Judicial Activism and the Concept of Rights

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Judicial Activism and the Concept of Rights"

Transcription

1 Judcal Actvsm and the Concept of Rghts When Presdent Clnton made hs frst Suprelne Court appontment last summer, he chose someone wth a decdedly centrst vew of the judcary's role n Anercan socety. Nonetheless, on the frst day of Ruth Bader Gnsburg'S confrmaton hearngs, a number of Senate Republcans expressed concern that her nomnaton nght sgnal a return to the "judcal actvsm" of the recent past. Senator Orrn Hatch took up the theme wth these cautonary words: Under our system, a Supreme Court justce should nterpret the law, and not legslate hs or her own polcy preference from the bench. The role of the judcll br(lnch s to enforcc the provsons of the Consttuton and laws we enact n Congress as ther lllclnng WlS orgnally ntended by the framers. Any other phlosophy of judgng requres unelected Federal judges to mpose ther own persollll vews on the Amercan people n the guse of construng the Consttuton "nd Fcdcml statutcs. There s no way around ths ~onduson. Such an approach s judcal actvsm, plan and smple, lnd t s wrong, whether t comes from the poltcal left, or whether t comes from the poltcal rght. Now the socal ssues nvoked by ths lst - desegregaton, the rghts of crmnals, school prayer, and aborton - have sharply dvded lberals and conservatves for nearly three decades. And for much of ths tme, conservatve theorsts have crtczed the key judcal decsons n these areas by accusng the Warren Court and subsequent Jberal judges of readng ther own vews nto the Consttuton and usurpng the powers of the executve and legslatve branches. For polemcal purposes, the phrase "judcal actvsm" has thus become a cod e word for judcal protecton and pro lloton of socal engneerng, left-wng protest, crme on the streets,' athesm, and sexual promscuty. Conservatve theorsts have accused the Warren Court and subseque11t lberal judges of readng ther own vews nto tlte Consttuton and usurpng the powers of the executve and legslatve branches.,... 1 : ' :.~' 1' t does not seem to me, as t does to Senator Hatch, that there are only two phlosophes of judgng - that one must be ether a strct constructonst or, by default a freewheelng judcal actvst. That dchotomy by no neans exhausts the possble strateges and shadngs of consttutonal nterpretaton. For the molnent, however, there s a second feature of hs argument that nterests me more. Although he condemned judcal actvsm per se, the Senator's account of ts consequences focused chefly on the rulngs of lberal jursts over the past thrty years. "Snce the advent of the Warren Court," he declared, "judcal actvsm has resulted n the elevaton of the rghts of crtnnals ajld crmnal suspects, and the conconltant strengthenng of the crmnal forces aganst the polce forces of our country." t has also led, he argued, to reverse dscrmnaton, "prayer beng chased out of the schools, and the courts creatng out of thn ar a consttutonal rght to aborton on demand." Ths characterzaton of the Warren Court and ts legacy, however, s deeply mstaken. The Court's lastng sgnfcance does not le n ts supposed expanson of the judcal role, or even ll the specfc decsons to whch Senator Hatch objects. Rather, ts sgnfcance les n a seemngly abstract ssue of jursprudence: the nature of a legal rght. Each of the Warren Court's controversal decsons proceeded fron a self-conscous and sophstcated understandng of the manner and scope of rghts protecton. My purpose here s to explan and defend that understandng. Two Concepts of Rghts Protecton Phlosophers and legal scholars have offered varous defntons of a rght, but all agree that rghts are values of partcular nportancc and that ther protecton s a central an of publc nsttutons. For ths reason, the queston of what t takes to secure rghts s a cen- 12

2 "Can You See Me Now?" 1.. J -.". j 6/18/51.. j j tral queston facng any poltcal and legal theory that ncludes the concept of rghts n ts vocabulary. Accordng to one common understandng, rghts are protected reactvely: an ndvdual whose rghts have been nfrnged may seek satsfacton of some sort after the fact, ether n the form of compensaton or fro punshment of the nfrnger. For example, pror to the Warren Court's decson n Mal'l' v. Oho (1961), an ndvdual's rght to be free from llegal searches by polce was protected only reactvely; the vctm of an llegal search could seek monetary damages or nternal polce dscplnary acton, but the llegally sezed evdence could stll be used at tral. The Warren Court crtczed ths entre approach to rghts protecton on the grounds that reactve remedes, such as "aroused publc opnon and nternal polce dscplne," had proved to be "wthout deterrent value." n ther place, the Court adopted the exclusonary rule, whch forbds ntroducng llegally sezed evdence at tral, as a morc effectve way of deterrng. polce mscond lct. The exclusonary rule dffers from the remed es avalable before Mapp n that t protects rghts prospec- From Herblock's Specal for Today (Smon and Schuster, 1958). Reprl1ted wth permsson. tvely, not reactvely. That s to say, by preventng the state from ntroducng llega lly sezed evdence at tral, t removes n advance much of the ncent ve for the Nasty Boys to batter down one's door at 5 o'clock n the mornng. Analogously, by rulng that suspects' statements to polce arc nadmssble n court unless those suspects have been advsed of ther rght to counsel and ther rght to reman slent, the Warren Court n the Mrnlldn case mnm zed n advance the possblty of gruellng nterrogatons and coerced confessons. Wthout such protectons, the Court beleved, vctms of polce overreachng are gven over to the tender merces of the tort system or the polce dscplne system for redress of the volaton of ther rghts. t s too easly forgotten that before the Warren Court crnnal procedure cases, polce departments (partcularly n rural areas) often conssted of poorly traned, poorly screened goons. n the early 1960s, as R chard Neely observes, suspects were "routnely pcked up off the street wthout a warrant" and subjected to nterrogatons that frequently nvolved "humlatng nsults and a good d ea l of slappng 13

3 . ~..,.;. ~ - around." Nor were local offcals lkely to provde redress - not when poltcans were eager to lnpress the electorate wth ther detennnaton to "crack down on crme," and when judges were often the alles and personal frends of sherffs and polce chefs. After the crmnal procedure cases, however, muncpaltes suddenly dscovered that the badly traned muscleheads n ther polce deparhnents were brngng cases that would be thrown out of court. The prospect of crmnals walkng out the door because "the constable had blundered" by jammng hs nghtstck nto the suspect's kdneys brought consderable poltcal heat down on prosecutors and polce chefs. The result was a transformaton of polce deparhnents nto better-traned, better-educated, nlore professonal organzatons that reled lnore on fnesse and less on force n conductng nvestgatons. The prospectve protectons of rghts establshed by the Warren Court created rpple effects leadng to further and better prospectve protectons. n the aftermath of the Rodney Kng beatng case, as well as thousands of less publczed nstances of polce brutalty, t s obvous that polce departments stll nclude a nmnber of sadsts, racsts, and fa scsts who have nothng but contempt for procedural ncetes and even for basc human rghts. Yet ths fact, w hch mght appear to cast doubt on the effectveness of the Warren Court's prospectve approach n crmnal procedure cases, demonstrates only that the Court's successors erred n declnng to extend ts approach from the context of nvestgaton to those of arrest and ordnary patrollng. When the ordnanj workng of nsttutons creates typcal, persstent, and chronc threats to Ollr rghts, we have a dervatve consttutonal rght to have tte tlrcats dssolved. n 1983, for example, n Cty of Los Angeles v. Lyons, the Supreme Court heard the case of a 24-year-old black man who had been stopped by Los Angeles polce because of a burned-out tallght on hs car. Mr. Lyons was searched, beaten on the head, and choked untl he blacked out. n subsequent legal acton, he asked not only for damages - a reactve remedy - but also for an njuncton forbddng the polce from usng choke holds n the future aganst suspects not threatenng volence - a prospectve relnedy. Although the Court agreed that Mr. Lyons could sue for damages, t dened hm standng n seekng the njuncton. f the Court had adopted a prospectve rather than a reactve concepton of rghts, t would have decded the case dfferently, wth practcal consequences for the preventon of polce brutalty about whch one can only speculate. Safeguards aganst a "Standard Threat" As a general prncple, the Warren Court nssted that to enjoy meanngful protecton, and thus to count as rghts at all, prlnary consttutonal rghts must often be hedged about wth dervatve, prophylactc rghts desgned to forestall nfrngements before they happen. Ths s not to say that every rght must be protected by ths strategy; ll many cases, reactve remedes wll suffce. Prospectve protecton s requred prncpally when a rghts volaton s part of an nsttutonal pattern. To understand why, let me ntroduce a concept from Henry Shue's analyss of rghts - the concept of a "standard threa t." The ordnary workng of nsttutons often creates typcal, persstent, and chronc threats to our rghts, When offcers from a poorly dscplned polce force brutally nterrogate a suspect, or when segregatonst nsttutons volate the rghts of blacks, t s clear that we are not confrontng solated ncdents or the actons of a sngle msguded offcal. Rather, we are confrontng the predctable effect of an nsttutonal cause - a standard threat. And t s prncpally n cases of standard threats that we have a der vat ve consttutonal rght to have the threat dssolved. There s a smple reason why ths rght to prospectve protecton s lmted to forms of standard threat: the world s so chock-full of non-standard threats that t would be vrtually mpossble to protect us aganst them prospectvely. To antcpate and guard aganst the full range of non-standard thr~at s would requre an omnpresent, omnpotent, omn-ntrusve, and omn-expensve government that had abandoned all actvtes except one: the spnnng out of mprobable rght-threatenng scenaros that must be warded off. Tt makes more sense, therefore, to leave the unusual rghts volatons to a system of purely reactve remedes. Only the standard threats need be guarded aganst n advance. And thus both prospectve and reactve approaches to rghts protecton have a place n a system of rghts. t s lllportant to see, however, that the two strateges dffer markedly n ther understandng of the manner and scope of rghts protecton. Reactvsts deny that rghts by ther nature demand protecton from merely potental nfrngements. Such a premse, they argue, amounts to a presumpton that publc offcals, gven half a chance, wll volate the Consttuton. nstead, reactvst opponents nsst, we should presume - pendng decsve evdence to the contrary - that offcals wll respect consttuhonal rghts, and that those who fal to do so are ma vercks, sngle "rotten 14

4 -'. 1 apples," rather than typcal members of an untrustworthy system. Prospect.vsts, n contrast, tend to entertan suspcons about the government and the authortes. They are w llng to scrutnze powerful nsttutons n order to see whether a rghts volaton was merely an solated ncdent or, on the contrary, the consequence of the nsttuton's standard operatng procedure. Thus, bult nto the prospectvst outlook s an ant-authortaran tlt coupled wth a penchant for consderng socal and structural explanatons for rghts volatons. t s, beleve, ths double tendency of the Warren Court's prospect vst account of rghts protecton - toward ant-authortaransm and toward structural explanatons - that draws down the wrath of conservatve theorsts, just as the partcular results the Court acheved draw down the wrath of conserva tve pol tcans. f ths s true, then the fundamental dvde between the Warren Court and ts crtcs has to do not wth the clash between judcal actvsm and judcal Legal Modernsm Davd Luban Mod ernsm n legal theory s no dfferent from modernsm n the arts: each responds to cultural crss, a sense that nsttutons and tradtons have lost ther veldty. n hs new book, legal phlosopher Davd Luban argues that pragmatsm, tradtonalsm, and nhlsm are each a flawed response to the modernst predcament. nvokng Walter Benjamn's reflectons on narratve and hstorcal conscollsness, he explores the nature of justce by analyzng Martn Luther Kng, 1r.'5 "Letter from the Brmngham Jal," the Nuremberg trals, and tral scenes n Homer, Hesod, and Aeschylus. Wth these examples, Professor Luban artculates several of the tensons that mot va te con temporary legal theory - tensons between order and justce, obedence and resstance, statsm and communtaransm. Add ressed to lterary and socal theorsts as well as lawyers and phlosophers, Legal ModemsJ1/ provdes mportant dscussons of Crtcal Legal Studes and of wrters as dverse as Hannah Arendt, Olver Wendell Holmes, Anthony Kronman, Rchard Posner, Rchard Rorty, and Roberto Unger. Publcaton date: June pages, $47.50 Unversty of Mchgan Press P. O. Box Ann Arbor, MT Tel: Fax for orders only: Credt cards accepted res trant, but rather w th th e dfference be tween prospectvst and reactlvst approaches to the securng o f rghts. When Senator Hatch argues otherwse, he msconstrues the Warren Court decsons and actons that he opposes. The restructurng of nsttutons n order to abolsh racal segregaton "root and branch," the Court-approved judca l takeover of prsons and mental hosptals that abused and tormented ther nn1ates, the rgd separaton of church and state that the Warren Court beleved essental to prevent belevers from pressurng relgous mnortes to pray to an alen god - all these may be best understood not as nstances of judcal actvsm, but as prospectve protectons of consttutonal rghts. They grew out of the Court's belef that prmary consttutonal rghts create dervatve, or secondary, rghts whose purpose s to forestall standard threats to those prmary rghts. The Example of Prvacy Havng presented the Warren Court's prospectvst credentels, can now offer two qualfcatons of my argument. Frst, not all conservatve theorsts reject the prospectvst approacl1 to rghts protecton, nor do all crtcs of the Warren Court fal to acknowledge ts commtment to that approach as the bass for ts controversal decsons. Second, and perhaps more mportant, not all of the Warren Court's expansons of rghts can be explaned as prospectvst protectons of prmary rghts. Take the Court's famous fndng of a general rght to prvacy, n the 1965 case Grswold v. Connectcut. The Grswold decson struck down a Connectcut statute forbddng the sale and use of contraceptves; t held that the statute volated a rght to prvacy mplct n the Frst, Thrd, Fourth, Ffth, end N nth Amendments. Now, none of these amendments n fact mentons prvacy, and none has anythng to do wth contracepton - let alone cohabtaton or copulaton. Nevertheless, n the key passage of the Grswold opnon, Justce W llam O. Douglas argued that these amendments provde grounds for belevng that the Consttuton guarantees a general rght of prvacy. Hs metaphorcal language has snce become a source of bewlderment for law students and an object of rdcule n law school faculty lounges: Slpccfc g uarantees n the Bll of Rghts have penumbras, formed by emanatons from those guarnntccs that help g ve them l fe and su bstance. Varous guaran tees crea te zones of prvacy.... The present case... concerns a relatonsh p ly ng w thn the zone of prvacy crecltcd by several fundamental consttu tonal guarantees. There are at least two ways of understandng ths passage. The frst s to read t as a restatement of the prospectvst vew, assertng that the specfc guarantees n the Consttuton crea te dervatve, secondary, 15

5 :. :... ~ or what Douglas here calls "penulnbral" rg hts. Comn1entators who adopt ths readng assull1e that wherever Justce Douglas lnentons "guarantees," he s referrng (as he does n the openng phrase) to specfc guaran tees explctly stated n the Consttllton as the source of these penumbral rg hts. Ths s Robert Bork's assulnpton, for example, when he observes, Courts often gve protecton to ( consttutoll(l freedom by creatng a buffer zone, by prohbtng a government from dong somethng not n tself forbdden but lkely to lead to an nvason of a rght specfed n the Consttuton. DOllg](lS named the buffer zone or "penumbra" of the frst amendment a protecton of prv(lcy.. [(lndl then asserted that other amendments cre<l te "zones of pr v(lcy." Perhaps surprsngly, Judge Bark has no objecton to the dea of penumbral rghts; though he fnd s Justce Douglas'S termnology "exceptonal," he accepts the theory tself. He's a prospectvst. However, Judge Bark does not accept the dea, whch he also fnds n Grswold, that the specfc prvacy rghts emanatng froln varous amendments can somehow fuse and create a general, freestandng prvacy rght - one that exsts on an equal footng wth the explct guarantees of the Bll of Rghts and s capable of ndependent growth and development. Accordng to hs account of Grswold, the Warren Court calne to assert the exstence of such a prvacy rght n two steps. Frst, t nferred penumbral rghts of prvacy from explct consttutonal guarantees. Then t fused these varous penumbral rghts nto a general rght of prvacy. The frst step, Judge Bark argues, s sound; but the second s not. Rghts of specfc and lmted scope do not magcally "fu se" nto general, lulmted rghts. As lucd as t s, ths account of the Warren Court's logc n Grswold seems to me dead wrong. To see why, we need only examne one of the alnendments that Justce Douglas nvokes n assertng the rght to prvacy. suggest the Thrd: "No Solder shall, n tme of peace, be quartered n any house, wthout the consent of the Owner, nor n tme of w<:tr, but n a manner to be prescrbed by law." f the Warren Court had ndeed taken the prospectvst approach n assertng the rght to prvacy, t would have sad that ths rght derves (or emanates) from the Thrd Amendment - that the rght to prvacy s a secondary rght protectng our prmary consttutonal rght to exclude solders from our homes. Yet a moment's thought tells us that the relatonshp between the two rghts only makes sense the other way around. A rght to p rvacy, after ~11, cannot afford any greater protecton - cannot excluae solders from our homes any more effectvely - than does the Thrd Amendment tself. On the other hand, the Thrd Amendlnent con help protect the relevant rght to prvacy - that s, prvacy n our own home. Obvously, havng a platoon of solders blleted n the basement would put a damper on the ntmate actvtes of the household. By forbddng the government from nstallng nfantry n the house, the Thrd Amendment prospectvely wards off what mght otherwse become a standard threat to prvacy. The Thrd Amendment thlls belongs to the penllmbra of the rght to prvacy, not the other way arollnd. Smlarly wth the Fourth Amendment rght aganst llegal searches and the Ffth Amendment rght aganst comp elled self-ncrmnaton: all of these rghts are penumbral rghts, derved from our rght to prvacy understood as a prospectve protecton aganst standard threats from the government. Tn each nstance, t s by examnng the specfc guarantees n the Consttuton that we dscover and artculate the general guarantees (such as the rght to prvacy) they are establshed n order to defend. At ths pont, let us return to the key passage from Grswold. Our frst readng of the passage assumed that all the "guarantees" mentoned n t are specfc and explct gllarantees understood as the source of penumbral rghts. But a second, more plausble readng, proposed by Rchard Mohr, argues that the opnon also nvokes geneml and mplct g,wrnntees. n the crucal sentence froln Grswold, t s precsely these general guarantees that help gve the specfc guarantees "lfe and substance," provdng the motve and justfcaton for those rghts enumerated n the Consttuton. n Justce Douglas's vew, the specfc textual rghts are best nterpreted as protectons of an unenumerated general rght of prvacy aganst a handful of standard threats antcpated by the framers. And once we come to recognze the rght to prvacy as a prncple gvng specfc textual rghts "lfe and substance," we may proceed to consder whether contracepton, for example, s protected by that rght of prvacy wthout attachng the queston to any specfc enumerated rght. The Human Goods that Rghts Secure There s more to say about the process by whch we reason about and dentfy general guarantees. For ths purpose, we may fnd an llumnatng analogy n another area of the law of prvacy - the testmonal prvleges. These are. rghts to prevent persons n whom we confde from testfyng aganst us n court, or to refuse to testfy aganst persons who have confded n us. The comlnon law recognzed such prvleges protectng comn1uncaton between attorney and clent, physcan and patent, prest and pentent, and husband and wfe. (The prvlege aganst self-ncrmnaton s also a testtnonal prvlege; whle the others protect COll11nuncaton between two partes, the prvlege aganst self-ncrmnaton preserves the sanctty of one's own thoughts, one's relaton to oneself n nner dalogue.) 16

6 1. 1 The testmonal p r v leges are best thought of as prospectve protectons of our rght to enjoy confdental relatonshps wth our attorneys, our doctors, our clergymen, our spouses, and even ourselves. The queston then arses: "Why just these?" And n turn, how ths queston s answered determnes whether courts and legslatures should extend the pr vleges to other relatonshps. The physcan-patent prvlege, for example, has been ex tended to psychologsts and counselors; the spousal prvlege has been extended n three states to parents and chldren; and severa] jursd ctons have estabhshed accountant-clent pr vleges. What prncple s nvolved? Should the testmonal prvlege be extended to fnancal planners? nsurance salesmen, who often receve senst ve fnancal nformaton from th er cus tomers? G ra ndparents? Unmarred lovers? Best frends? Our Hqury nto tle 171rd Amendment drects Ollr v son to the mportance of prvate actvtes to a decellt lfe. Tle allalyss leads ls fro m the postve law to the basc valles t embodes. To answer these and smlar questons, one needs some sense of what makes the f ve orgnal relatonshps especally mportant. suggest that these relatonshps correspond to fve fundamental aspects of the human personalty. an, frst of all, a self engaged n my own nner dalogue - a dalogue essental to my ntegrty. Hence tbe rght aganst self-ncrmnaton. Second, am a physcal body subject to all the nfrmtes and corruptons of the fl esh. Hence, the rght to speak conf dentally wth my doctors. Thrd, am a socal and lovng beng who may fnd a lfe's companon to share that love - a love that demands opelu1ess. Hence, the spousal prvlege. Fourth, T am a moral and sprtual beng, wth a soul to tend and a burden of gult that must be gven voce. Hence, the prest-pentent prvlege. Ffth, am a ctzen, a jurdcal person lvng n a network of publc rghts and relatonshps that are fragle and shftng and hard to understand. Hence, the attorney-clent prvl ege. Thus, we fnd that the testmonal prvleges are shaped to ft the contours of an entre phlosophca anthropology - an answer to Kant's queston, 'What s man?" To make sense of the laws grantng testmonal prvleges, then, we must vew these prvleges as penulllbral protectons of the f ve prvleged relatonshps; and these, n tun~, we best regard as thelnselves penumbral protectons of fve fundamental aspects of human exstence. The relatonshps "emanate" from these basc aspects of exstence, and the pr vleges "emanate" from the relatonshps. Such an analyss a ll ows us to understand what t means to regard a pece of postve law n such a way as to glmpse a more general prncple that helps gve t "l fe and substance." n much the sa me way, we would begn an analyss of the Thrd Amend ment by askng what s so burdensome about quarterng solders n one's home. Ths queston drects us to what s valuable about a home. The answer s that a home s a protecton of the lfe that goes on wthn t, fosterng t by sheld ng t from the outsde world. (Of all the horrors of homelessness, the permanent lack of prvacy s surely among the worst.) Our nqury nto the Thrd Amendment d rects our vson to the mportance of prvate actvt es to a decent lfe. The analyss leads us from the postve law to the basc values t embodes. The Warren Court's Legacy When we jon ths way of vewng legal rghts wth the prospectvst approach, we can apprecate the full magntude of the Warren Court's contrbuton to the theory of rghts, partcularly consttutonal rghts. The Court began wth specfc textual rghts, and then proceeded to elaborate them Smultaneously n opposte d rectons: frst, reasonng from these rghts "down the lne" to the secondary rghts that must be put n place n order to secure them from stand ard threats; second, reasonng from these rghts "up the lne" to the values that the textual rghts were themselves put n place to protect aga nst standard threats. n dong so, the Warren Court gave meanng to the noton of a rght as the moral and legal embodment of a va lue that stands n need of strngent p rotecton. At ths moment n our legal hstory, when the Supreme Court has convened for the frst tme n forty yea rs wthout a member of the Warren Court sea ted a m ong the Justces, ths s a legacy worth recallng accurately. - Davd Luban Sources: The New York Tmes (July 20, 1993); MallJ' v. Oho, 367 U.S '1); Mrmufn f. Arzoll(1, 384 U.s. 436 (1966); Rchard Neely, -low COllrls Govall Al1crm (Ya le Un versty Press, 1981); Cty of Los Allgrll's "'. LyOlls, 461 U.s. 95 (1983); Henry Shue, Bn::;c Rghts: SlllsMl'ce, Affllll'el', nlld u.s. Foregll Polcy (Prnceton Unversty Press, 1980); Grswold ('. COllllt'cl(lft, 38 1 U.s. 479 (1 965); Robert H. Bork. Tlt' Temptllg of Amercn (The Free Press, 1990); R cha rd D. Mohr, Gnys/Jlslcl' (Columb<l Unversty Press, 1988). 17

Discrimination and Hostile Work Environment Claims Based upon Religion, National Origin, and Alienage

Discrimination and Hostile Work Environment Claims Based upon Religion, National Origin, and Alienage Amercan Bar Assocaton Amercan Law Insttute Aprl, 2002 Dscrmnaton and Hostle Work Envronment Clams Based upon Relgon, Natonal Orgn, and Alenage by Rchard T. Seymour Table of Contents A. Introducton B. The

More information

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA. , \ t f ( l N THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATC SOCALST REPUBLC OF SR LANKA. n the matter of an Appel from the order dated.02.204 made by the Provncal Hgh Court of Uva Provnce holden n Badulla n the

More information

DISCOURAGING DEMAND. Defining the concept of demand. What do we mean when we talk about demand in relation to trafficking?

DISCOURAGING DEMAND. Defining the concept of demand. What do we mean when we talk about demand in relation to trafficking? chapter 9 Preventon of traffckng n persons 491 DISCOURAGING DEMAND Tool 9.12 Defnng the concept of demand Overvew Ths tool consders what demand means wth respect to human traffckng. What do we mean when

More information

Matter of Brasky v City of New York 2006 NY Slip Op 30744(U) March 15, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /05 Judge: Lottie E.

Matter of Brasky v City of New York 2006 NY Slip Op 30744(U) March 15, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /05 Judge: Lottie E. Matter of Brasky v Cty of New York 2006 NY Slp Op 30744(U) March 15, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 114539/05 Judge: Lotte E. Wlkns Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013 NY Slp

More information

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION ,'" \.. 3 4 5 6 7 9 0 3 4 5 6 7 9 3 7 AARON S. DYER #999 aaron.dyer@plsburylaw.com LAUREN M. LEAHY #065 lauren.leahy@pllsburylaw.com PLLSBURY WNTHROP SHAW PTTMAN LLP.. 7 South Fgueroa Street, Sute 00 Los

More information

Combating Housing Benefit Fraud: Local Authorities' Discretionary Powers

Combating Housing Benefit Fraud: Local Authorities' Discretionary Powers Combatng Housng Beneft Fraud: Local Authortes' Dscretonary Powers A study carred out on behalf of the Department of Socal Securty by Roy Sansbury Socal Polcy Research Unt, Unversty of York Crown copyrght

More information

of any issue of law or fact, to the entry of the

of any issue of law or fact, to the entry of the J J FNANCAL?NDUSTRY REGU?ATORY AUTHORTY LETTER OF ACCEPTANCE WAVER AND CONSENT NO. 20705494530 TO: RE: Department of Enforcement Fnancal ndustry Regulatory Authorty ("FNRA") Anthony Vultaggo Jr. Respondent

More information

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF WEST VI'RGINIA CHARLESTON PROCEDURE. required to satisfy said complaint or make answer thereto, in writing,

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF WEST VI'RGINIA CHARLESTON PROCEDURE. required to satisfy said complaint or make answer thereto, in writing, _ ----- -- PUBLC SERVCE COMMSSON OF WEST V'RGNA CHARLESTON At a sesson of the PUBLC SERVCE COMMSSON OF WEST VRGNA, at the Captol n the Cty of Charleston on the 24th day of March, 1976. CASE NO. 8264 ELBERT

More information

State of New York Public Employment Relations Board Decisions from September 5, 1974

State of New York Public Employment Relations Board Decisions from September 5, 1974 Cornell Unversty ILR School DgtalCommons@ILR Board Decsons - NYS PERB New York State Publc Employment Relatons Board (PERB) 9-5-1974 State of New York Publc Employment Relatons Board Decsons from September

More information

Money is where the fun ends: material interests and individuals preference for direct democracy

Money is where the fun ends: material interests and individuals preference for direct democracy Gutenberg School of Management and Economcs & Research Unt Interdscplnary Publc Polcy Dscusson Paper Seres Money s where the fun ends: materal nterests and ndvduals preference for drect democracy Phlpp

More information

Restitution and compensation for victims

Restitution and compensation for victims 434 Toolkt to Combat Traffckng n Persons Tool 8.17 Resttuton and compensaton for vctms Overvew Ths tool refers to the provsons of the Organzed Crme Conventon and the Traffckng n Persons Protocol that requre

More information

I i IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA CA 1 WAKFS 1 01/2017. I j

I i IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA CA 1 WAKFS 1 01/2017. I j ,! j j! { l j N THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATC SOCALST REPUBLC OF SR LANKA CA WAKFS 0/207 Wakfs Trbunal No. WT/242/207 Wakfs Board Case No. WB/727/206 n the matter of an appeal under and n terms

More information

Lord is righteous, he loves justice; upright will see his face. Psalm 11:7

Lord is righteous, he loves justice; upright will see his face. Psalm 11:7 ca amer r o f sors s e c nter l a c e p S t r o Rep s ment t n o l App n a c e Jud nstrato h t or de f ump Adm u G er e Tr Pray of th Appealng to God for our U.S. Courts P resdent Donald Trump s changng

More information

CONSTITUTION OF THE New Democratic Party of Canada EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 2018

CONSTITUTION OF THE New Democratic Party of Canada EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 2018 CONSTITUTION OF THE New Democratc Party of Canada EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 2018 PREAMBLE Canada s a great country, one of the hopes of the world. New Democrats are Canadans who beleve we can be a better one

More information

Plaintiff, Defendant. This libel action arises out of the public controversy. concerning the safety.of fluoridation o:f public water supplies,

Plaintiff, Defendant. This libel action arises out of the public controversy. concerning the safety.of fluoridation o:f public water supplies, UNTED STATES DSTRCT COURT SOUTHERN DSTRCT OF NEW YORK --------------------------~----------x J6HN YAMOUYANNS, PhD, -aganst- Plantff, CONSUMERS UNON OF UNTED STATES, NC, Defendant -------------------------------------x

More information

PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE BOARD OF REGENTS POLICY ON WEAPONS POSSESSION

PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE BOARD OF REGENTS POLICY ON WEAPONS POSSESSION PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE BOARD OF REGENTS POLICY ON WEAPONS POSSESSION The 2013 Kansas Legslature enacted a statute to preclude state and muncpal enttes from prohbtng the concealed carry of handguns

More information

Oregon Round Dance Teachers Association

Oregon Round Dance Teachers Association Oregon Round Dance Teachers Assocaton Bylaws Adopted January 1982 Amended October 1983 Amended July 1987 Amended September 1990 Amended May 1995 Amended January 2000 Amended October 2000 Amended January

More information

Immigration New Zealand Operational Manual. Border Entry. Issue Date: 2 March 2009

Immigration New Zealand Operational Manual. Border Entry. Issue Date: 2 March 2009 Immgraton New Zealand Operatonal Manual Border Entry Issue Date: 2 March 2009 INZ Operatonal Manual Border Entry Contents Y1 Objectve 1-1 Y2 Arrvals and departures 2-1 Y3 People refused entry 3-1 Y4 Detenton

More information

Immigration New Zealand Operational Manual. Border entry. Issue Date: 29 Novemer 2010

Immigration New Zealand Operational Manual. Border entry. Issue Date: 29 Novemer 2010 Immgraton New Zealand Operatonal Manual Border entry Issue Date: 29 Novemer 2010 CONTENTS Y1 Objectve...1-1 Y2 Arrvals and departures...2-1 Y3 People refused entry permsson...3-1 Y4 Vsas n error...4-1

More information

CONSTITUTION OF ADASTRAL PARK LEISURE AND SPORTS (ATLAS) BODY TALK GYM CLUB

CONSTITUTION OF ADASTRAL PARK LEISURE AND SPORTS (ATLAS) BODY TALK GYM CLUB CONSTITUTION OF ADASTRAL PARK LEISURE AND SPORTS (ATLAS) BODY TALK GYM CLUB 1. The organsaton shall be called Adastral Park Lesure and Sports (ATLAS) Body Talk Gym Club, herenafter referred as the Club.

More information

Judicial Review as a Constraint on Tyranny of the Majority

Judicial Review as a Constraint on Tyranny of the Majority Judcal Revew as a Constrant on Tyranny of the Majorty Robert K. Fleck Department of Agrcultural Economcs and Economcs Montana State Unversty Bozeman, MT 59717 phone: (406) 994-5603 e-mal: rfleck@montana.edu

More information

Legal Strategies for FDA Consent Decrees

Legal Strategies for FDA Consent Decrees RU1 Legal Strateges for FDA Consent Decrees Wllam W. Vodra PDA Taormna Conference 14 October 2003 14 October 2003 Legal Strateges for FDA Consent Decrees Slde 1 Slde 1 RU1 #1001401.2-PDA Taormna speech

More information

87 faces of the English clause

87 faces of the English clause Work Papers of the Summer nsttute of Lngustcs, Unversty of North Dakota Sesson Volume 11 Artcle 9 1967 87 faces of the Englsh clause Rchard Pttman SL-UND Davd Thomas SL-UND Follow ths and addtonal works

More information

Scoring Guidelines and Notes for Document-Based Question

Scoring Guidelines and Notes for Document-Based Question Scorng Gudelnes and Notes for Document-Based Queston Evaluate the causes of the begnnng of the Cold War between the U.S. and the USSR from 1945 to 1950. Currculum Framework Algnment Learnng Objectves WOR-2.0

More information

Gaber v Benhuri Ctr. for Laser Dentistry 2013 NY Slip Op 30378(U) February 15, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /11 Judge:

Gaber v Benhuri Ctr. for Laser Dentistry 2013 NY Slip Op 30378(U) February 15, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /11 Judge: Gaber v Benhur Ctr. for Laser Dentstry 203 NY Slp Op 30378(U) February 5, 203 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 80064/ Judge: Joan B. Lobs Republshed from New York State Unfed Court System's

More information

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT. I i I. District of. l by Failing to Maintain an Accurate Oil Record:Book, to

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT. I i I. District of. l by Failing to Maintain an Accurate Oil Record:Book, to ~AO 245E (Rev. 12/03) Judgment n a Crmnal Case for Organzatonal efendants Sheet EASTERN UNTE STATES OF AMERCA v. OCEANC LLSABE LMTE THE EFENANT ORGANZATON: pleaded gulty to count(s) pleaded nolo contendere

More information

I I I I I l I I I I I

I I I I I l I I I I I l RCHARD STATE P. WALLACE, Appellant (Defendant Below), V. OF NDANA, Appellee (Plantff Below). N THE COURT OF APPEALS OF NDANA CAUSE NO. 49A02-0706-CR-498 An appeal from: Maron Superor Court, Crm Dvson,

More information

Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes

Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes Bowlng Green State Unversty ScholarWorks@BGSU Board of Trustees Meetng Mnutes Unversty Publcatons 10-14-1913 Board of Trustees Meetng Mnutes 1913-10-14 Bowlng Green State Unversty Follow ths and addtonal

More information

Rubin v Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik, LLP 2016 NY Slip Op 31096(U) June 15, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge:

Rubin v Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik, LLP 2016 NY Slip Op 31096(U) June 15, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2015 Judge: Rubn v Napol Bern Rpka Shkolnk, LLP 2016 NY Slp Op 31096(U) June 15, 2016 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 154060/2015 Judge: Cyntha S. Kern Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013 NY

More information

Principles of prevention

Principles of prevention 449 Tool 9.1 Prncples of preventon Overvew Ths tool provdes prncples and gudelnes for preventng traffckng n persons. The preventon of traffckng n persons requres creatve and coordnated responses. Efforts

More information

Matter of Diaz v New York City Dept. of Health & Mental Hygiene 2013 NY Slip Op 32360(U) September 25, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket

Matter of Diaz v New York City Dept. of Health & Mental Hygiene 2013 NY Slip Op 32360(U) September 25, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Matter of Daz v New York Cty Dept. of Health & Mental Hygene 2013 NY Slp Op 32360(U) September 25, 2013 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 100846/13 Judge: Joan B. Lobs Cases posted wth a "30000"

More information

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CASES. Bates v. City of Little Rock, 361 U.S. 516 (1900)... 22

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CASES. Bates v. City of Little Rock, 361 U.S. 516 (1900)... 22 -.: 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 0 2 3 l 4 J 5 6 7 9 20 2 22 oj 23 25 26 27 2 TABLE OF AUTHORTES CASES Alexander v. Unted States 509 U.S. 544... 7 Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood of Northern New England 546 U.S. 320 (20@6)...

More information

Full name Title Date of birth

Full name Title Date of birth PIB (UK) 2019 Applcaton for regstraton of a non-acca partner/drector/controller or a non-partner/drector responsble for Exempt Regulated Actvtes work n a frm seekng Exempt Regulated Actvtes regstraton

More information

SUPPLEMENT ISIOLO COUNTY GAZETTE BILLS, NAIROBI, 13th September,?fr16 SPECIAL ISSUE. REPUBLIC OF KEr.fYA

SUPPLEMENT ISIOLO COUNTY GAZETTE BILLS, NAIROBI, 13th September,?fr16 SPECIAL ISSUE. REPUBLIC OF KEr.fYA SPECAL SSUE solo County Gazette Supplement No. (Blls No.9) REPUBLC OF KEr.fYA SOLO COUNTY GAZETTE SUPPLEMENT BLLS, 2016 NAROB, 13th September,?fr16 CONTENT Bll for ntroducton nto the solo County Assembly-

More information

AGENDA REQUEST AGENDA ITEM NO: V.3. Board Appointments. July 21, 2014 BY City Auditor and Clerk Pamela M. Nadalini City Auditor and Clerk Nadalini

AGENDA REQUEST AGENDA ITEM NO: V.3. Board Appointments. July 21, 2014 BY City Auditor and Clerk Pamela M. Nadalini City Auditor and Clerk Nadalini AGENDA HEADNG: Board Appontments AGENDA REQUEST COMMSSON MEETNG DATE: July 21, 2014 BY Cty Audtor and Clerk Pamela M. Nadaln Cty Audtor and Clerk Nadaln AGENDA TEM NO: V.3. Orgnatng Department SUBJECT:

More information

A comparative study of the use of the Istanbul Protocol amongst civil society organizations in low-income countries i

A comparative study of the use of the Istanbul Protocol amongst civil society organizations in low-income countries i 60 A comparatve study of the use of the Istanbul Protocol amongst cvl socety organzatons n low-ncome countres Tobas Kelly, PhD*, Steffen Jensen, PhD**, Morten Koch Andersen, PhD**, Catrne Chrstansen, PhD***,

More information

LL.M FIRST SEMESTER BACKLOG EXAMINATIONS. August Timings: 2.00 p.m. to 5.00 p.m.

LL.M FIRST SEMESTER BACKLOG EXAMINATIONS. August Timings: 2.00 p.m. to 5.00 p.m. EXAMNATON BRANCH OSMANA UNERSTY HYDERABAD 500 007 LL.M FRST SEMESTER BACKLOG EXAMNATONS (For Regular, Self Finance & Private Appearance Course) August 2013 DAY & DATE PAPER SUBJECT[S] 16.08.2013 Schools

More information

Commercial sexual exploitation of children

Commercial sexual exploitation of children chapter 9 Preventon of traffckng n persons 497 Tool 9.13 Commercal sexual explotaton of chldren Overvew Ths tool looks at legslatve and other measures, such as ethcal gudelnes and campagns, that can be

More information

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/12/ :25 PM INDEX NO /2015 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 116 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/12/2018

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 06/12/ :25 PM INDEX NO /2015 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 116 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/12/2018 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------X KAMCO SUPPLY CORP., On behalf of tself and ndex No. 651725-15

More information

STATE OF FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR EXECUTIVE ORDER NUMBER 18-19

STATE OF FLORIDA OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR EXECUTIVE ORDER NUMBER 18-19 STATE OF FLORDA OFFCE OF THE GOVERNOR EXECUTVE ORDER NUMBER 18-19 WHEREAS, Joy Cooper s presently servng as Mayor for the Cty of Hallandale Beach, Florda; and WHEREAS, on January 25, 2018, Joy Cooper was

More information

Minorcyzk v City of New York 2006 NY Slip Op 30833(U) October 30, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /04 Judge: Eileen A.

Minorcyzk v City of New York 2006 NY Slip Op 30833(U) October 30, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /04 Judge: Eileen A. Mnorcyzk v Cty of New York 2006 NY Slp Op 30833(U) October 30, 2006 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 02928/04 Judge: Eleen A. Rakower Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 203 NY Slp Op

More information

Calculating Equivalent and Compensating Variations in CGE Models

Calculating Equivalent and Compensating Variations in CGE Models ntroducton Calculatng Equvalent and Copensatng Varatons n CGE Models Véronque Robchaud July Most CGE odelers use these odels to assess the pacts of gven shocks or polces on a specfc econoy. Whle t s qute

More information

CANTONMENT BOARD, RANIKHET MINISTRY OF DEFENCE, GOVT. OF INDIA

CANTONMENT BOARD, RANIKHET MINISTRY OF DEFENCE, GOVT. OF INDIA \ APPONTMENT TO THE POST OF TOLL COLLECTOR, JUNOR CLERK AND WATER LNEMAN N CANTONMENT BOARD, RANKHET CANTONMENT BOARD, RANKHET MNSTRY OF DEFENCE, GOVT. OF NDA No. 121Recrutment 12017 01- Sept, 2017 Onlne

More information

Fairfield Sentry and the limits of comity in Chapter15cases

Fairfield Sentry and the limits of comity in Chapter15cases IILR_2015_30001_1 IILR 1 ARTICLES Jeffrey A. Lesemer 1 Farfeld Sentry and the lmts of comty n Chapter15cases Introducton In the cross-border nsolvency case of Farfeld Sentry Lmted, the Unted States Court

More information

BY-LAW NO NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Kingston hereby ENACTS as follows.

BY-LAW NO NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Kingston hereby ENACTS as follows. Clause (2), Report No_ 28. 2014 D142332012 BYLAW NO. 201440 A BYLAW TO AMEND BYLAW NO. 8499, "RESTRCTED AREA (ZONNG) BY LAW OF THE CORPORATON OF THE CTY OF KNGSTON" (Zone Modfcaton to allow 6 dwellng unt

More information

Act 45 of Keyword(s): Backward Classes of Citizens, Educational Institution, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes

Act 45 of Keyword(s): Backward Classes of Citizens, Educational Institution, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes The Taml Nadu Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Trbes (Reservaton of Seats n Educatonal nsttutons and of Appontments or Posts n the Servces Under the State) Act, 1993 Act 45 of 1994 Keyword(s):

More information

Garcia v Estate of Scott 2015 NY Slip Op 30567(U) March 2, 2015 Sup Ct, Bronx County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Alison Y. Tuitt Cases posted

Garcia v Estate of Scott 2015 NY Slip Op 30567(U) March 2, 2015 Sup Ct, Bronx County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Alison Y. Tuitt Cases posted Garca v Estate of Scott 2015 NY Slp Op 30567(U) March 2, 2015 Sup Ct, Bronx County Docket Number: 301087/2012 Judge: Alson Y. Tutt Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013 NY Slp Op 30001(U), are republshed

More information

THE FOLLOWING IS HEREBY STIPULATED by and between Robert H. 2. Judge LaPiana was apprised by the Commission in June 2017 that it was

THE FOLLOWING IS HEREBY STIPULATED by and between Robert H. 2. Judge LaPiana was apprised by the Commission in June 2017 that it was !! 1 STATE OF NEW YORK COMMSSON ON JUDCAL CONDUCT n the Matter of the nvestgaton of Complants! Pursuant to Secton 44, subdvsons and 2,, J of the Judcary Law n Relaton to ' l. JAMES D. LAPANA, STPULATON

More information

How minorities fare under referendums. A cross national study *

How minorities fare under referendums. A cross national study * How mnortes fare under referendums. A cross natonal study * Danel Bochsler and Smon Hug CIS and IPZ, Unverstät Zürch Département de scence poltque, Unversté de Genève Paper prepared for presentaton at

More information

UNCLASSIFIED UNITED STATES ARMY SPECIAL OPERATIONS COMMAND. White Paper. Redefining the Win. 06 Jan 2015 UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED UNITED STATES ARMY SPECIAL OPERATIONS COMMAND. White Paper. Redefining the Win. 06 Jan 2015 UNCLASSIFIED UNITED STATES ARMY SPECIAL OPERATIONS COMMAND Whte Paper Redefnng the Wn 06 Jan 2015 Redefnng the Wn The Redefned Wn Concept The Redefned Wn Concept centers on proactve U.S. competton wth State / Non-State

More information

NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P

NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P J-A29036-16 NON-PRECEDENTAL DECSON - SEE SUPEROR COURT.O.P. 65.37 NORTHWEST SAVNGS BANK, : N THE SUPEROR COURT OF : PENNSYLVANA Appeant : : v. : : FDELTY NATONAL TTLE NSURANCE COMPANY AND THE CLOSNG COMPANY

More information

OSMANIA UNIVERSITY TIME TABLE. B.A. LL.B (5-YDC) First Year I Semester Backlog Examinations. May / Jun Timings: a.m. to 1.00 p.m.

OSMANIA UNIVERSITY TIME TABLE. B.A. LL.B (5-YDC) First Year I Semester Backlog Examinations. May / Jun Timings: a.m. to 1.00 p.m. B.A. LL.B (5-YDC) First Year Semester Backlog Examinations Timings: 10.00 a.m. to 1.00 p.m. Saturday 31-05-2014 13-06-2014 20-06-2014 25-06-2014 01-07-2014 ENGLSH HSTORY POLTCAL SCENCE LEGAL LANGUAGE AND

More information

FOREIGN WORKERS IN SOUTHERN AGRICULTURE *

FOREIGN WORKERS IN SOUTHERN AGRICULTURE * FOREIGN WORKERS IN SOUTHERN AGRICULTURE * Robert D. Emerson and Orachos Napasntuwong Unversty of Florda The queston addressed n ths paper s the length of tme farm workers wth dfferent characterstcs are

More information

Scoring Guidelines and Notes for Long Essay Question

Scoring Guidelines and Notes for Long Essay Question Scorng Gudelnes and Notes for Long Essay Queston Queston: Compare and contrast the patterns of mmgraton n the perod 1880 to 1928 to the patterns of mmgraton n the perod 1965 to 2000. In your response,

More information

LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE REPORT

LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE REPORT County ofsanta Clara Offce ofthe Clerk ofthe Board ofsupervsors County Government Center, East Wng 70 West Heddng Street San Jose, Calforna 95110-1770 (408)299-5001 FAX 938-4525 Megan Doyle Clerk ofthe

More information

I \ I i 15 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 16 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION. No. IN RE MAITER OF Y ) ) ) )

I \ I i 15 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 16 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION. No. IN RE MAITER OF Y ) ) ) ) l \ AARON S. DYER # aaron.dyer@pllsburylaw.com. LAUREN M. LEAHY #0 lauren.leahy@pllsburylaw.com rllsbury WNTHROP SHAW PTTMAN LLP South Fgueroa Street Sute 00 Los Angeles CA 00-0 Telephone: ( -00 Facsmle:

More information

Ortega v Neris 2015 NY Slip Op 30987(U) May 4, 2015 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Lucindo Suarez Cases posted with a

Ortega v Neris 2015 NY Slip Op 30987(U) May 4, 2015 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Lucindo Suarez Cases posted with a Ortega v Ners 2015 NY Slp Op 30987(U) May 4, 2015 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: 303825/2012 Judge: Lucndo Suarez Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013 NY Slp Op 30001(U), are republshed

More information

APPELLATE DIVISION DOCKET NO. L P.W. L P.W.

APPELLATE DIVISION DOCKET NO. L P.W. L P.W. ML000946M S U P E R I O R C O U R T OF NEW J E R S E Y APPELLATE DIVISION DOCKET NO. L-6001-78 P.W. L-59128-85 P.W. MORRIS COUNTY FAIR HOUSING COUNCIL, et. al. r Plantffs v. BOONTON TOWNSHIP, et. al. Defendant

More information

- r. &he Gazette of Andia (a) ~~m;t-im;imjmit~&~~~is9f&i PUBLISHED BY AUTHOFUTY. otm 11-m3-3P-m (i) REGD. NO. D. L;-33~"

- r. &he Gazette of Andia (a) ~~m;t-im;imjmit~&~~~is9f&i PUBLISHED BY AUTHOFUTY. otm 11-m3-3P-m (i) REGD. NO. D. L;-33~ ...@. 3 REGD. NO. D. L;-33~" - r &he Gazette of Anda L EXTRAORDNARY otm 11-m3-3P-m () - - PKRm~&o-b-seq - ~ + r ~ PUBLSHED BY AUTHOFUTY U. 4851 m, m, Wl'W 30, 20ll/un: 8, 1933 Na 4851 NEW DELH, TUESDAY,

More information

The Law Commission FAMILY LAW THE GROUND FOR DIVORCE. of the Law Commissions Act 1965

The Law Commission FAMILY LAW THE GROUND FOR DIVORCE. of the Law Commissions Act 1965 The Law Commsson (LAW COM. No. 192) FAMILY LAW THE GROUND FOR DIVORCE Lad before Parlament by the Lord Hgh Chancellor pursuant to secton 3(2) of the Law Commssons Act 1965 Ordered by The House of Commons

More information

Legal Presumptions in the Context of Contemporary Criminal Justice: Formulation of a Paradigm

Legal Presumptions in the Context of Contemporary Criminal Justice: Formulation of a Paradigm 2498-5473 / USD 20.00 2016 Akadéma Kadó, Budapest Hungaran Journal of Legal Studes 57, No 4, pp. 462 476 (2016) DOI: 10.1556/2052.2016.57.4.5 Legal Presumptons n the Context of Contemporary Crmnal Justce:

More information

Loreley Fin. (Jersey) No. 3, Ltd. v Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc NY Slip Op 32624(U) October 1, 2014 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number:

Loreley Fin. (Jersey) No. 3, Ltd. v Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc NY Slip Op 32624(U) October 1, 2014 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: Loreley Fn. (Jersey) No. 3, Ltd. v Morgan Stanley & Co. nc. 2014 NY Slp Op 32624(U) October 1, 2014 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: 653316/12 Judge: Jeffrey K. Ong Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e.,

More information

Rural Municipality ofciayton No. 333 BYLAW NO. 4/2011. The council for the Rural Municipality ofclayton No. 333 in the Province ofsaskatchewan enacts

Rural Municipality ofciayton No. 333 BYLAW NO. 4/2011. The council for the Rural Municipality ofclayton No. 333 in the Province ofsaskatchewan enacts M (a Nusance Abatement Bylaw Rural Muncpalty ofcayton No. 333 BYLAW NO. 4/2011 A B^LAW TO PROVDE FOR THE ABATEMENT OF NUSANCES WTHN THE BOUNDARES OF THE ORGANZED HAMLET OF SWAN PLAN The councl for the

More information

E D ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE I L ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NO

E D ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE I L ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NO Doc # 008308, OR BK 478 Page, Number Pages: 6, Recorded /08/008 at 0 :4 AM, JIM FULLER CLERK CIRCUIT COURT DUVAL COUNTY IN THE CIRCUIT COURT, FOURTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR DUVAL, CLAY AND NASSAU

More information

IN THE SUPREME COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA

IN THE SUPREME COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA IN THE SUPREME COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA ASA'CARSARMIUT TRIBAL COUNCIL, vs. APPELLANT JOHN D. WHEELER III JEANETTE MYRE, APPELLEES. Case No.: S-15318 Tral Case No. 3AN-12-4581 APPEAL FROM THE SUPERIOR

More information

Application for Exempt Regulated Activities registration (UK)

Application for Exempt Regulated Activities registration (UK) ERA 2019 Applcaton for Exempt Regulated Actvtes regstraton (UK) Ths form should be completed f you wsh your frm to undertake exempt regulated actvtes through ACCA under the Fnancal Servces and Markets

More information

The Optimal Weighting of Pre-Election Polling Data

The Optimal Weighting of Pre-Election Polling Data Brgham Young Unversty BYU ScholarsArchve All Theses and Dssertatons 2008-04-23 The Optmal Weghtng of Pre-Electon Pollng Data Gregory K. Johnson Brgham Young Unversty - Provo Follow ths and addtonal works

More information

CONTRACT REMEDIES AND INALIENABLE RIGHTS *

CONTRACT REMEDIES AND INALIENABLE RIGHTS * 178 JOEL FENBERG are wronged and harmed on balance by them. These prohbtons would be legtmate only when an nterest-connected nongrevance evl s extreme. Ths result appears to be a departure from the strct

More information

Last Time. u Priority-based scheduling. u Schedulable utilization u Rate monotonic rule: Keep utilization below 69%

Last Time. u Priority-based scheduling. u Schedulable utilization u Rate monotonic rule: Keep utilization below 69% Last Tme u Prorty-based schedulng Ø Statc prortes Ø Dynamc prortes u Schedulable utlzaton u Rate monotonc rule: Keep utlzaton below 69% Today u Response tme analyss u Blockng terms u Prorty nverson Ø And

More information

Solano v QLR Six, Inc NY Slip Op 33989(U) June 14, 2013 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /10 Judge: Wilma Guzman Cases posted

Solano v QLR Six, Inc NY Slip Op 33989(U) June 14, 2013 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: /10 Judge: Wilma Guzman Cases posted Solano v QLR Sx, nc. 2013 NY Slp Op 33989(U) June 14, 2013 Supreme Court, Bronx County Docket Number: 308771/10 Judge: Wlma Guzman Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013 NY Slp Op 30001(U), are republshed

More information

I" f_jj" Erwln 0. Canham Post Office Box 185. t Plebiscite Commissioner Capitol Hill Rural Branch

I f_jj Erwln 0. Canham Post Office Box 185. t Plebiscite Commissioner Capitol Hill Rural Branch " "2' - / OFFICE OF THE PLEBISCITE COMMISSIONER '' / " Marana Islands Dstrct f _"_ Sapan, Marana Islands 96950 I" f_jj" Erwln 0. Canham Post Offce Box 185 t Plebscte Commssoner Captol Hll Rural Branch

More information

The Impact Local Government Consolidation has on Community Goals: Experiences in Other Regions

The Impact Local Government Consolidation has on Community Goals: Experiences in Other Regions The Impact Local Government Consoldaton has on Communty Goals: Experences n Other Regons Prepared by Erc Persons for the Onondaga Ctzens League Study Commttee Aprl 2005 Summary: Ths document hghlghts the

More information

California Ballot Propositions and Initiatives. Follow this and additional works at:

California Ballot Propositions and Initiatives. Follow this and additional works at: Unversty of Calforna Hastngs College of the Law UC Hastngs Scholarshp Repostory ntatves Calforna Ballot Propostons and ntatves 3-7-1994 ntatve Power. Follow ths and addtonal works at: http://repostory.uchastngs.edu/ca_ballot_nts

More information

Does Bicameralism Matter?

Does Bicameralism Matter? Does Bcameralsm Matter? Mchael Cutrone Dept. of Poltcs Prnceton Unversty Nolan McCarty Woodrow Wlson School Prnceton Unversty . Introducton Perhaps the most conspcuous varaton n modern legslatures concerns

More information

I I, IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA ACCUSED APPELLANT. Accused Appellant. Case No.

I I, IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA ACCUSED APPELLANT. Accused Appellant. Case No. N THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE DEMOCRATC SOCALST REPUBLC OF SR LANKA n the matter of an Appeal made under secton 331 of the Code of Crmnal Procedure Act No. 15 of 1979 beng an appeal aganst the convcton

More information

Democratization and clientelism: Why are young democracies badly governed?

Democratization and clientelism: Why are young democracies badly governed? Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Publc Dsclosure Authorzed Democratzaton and clentelsm: Why are young democraces badly governed? Phlp Keefer Development Research

More information

% % ^GRANT CHANDLER, CHAIRMAN. PBPmftMCK NQ.».

% % ^GRANT CHANDLER, CHAIRMAN. PBPmftMCK NQ.». PBPmftMCK NQ.». AN ORDINANCE ALLOWING FOR DIRECT LEGISLATION BY THE PEOPLE THROUGH THE INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM; ADOPTING AS COUNTY 3-7 AND ITS AMENDMENTS THERETO; AND ESTABLISHING THE EFFECTIVE REQUIREMENTS

More information

Matter of Dukhon v Kim 2013 NY Slip Op 31721(U) July 25, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Cynthia S.

Matter of Dukhon v Kim 2013 NY Slip Op 31721(U) July 25, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Cynthia S. Matter of Dukhon v Km 203 NY Slp Op 372(U) July 25 203 Sup Ct New York County Docket Number: 65776/203 Judge: Cyntha S. Kern Republshed from New York State Unfed Court System's E-Courts Servce. Search

More information

1 Senate and House of Representatives.

1 Senate and House of Representatives. CONSTTUTON OF THE UNTED STATES-' 1 WE THE PEOPLE of the Unted States, n Order to form a more perfect Unon, establsh Justce, nsure domestc Tranqulty, provde for the common defence, promote the general Welfare,

More information

Did Illegal Overseas Absentee Ballots Decide the 2000 U.S. Presidential Election? 1

Did Illegal Overseas Absentee Ballots Decide the 2000 U.S. Presidential Election? 1 Dd Illegal Overseas Absentee Ballots Decde the 2000 U.S. Presdental Electon? 1 Kosuke Ima 2 Gary Kng 3 March 23, 2004 1 We are deeply grateful to the many prvate ctzens of every poltcal strpe who took

More information

NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P : : : : :

NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P : : : : : J-S01007-16 NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P. 65.37 ROOSEVELT-BENTMAN TRUST FOR AMERICAN VOTERS INTER VIVOS TRUST APPEAL OF: HONORABLE PETER J. WIRS, TRUSTEE OF THE INTER VIVOS TRUST

More information

.. - LAW AND THE CONCEPT OF LAW - BEYOND THE NATION-STATE

.. - LAW AND THE CONCEPT OF LAW - BEYOND THE NATION-STATE .. - LAW AND THE CONCEPT OF LAW - BEYOND THE NATION-STATE LAW AND THE CONCEPT OF LAW - BEYOND THE NATION-STATE By: TALENE THOMAS IAN B.SC., B.A. A Thess Submtted to the School of Graduate Studes n Partal

More information

SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES The specific objectives of the Trust are to: a) identifyvulnerable individuals under 21 years of age to benefit from this

SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES The specific objectives of the Trust are to: a) identifyvulnerable individuals under 21 years of age to benefit from this ' ' ' s...,- 'W-' ","",-"""""=",,,,,,',"-==""""'"'--'";J;, '. - / c,5 /\ :J::..,--J ['" ';Ylc 1(\;1ef:l!.:t1!- THS DECLARATON OF TRUST s made the \,+L d;";:'':1h:.> T; Sj l Thousand and Fve by MSKWAMBOKA

More information

Attorney Docket Number Application Number

Attorney Docket Number Application Number The applcaton data sheet s part of the provsonal or nonprovsonal applcaton for whch t s beng submtted. The followng form contans the bblographc data arranged n a format specfed by the Unted States Patent

More information

UC Irvine CSD Working Papers

UC Irvine CSD Working Papers U Irvne SD Workng Papers Ttle The Tyranny of the Super-Majorty: How Majorty Rule Protects Mnortes Permalnk https://escholarshp.org/uc/tem/18b448r6 Author McGann, Anthony J. Publcaton Date 2002-10-01 escholarshp.org

More information

AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN BEFORE : I MARSHALL A. SNIDER ARBITRATORI

AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN BEFORE : I MARSHALL A. SNIDER ARBITRATORI SEP-09-2011 03:52 SSA-ODAR P.002 AN ARBTRATON BETWEEN :1 SOCAL securty ) ADMNSTRAOON OFFCE OF ) DSABLTY ADJUDCA non AND ) REVEW ) RE: Removal of Cases from ) Judge Eart W. Shaffer and ) ) FMCS No. 1G-60265-3

More information

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA. v. CASE NO.: SC03-37 ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR LEON COUNTY, FLORIDA

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA. v. CASE NO.: SC03-37 ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR LEON COUNTY, FLORIDA IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA CLARENCE JAMES JONES, Appellant, v. CASE NO.: SC03-37 STATE OF FLORIDA, Appellee. / ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR LEON COUNTY,

More information

The Greek Indignants through the domestic TV news bulletins

The Greek Indignants through the domestic TV news bulletins The Greek Indgnants through the domestc TV news bulletns Anastasa Venet, Stamats Poulakdakos, Kostas Theologou Technologcal Educatonal Insttuton of Ionan Islands, Unversty of Athens, Natonal Techncal Unversty

More information

AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM AND THE REP,UBLIC OF POLAND FOR THE PROMOTION AND RECIPROCAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS "

AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM AND THE REP,UBLIC OF POLAND FOR THE PROMOTION AND RECIPROCAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS /.. --------------~-- AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE SOCALST REPUBLC OF VETNAM 1,.1. ;j, AND THE REP,UBLC OF POLAND " ' l FOR THE PROMOTON AND RECPROCAL PROTECTON OF NVESTMENTS ",, /1 ( T~e Socalst Republc of Vetnam

More information

Rules of Frensham Pond Sailing Club

Rules of Frensham Pond Sailing Club Rules of Frensham Pond Salng Club Revsed 11 Aprl 2016 1 Name The name of the Club shall be Frensham Pond Salng Club. 2 Ams The ams of the Club are to encourage amateur boat salng and racng. The Club s

More information

Present: Simon G. Hare, Chair; Lily N. Morgan, Vice-Chair; and Daniel E. DeYoung, Commissioner; Wendy Watkins, Recorder

Present: Simon G. Hare, Chair; Lily N. Morgan, Vice-Chair; and Daniel E. DeYoung, Commissioner; Wendy Watkins, Recorder APPROVED ON APRL 5, 07 BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMSSONERS AT THE WEEKLY BUSNESS SESSON WEEKLY BUSNESS SESSON February 8, 07 5: 30 p. m. Anne G. Basker Audtorum 600 N. W. Sxth Street, Grants Pass, OR 9756

More information

POLITICAL STABILITY AND ECONOMIC GROWTH. A TWO WAY RELATION. EDGARDO E. ZABLOTSKY

POLITICAL STABILITY AND ECONOMIC GROWTH. A TWO WAY RELATION. EDGARDO E. ZABLOTSKY POLITICAL STABILITY AND ECONOMIC GROWTH. A TWO WAY RELATION. EDGARDO E. ZABLOTSKY FEBRUARY 1996 POLITICAL STABILITY AND ECONOMIC GROWTH. A TWO WAY RELATION. EDGARDO E. ZABLOTSKY 1 FEBRUARY 1996 I. INTRODUCTION.

More information

AUSTRALIAN HERITAGE COMMISSION ACT 1975

AUSTRALIAN HERITAGE COMMISSION ACT 1975 DSCLAMER: As Member States provde natonal legslatons hyperlnks and explanatory notes (f any) UNESCO does not guarantee ther accuracy nor ther up-datng on ths web ste and s not lable for any ncorrect nformaton.

More information

Biased Democracies: The Social and Economic Logic of Interest-Based Voting

Biased Democracies: The Social and Economic Logic of Interest-Based Voting 0 Based Democraces: The Socal and Economc Logc of Interest-Based Votng Torben Iversen Department of Government Harvard Unversty Davd Soskce Department of Government London School of Economcs Earler versons

More information

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GOOD GOVERNANCE AND SUSTAINABILITY IN AUSTRALIAN SPORT

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GOOD GOVERNANCE AND SUSTAINABILITY IN AUSTRALIAN SPORT 1 THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN GOOD GOVERNANCE AND SUSTAINABILITY IN AUSTRALIAN SPORT Francesco Bonollo de Zwart * and George Gllgan ** Workng Paper Not to be quoted wthout the express permsson of the authors,

More information

Matter of Interview, Inc. v Fuller 2014 NY Slip Op 32469(U) September 18, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge:

Matter of Interview, Inc. v Fuller 2014 NY Slip Op 32469(U) September 18, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /2013 Judge: Matter of ntervew, nc. v Fuller 2014 NY Slp Op 32469(U) September 18, 2014 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 653330/2013 Judge: Mchael D. Stallman Cases posted wth a "30000" dentfer,.e., 2013

More information

Innovations In Greek Political Communication And Consequences: Significant changes from

Innovations In Greek Political Communication And Consequences: Significant changes from Innovatons In Greek Poltcal Communcaton And Consequences: Sgnfcant changes from 1981-2009 Anastasa Delgaour TEI of Western Macedona, Greece E-mal: a.delgaour@kastora.tekoz.gr Abstract The ntroducton of

More information

National Defense and the Public-Goods Problem

National Defense and the Public-Goods Problem San Jose State Unversty SJSU ScholarWorks Faculty Publcatons Economcs 6-1-1994 Natonal Defense and the Publc-Goods Problem JEFFREY ROGERS HUMMEL San Jose State Unversty, jeff@jrhummel.com Don Lavoe Follow

More information

OSMANIA UNIVERSITY TIME TABLE. LL.B (3-YDC) First Year I Semester Backlog Examinations May / Jun Timings: a.m. to 1.00 p.m.

OSMANIA UNIVERSITY TIME TABLE. LL.B (3-YDC) First Year I Semester Backlog Examinations May / Jun Timings: a.m. to 1.00 p.m. LL.B (3-YDC) First Year Semester Backlog Examinations Timings: 10.00 a.m. to 1.00 p.m. 27-05-2015 01-06-2015 03-06-2015 10-06-2015 LAW OF CONTRACT FAMLY LAW CONSTTUTONAL LAW LAW OF TORTS NCLUDNG MOTOR

More information

TENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT Request for Qualifications (RFQ)

TENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT Request for Qualifications (RFQ) TENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT Request for Qualfcatons (RFQ) STENOGRAPHIC COURT REPORTING SERVICES RFQ # 10-2018-01 RFQ ISSUE DATE: May 17, 2018 RFQ RESPONSE DEADLINE: June 7, 2018, at 5:00 PM EST Note:

More information