, at 1A 10/24/04 JA-SC JA-SC 1188

15 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 12 of State of South Carolina v. Terrence 6/22/06 JA-SC 1189 Hines, Case No. H (Twelfth Judicial Circuit Court) (available at Florence County Twelfth Circuit Public Index) (June 22, 2006) (Guilty Plea Record Fraudulent Registration or Voting) Def- 135 State of South Carolina v. Terrence Hines, Case No. H (Twelfth Judicial Circuit Court) (available at Florence County Twelfth Circuit Public Index) (June 22, 2006) (Sentencing Record) 6/22/06 JA-SC South Carolina Senate Rule 33 JA-SC 1191; JA-DI Alvarez, et al., Voter Opinions about 2011 JA-SC Election Reform: Do They Support Making Voting More Convenient?, Election Law Journal, Vol. 10, No. 2 (2011) JA-SC Demonstrative: Voter Identification JA-SC , 4, 7 Timeline 139 Demonstrative: Comparison of Voter Identification Legislation The State hereby withdraws the designation of this exhibit 140 Demonstrative: Hood Tables & Exhibits JA-SC JA-SC from Dwight James to Gladys Wallace forwarding an from Carolyn Reed Smith re planned response to the voter ID law 7/21/11 JA-SC JA-SC 1458; SCNAACP JA-DI JA- SCNAACP DI Letter from South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP to T. Christian Herren at DOJ about rejecting Act R54 8/29/11 JA-SC JA-SC 1462; SCNAACP JA-DI JA- SCNAACP DI

16 Case 1:12-cv CKK-BMK-JDB Document Filed 09/18/12 Page 13 of LWV Action Alert: Protect South 25 Carolina Citizens' Access to Voting 144 from Carole Cato to Dwight James about procedures for students to register to vote 3/16/09 JA-SC JA-SC 1464; JA-DI JA- DI /8/11 JA-SC 1465; JA-DI SCNAACP SCNAACP SCNAACP Def-