COUNTY OF PRINCE EDWARD PLANNING SERVICES COMMITTEE

Transcription

1 COUNTY OF PRINCE EDWARD PLANNING SERVICES COMMITTEE A public meeting of the Planning Services Committee was held under Sections 21, 34, 51 and 53 of the Planning Act on Wednesday, May 30, 2007 at 7:20 p.m. in the Council Chambers, Shire Hall. The following Committee members were present: Ward 1 (Picton) Councillor Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) Councillor Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) Councillor Ward 5 (Athol) Councillor Ward 6 (Hallowell) Councillor Ward 10 (Sophiasburgh) Councillor Laverne Bailey Sandy Latchford Lori Slik, Vice Chair Brian Marisett, Chair Richard Parks John Thompson Regrets: Mayor Ward 9 (South Marysburgh) Councillor Leo P. Finnegan Monica Alyea Other members of Council present: Ward 1 (Picton) Councillor Ward 2 (Bloomfield) Councillor Ward 3 (Wellington) Councillor Ward 6 (Hallowell) Councillor Ward 8 (North Marysburgh) Councillor Bev Campbell (arrived at 7:30 p.m.) Barry Turpin Peter Mertens Keith MacDonald Ray Best The following Staff were present: Commissioner of Planning Services PublicWorks Deputy Engineer Manager of Planning Senior Planner Senior Planner Assistant to the Mayor Brian McComb Ray Ford Jo-Anne Egan Ryan Leary Justin Harrow Karen Kirby 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order by the Chair at 7:20 p.m. 2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof

2 There were no disclosures of pecuniary interest at this time. 3. Applications 3.1 Sandbank Homes Inc. Lot 202, Plan 8 - Ward 3 (Wellington) Meeting, Staff Report, Preliminary Recommendations and Recommended Conditions of Draft Approval. The following individual appeared before Committee: a) Heather Reilly, agent for the applicant, in agreement with the recommendations as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey THAT the proposed Draft Plan of Subdivision, County File No. 13-T (Sandbank Homes Inc.) located in Part of Lot 202, Plan 8, Ward 3 (Wellington) BE DRAFT APPROVED, subject to the conditions identified within the planning staff report. 3.2 Sarah Redka and Lidia Redka Part Lot 62, Concession 1, Hamlet of Rossmore - Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) The following applicant appeared before Committee: a) Mark and Sarah Redka, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. 2

3 Motion PL Moved by Councillor Slik THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, Consent File B51-07 (Sarah Redka and Lidia Redka) for lands located in Part Lot 62, Concession 1, Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Sara Redka and Lidia Redka) for the lands located in Part Lot 62, Concession 1, Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) BE APPROVED Ontario Ltd. Part Lot 76, Concession Irvine Gore - Ward 6 (Hallowell) The following individual appeared before Committee: a) George Markey, on behalf of Ontario Ltd., in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Parks Seconded by Councillor Slik THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, Consent File B52-07 ( Ontario Ltd.) for lands located in Part of Lot 76, Concession Irvine Gore, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward, ( Ontario Ltd.) for lands located in Part Lot 76, Concession Irvine Gore, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED. 3.4 Gordon Carter Part Lot 89, Concession 2 Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) The following applicant appeared before Committee: 3

4 a) Gordon Carter, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Slik THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, Consent File B53-07 (Gordon Carter) for lands located in Part of Lot 89, Concession 2, Ward 4, (Ameliasburgh) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Gordon Carter) for lands located in Pt. Lot 89, Concession 2, Ward 4 (Ameliasburgh) BE APPROVED. 3.5 Daniel and Nicole DeAraujo Part Lot 72, Concession 6 - Ward 7 (Hillier) Neither the Applicant nor the Agent for the applicant appeared before Committee. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, Consent File B54-07 (Daniel and Nicole DeAraujo) for lands located in Part of Lot 72, Concession 6, Ward 7 (Hillier) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Daniel and Nicole DeAraujo) for lands located in Part Lot 72, Concession 6, Ward 7 (Hillier) BE APPROVED. 3.6 C. Fred Weeks Jr. and John and Margaret Moore Lots 3, 4 and 5, Plan 19 - Ward 6 (Hallowell) 4

5 The Committee received a verbal report from Senior Planner, Ryan Leary regarding a new condition being added to the Recommended Consent Conditions for Files B55-07 and B56-07, as follows: Condition #11 That the applicants install a pool enclosure/fencing, to comply with the required minimum standards outlined in the Ontario Building Code; and the County of Prince Edward Comprehensive Zoning By-law around the entirety of the existing pond on all the affected portions of the proposed severed, retained and benefiting parcels, to the satisfaction of the County s Chief Building Official. The following individual appeared before Committee: a) Dan O Neill, agent for the applicant, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report, save and except Condition #11. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey THAT the Deeming By-law (C. Fred Weeks Jr., John and Margaret Moore, and the Corporation of the County of Prince Edward) for lands located in Part of Lots 3, 4 and 5 and the Unopened Road Allowance known as Sheba Drive, Plan 19, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED and given Three Readings by Council; THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, save and except Condition #11 regarding the provision of a fence around the pond, Consent Files B55-07 and B56-07 (C. Fred Weeks Jr. and John and Margaret Moore) for lands located in Lots 3, 4 and 5, Plan 19, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (C. Fred Weeks Jr., John and Margaret Moore, and the Corporation of the County of Prince Edward) for lands located Lots 3, 4 and 5 and the Unopened Road Allowance known as Sheba Drive, Plan 19, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED. 3.7 Bruce and Janet Hoekstra Part Lot 41, Concession 2, West Green Point - Ward 10 (Sophiasburgh) 5

6 The following applicant appeared before Committee: a) Bruce Hoekstra, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Thompson Seconded by Councillor Parks THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, Consent Files B57-07 and B58-07 (Bruce and Janet Hoekstra) for lands located in Part Lot 41, Concession 2, West Green Point Ward 10 (Sophiasburgh) BE APPROVED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Bruce and Janet Hoekstra) for lands located Part Lot 41, Concession 2, West Green Point, Ward 10 (Sophiasburgh) BE APPROVED. 3.8 Richard Johnston and Vida Zalnieriunas Part Lots 14 and 15, Concession 1 Ward 7 (Hillier) The following applicant appeared before Committee: a) Richard Johnston, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report, save and except Conditions #2 and #3. 6

7 Motion PL Moved by Councillor Slik Seconded by Councillor Parks THAT subject to the conditions outlined in the Planning Staff Report, save and except Condition #2 regarding the provision of a test well, and Condition #3 regarding one of the two entrances on the retained lands being removed, Consent File B59-07 (Richard Johnston and Vida Zalnieriunas) for lands located in Part Lots 14 and 15, Concession 1, Ward 7 (Hillier) BE APPROVED; THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Richard Johnston and Vida Zalnieriunas) for lands located in Part Lots 14 and 15, Concession 1, Ward 7 (Hillier) BE APPROVED; and THAT no further notice is required pursuant to Section 34(17) of the Planning Act. The Chair called for a 10 minute break to reconvene at 8:40 p.m. Committee reconvened with all members present, excepting Mayor Finnegan and Councillor Alyea. Councillors Campbell, Best, Mertens, Turpin and MacDonald were also present. 3.9 Donna Carmichael (Millpond Marketplace Inc.) Part Lots 70 and 71, Plan 2 Ward 2 (Bloomfield) The Committee received a verbal report on the following correspondence received by the Planning Department that was not included with the printed agenda: a) dated May 28, 2007 from Dave Smythe, part owner and Project Manager for Mill Pond Marketplace, 15 Mill Street, Box 301, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, providing additional information in favour of the subject application, b) Letter dated May 30, 2007 from William Procter, Solicitor for Beatty Seads Ltd., in opposition to the subject application. The following individuals appeared before Committee: a) Dave Smythe, on behalf of himself and Donna Carmichael, part owner, in agreement with the recommendations as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Mr. Smythe provided a powerpoint presentation to Committee on the subject application. b) Ernie Margetson, Project Engineer and Ruth Ferguson Aulthouse, Planner, were also present on behalf of the applicants. 7

8 The following deputations appeared before Committee in opposition: a) Richard Hampton, 29 Stanley Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, b) John Weston, 19 Mill Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, c) Gordon Laurie, 106 Main Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, d) Don Roberts, 12 Brick Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, e) John Anderson, RR #2, Picton, Ontario, K0K 2T0, f) Wayne Carruthers, 19 Mill Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, g) Marilyn Toomes, 18 Brick Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, h) Kim Stacey, 14 Brick Street, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey Seconded by Councillor Thompson THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Donna Carmichael) for lands located in Part Lots 70 and 71, Plan 2, Ward 2 (Bloomfield ) BE DEFERRED. The Chair called for a 5 minute break to reconvene at 10:10 p.m. Committee reconvened with all members present, excepting Mayor Finnegan and Councillor Alyea. Councillors Campbell, Best, Mertens, Turpin and MacDonald were also present. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey Seconded by Councillor Parks THAT the provisions of the Procedure By-law be waived to allow the meeting to continue beyond the three-hour time limit. Councillor Turpin left at this point in the meeting Ontario Ltd. (Lloyd s Construction) Part Lot 18, Concession 11, NWWL Part of Lot 2, Reference Compiled Plan 29 - Ward 6 (Hallowell) The Committee received a verbal report on the following correspondence received by the Planning Department that was not included with the printed agenda: 8

9 a) Letter dated May 24, 2007 from Jim and Margaret Tripp, RR #1, 2133 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, in opposition to the subject application. The following applicant appeared before Committee: a) Lyle Lloyd, in agreement with the recommendations as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Mr. Lloyd circulated additional information to Committee members regarding the subject application. The following deputations appeared before Committee in opposition: a) Richard Davies, 2084 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, b) Paul Squire, 2169 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, c) Margaret Mark, 2149 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, d) Jim Tripp, 2133 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0, e) Erich Hubner, 2083 County Road 1, Bloomfield, Ontario, K0K 1G0. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Parks THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward ( Ontario Limited) for lands located in Part of Lot 18, Concession 11, NWWL, Part of Lot 2, Reference Compiled Plan 29, Ward 6 (Hallowell), BE DEFERRED. Councillor Best left at this point in the meeting Robert and Grace Williams Part Lot 8, Concession 1, NWCP - Ward 6 (Hallowell) The following individual appeared before Committee: a) Linda Denboer, new property owner of the subject lands, in agreement with the conditions of consent as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. 9

10 Motion PL Moved by Councillor Bailey THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Robert and Grace Williams) for lands located in Part Lot 8, Concession 1, NWGP, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE APPROVED. Councillor Mertens left at this point in the meeting Ontario Inc. (Sandbank Homes Inc.) Lots , Lot 1024 and Part of Lot 1023, Plan 24 - Ward 1 (Picton) Neither the Applicant nor the Agent for the applicant appeared before Committee. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Thompson THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Sandbank Homes Inc.) for lands located in Lots , Lot 1024 and Part of Lot 1023, Plan 24, and Parts 1 and 2 on Registered Plan 47R-1331, Ward 1 (Picton) BE APPROVED Archives and Collections Society Part Lot 265, Plan 24 - Ward 1 (Picton) The following applicant appeared before Committee: a) Paul Adamthwaite, in agreement with the Planning Staff Report, but in opposition to the recommendation regarding the waiving of application fees. 10

11 Motion PL Moved by Councillor Thompson Seconded by Councillor Parks THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Archives and Collections Society) for lands located in Part Lot 265, Plan 24, Ward 1 (Picton) BE APPROVED. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Latchford Seconded by Councillor Bailey THAT the request to waive the Rezoning and Site Plan Review Application fees BE DENIED Rosemary Anderson (Home Hardware) Part Lot 18, Concession 3, Military Tract - Ward 6 (Hallowell) The following individual appeared before Committee: a) Heather Reilly, agent for the applicant, and Adam Busscher, owner of the Home Hardward Picton Store, in agreement with the recommendations as outlined in the Planning Staff Report. Dan Lucas of Cornerstone Builders Ltd. and an engineering representative from Read, Voorhees & Associates provided additional information to Committee on the subject application. The following deputation appeared before Committee in opposition: a) Ed Taylor, 265 Sandy Hook Road, Picton, Ontario, K0K 2T0, b) Willem Maas, 25 Main Street, Picton, Ontario, K0K 2T0, c) Valerie Taylor, Loyalist Parkway, Picton, Ontario, K0K 2T0. Councillor MacDonald left at this point in the meeting. 11

12 Motion PL Moved by Councillor Thompson THAT Official Plan Amendment No. 34 to the County Official Plan (Rosemary Anderson/Home Hardware) for lands located in Part Lot 18, Concession 3, Military Tract, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE DEFERRED; and THAT Zoning Amendment File Z to Comprehensive Zoning By-law No , as amended for the County of Prince Edward (Rosemary Anderson/Home Hardware) for lands located in Part of Lot 18, Concession 3, Military Tract, Ward 6 (Hallowell) BE DEFERRED. Councillor Slik left at this point in the meeting. Motion PL Moved by Councillor Parks Seconded by Councillor Bailey THAT the Planning Services Committee now adjourn at 12:20 a.m. on May 31, CLERK Victoria Leskie MAYOR Leo P. Finnegan 12