MAO Jianwen, CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT
|
|
- Branden Atkinson
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 MAO Jianwen, A Case of Refusing to Carry Out a Judgment or Ruling Guiding Case No. 71 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on December 28, 2016) CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT English Guiding Case (EGC71) May 16, 2018 Edition The citation of this translation of this Guiding Case is: 毛建文拒不执行判决 裁定案 (MAO Jianwen, A Case of Refusing to Carry Out a Judgment or Ruling), STANFORD LAW SCHOOL CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT, English Guiding Case (EGC71), May 16, 2018 Edition, The original, Chinese version of this case is available at 最高人民法院网 ( See also 最高人民法院关于发布第 15 批指导性案例的通知 (Notice of the Supreme People s Court on the Release of the 15 th Batch of Guiding Cases), issued on and effective as of Dec. 28, 2016, This document was primarily prepared by Sean Webb and Dr. Mei Gechlik; it was finalized by Sean Webb, Dimitri Phillips, and Dr. Mei Gechlik. Minor editing, such as splitting long paragraphs, adding a few words included in square brackets, and boldfacing the headings, was done to make the piece more comprehensible to readers; all footnotes, unless otherwise noted, have been added by the China Guiding Cases Project. The following text is otherwise a direct translation of the original text released by the Supreme People s Court.
2 2 Keywords Criminal Crime of Refusing to Carry Out a Judgment or Ruling Start Time Main Points of the Adjudication The time from which [a person] has the ability to carry out a judgment or ruling but refuses to carry it out starts when the judgment or ruling comes into legal effect. Where, after the coming into legal effect of a judgment or ruling which has enforcement content, a person with the obligation to carry out [the judgment or ruling commits] an act of refusing to carry [it] out, including hiding, transferring, or intentionally damaging property, making it impossible [for a people s court] to enforce the judgment or ruling, and the circumstances are serious, [the person] should be convicted of and punished for the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling. Related Legal Rule(s) Article 313 of the Criminal Law of the People s Republic of China 1 Basic Facts of the Case On December 11, 2012, the Pingyang County People s Court of [Wenzhou Municipality,] Zhejiang Province[,] rendered the (2012) Wen Ping Ao Shang Chu Zi No. 595 Civil Judgment, ordering defendant MAO Jianwen to repay, within 15 days of the judgment s coming into effect, 2 CHEN Xianyin RMB 200,000, an amount invested in [MAO Jianwen s] Wenzhou Hongyuan 1 中华人民共和国刑法 (Criminal Law of the People s Republic of China), passed on July 1, 1979, issued on July 6, 1979, effective as of Jan. 1, 1980, revised on Mar. 14, 1997, effective as of Oct. 1, 1997, amended ten times, most recently on Nov. 4, 2017, effective as of Nov. 4, 2017, Given that the original judgment of this Guiding Case was rendered in June 2014 (see below), the Criminal Law referred to in this Guiding Case should mean the law as amended by Amendment VIII. See 中华人民共和国刑法修正案( 八 ) (Amendment (VIII) to the Criminal Law of the People s Republic of China), passed and issued on Feb. 25, 2011, effective as of May 1, 2011, Amendment IX of the Criminal Law amended Article 313 by adding other content, but the content that is relevant to this Guiding Case remains unchanged. 2 The original text reads 判决生效 ( the judgment s coming into effect ). According to Article 155 of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China, judgments and rulings that have come into effect are judgments and rulings of the Supreme People s Court as well as judgments and rulings which, according to law, may not be appealed or which have not been appealed within the prescribed time limit. See 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法 (Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China), passed on, issued on, and effective as of Apr. 9, 1991, amended three times, most recently on June 27, 2017, effective as of July 1, 2017,
3 3 Packaging Products Co., Ltd., plus interest. The judgment came into effect on January 6, Because MAO Jianwen did not, on his 3 own initiative, perform the obligation as determined in the effective legal document, CHEN Xianyin applied to the Pingyang County People s Court on February 16, 2013, for compulsory enforcement. After the case was registered, the Pingyang County People s Court ascertained during enforcement that, on January 17, 2013, MAO Jianwen resold his small and ordinary passenger vehicle [bearing the license plate] Zhe CVU661 4 at the price of RMB 150,000 and used the proceeds for personal expenses, refusing to carry out the effective judgment. On November 30, 2013, after he was apprehended, MAO Jianwen gave a true account of the aforementioned facts. Results of the Adjudication On June 17, 2014, the Pingyang County People s Court of [Wenzhou Municipality,] Zhejiang Province[,] rendered the (2014) Wen Ping Xing Chu Zi No. 314 Criminal Judgment: defendant MAO Jianwen committed the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment [or ruling] and is [therefore] sentenced to a limited-term imprisonment of ten months. After the judgment was pronounced, MAO Jianwen did not appeal and the public prosecution organ did not protest. The judgment has already come into legal effect. 5 Reasons for the Adjudication In the effective judgment, the court opined: defendant MAO Jianwen was responsible for performing the enforcement obligations determined in the effective adjudication [document]. After the coming into legal effect of a people s court s judgment or ruling which has enforcement content, [MAO Jianwen] committed acts of refusing to carry it out, including hiding and transferring property, making it impossible [for the people s court] to enforce the judgment or ruling. The circumstances were serious. His acts constituted the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment [or ruling]. [He] was guilty of the crime as alleged by the public prosecution organ. 3 Masculine pronouns are used to refer to the defendant because the name 毛建文 ( MAO Jianwen ) is more likely to be a name for a male. The gender of MAO Jianwen cannot be asercertained because the original judgment has not been found and may have been excluded from publication. 4 The identifier 浙 ( Zhe ) preceding the alphanumeric CVU661 is the abbreviation of Zhejiang Province, where the license plate CVU661 was registered. 5 The original text reads 判决已发生法律效力 ( the judgment has already come into legal effect ). According to Article 248 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China, judgments and rulings that have already come into legal effect are judgments and rulings which have not been appealed or protested within the prescribed time limit, judgments and rulings of the final instance, as well as death sentences approved by the Supreme People s Court and death sentences with a two-year suspension of execution approved by a Higher People s Court. See 中华人民共和国刑事诉讼法 (Criminal Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China), passed on July 1, 1979, issued on July 7, 1979, effective as of Jan. 1, 1980, amended two times, most recently on Mar. 14, 2012, effective as of Jan. 1, 2013,
4 4 After MAO Jianwen was apprehended, he gave a true account of his crime and [therefore his] punishment could be reduced. The focal point of the dispute in this case was how to determine the start time for [a defendant s] act [showing] having the ability to carry out [a judgment or ruling] but refusing to carry it out, as provided in the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling (i.e., whether defendant MAO Jianwen s act of refusing to carry out a judgment [should] start from the time when the related civil judgment came into legal effect or from the time when the case was registered for enforcement). On this, the court opined that the entry of an effective legal document into compulsory enforcement procedures does not constitute an element of or a prerequisite for the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling. MAO Jianwen s act of refusing to carry out a judgment should start from January 6, 2013, when the related civil judgment came into legal effect. The main reasons were as follows: (1) [This conclusion] accords with the original meaning [of Article 313]. When the Standing Committee of the National People s Congress interpreted Article 313 of the Criminal Law, it pointed out that [the phrase] a judgment or ruling of a people s court in that provision refers to a judgment or ruling which has enforcement content, is rendered by a people s court in accordance with law, and has already come into legal effect. This is to say that only after the coming into legal effect of a judgment or ruling which has enforcement content will [(a) the judgment or ruling] have legal binding force and compulsory enforcement force and [(b)] the obligor have the responsibility to promptly and actively perform an obligation determined in the effective legal document. The compulsory enforcement force of an effective legal document does not come into existence only after the compulsory enforcement procedures are entered into, but comes into existence immediately on the date when the legal document comes into effect. (2) [This conclusion] is consistent with the Civil Procedure Law and its judicial interpretation. Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China provides[, inter alia,] that where a litigation participant or another person refuses to carry out 6 a judgment or ruling of a people s court that has already come into legal effect, [ ]a people s court may, according to the severity of the circumstances, fine or detain him. 7 Where [the refusal] constitutes commission of a crime, criminal liability shall be pursued in accordance with law[ ]. 8 Article 188 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People s Court on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China provides: 9 6 The original text reads 履行 ( perform ), which is translated here as carry out ( 执行 ) for the sake of consistency with the crime described in Article 313 of the Criminal Law, supra note 1. 7 The word him as used here may also refer to her or it. 8 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法 (Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China), supra note x. 9 最高人民法院关于适用 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法 的解释 (Interpretation of the Supreme People s Court on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China ), passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court on Dec. 18, 2014, issued on Jan. 30, 2015, effective as of Feb.
5 5 The act of refusing to carry out 10 a judgment or ruling of a people s court that has already come into legal effect as provided for in Article 111 Paragraph 1 Item 6 of the Civil Procedure Law includes[:] [(1)] after a legal document has come into legal effect, hide, transfer, sell, or damage property, transfer property for free, trade property at a clearly unreasonable price, give up matured claims of debt, or provide other people with guarantees for free, etc., making it impossible for a people s court to enforce [the judgment or ruling.] This shows that the law clearly defines the act of refusing to carry out [a judgment or ruling] as [an act that occurs] after a legal document has come into legal effect. [The law] does not confine the subject who refuses to carry out [a judgment or ruling] to a person subject to enforcement after the compulsory enforcement procedures begin or to a person who assists in carrying out an [enforcement] obligation [after the compulsory enforcement procedures begin]. Neither does [the law] confine the regulatory scope of the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling to an act that occurs after an effective legal document enters into compulsory enforcement procedures. (3) [This conclusion] accords with the legislative purpose [of Article 313]. The legislative purpose [underlying] the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling is to resolve the difficulty of enforcement problem of courts effective judgments and rulings. Bringing an act of evading performance obligations that [occurs] after a judgment or ruling has come into effect but before the case is registered for enforcement into the regulatory scope of the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling should be the intent of establishing that crime in the law. Setting the date on which a judgment or ruling comes into effect as the start time for the act refusing to carry out [stated] in the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling can effectively make an obligor, who is deterred by criminal punishment, take the initiative to perform the obligation 4, 2015, (hereainafter the 2015 Interpretation ). Given that the 2015 Interpretation did not come into effect until February 4, 2015, a few months after the original judgment of this Guiding Case was rendered (i.e., June 17, 2014), it cannot be a document upon which the original judgment was based. As mentioned above, the original judgment has not been found and may have been excluded from publication. However, if the original judgment contained a point similar to the one made here in the Guding Case, the reference was likely to Paragraph 123 Item (1) of the then-effective Opinions of the Supreme People s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China (hereainafter the 1992 Opinion ), which was repealed by the 2015 Interpretation. The relevant text of the 1992 Opinion was essentially the same as that of Article 188 Item (1) of the 2015 Interpretation except that the former had no reference to transfer property for free, trade property at a clearly unreasonable price, give up matured claims of debt, provide other people with guarantees for free, etc. ( 无偿转让财产 以明显不合理的价格交易财产 放弃到期债权 无偿为他人提供担保等 ). See 最高人民法院关于适用 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法 若干问题的意见 (Opinions of the Supreme People s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People s Republic of China ), passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court on, issued on, and effective as of July 14, 1992, 10 The original text reads 履行 ( perform ), which is translated here as carry out ( 执行 ) for the sake of consistency with the crime described in Article 313 of the Criminal Law, supra note 1.
6 6 determined in the effective adjudication immediately after the judgment or ruling comes into effect. This avoids turning an effective adjudication into a piece of blank paper, thus making society and the public truly respect judicial adjudications, safeguarding the authority of law, fundamentally resolving the difficulty of enforcement problem, and realizing the legislative purpose [underlying] the crime of refusing to carry out a judgment or ruling. (Adjudication personnel of the effective judgment: GUO Chaohui, ZENG Hongning, and PEI Lun)
WANG Xinming, A Contract Fraud Case CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT
WANG Xinming, A Contract Fraud Case Guiding Case No. 62 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on June 30, 2016) CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT English
More informationLI Jianxiong v. Department of Transport of Guangdong Province, A Case About Open Government Information
LI Jianxiong v. Department of Transport of Guangdong Province, A Case About Open Government Information Guiding Case No. 26 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court
More informationGuiding Case No. 53 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on November 19, 2015)
The Fuzhou Wuyi Sub-Branch of Fujian Haixia Bank Co., Ltd. v. Changle Yaxin Sewage Treatment Co., Ltd. and Fuzhou Municipal Administration and Engineering Co., Ltd., A Dispute over a Financial Borrowing
More informationShanghai Jwell Machinery Co., Ltd. and Retech Aktiengesellschaft, Switzerland, An Enforcement Reconsideration Case on an Arbitral Award
Shanghai Jwell Machinery Co., Ltd. and Retech Aktiengesellschaft, Switzerland, An Enforcement Reconsideration Case on an Arbitral Award Guiding Case No. 37 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee
More informationGuiding Cases in Perspective TM 指导性案例透视. Guiding Case No. 10: CGCP Annotations. April 30, 2016 Edition
Guiding Cases in Perspective TM TM 指导性案例透视 Dr. Mei Gechlik Founder and Director, China Guiding Cases Project Lear Liu and XIAO Qin Editors, China Guiding Cases Project Guiding Case No. 10: CGCP Annotations
More informationGuiding Case No. 43 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on December 25, 2014)
Haikou Binhai Avenue (Tianfu Hotel) Securities Business Department of Guotai Junan Securities Co., Ltd., A Case of an Application for Compensation for Erroneous Enforcement Guiding Case No. 43 (Discussed
More informationMA Le, A Case About Using Nonpublic Information for Trading CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT
MA Le, A Case About Using Nonpublic Information for Trading Guiding Case No. 61 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on June 30, 2016) CHINA GUIDING
More informationGuiding Case No. 88 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on November 15, 2017)
ZHANG Daowen, TAO Ren, et al. v. The People s Government of Jianyang Municipality, Sichuan Province, A Case of Infringing Upon the Right to Operate Manpower Passenger Tricycle Businesses Guiding Case No.
More informationSHA Mingbao et al. v. The People s Government of Huashan District, Ma anshan Municipality, CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT
SHA Mingbao et al. v. The People s Government of Huashan District, Ma anshan Municipality, A Case of Administrative Compensation for Compulsory Demolition of Housing Guiding Case No. 91 (Discussed and
More informationThe Compilation and Application of China s Guiding Cases
Judge GUO Feng Deputy Director, Research Office of the Supreme People s Court Executive Editor-in-Chief, Case Guidance in China Honorary Adviser, China Guiding Cases Project of Stanford Law School The
More informationGuiding Cases in Perspective TM 指导性案例透视. Guiding Case No. 11: CGCP Annotations. April 30, 2016 Edition
Guiding Cases in Perspective TM TM 指导性案例透视 Dr. Mei Gechlik Founder and Director, China Guiding Cases Project Adrian Lo and Roland C. Reimers Editors, China Guiding Cases Project : CGCP Annotations April
More informationGuiding Cases in Perspective TM 指导性案例透视
Guiding Cases in Perspective TM TM 指导性案例透视 LI Jianjun v. Shanghai Jiapower Environment Protection Science and Technology Co., Ltd., A Corporate Resolution Revocation Dispute Guiding Case No. 10 (Discussed
More informationOU Zelin. Discussing the Guiding Case System with Chinese Characteristics By First Combining Guiding Case No. 1 with Adjudication Practices
OU Zelin Judge of the Second Civil Tribunal of the Dongguan Municipality No. 2 People s Court in Guangdong Province * Discussing the Guiding Case System with Chinese Characteristics By First Combining
More informationChina s Case Guidance System: Application and Lessons Learned (Part I)
Guiding Cases Surveys TM TM 指导性案例调查 Dr. Mei Gechlik Founder and Director, China Guiding Cases Project Chenchen Zhang Editor, China Guiding Cases Project Li Huang Editor, China Guiding Cases Project China
More informationStrategies for Trade Secrets Protection in China
Northwestern Journal of Technology and Intellectual Property Volume 9 Issue 7 Spring Article 1 Spring 2011 Strategies for Trade Secrets Protection in China J. Benjamin Bai Partner, Allen & Overy, benjamin.bai@allenovery.com
More informationFRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA ARTICLE. ZHAO Yanrong *
FRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA VOL. 12 JUNE 2017 NO. 2 DOI 10.3868/s050-006-017-0015-7 ARTICLE THE COURTS ACTIVE ROLE IN THE STRIVING FOR JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE IN CHINA ZHAO Yanrong * Abstract In China, different
More informationGuiding Cases Analytics TM 指导性案例分析
Guiding Cases Analytics TM TM 指导性案例分析 Issue No. 3 (January 2015) Dr. Mei Gechlik * Founder and Director, China Guiding Cases Project * * * Guiding Cases Analytics TM analyzes trends in the Guiding Cases
More informationBriefing Paper. A Brief Introduction to the Chinese Judicial System and Court Hierarchy. Yifan Wang, Sarah Biddulph and Andrew Godwin
Briefing Paper A Brief Introduction to the Chinese Judicial System and Court Hierarchy Yifan Wang, Sarah Biddulph and Andrew Godwin S The Briefing Paper Series is edited by Professor Pip Nicholson and
More informationTowards the Rule of Law: Judicial Lawmaking in China
Bond Law Review Volume 28 Issue 2 Article 3 2016 Towards the Rule of Law: Judicial Lawmaking in China Vai Io Lo Bond University, vlo@bond.edu.au Follow this and additional works at: http://epublications.bond.edu.au/blr
More informationFRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA ARTICLE. FAN Xiaoliang, * LI Qingming **
FRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA VOL. 10 JUNE 2015 NO. 2 DOI 10.3868/s050-004-015-0017-3 ARTICLE COMPARATIVE STUDY ON SELECTED ASPECTS OF THE LATEST PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW LEGISLATION ACROSS THE TAIWAN STRAITS
More informationGuiding Cases Analytics TM
Guiding Cases Analytics TM TM 指导性案例分析 Dr. Mei Gechlik Founder and Director, China Guiding Cases Project Issue No. 2 (July 2014) Guiding Cases Analytics TM analyzes trends in the Guiding Cases selected
More informationNinon Colneric. Guiding by Cases in a Legal System Without Binding Precedent: The German Example
Ninon Colneric Former Co-Dean of the China EU School of Law at the China University of Political Science and Law Former Judge of the Court of Justice of the European Communities Guiding by Cases in a Legal
More informationNinon Colneric. Guiding by Cases in a Legal System Without Binding Precedent: The German Example
Ninon Colneric Former Co-Dean of the China EU School of Law at the China University of Political Science and Law Former Judge of the Court of Justice of the European Communities Guiding by Cases in a Legal
More informationThe Changing Landscape of Environmental Litigation in China from the 1990s to 2016
The Changing Landscape of Environmental Litigation in China from the 1990s to 2016 Zhang Jingjing 张兢兢 Environmental Law Institute Visiting Scholar Center for Legal Assistance to Pollution Victims (CLAPV)
More informationBelt & Road Typical Case 13: Towards a Liberal Interpretation of the Reciprocity Principle for Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments
Issue No. 3 March 27, 2018 In Belt & Road Typical Case 13, 1 the Supreme People s Court (the SPC ) endorsed the liberal approach that the Intermediate People s Court of Nanjing Municipality, Jiangsu Province,
More informationCIETAC HONG KONG MOCK ARBITRATION. 29 September 2016 Beijing
CIETAC HONG KONG MOCK ARBITRATION 29 September 2016 Beijing WELCOME REMARKS Dr. WANG Wenying Secretary General, CIETAC Hong Kong Arbitration Center Secretary General, CMAC Hong Kong Arbitration Center
More informationChapter 2 An Overview of Shareholder Litigation
Chapter 2 An Overview of Shareholder Litigation 2.1 Introduction Shareholder litigation is traditionally perceived as being about compensating shareholders for infringements of their rights or for losses
More informationTHE CISG AND MODERNISATION OF CHINESE CONTRACT LAW
67 THE CISG AND MODERNISATION OF CHINESE CONTRACT LAW Shiyuan Han * This paper considers the impact of the CISG on the modernisation of Chinese contract law. The impact will be examined from a historical
More informationChinese Business Law. Contract Law in China A Comparative Approach
Prof. Knut B. Pißler Research Fellow Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law Chinese Business Law Contract Law in China A Comparative Approach 1 Contract Law in the PR China:
More informationON BUILDING CHINA S NEW IP CASE SYSTEM: A DISCUSSION WITH CHINESE JUDGES LEGAL AND BIG DATA EXPERTS. Guiding Cases Seminars TM TM 指导性案例研讨会
Guiding Cases Seminars TM TM 指导性案例研讨会 SEMINAR SUMMARY ON BUILDING CHINA S NEW IP CASE SYSTEM: A DISCUSSION WITH CHINESE JUDGES AS WELL AS LEGAL AND BIG DATA EXPERTS STANFORD LAW SCHOOL October 19, 2017
More information跨境争议解决 Cross-border Dispute Resolution
www.dachenglaw.com 北京市东直门南大街 3 号国华投资大厦 5 层 /12 层 /15 层 (100007) 5/F, 12/F, 15/F, Guohua Plaza, 3 Dongzhimennan Avenue, Beijing 100007, China Tel: +8610-58137799 Fax: +8610-58137788 中国法通讯 China Law Newsletter
More informationPRACTITIONERS PERSPECTIVE ON ADVANCES IN CHINA S JUDICIAL REFORM
PRACTITIONERS PERSPECTIVE ON ADVANCES IN CHINA S JUDICIAL REFORM Primary Author: Jacob Blacklock Contributing Authors: Christopher Fung, ZHENG Yang, ZHANG Shili, KONG Xingxing, WANG Yu, XU Hui** Table
More informationChinese Business Law. Chinese Legal System: Sources and Lawmaking in the People s Republic of China
Prof. Knut B. Pißler Research Fellow Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law Chinese Business Law Chinese Legal System: Sources and Lawmaking in the People s Republic of China
More informationGuiding Cases in Perspective TM 指导性案例透视. CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT Guiding Case No. 11 Highlighted Edition April 30, 2016 *
Guiding Cases in Perspective TM TM 指导性案例透视 YANG Yanhu et al., A Graft Case Guiding Case No. 11 (Discussed and Passed by the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People s Court Released on September 18,
More informationBriefing Note on China s Response to the Committee s List of Issues Submitted to the Committee on the Rights of the Child.
Briefing Note on China s Response to the Committee s List of Issues Submitted to the Committee on the Rights of the Child September 2013 The diverse and complex issues impacting on the rights of children
More informationGuiding Cases SeminarsTM 指导性案例研讨会 TM
Guiding Cases SeminarsTM 指导性案例研讨会 TM SEMINAR SUMMARY CHINA S GUIDING CASES SYSTEM TURNS SIX: RETROSPECT AND PROSPECT STANFORD CENTER AT PEKING UNIVERSITY NOVEMBER 22, 2016* I. Overview On November 22,
More informationPUSHING THE ENVELOPE: APPLICATION OF GUIDING CASES IN CHINESE COURTS AND DEVELOPMENT OF CASE LAW IN CHINA
Compilation 2017 Washington International Law Journal Association PUSHING THE ENVELOPE: APPLICATION OF GUIDING CASES IN CHINESE COURTS AND DEVELOPMENT OF CASE LAW IN CHINA Mo Zhang Abstract: The modern
More informationREHABILITATING OR STRENTHENING THE U.S. PATENT THAT MAY BE DEFECTIVE OR VUNERABLE TO THIRD PARTY VALIDITY CHALLENGE
REHABILITATING OR STRENTHENING THE U.S. PATENT THAT MAY BE DEFECTIVE OR VUNERABLE TO THIRD PARTY VALIDITY CHALLENGE THREE EX PARTE PROCEDURES IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE (USPTO) AVAILABLE
More informationWANG Lifeng. The Necessity and Function of China s Guiding Cases System
WANG Lifeng Professor of the Central Party School of the People s Republic of China The Necessity and Function of China s Guiding Cases System CHINA GUIDING CASES PROJECT October 15, 2013 () The citation
More informationPart I PPH using the national work products from the NBPR
Procedures to File a Request to the SIPO (State Intellectual Property Office of the P R China) for Patent Prosecution Highway Pilot Program between the SIPO and the NBPR (National Board of Patents and
More informationFRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA ARTICLE. LU Haina, HAO Wanyuan. nationality issues, Vietnam brides, reduction of statelessness
FRONTIERS OF LAW IN CHINA VOL. 12 SEPTEMBER 2017 NO. 3 DOI 10.3868/s050-006-017-0023-0 ARTICLE PROTECTION OF STATELESS PERSONS IN CHINA: A HUMAN RIGHTS PERSPECTIVE LU Haina, HAO Wanyuan Abstract Statelessness
More informationThe Anti-Monopoly Law: Still a Work in Progress
I. Introduction The Anti-Monopoly Law: Still a Work in Progress Paul Jones The adoption of the 中华人民共和国反垄断法 1 or Anti-Monopoly law (the AML ) on August 30, 2007 may yet turn out to be one of the more significant
More informationArticle 37: The right to liberty of person under the Chinese constitution
China-EU Law J (2013) 2:35 67 DOI 10.1007/s12689-011-0002-9 ARTICLE Article 37: The right to liberty of person under the Chinese constitution Otto Malmgren Published online: 13 July 2011 The Author(s)
More informationThe Dui Hua Foundation 450 Sutter Street, Suite 900, San Francisco, CA Tel: (415) Fax: (415)
450 Sutter Street, Suite 900, San Francisco, CA 94108 Tel: (415) 986-0536 Fax: (415) 986-0579 NGO Submission for the Universal Periodic Review of the People s Republic of China: Promoting Increased Transparency
More informationPrivate securities litigation in China: Passive people's courts and weak investor protection
Bond Law Review Volume 26 Issue 1 Article 4 2015 Private securities litigation in China: Passive people's courts and weak investor protection Jin Sheng Follow this and additional works at: http://epublications.bond.edu.au/blr
More informationThe New Chinese Anti-Monopoly Law An Overview
VIEWPOINT: The New Chinese Anti-Monopoly Law An Overview Adrian Emch and Qian Hao An eccp Publication November 2007 2007 Adrian Emch and Qian Hao. Published with permission by eccp. The New Chinese Anti-Monopoly
More informationCHINA S EVOLVING CASE LAW SYSTEM IN PRACTICE. Susan Finder* Table of Contents
CHINA S EVOLVING CASE LAW SYSTEM IN PRACTICE Susan Finder* Table of Contents I. CASE LAW PRACTICE...247 A. Judiciary...247 1. The Supreme People's Court... 247 2. Lower courts... 251 B. Procuratorate...253
More informationBurdensome Secrets: A Comparative Approach to Improving China s Trade Secret Protections
Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal Volume 25 Volume XXV Number 2 Volume XXV Book 2 Article 6 2015 Burdensome Secrets: A Comparative Approach to Improving China s Trade Secret
More informationAdministrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China (2014 Amendment)[Effective] 中华人民共和国行政诉讼法 (2014 修正 ) [ 现行有效 ]
Please note: This translation is provided by www.lawinfochina.com with exclusive copyright and can not be reproduced for commercial use. Administrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China
More informationFood Safety Governance and Its Reform in China
Food Safety Governance and Its Reform in China Song Hualin (Law Professor of Nankai Law School) About Me v Law Professor, Law School, Nankai University v Ph.D. in Constitutional Law and Administrative
More informationCULPA IN CONTRAHENDO IN CHINESE CONTRACT LAW
CULPA IN CONTRAHENDO IN CHINESE CONTRACT LAW HAN Shiyuan Table of Contents I. INTRODUCTION... 158 II. CHINESE LEGISLATION... 159 III. JUDICIAL INTERPRETATIONS AND CASES... 161 IV. LEGAL THEORIES... 165
More informationThe Culture Variable Vis-à-Vis Anti-bribery Law: A Grey Area in Transnational Corporate Criminal Liability
Eur Bus Org Law Rev (2018) 19:183 213 DOI 10.1007/s40804-017-0089-8 ARTICLE The Culture Variable Vis-à-Vis Anti-bribery Law: A Grey Area in Transnational Corporate Criminal Liability Qingxiu Bu 1 Published
More informationAREAS OF RESEARCH AND TEACHING
Xin HE (Frank) School of Law, City University of Hong Kong; lwxin@cityu.edu.hk; 3442-7202 EDUCATION Doctor of the Science of Law (JSD), School of Law, STANFORD UNIVERSITY, 2004 Master of the Science of
More informationWhither the Next Chinese Judicial Reform on the Local Judiciary Challenging the Government Under the Judicial Context
Whither the Next Chinese Judicial Reform on the Local Judiciary Challenging the Government Under the Judicial Context Zhou Yu ABSTRACT Having noted the latest judicial reform proposal in China, this paper
More informationCharting a steady Course In a Turbulent world
Charting a steady Course In a Turbulent world Jonathan Holslag ESPO, Barcelona, June 2017 2030 2050 Mediterranean +82 +255 Intra-Europe +82 +205 North-Atlantic +74 +268 Asia-Med +104 +325 Table. Expected
More informationChina Environment Forum
China Environment Forum Woodrow Wilson Center Washington D.C. April 11, 2007 环境维权诉讼是促进公众参与环境保护的重要途径 The Litigation of Protecting Environmental Rights: An Important Route of the Public Participation in
More informationACCA F4 习题详解. Provided by Academy of Professional Accounting (APA) Corporate and Business Law (CL) 公司法和商法第四讲 ACCA Lecturer: Carrie Ni
Professional Accounting Education Provided by Academy of Professional Accounting (APA) ACCA F4 习题详解 Corporate and Business Law (CL) 公司法和商法第四讲 ACCA Lecturer: Carrie Ni ACCAspace 中国 ACCA 特许公认会计师教育平台 Copyright
More informationEmployment of Expatriates the Legal Issues
Employment of Expatriates the Legal Issues Garden Hotel Guangzhou 2 November 2011 Jeremy Sargent Managing Partner JSA Guangzhou Office LETS START WITH SOME SCENARIOS 1. Neil starts working with his company
More informationThe dissemination of the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence
The Journal of International Studies No. 05, 66 8, 05 The dissemination of the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence YUAN Zhengqing, SONG Xiaoqin Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy
More information출입국관리법시행규칙 [ 별지제17 호서식] ( 第一页 / Page1) 签证发给申请表 APPLICATION FOR VISA
출입국관리법시행규칙 [ 별지제17 호서식] ( 第一页 / Page1) 签证发给申请表 APPLICATION FOR VISA < 申请表填写方法 > 申请人须以事实为根据, 并将在以下空格处完整记载 申请人必须用韩文 在相关选项的 [ ] 内打钩 如您选择其他 英文或中文填写以下申请表 请写具体内容 You must fill out
More informationCurrent Status of Civil-Service System in China and Its Orientation to Reform
Chinese Studies, 2015, 4, 45-49 Published Online May 2015 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/chnstd http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/chnstd.2015.42007 Current Status of Civil-Service System in China and
More informationEmpirical Study on Utilizing Rural Settlement of Manchu. Taking Qidaoliang Village, Manchu, Beijing as An Example
Empirical Study on Utilizing Rural Settlement of Manchu Taking Qidaoliang Village, Manchu, Beijing as An Example Zhangxiuzhi 1 Chenyuting 2 China Key words: land consolidation;rural settlement;rural tourism;manchu
More informationA/HRC/19/57/Add.3 大会 联合国 任意拘留问题工作组报告 人权理事会第十九届会议议程项目 3 对德国的访问 * **
联合国 A/HRC/19/57/Add.3 大会 Distr.: General 23 February 2012 Chinese Original: English 人权理事会第十九届会议议程项目 3 增进和保护所有人权 公民权利 政治权利 经济 社会和文化权利, 包括发展权 任意拘留问题工作组报告 增编 对德国的访问 * ** 概要任意拘留问题工作组应德国政府邀请, 于 2011 年 9 月 26
More informationCOURT REFORM WITH CHINESE CHARACTERISTICS
Compilation 2017 Washington International Law Journal Association COURT REFORM WITH CHINESE CHARACTERISTICS Margaret Y.K. Woo Abstract: In Court Reform on Trial: Why Simple Solutions Fail, Malcolm Feeley
More information590 HOFSTRA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 42:589
THE DEVELOPMENT OF CHINA S DEATH PENALTY REPRESENTATION GUIDELINES: A LEARNING MODEL BASED ON THE ABA GUIDELINES FOR THE APPOINTMENT AND PERFORMANCE OF DEFENSE COUNSEL IN DEATH PENALTY CASES Jie Yang*
More informationReflecting on Development of Evidence Law in China
Reflecting on Development of Evidence Law in China Baosheng Zhang Abstract:Since 1978, Chinese evidence law has experienced significant changes and is now entering a rapid developmental stage prompted
More informationOnce you have gathered all the information required please send to Key Travel s visa department
Dear Applicant, Thank you for choosing Key Travel to handle your visa application to China Your visa pack contains: Embassy Information Visa requirements for Business and Tourist applications Application
More informationBeijing Intellectual Property Court. Judicial Protection Data Analysis Report (2015)
Beijing Intellectual Property Court Judicial Protection Data Analysis Report (2015) IPHOUSE Judicial Data Research Center Brief Introduction to the Editorial Organization Beijing IPHOUSE Network Technology
More informationOnce you have gathered all the information required, please send to Key Travel s visa department
Dear Applicant, Thank you for choosing Key Travel to handle your visa application to China Your visa pack contains: Embassy Information Visa requirements for Business and Tourist applications Application
More informationA Nation of Diversity
Unit 01 A Nation of Diversity 多樣性的民族 Key Words CD1-1 01 diversity [da0'v"s3t0] 02 ethnic group ['GLn0k Erup] 03 melting pot ['mglt0h pat] 04 national identity ['n$n3n9 a0'dgnt3t0] 05 authority [3'LCr3t0]
More informationArista Passport & Visa Services Inc.
Arista Passport & Visa Services Inc. 1. Your Passport. Visa Checklist China Non-US 2. A completed 4-page visa application. (Application must be typed) 3. Present your previous visas to China. 4. Original
More informationThe Xinfang Phenomenon: Why the Chinese Prefer Administrative Petitioning over Litigation
Yale Law School Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository Student Scholarship Papers Yale Law School Student Scholarship 8-7-2008 The Xinfang Phenomenon: Why the Chinese Prefer Administrative Petitioning
More informationStudent Enrolment Form (International) 国际学生入学申请表 INSTRUCTION 1. The enrolment form should be type written or hand-written in BLOCK LETTERS.
Student Enrolment Form (International) 国际学生入学申请表 INSTRUCTION 1. The enrolment form should be type written or hand-written in BLOCK LETTERS. PHOTO 此表格需要用大写英文字体填写 2. Please refer to the terms & conditions
More information中华人民共和国签证申请表. thfully 1.3 别名或曾用名 1.5 出生日期 DOB. OB(yyyy-mm-dd. yyyy-mm-dd) 外交 Diplomatic 普通 Ordinary 签发日期 ssue(yyyy-mm-dd.
Form V.2013 中华人民共和国签证申请表 Visa Application Form of the People s Republic of China (For the Mainland of China only) 申请人必须如实 完整 清楚地完整 清楚地填写本表格 请逐项在空白处用中文或英文大写字母打印填写, 或在 内打 选择 如有关项目不适用, 请写 无 The applicant
More informationChina s Development Strategy 中国的发展战略
China s Development Strategy 中国的发展战略 Professor Li Zhongjie Member of CPPCC National Committee, Former Deputy Director of Party History Research Center of the CPC Central Committee 李忠杰全国政协委员 中共中央党史研究室原副主任
More informationOnce you have gathered all the information required please send to Key Travel s visa department
Dear Applicant, Thank you for choosing Key Travel to handle your visa application to China Your visa pack contains: Embassy Information Visa requirements for Business and Tourist applications Application
More informationSubmitted to the Committee on the Rights of the Child for its pre-sessional working group NOVEMBER 2012
Suggested questions and issues to be raised with the Chinese government in advance of the review of its third report on the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child Submitted to the
More informationChina Business Visa Application Pack
China Business Visa Application Pack Thank you for requesting an application pack for a China Business Visa. Please complete these three sections and then return the application pack and all supporting
More informationUnderstanding Socialized Liability Under Chinese Tort Law
VOLUME 59, SPRING 2018, ONLINE JOURNAL Understanding Socialized Liability Under Chinese Tort Law Chenglin Liu* ABSTRACT This article explores two unique aspects of the Chinese Tort Liability Law (TLL):
More informationSocialized Liability in Chinese Tort Law
HARVARD INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNAL VOLUME 59, SPRING 2018, ONLINE JOURNAL Socialized Liability in Chinese Tort Law Chenglin Liu* ABSTRACT This article explores two unique aspects of the Chinese Tort Liability
More informationCHINA VISA APPLICATION
CHINA VISA APPLICATION TRAVELER NATIONALITY Australia STATE OF RESIDENCE Australian Capital Territory DESTINATION China PURPOSE Tourist ALLOWED ENTRIES Single Entry VALIDITY Three Month Validity WE ARE
More informationNational Changhua University of Education Syllabus & Course Schedule
National Changhua University of Education 107-2 Syllabus & Course Schedule ( 留白 )body{font-size:12px;} Course: Foreign Policy Analysis Course Number: 78020 (1SPPC0131620) Instructor: 李毓峰 Credit: 2 Hour(s);
More informationBEGELEIDINGSFORMULIER VOOR VISUM AANVRAAG
Form V.2013 BEGELEIDINGSFORMULIER VOOR VISUM AANVRAAG LET OP: ALLE FORMULIEREN DIENEN DIGITAAL INGEVULD TE WORDEN!! FACTUURGEGEVENS - alleen de velden invullen die op uw aanvraag van toepassing zijn -
More informationSocial Dialogue in Uganda The FUE NHO CEC Cooperation Eng. Martin S Kasekende Chairman FUE
Foto: Jo Michael Social Dialogue in Uganda The FUE NHO CEC Cooperation Eng. Martin S Kasekende Chairman FUE 1 Social Dialogue in Uganda: The practice It is based on ILO s principle of tripartism Tripartite
More informationConstruction Bulletin Hong Kong
Construction Bulletin Projects Procurement Construction Issue 7 July 2013 Welcome to the 7th Issue of our Bulletin. We start this issue with a focus on two perennial issues the back to back payment clause
More informationPART 1. WHERE TO APPLY FOR YOUR VISA
General guidance for Chinese visa application. Page 1 / 10 PART 1. WHERE TO APPLY FOR YOUR VISA IMPORTANT Please lodge your application with the visa office of the Embassy/Consulate-General which holds
More informationMANDATORY ORDER FORM. 323 Geary Street, # 815 San Francisco, CA Toll Free
MANDATORY ORDER FORM Deliver / Mail / Drop-off to a location that is closest to your jurisdiction: 2200 Pennsylvania Ave NW 4th Floor E. Washington, DC 20037 Toll Free 1-877-400-0235 Fax 1-866-835-4372
More informationPolicy Forming Mechanisms in Rural China
Policy Forming Mechanisms in Rural China Ai-Jun Qiu China Center for Town Reform and Development Beijing, China 2008 CSD Working Papers No. 08-11 Campus Box 1196 One Brookings Drive St. Louis, MO 63130-9906
More informationSilver Whisper Voyage # # 4508 Los Angeles to Ft. Lauderdale January 5 May 1, 2015
1625 K Street NW Suite 750 Washington DC 20006 Tel: 888 838 4867 Email: SILVERSEA@TravelDocs.com Visa requirements shown below are for U.S. CITIZENS ONLY. Nationals of all other countries please contact
More informationThe Multi-angle Perspective on the Doctrine of the Most Significant Relationship in the Practice of the Private International Law in China
From the SelectedWorks of Jiayi Geng June 25, 2015 The Multi-angle Perspective on the Doctrine of the Most Significant Relationship in the Practice of the Private International Law in China Hong Yun Tian,
More informationVISACONNECTION. Passport type: Canadian Country of Travel: China Purpose of Travel: Tourism
Requirements: VISACONNECTION Passport type: Canadian Country of Travel: China Purpose of Travel: Tourism Passport: Please submit your passport with enough blank pages for visa and entry/exit stamps. **Passport
More informationYOUR RETURN SHIPPING ADDRESS
TOURIST VISA REQUIREMENTS FOR CHINA Roof of The World (Tibet) This kit is for passengers booked on Roof of the World only. If you have booked another Viking Itinerary, please contact Viking Cruises for
More information厦门大学学位论文原创性声明 本人呈交的学位论文是本人在导师指导下, 独立完成的研究成 果 本人在论文写作中参考其他个人或集体已经发表的研究成果, 均 在文中以适当方式明确标明, 并符合法律规范和 厦门大学研究生学 术活动规范 ( 试行 ) 另外, 该学位论文为 ( ) 课题 ( 组 ) 的研究成果,
学校编码 :10384 分类号密级 学号 :25520121154242 UDC 硕士学位论文 金龙公司在印尼的市场调查 Survey on Golden Dragon in Indonesian Market Prianto Indra 指导教师姓名 : 施雪琴 教授 专业名称 : 国际关系 论文提交日期 : 2 0 1 5 论文答辩时间 : 2 0 1 5 学位授予日期 : 2 015 年 4
More information联合国 增进和保护所有人权 公民 政治 经济 社会和文化权利, 包括发展权 对阿富汗的访问 ** Distr. GENERAL A/HRC/11/2/Add.4 6 May 2009 CHINESE Original: ENGLISH 人权理事会 第十一届会议 议程项目 3
联合国 A 大会 Distr. GENERAL A/HRC/11/2/Add.4 6 May 2009 CHINESE Original: ENGLISH 人权理事会 第十一届会议 议程项目 3 增进和保护所有人权 公民 政治 经济 社会和文化权利, 包括发展权 法外处决 即审即决或任意处决问题特别报告员 菲利普 奥尔斯顿的报告 * 增 编 对阿富汗的访问 ** * oêd ** È d œè Ð
More informationJAPAN PATENT OFFICE AS DESIGNATED (OR ELECTED) OFFICE CONTENTS
Page 1 JP JAPAN PATENT OFFICE AS DESIGNATED (OR ELECTED) OFFICE CONTENTS THE ENTRY INTO THE NATIONAL PHASE SUMMARY THE PROCEDURE IN THE NATIONAL PHASE ANNEXES Fees... Annex JP.I Form No. 53: Transmittal
More informationISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2. Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character Set (UCS) - ISO/IEC Secretariat: ANSI
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2 N3271 DATE: 2007-05-23 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2 Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character Set (UCS) - ISO/IEC 10646 Secretariat: ANSI DOC TYPE: Calling Notice Meeting 51 TITLE: 1st
More informationISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2. Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character Set (UCS) - ISO/IEC Secretariat: ANSI
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2 N3271R DATE: 2007-07-10 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 2/WG 2 Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character Set (UCS) - ISO/IEC 10646 Secretariat: ANSI DOC TYPE: 2 nd Calling Notice Meeting 51 TITLE:
More informationC-8/DG.5/Add 年 10 月 20 日至 24 日 22 October 2003 CHINESE Original: ENGLISH 总干事的说明 关于国家执行措施的报告
禁止化学武器组织 缔约国大会 第八届会议 2003 年 10 月 20 日至 24 日 22 October 2003 CHINESE Original: ENGLISH 总干事的说明 关于国家执行措施的报告 增补 本增补的附件载有总干事关于国家执行措施的报告 (C-8/DG.5,2003 年 9 月 18 日 ) 附件 1 和附件 2 部分条目的修订, 反映了截至 2003 年 10 月 22 日技术秘书处收到的补充资料,
More information1. Requirements. PPH using the national work products from NOIP
Procedures to file a request to JPO (Japan Patent Office) for Patent Prosecution Highway Pilot Program between JPO and NOIP (National Office of Intellectual Property) Applicants can request accelerated
More information1. Requirements. PPH using the national work products from the TIPO
Procedures to file a request to the JPO for Patent Prosecution Highway Pilot Program between the JPO (Japan Patent Office) and the TIPO (Taiwan Intellectual Property Office) Applicants can request accelerated
More information