Electing the President. Chapter 12 Mathematical Modeling

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Electing the President. Chapter 12 Mathematical Modeling"

Transcription

1 Electing the President Chapter 12 Mathematical Modeling

2 Phases of the Election 1. State Primaries seeking nomination how to position the candidate to gather momentum in a set of contests 2. Conventions now mostly for show 3. General Election how to win enough Electoral Votes

3 Mathematics and Elections Clarify the better and worse campaign strategies in each phase (dominate?) Help understand the effect that different election reforms would have on strategies and outcomes

4 Two-Candidate Elections (Spatial Models) Modeling the Election: Assume voters respond to positions that candidates take on issues Assume that attitudes of voters can be represented along a left-right continuum from very liberal (on the left) to very conservative (on the right) e.g. government intervention in the economy liberal/left= much intervention conservative/right=little intervention

5 Symmetric Unimodal Distribution Voter distribution represented by a curve that gives the number of voters who have attitudes at each point along a horizontal axis One peak(mode) = Unimodal Median M of a voter distribution is the point on the horizontal axis where half the voters have attitudes that lie to the left and half to the right

6 Two-Candidates Attitudes of the voters are considered a fixed quantity in calculations BUT: The decisions of the voters will depend on the positions that candidates take. Voters will vote for the candidate with attitudes closer to their own

7 Symmetric Unimodal Distribution Both Candidates Take a position In the middle

8

9

10

11 Two-Candidates There is an incentive for both candidates to move toward M but not overstep it. Taking a position at M, guarantees A at least 50% of the total votes no matter what B does

12 Two-Candidates A position is maximin for a candidate if there is no other position that can guarantee a better outcome more votes for that candidate whatever position the other candidate adopts.

13 Two-Candidates A pair of positions is in equilibrium if, once chosen by both candidates, neither candidate has an incentive to depart from it unilaterally (i.e., by himself)

14 Two-Candidates Median-voter theorem: In a two-candidate election with an odd number of voters, M is the unique equilibrium position.

15 Spatial modeling Dept Stores First Application in business Two retail businesses want to locate on main street Assume transportation is costly and people will go to the store closer to them Where to locate? No matter how the population is distributed the best location is the median

16 Mean Distribution l = 1 n k i= 1 nili k=number of different positions i that voters take on the continuum n i =number of voters at position i l i =location of position i on the continuum n = k i= 1 n 1 + n nk = total number of voters

17 Median and Mean Bimodal two peaks (and not symmetric) Not Symmetric Skewed more voters to the right average position is not best

18 Mean Distribution l = 1 n k i= 1 nili l= 1/19[1(0.1)+3(0.2)+

19 Mean Distribution l = 1 n k i= 1 nili M=.60 l=.56

20 Spatial Models: Multicandidate Elections

21 1/3 Separation Obstacle 1/3-separation obstacle. If A and B are distinct positions that are equidistant from the median of a symmetric distribution and separated from each other by no more than 1/3 of the area under the curve C can take no position that will displace both A and B and enable C to win.

22 2/3 Separation Opportunity 2/3 separation opportunity. If A and B are distinct positions that are equidistant from the median of a symmetric unimodal distribution and separated from each other by at least 2/3 of the area under the curve C can defeat both A and B by taking a position at M.

23 2/3 Separation Opportunity if there is a wide separation between A and B there may be enough room in the middle for C to win.

24 Optimal entry Optimal entry of two candidates, anticipating a third entrant- Assume A and B are the first candidates to enter an election and anticipate the later entry of C. Assume that the distribution of voters is uniform. Then the optimal positions of A and B are to enter at ¼ and ¾, whereby ¼ of the voters lie to the left of A and ¼ to the right of B. Then C can do no better than win 25% of the vote.

25 Winnowing the Field Positioning is important Maximize your vote totals Deter new candidates from entering Beating expectations is the name of the game in the early primaries Result Bandwagon Effect induces voters to vote for the presumed winner, independent of his merit

26 Poll Plurality Voting voters are sincere A B C C C A B A B Then A=6, B=3, C=2 A vs B A-6 B-3 A vs C A-4 C-5 B vs C - B-3 C-6

27 Poll assumption If necessary, voters adjust their sincere voting strategies to differentiate between the top two candidates as revealed in the poll, voting for the one they prefer

28 Poll A B C C C A B A B Poll assumption. If necessary, voters adjust their sincere voting strategies to differentiate between the top two candidates as revealed in the poll, voting for the one they prefer Then A=6, B=3, C=0

29 Condorcet Winner Unsuccessful Given the poll assumption, a Condorcet winner will always lose if he or she is not one of the top two candidates identified by the poll Note even if C was given serious consideration in this race A would still win with a plurality of the votes

30 Election Reform: Concern after the 2000 Election has centered on making balloting more accurate and reliable and discrimination among different classes of voters No reforms have tried to address the Plurality flaw of the CWC.

31 Condorcet Winner Successful Given the poll assumption, a Condorcet winner will always win if he or she is one of the top two candidates identified by the poll.

32 Approval Voting Approval Voting voters can vote for as many candidates as they like or find acceptable. The candidate with the most approval votes wins the election. In 2000 polls showed that Gore was the second choice of most Nader voters. Gore would have won Florida and the Election.

33 Voting for your second choice In a three-candidate election under approval voting, it is never rational for a voter to vote only for a second choice. If a voter finds a second choice acceptable, he should also vote for the first choice. In plurality voting a strategic voter would vote for his second choice if he thought his first couldn t win

34 Dichotomous preferences Dichotomous preferences if the voter divides the set of candidates into two subsets a preferred subset and a not preferred subset and is indifferent among all candidates in each subset.

35 Dichotomous Preferences Blue = approve Red = disapprove Results B=6, C=5, A= A C B B A C C B D D D A

36 Dichotomous Preferences Blue = approve Red = disapprove In pairwise contests? 4: (A B), (C D) 3: (C), (A B D) 2: (B C D), (A) A C B B A C C B D D D A

37 Approval Voting A Condorcet winner will always be elected under approval voting if all voters have dichotomous preferences and choose their dominant strategies.

38 Electoral College It s original purpose was to place the selection of a president in the hands of a body that, while its members would be chosen by the people, would be sufficiently removed from them that it could make more deliberative choices Is this true today?

39 Electoral College Problem winner takes all of the state electoral votes. Solution split the electoral votes among the candidates by the % of their votes this was done in 2004 in Maine and Nebraska.

40 Electoral College The presidency is decided by 51 players who cast their votes in block this is a weighted voting system The power of the individual voters in each state, as pivotal voters in the decision, makes California voters about 3 times as powerful as voters in small states.

41 Electoral College Focus in the 2004 Election was on the tossup states in an effort to maximize the candidates expected electoral vote. Candidates spent their time and money on states where the election was uncertain and ignored states where the polls showed either certain victory or defeat. E.g. can you remember seeing George Bush in New York during the campaign (after the convention)?

Electing the President. Chapter 17 Mathematical Modeling

Electing the President. Chapter 17 Mathematical Modeling Electing the President Chapter 17 Mathematical Modeling What do these events have in common? 1824 John Quincy Adams defeats Andrew Jackson 1876 Rutherford B. Hayes defeats Samuel Tilden 1888 Benjamin Harrison

More information

Math for Liberal Studies

Math for Liberal Studies Math for Liberal Studies As we have discussed, when there are only two candidates in an election, deciding the winner is easy May s Theorem states that majority rule is the best system However, the situation

More information

Answers to Practice Problems. Median voter theorem, supermajority rule, & bicameralism.

Answers to Practice Problems. Median voter theorem, supermajority rule, & bicameralism. Answers to Practice Problems Median voter theorem, supermajority rule, & bicameralism. Median Voter Theorem Questions: 2.1-2.4, and 2.8. Located at the end of Hinich and Munger, chapter 2, The Spatial

More information

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream Lesson Plan

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream Lesson Plan Lesson Plan For All Practical Purposes An Introduction to Social Choice Majority Rule and Condorcet s Method Mathematical Literacy in Today s World, 9th ed. Other Voting Systems for Three or More Candidates

More information

Main idea: Voting systems matter.

Main idea: Voting systems matter. Voting Systems Main idea: Voting systems matter. Electoral College Winner takes all in most states (48/50) (plurality in states) 270/538 electoral votes needed to win (majority) If 270 isn t obtained -

More information

Math for Liberal Arts MAT 110: Chapter 12 Notes

Math for Liberal Arts MAT 110: Chapter 12 Notes Math for Liberal Arts MAT 110: Chapter 12 Notes Voting Methods David J. Gisch Voting: Does the Majority Always Rule? Choosing a Winner In elections with more then 2 candidates, there are several acceptable

More information

Font Size: A A. Eric Maskin and Amartya Sen JANUARY 19, 2017 ISSUE. 1 of 7 2/21/ :01 AM

Font Size: A A. Eric Maskin and Amartya Sen JANUARY 19, 2017 ISSUE. 1 of 7 2/21/ :01 AM 1 of 7 2/21/2017 10:01 AM Font Size: A A Eric Maskin and Amartya Sen JANUARY 19, 2017 ISSUE Americans have been using essentially the same rules to elect presidents since the beginning of the Republic.

More information

Arrow s Impossibility Theorem

Arrow s Impossibility Theorem Arrow s Impossibility Theorem Some announcements Final reflections due on Monday. You now have all of the methods and so you can begin analyzing the results of your election. Today s Goals We will discuss

More information

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream The application of mathematics to the study of human beings their behavior, values, interactions, conflicts, and methods of making decisions is generally

More information

Candidate Citizen Models

Candidate Citizen Models Candidate Citizen Models General setup Number of candidates is endogenous Candidates are unable to make binding campaign promises whoever wins office implements her ideal policy Citizens preferences are

More information

VOTING TO ELECT A SINGLE CANDIDATE

VOTING TO ELECT A SINGLE CANDIDATE N. R. Miller 05/01/97 5 th rev. 8/22/06 VOTING TO ELECT A SINGLE CANDIDATE This discussion focuses on single-winner elections, in which a single candidate is elected from a field of two or more candidates.

More information

1.6 Arrow s Impossibility Theorem

1.6 Arrow s Impossibility Theorem 1.6 Arrow s Impossibility Theorem Some announcements Homework #2: Text (pages 33-35) 51, 56-60, 61, 65, 71-75 (this is posted on Sakai) For Monday, read Chapter 2 (pages 36-57) Today s Goals We will discuss

More information

Problems with Group Decision Making

Problems with Group Decision Making Problems with Group Decision Making There are two ways of evaluating political systems. 1. Consequentialist ethics evaluate actions, policies, or institutions in regard to the outcomes they produce. 2.

More information

1 Electoral Competition under Certainty

1 Electoral Competition under Certainty 1 Electoral Competition under Certainty We begin with models of electoral competition. This chapter explores electoral competition when voting behavior is deterministic; the following chapter considers

More information

Published in Canadian Journal of Economics 27 (1995), Copyright c 1995 by Canadian Economics Association

Published in Canadian Journal of Economics 27 (1995), Copyright c 1995 by Canadian Economics Association Published in Canadian Journal of Economics 27 (1995), 261 301. Copyright c 1995 by Canadian Economics Association Spatial Models of Political Competition Under Plurality Rule: A Survey of Some Explanations

More information

Desirable properties of social choice procedures. We now outline a number of properties that are desirable for these social choice procedures:

Desirable properties of social choice procedures. We now outline a number of properties that are desirable for these social choice procedures: Desirable properties of social choice procedures We now outline a number of properties that are desirable for these social choice procedures: 1. Pareto [named for noted economist Vilfredo Pareto (1848-1923)]

More information

Elections with Only 2 Alternatives

Elections with Only 2 Alternatives Math 203: Chapter 12: Voting Systems and Drawbacks: How do we decide the best voting system? Elections with Only 2 Alternatives What is an individual preference list? Majority Rules: Pick 1 of 2 candidates

More information

that changes needed to be made when electing their Presidential nominee. Iowa, at the time had a

that changes needed to be made when electing their Presidential nominee. Iowa, at the time had a Part I The Iowa caucuses are perhaps the most important yet mysterious contest in American politics. It all began after the 1968 Democratic National Convention protest, the party decided that changes needed

More information

Problems with Group Decision Making

Problems with Group Decision Making Problems with Group Decision Making There are two ways of evaluating political systems: 1. Consequentialist ethics evaluate actions, policies, or institutions in regard to the outcomes they produce. 2.

More information

answers to some of the sample exercises : Public Choice

answers to some of the sample exercises : Public Choice answers to some of the sample exercises : Public Choice Ques 1 The following table lists the way that 5 different voters rank five different alternatives. Is there a Condorcet winner under pairwise majority

More information

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems. Voting I 1/36

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems. Voting I 1/36 Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems Voting I 1/36 Each even year every member of the house is up for election and about a third of the senate seats are up for grabs. Most people do not realize that there

More information

12.2 Defects in Voting Methods

12.2 Defects in Voting Methods 12.2 Defects in Voting Methods Recall the different Voting Methods: 1. Plurality - one vote to one candidate, the others get nothing The remaining three use a preference ballot, where all candidates are

More information

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems. Voting I 1/31

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems. Voting I 1/31 Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems Voting I 1/31 In 2014 every member of the house is up for election and about a third of the senate seats will be up for grabs. Most people do not realize that there

More information

Public Choice : (c) Single Peaked Preferences and the Median Voter Theorem

Public Choice : (c) Single Peaked Preferences and the Median Voter Theorem Public Choice : (c) Single Peaked Preferences and the Median Voter Theorem The problem with pairwise majority rule as a choice mechanism, is that it does not always produce a winner. What is meant by a

More information

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems, Continued

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems, Continued Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems, Continued 7 March 2014 Voting III 7 March 2014 1/27 Last Time We ve discussed several voting systems and conditions which may or may not be satisfied by a system.

More information

The Manipulability of Voting Systems. Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them.

The Manipulability of Voting Systems. Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them. Chapter 10 The Manipulability of Voting Systems Chapter Objectives Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them. Explain what is meant by voting manipulation. Determine if a voter,

More information

Public Choice. Slide 1

Public Choice. Slide 1 Public Choice We investigate how people can come up with a group decision mechanism. Several aspects of our economy can not be handled by the competitive market. Whenever there is market failure, there

More information

THE MEDIAN VOTER THEOREM (ONE DIMENSION)

THE MEDIAN VOTER THEOREM (ONE DIMENSION) THE MEDIAN VOTER THEOREM (ONE DIMENSION) 1 2 Single Dimensional Spatial Model Alternatives are the set of points on a line Various ideologies on a spectrum Spending on different programs etc. Single-peaked

More information

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems

Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems Voting: Issues, Problems, and Systems 3 March 2014 Voting I 3 March 2014 1/27 In 2014 every member of the house is up for election and about a third of the senate seats will be up for grabs. Most people

More information

Lecture 11. Voting. Outline

Lecture 11. Voting. Outline Lecture 11 Voting Outline Hanging Chads Again Did Ralph Nader cause the Bush presidency? A Paradox Left Middle Right 40 25 35 Robespierre Danton Lafarge D L R L R D A Paradox Consider Robespierre versus

More information

Chapter 1 Practice Test Questions

Chapter 1 Practice Test Questions 0728 Finite Math Chapter 1 Practice Test Questions VOCABULARY. On the exam, be prepared to match the correct definition to the following terms: 1) Voting Elements: Single-choice ballot, preference ballot,

More information

A MODEL OF POLITICAL COMPETITION WITH CITIZEN-CANDIDATES. Martin J. Osborne and Al Slivinski. Abstract

A MODEL OF POLITICAL COMPETITION WITH CITIZEN-CANDIDATES. Martin J. Osborne and Al Slivinski. Abstract Published in Quarterly Journal of Economics 111 (1996), 65 96. Copyright c 1996 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. A MODEL OF POLITICAL COMPETITION

More information

Voting rules: (Dixit and Skeath, ch 14) Recall parkland provision decision:

Voting rules: (Dixit and Skeath, ch 14) Recall parkland provision decision: rules: (Dixit and Skeath, ch 14) Recall parkland provision decision: Assume - n=10; - total cost of proposed parkland=38; - if provided, each pays equal share = 3.8 - there are two groups of individuals

More information

Simple methods for single winner elections

Simple methods for single winner elections Simple methods for single winner elections Christoph Börgers Mathematics Department Tufts University Medford, MA April 14, 2018 http://emerald.tufts.edu/~cborgers/ I have posted these slides there. 1 /

More information

A Study of Approval voting on Large Poisson Games

A Study of Approval voting on Large Poisson Games A Study of Approval voting on Large Poisson Games Ecole Polytechnique Simposio de Analisis Económico December 2008 Matías Núñez () A Study of Approval voting on Large Poisson Games 1 / 15 A controversy

More information

Math116Chap1VotingPart2.notebook January 12, Part II. Other Methods of Voting and Other "Fairness Criteria"

Math116Chap1VotingPart2.notebook January 12, Part II. Other Methods of Voting and Other Fairness Criteria Part II Other Methods of Voting and Other "Fairness Criteria" Plurality with Elimination Method Round 1. Count the first place votes for each candidate, just as you would in the plurality method. If a

More information

(67686) Mathematical Foundations of AI June 18, Lecture 6

(67686) Mathematical Foundations of AI June 18, Lecture 6 (67686) Mathematical Foundations of AI June 18, 2008 Lecturer: Ariel D. Procaccia Lecture 6 Scribe: Ezra Resnick & Ariel Imber 1 Introduction: Social choice theory Thus far in the course, we have dealt

More information

Election Theory. How voters and parties behave strategically in democratic systems. Mark Crowley

Election Theory. How voters and parties behave strategically in democratic systems. Mark Crowley How voters and parties behave strategically in democratic systems Department of Computer Science University of British Columbia January 30, 2006 Sources Voting Theory Jeff Gill and Jason Gainous. "Why

More information

Lecture 12: Topics in Voting Theory

Lecture 12: Topics in Voting Theory Lecture 12: Topics in Voting Theory Eric Pacuit ILLC, University of Amsterdam staff.science.uva.nl/ epacuit epacuit@science.uva.nl Lecture Date: May 11, 2006 Caput Logic, Language and Information: Social

More information

Notes for Session 7 Basic Voting Theory and Arrow s Theorem

Notes for Session 7 Basic Voting Theory and Arrow s Theorem Notes for Session 7 Basic Voting Theory and Arrow s Theorem We follow up the Impossibility (Session 6) of pooling expert probabilities, while preserving unanimities in both unconditional and conditional

More information

Mathematical Thinking. Chapter 9 Voting Systems

Mathematical Thinking. Chapter 9 Voting Systems Mathematical Thinking Chapter 9 Voting Systems Voting Systems A voting system is a rule for transforming a set of individual preferences into a single group decision. What are the desirable properties

More information

Josh Engwer (TTU) Voting Methods 15 July / 49

Josh Engwer (TTU) Voting Methods 15 July / 49 Voting Methods Contemporary Math Josh Engwer TTU 15 July 2015 Josh Engwer (TTU) Voting Methods 15 July 2015 1 / 49 Introduction In free societies, citizens vote for politicians whose values & opinions

More information

On the Rationale of Group Decision-Making

On the Rationale of Group Decision-Making I. SOCIAL CHOICE 1 On the Rationale of Group Decision-Making Duncan Black Source: Journal of Political Economy, 56(1) (1948): 23 34. When a decision is reached by voting or is arrived at by a group all

More information

Lecture 16: Voting systems

Lecture 16: Voting systems Lecture 16: Voting systems Economics 336 Economics 336 (Toronto) Lecture 16: Voting systems 1 / 18 Introduction Last lecture we looked at the basic theory of majority voting: instability in voting: Condorcet

More information

9.3 Other Voting Systems for Three or More Candidates

9.3 Other Voting Systems for Three or More Candidates 9.3 Other Voting Systems for Three or More Candidates With three or more candidates, there are several additional procedures that seem to give reasonable ways to choose a winner. If we look closely at

More information

PROBLEM SET #2: VOTING RULES

PROBLEM SET #2: VOTING RULES POLI 309 Fall 2006 due 10/13/06 PROBLEM SET #2: VOTING RULES Write your answers directly on this page. Unless otherwise specified, assume all voters vote sincerely, i.e., in accordance with their preferences.

More information

Chapter 10. The Manipulability of Voting Systems. For All Practical Purposes: Effective Teaching. Chapter Briefing

Chapter 10. The Manipulability of Voting Systems. For All Practical Purposes: Effective Teaching. Chapter Briefing Chapter 10 The Manipulability of Voting Systems For All Practical Purposes: Effective Teaching As a teaching assistant, you most likely will administer and proctor many exams. Although it is tempting to

More information

First Principle Black s Median Voter Theorem (S&B definition):

First Principle Black s Median Voter Theorem (S&B definition): The Unidimensional Spatial Model First Principle Black s Median Voter Theorem (S&B definition): If members of a group have single-peaked preferences, then the ideal point of the median voter has an empty

More information

Measuring Fairness. Paul Koester () MA 111, Voting Theory September 7, / 25

Measuring Fairness. Paul Koester () MA 111, Voting Theory September 7, / 25 Measuring Fairness We ve seen FOUR methods for tallying votes: Plurality Borda Count Pairwise Comparisons Plurality with Elimination Are these methods reasonable? Are these methods fair? Today we study

More information

Computational Social Choice: Spring 2007

Computational Social Choice: Spring 2007 Computational Social Choice: Spring 2007 Ulle Endriss Institute for Logic, Language and Computation University of Amsterdam Ulle Endriss 1 Plan for Today This lecture will be an introduction to voting

More information

Voting Methods for Municipal Elections: Propaganda, Field Experiments and what USA voters want from an Election Algorithm

Voting Methods for Municipal Elections: Propaganda, Field Experiments and what USA voters want from an Election Algorithm Voting Methods for Municipal Elections: Propaganda, Field Experiments and what USA voters want from an Election Algorithm Kathryn Lenz, Mathematics and Statistics Department, University of Minnesota Duluth

More information

Indicate the answer choice that best completes the statement or answers the question.

Indicate the answer choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. Indicate the answer choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. The Electoral College Process 1. According to the diagram, what is Congress s role in the Electoral College process?

More information

University of Toronto Department of Economics. Party formation in single-issue politics [revised]

University of Toronto Department of Economics. Party formation in single-issue politics [revised] University of Toronto Department of Economics Working Paper 296 Party formation in single-issue politics [revised] By Martin J. Osborne and Rabee Tourky July 13, 2007 Party formation in single-issue politics

More information

Many Social Choice Rules

Many Social Choice Rules Many Social Choice Rules 1 Introduction So far, I have mentioned several of the most commonly used social choice rules : pairwise majority rule, plurality, plurality with a single run off, the Borda count.

More information

Math Circle Voting Methods Practice. March 31, 2013

Math Circle Voting Methods Practice. March 31, 2013 Voting Methods Practice 1) Three students are running for class vice president: Chad, Courtney and Gwyn. Each student ranked the candidates in order of preference. The chart below shows the results of

More information

Social choice theory

Social choice theory Social choice theory A brief introduction Denis Bouyssou CNRS LAMSADE Paris, France Introduction Motivation Aims analyze a number of properties of electoral systems present a few elements of the classical

More information

Intro Prefs & Voting Electoral comp. Voter Turnout Agency GIP SIP Rent seeking Partisans. Political Economics. Dr. Marc Gronwald Dr.

Intro Prefs & Voting Electoral comp. Voter Turnout Agency GIP SIP Rent seeking Partisans. Political Economics. Dr. Marc Gronwald Dr. Political Economics Dr. Marc Gronwald Dr. Silke Uebelmesser Ludwig-Maximilians University Munich Summer term 2010 Motivation Total government spending as fraction of GDP in the late 1990s: Sweden: 60%;

More information

The Electoral College. What is it?, how does it work?, the pros, and the cons

The Electoral College. What is it?, how does it work?, the pros, and the cons The Electoral College What is it?, how does it work?, the pros, and the cons What is the Electoral College? n E lec tor al College- A body of electors chosen to elect the President and Vice President of

More information

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream Lesson Plan

Chapter 9: Social Choice: The Impossible Dream Lesson Plan Lesson Plan For ll Practical Purposes Voting and Social hoice Majority Rule and ondorcet s Method Mathematical Literacy in Today s World, 7th ed. Other Voting Systems for Three or More andidates Plurality

More information

Classical papers: Osborbe and Slivinski (1996) and Besley and Coate (1997)

Classical papers: Osborbe and Slivinski (1996) and Besley and Coate (1997) The identity of politicians is endogenized Typical approach: any citizen may enter electoral competition at a cost. There is no pre-commitment on the platforms, and winner implements his or her ideal policy.

More information

Fairness Criteria. Review: Election Methods

Fairness Criteria. Review: Election Methods Review: Election Methods Plurality method: the candidate with a plurality of votes wins. Plurality-with-elimination method (Instant runoff): Eliminate the candidate with the fewest first place votes. Keep

More information

Issue Overview: How the U.S. elects its presidents

Issue Overview: How the U.S. elects its presidents Issue Overview: How the U.S. elects its presidents By Bloomberg, adapted by Newsela staff on 09.27.16 Word Count 660 TOP: Voters head to the polls on Super Tuesday during the primaries. Photo by Alex Wong.

More information

Arrow s Impossibility Theorem on Social Choice Systems

Arrow s Impossibility Theorem on Social Choice Systems Arrow s Impossibility Theorem on Social Choice Systems Ashvin A. Swaminathan January 11, 2013 Abstract Social choice theory is a field that concerns methods of aggregating individual interests to determine

More information

Voting Systems That Combine Approval and Preference

Voting Systems That Combine Approval and Preference Voting Systems That Combine Approval and Preference Steven J. Brams Department of Politics New York University New York, NY 10003 USA steven.brams@nyu.edu M. Remzi Sanver Department of Economics Istanbul

More information

How Should Members of Parliament (and Presidents) Be Elected? E. Maskin Institute for Advanced Study

How Should Members of Parliament (and Presidents) Be Elected? E. Maskin Institute for Advanced Study How Should Members of Parliament (and Presidents) Be Elected? E. Maskin Institute for Advanced Study What s wrong with this picture? 2005 U.K. General Election Constituency of Croyden Central vote totals

More information

WHY TWO PARTIES? T H I R D PA RT I E S, M E D I A N V O T E RS, D U V E R G E R S L AW, A N D S T R U C T U R A L C O N C E R N S

WHY TWO PARTIES? T H I R D PA RT I E S, M E D I A N V O T E RS, D U V E R G E R S L AW, A N D S T R U C T U R A L C O N C E R N S WHY TWO PARTIES? T H I R D PA RT I E S, M E D I A N V O T E RS, D U V E R G E R S L AW, A N D S T R U C T U R A L C O N C E R N S DUVERGER S LAW Part societal cleavages Capital v. workers Wealthy vs. less

More information

Mathematics and Democracy: Designing Better Voting and Fair-Division Procedures*

Mathematics and Democracy: Designing Better Voting and Fair-Division Procedures* Mathematics and Democracy: Designing Better Voting and Fair-Division Procedures* Steven J. Brams Department of Politics New York University New York, NY 10012 *This essay is adapted, with permission, from

More information

Voting Methods

Voting Methods 1.3-1.5 Voting Methods Some announcements Homework #1: Text (pages 28-33) 1, 4, 7, 10, 12, 19, 22, 29, 32, 38, 42, 50, 51, 56-60, 61, 65 (this is posted on Sakai) Math Center study sessions with Katie

More information

Possible voting reforms in the United States

Possible voting reforms in the United States Possible voting reforms in the United States Since the disputed 2000 Presidential election, there have numerous proposals to improve how elections are conducted. While most proposals have attempted to

More information

Elections and Voting Behavior

Elections and Voting Behavior Edwards, Wattenberg, and Lineberry Government in America: People, Politics, and Policy Fourteenth Edition Chapter 10 Elections and Voting Behavior How American Elections Work Three types of elections:

More information

HOTELLING-DOWNS MODEL OF ELECTORAL COMPETITION AND THE OPTION TO QUIT

HOTELLING-DOWNS MODEL OF ELECTORAL COMPETITION AND THE OPTION TO QUIT HOTELLING-DOWNS MODEL OF ELECTORAL COMPETITION AND THE OPTION TO QUIT ABHIJIT SENGUPTA AND KUNAL SENGUPTA SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS AND POLITICAL SCIENCE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY SYDNEY, NSW 2006 AUSTRALIA Abstract.

More information

SOCIAL CHOICES (Voting Methods) THE PROBLEM. Social Choice and Voting. Terminologies

SOCIAL CHOICES (Voting Methods) THE PROBLEM. Social Choice and Voting. Terminologies SOCIAL CHOICES (Voting Methods) THE PROBLEM In a society, decisions are made by its members in order to come up with a situation that benefits the most. What is the best voting method of arriving at a

More information

VOTING SYSTEMS AND ARROW S THEOREM

VOTING SYSTEMS AND ARROW S THEOREM VOTING SYSTEMS AND ARROW S THEOREM AKHIL MATHEW Abstract. The following is a brief discussion of Arrow s theorem in economics. I wrote it for an economics class in high school. 1. Background Arrow s theorem

More information

Sampling Equilibrium, with an Application to Strategic Voting Martin J. Osborne 1 and Ariel Rubinstein 2 September 12th, 2002.

Sampling Equilibrium, with an Application to Strategic Voting Martin J. Osborne 1 and Ariel Rubinstein 2 September 12th, 2002. Sampling Equilibrium, with an Application to Strategic Voting Martin J. Osborne 1 and Ariel Rubinstein 2 September 12th, 2002 Abstract We suggest an equilibrium concept for a strategic model with a large

More information

Fairness Criteria. Majority Criterion: If a candidate receives a majority of the first place votes, that candidate should win the election.

Fairness Criteria. Majority Criterion: If a candidate receives a majority of the first place votes, that candidate should win the election. Fairness Criteria Majority Criterion: If a candidate receives a majority of the first place votes, that candidate should win the election. The plurality, plurality-with-elimination, and pairwise comparisons

More information

3 Electoral Competition

3 Electoral Competition 3 Electoral Competition We now turn to a discussion of two-party electoral competition in representative democracy. The underlying policy question addressed in this chapter, as well as the remaining chapters

More information

Voting and Electoral Competition

Voting and Electoral Competition Voting and Electoral Competition Prof. Panu Poutvaara University of Munich and Ifo Institute On the organization of the course Lectures, exam at the end Articles to read. In more technical articles, it

More information

MATH4999 Capstone Projects in Mathematics and Economics Topic 3 Voting methods and social choice theory

MATH4999 Capstone Projects in Mathematics and Economics Topic 3 Voting methods and social choice theory MATH4999 Capstone Projects in Mathematics and Economics Topic 3 Voting methods and social choice theory 3.1 Social choice procedures Plurality voting Borda count Elimination procedures Sequential pairwise

More information

Repeat Voting: Two-Vote May Lead More People To Vote

Repeat Voting: Two-Vote May Lead More People To Vote Repeat Voting: Two-Vote May Lead More People To Vote Sergiu Hart October 17, 2017 Abstract A repeat voting procedure is proposed, whereby voting is carried out in two identical rounds. Every voter can

More information

Federal Primary Election Runoffs and Voter Turnout Decline,

Federal Primary Election Runoffs and Voter Turnout Decline, Federal Primary Election Runoffs and Voter Turnout Decline, 1994-2010 July 2011 By: Katherine Sicienski, William Hix, and Rob Richie Summary of Facts and Findings Near-Universal Decline in Turnout: Of

More information

Social Choice: The Impossible Dream. Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them.

Social Choice: The Impossible Dream. Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them. Chapter Objectives Check off these skills when you feel that you have mastered them. Analyze and interpret preference list ballots. Explain three desired properties of Majority Rule. Explain May s theorem.

More information

To understand the U.S. electoral college and, more generally, American democracy, it is critical to understand that when voters go to the polls on

To understand the U.S. electoral college and, more generally, American democracy, it is critical to understand that when voters go to the polls on To understand the U.S. electoral college and, more generally, American democracy, it is critical to understand that when voters go to the polls on Tuesday, November 8th, they are not voting together in

More information

10/23/2012. Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5

10/23/2012. Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5 Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5 Objectives 1. Describe the features of the presidential campaign. 2. Explain how the electoral college provides for the election of the President. 3. Identify several

More information

Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5

Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5 Chapter 13: The Presidency Section 5 Objectives 1. Describe the features of the presidential campaign. 2. Explain how the electoral college provides for the election of the President. 3. Identify several

More information

Mathematics of Voting Systems. Tanya Leise Mathematics & Statistics Amherst College

Mathematics of Voting Systems. Tanya Leise Mathematics & Statistics Amherst College Mathematics of Voting Systems Tanya Leise Mathematics & Statistics Amherst College Arrow s Impossibility Theorem 1) No special treatment of particular voters or candidates 2) Transitivity A>B and B>C implies

More information

Enriqueta Aragones Harvard University and Universitat Pompeu Fabra Andrew Postlewaite University of Pennsylvania. March 9, 2000

Enriqueta Aragones Harvard University and Universitat Pompeu Fabra Andrew Postlewaite University of Pennsylvania. March 9, 2000 Campaign Rhetoric: a model of reputation Enriqueta Aragones Harvard University and Universitat Pompeu Fabra Andrew Postlewaite University of Pennsylvania March 9, 2000 Abstract We develop a model of infinitely

More information

The Mathematics of Voting. The Mathematics of Voting

The Mathematics of Voting. The Mathematics of Voting 1.3 The Borda Count Method 1 In the Borda Count Method each place on a ballot is assigned points. In an election with N candidates we give 1 point for last place, 2 points for second from last place, and

More information

Social Choice & Mechanism Design

Social Choice & Mechanism Design Decision Making in Robots and Autonomous Agents Social Choice & Mechanism Design Subramanian Ramamoorthy School of Informatics 2 April, 2013 Introduction Social Choice Our setting: a set of outcomes agents

More information

The Arrow Impossibility Theorem: Where Do We Go From Here?

The Arrow Impossibility Theorem: Where Do We Go From Here? The Arrow Impossibility Theorem: Where Do We Go From Here? Eric Maskin Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton Arrow Lecture Columbia University December 11, 2009 I thank Amartya Sen and Joseph Stiglitz

More information

The Impossibilities of Voting

The Impossibilities of Voting The Impossibilities of Voting Introduction Majority Criterion Condorcet Criterion Monotonicity Criterion Irrelevant Alternatives Criterion Arrow s Impossibility Theorem 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. Slide

More information

Mathematics and Social Choice Theory. Topic 4 Voting methods with more than 2 alternatives. 4.1 Social choice procedures

Mathematics and Social Choice Theory. Topic 4 Voting methods with more than 2 alternatives. 4.1 Social choice procedures Mathematics and Social Choice Theory Topic 4 Voting methods with more than 2 alternatives 4.1 Social choice procedures 4.2 Analysis of voting methods 4.3 Arrow s Impossibility Theorem 4.4 Cumulative voting

More information

What is the Best Election Method?

What is the Best Election Method? What is the Best Election Method? E. Maskin Harvard University Gorman Lectures University College, London February 2016 Today and tomorrow will explore 2 Today and tomorrow will explore election methods

More information

Intro to Contemporary Math

Intro to Contemporary Math Intro to Contemporary Math Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives Criteria Nicholas Nguyen nicholas.nguyen@uky.edu Department of Mathematics UK Agenda Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives Criteria

More information

Social Choice Majority Vote Graphs Supermajority Voting Supermajority Vote Graphs

Social Choice Majority Vote Graphs Supermajority Voting Supermajority Vote Graphs Social Choice Majority Vote Graphs Supermajority Voting Supermajority Vote Graphs Clemson Miniconference on Discrete Mathematics October 00 Craig A. Tovey Georgia Tech Social Choice HOW should and does

More information

Social welfare functions

Social welfare functions Social welfare functions We have defined a social choice function as a procedure that determines for each possible profile (set of preference ballots) of the voters the winner or set of winners for the

More information

Explaining the Impossible: Kenneth Arrow s Nobel Prize Winning Theorem on Elections

Explaining the Impossible: Kenneth Arrow s Nobel Prize Winning Theorem on Elections Explaining the Impossible: Kenneth Arrow s Nobel Prize Winning Theorem on Elections Dr. Rick Klima Appalachian State University Boone, North Carolina U.S. Presidential Vote Totals, 2000 Candidate Bush

More information

The Electoral College

The Electoral College The Electoral College 1 True or False? The candidate with the most votes is elected president. Answer: Not necessarily. Ask Al Gore. 2 The 2000 Election The Popular Vote Al Gore 50,996,039 George W. Bush

More information

Rationality & Social Choice. Dougherty, POLS 8000

Rationality & Social Choice. Dougherty, POLS 8000 Rationality & Social Choice Dougherty, POLS 8000 Social Choice A. Background 1. Social Choice examines how to aggregate individual preferences fairly. a. Voting is an example. b. Think of yourself writing

More information

The search for a perfect voting system. MATH 105: Contemporary Mathematics. University of Louisville. October 31, 2017

The search for a perfect voting system. MATH 105: Contemporary Mathematics. University of Louisville. October 31, 2017 The search for a perfect voting system MATH 105: Contemporary Mathematics University of Louisville October 31, 2017 Review of Fairness Criteria Fairness Criteria 2 / 14 We ve seen three fairness criteria

More information

Write all responses on separate paper. Use complete sentences, charts and diagrams, as appropriate.

Write all responses on separate paper. Use complete sentences, charts and diagrams, as appropriate. Math 13 HW 5 Chapter 9 Write all responses on separate paper. Use complete sentences, charts and diagrams, as appropriate. 1. Explain why majority rule is not a good way to choose between four alternatives.

More information