Lahore University of Management Sciences. Phil 228/Pol 207 Contemporary Debates in Political Philosophy Summer 2017

Transcription

1 Phil 228/Pol 207 Contemporary Debates in Political Philosophy Summer 2017 Instructor Room No. Office Hours Telephone Secretary/TA TA Office Hours Course URL (if any) Anwar ul Haq TBA TBA Course Basics Credit Hours 4 Lecture(s) Nbr of Lec(s) Per Recitation/Lab (per week) Nbr of Lec(s) Per Tutorial (per week) Nbr of Lec(s) Per 4 Duration 110 minutes NA Duration NA Duration Course Distribution Core Elective * Open for Student Category All Close for Student Category None COURSE DESCRIPTION This course engages with key contemporary issues in analytic western political philosophy. The focus will be on justice; however, we shall additionally touch upon debates surrounding rights, equality, and liberty. We will investigate justice to understand what is at issue; we will subject it to careful philosophical analyses, and examine its relevance to crucial contemporary issues. We will attempt to reach our own defensible conclusions through discussion and debate. The following questions will be central to our discussion: What is justice? Is it fairness? Is it equal treatment? Is it getting one s due? Or perhaps conception of justice varies across societies? Also, what requirements a society need fulfill to be called just? For instance, is it acceptable that a select few, virtually living next to extremely deprived, have more money than they could possibly spend? Or should the rich be heavily taxed to help the impoverished (and on what grounds)? Should earned income be taxed the same as unearned income? Moreover, is it just that people endowed with superior natural abilities enjoy ensuing rewards? Perhaps such rewards are undeserved and partly owed to those disadvantaged in the natural lottery? Our public policy depends on answers to these questions and every individual inhabiting a society has a stake in it.

2 COURSE PREREQUISITE(S) None COURSE OBJECTIVES Acquire a detailed knowledge of some of the concepts, positions and arguments in the central literature in contemporary political philosophy. Acquire a sense of how the positions on different topics relate to each other. Engage closely and critically with some of the ideas studied. Develop an ability to think independently about some of the ideas studied. Construct arguments, responding to but not merely reproducing the arguments of others. Learning Outcomes Ability to understand and analyze philosophical arguments. Ability to write sophisticated philosophical essays. Ability to develop defensible arguments for or against a philosophical issue. Grading Breakup and Policy Tests/assignments: 30 Midterm: 35 Final essay: 35% Examination Detail Midterm Exam Yes Final Exam No

3 COURSE OVERVIEW Topics INTRODUCTION Recommended Readings Session Introduction to contemporary political philosophy - The relationship between justice, rights, equality, and liberty Perry, J., Bratman, M., & Fischer, J. (2007). Ethics and Society. Introduction to philosophy (4th ed., pp ). New York: Oxford University Press. I. JUSTICE: AN INTRODUCTION Session The nature of justice - Situating justice in the historical context - Introduction to contemporary debates surrounding justice Ryan, A. (1991). Introduction. In Ryan, A. (Ed.), Justice. New York: Oxford University Press. Vallentyne, P. (2007). Distributive Justice. In Goodin, R., Pettit, P., Pogge, T., &. Distributive Justice. A companion to contemporary political philosophy (2nd ed., pp ). Malden, MA: Blackwell II. JOHN RAWLS THEORY OF JUSTICE Session 5-6 Justice as Fairness Rawls, J. (1971). Justice as Fairness. In A theory of justice. (pp. 3-46). Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Session 7-8 The Principles of Justice (Equal liberty for all; fair equality of opportunity, and compensating the worstoff) Rawls, J. (1971). The Principles of Justice. In A theory of justice. (pp ). Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Session The Original Position (Arguing for the principles of justice) - Political Equality Rawls, J. (1971). The Original Position. In A theory of justice. (pp ). Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Rawls, J. (1999). A Kantian Conception of Equality. In Freeman, S. (Ed.), John Rawls: Collected Papers. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Session Global Justice Rawls, J. (1999). The law of peoples. (pp ). Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

4 III. RAWLS AND HIS CRITICS Session The original position: is its characterization convincing? Nagel, T. (1989). Rawls on Justice. In Daniels, N. (Ed.), Reading Rawls. California: Stanford University Press. Hare, R. (1989). Rawls Theory of Justice. Daniels, N. (Ed.), California: Stanford University Press. Session Rawls methodology: is it compelling? Scanlon, T. (1989). Rawls Theory of Justice. In Daniels, N. (Ed.), Reading Rawls. California: Stanford University Press. Session Rawls principles of justice: are they defensible? Hart, H. (1989). Rawls on Liberty and its Priority. In Daniels, N. (Ed.), Reading Rawls. California: Stanford University Press. Daniels, N. (1989). Equal Liberty and Unequal Worth of Liberty. In Daniels, N. (Ed.), Reading Rawls. California: Stanford University Press. Session Rawls views on global justice: are they plausible? Are there cogent alternatives? O'Neill, O. (2000). Bounds of justice. (pp ). Cambridge: Cambridge university press. IV. COMPETING THEORIES OF JUSTICE (Perhaps Rawls got things wrong) Session Libertariansim Nozick R. (2006). Distributive Justice. In Goodin, R., Pettit, P. (Ed.), Contemporary Political philosophy: an anthology. Malden: Blackwell Publishing. Session Capabilities Approach Justice: Awarding capabilities, attaining welfare Sen, A. (2006). Equality of What? In Goodin, R., Pettit, P. (Ed.), Contemporary political philosophy: an anthology. Malden: Blackwell Publishing. Nussbaum M., (2011). Creating capabilities. (pp. 1-67, ). Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Session Communitariansim MacIntyre, A. (2007). After Virtue. Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press. (selections) Sandel, M. (2006). The Procedural Republic and the Unencumbered Self. In Goodin, R., Pettit, P. (Ed.), Contemporary political philosophy: an anthology. Malden: Blackwell Publishing.

5 Textbook(s)/Supplementary Readings Goodin, R., & Pettit, P., (Eds.). (2005). Contemporary political philosophy: an anthology. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing. Kymlicka, W., (2002). Contemporary political philosophy: an introduction. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Daniels, N. (Ed.). (1989). Reading Rawls. California: Stanford University Press. N.B. The list of readings may change depending on how the course proceeds.