Universität Bielefeld/I MW. Working Papers. Institut für Mathematische. Arbeiten aus dem. Institut für Mathematische Wirtschaftsforschung
|
|
- Steven Kevin Adams
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 .. Universität Bielefeld/I MW Working Papers Institute of Mathematical Arbeiten aus dem Institut für Mathematische No. 22 Economics Wirtschaftsforschung A Further Note On Rawls's Theory By John C. P~rsanyi University of Califürnia, BC1keley, and University of Bielefeld July = =-==-.._-- --,- -'--'.. ~~:~%:~;~j " ' H. G. Bergenthai Institut für Mathematische Wirtschaftsforschung an der Universität Bielefeld Adresse/ Address: Universitätsstraße 4800 Bielefeld 1 Bundesrepublik Deutschland Federal Republic of Germany
2 - --- A Further ~ote On Rawls's By John C. Harsanyi Theory This is a postscript to my review article "Can the Maximin Principle Serve as a Basis for Yorality? - A Critique of John Rawls's Theory" (Working Paper No. CP-351, Center for Research in Management ~8rkeley, California Science, University of California, Copies are available on request.) ~ince this paper was written in May, 1973, John R2wls has tried to c'1s\'lersome of my cri ticicisms in a p~per entitled "Svne Reasons for the!taximincriteric 1" (J..merican Economi~~-!.ew, Pc,pers & Proc., ~1ay 1974, pp. 1~1-146). His defense to the counterexamplesj have put forward against using the maxi""d n.[i i 'ci pi e,"'.sa moral In incirle (in Section 3 of the p e- eeding paper) is that "the maximin criterion is not meant to apply to s~allsc~le situations, say, to how a doetor should treat hi spat ic.'; s or a t::nivt rsi ty i ts students.... '1:axi min is a maero not a miero principle"(p. 142). Regretful1y, I ri\) st <ay thnt this is a singularly inept defense. Fjrst of all, though my counterexamples do refer to ~..~ll-', ~te sil~ati0ns, it is v ry c~sy to 2~2pt them to largesc'ale ~i t c tiens since they hc.~:eint r i Tl' {cally l10thing to do wi th ~Ce le,'hether s.'all or lc.. '_'ge.for I.Vi'!"ple,in stead of asking v~het"'it r a~' (~Ol' ';LUJld 8 a life" 2\riilg c"rug in short supply for t}.,t L:':].L:ti. it\ or r,tilt B, "e can o.skwhether, in allocating SCc lt.:e.~acc 1,"I'.'lu'.,;er end other resources, should society give priority to those patients who could best \-",,"'c it ffit Jcdical treatment, or should rather jl'e priority ",) 1',: t ~(~,,] 'sly ~ick pe,ticnts - - a policy ploblfffi sl1,llly ~j:tctig ( Cl Lntry of c r( e catiu.j I; t cl l'::;l.>,dt's"',:d indivi\.~pals in ;qy n:ajor cly g iv (~n in c p r t < 1:1, ~ f S t 0 :..;. " l.r? 1 tine. (Ir, i'!gain, i ~te d of ",)ring v,'hether l ~ 1., I r 1 <, \; 1 c' l.11 (.', (i ' s,..j(,1 t.y d E"nt s.. :'a ( ( i.' 1d. ' 1Y L~rJ":"'1d,,"L::{l:,lyiLt - ~ed dnor lc-lefits ftom ajditionc31, '" " i t~ L1l ~ or 1ty ~.i..d t'''ld ~~(J','j gifted stui i t i-,,;1: to;=j 1 h ~ d.;:, C'",, " ~.', ~ (, ( t i 1, t; t c.,-..i' -1,~('~l~e (. Y I?M rlally C~LO-
3 - 2 - over1ooked the simple fact that the counterexamples I have a~dl1ccd (and the many more counterexarnples one could easily adduce) have nothing whatever to do with scale at all. In fact, it would ~e a priori r~ther surprising if, at thc most fundamental level, the basic plinciples of morality should tare different :orms for 1arsc-scale and for small-scale situations. Does Rawls serious1y think t}~t there 1s a certain number x, such that a situation involving ~ore than x people will come under moral principles basically different from a situation involving lc3s than x people? In any ("a.se,what moral considerations will determine this curious r)u;;dary number x itself? T>1orefundamentally, what are the basic logical reasons that should make large-scale and s~nall-scale situations essentially different from a moral point of view? I C2n,:ot :"'-eehow arlyl.ody C2'1 plopose th~ st '1ge ('!OCtline tha t scale is a f'":1da:entalra~ ic ble in ),,(al phi ]:f( lhy, wiuout giving credible ans..:crs to these Cjuestions at the Sdi1e time. I heve ~_(;j"f>d th.it in!:p'ost fit.uc~tjonsr2wls's theory will have ruch the s.fle policy i!lplic-atio.s as ut i1 itarian theory does, but tr t there d:e s_~~ L1pOl.tC'1t c,itpatio!s ~I're this is not the case. ~()rt_(;.~~r,i 1ve tli.d to cl.y.'l J'hat, in those situat ions vihere two theorif's (~o ~. ve (...ui t.e cli ssiillilar policy implications, Rawls's theory consist.ently yields morally highly unac-_ ( "t ~ ( 1 1 ~ 1'01icy conclusions whereas utili tarian theory ("onsi st E:üt- 'y..l~ 1('s J ~L ]ly +ul1y q.cge.ntc\b!.ones (~E..:ctj(J'1S 3 cd 4 of t'1e prn ~ Hng i p.'r). 11 LO..1 '- ~ s " ~ II da; \ ; ] (' r v i ( 'fl r:.,.( 11r,'1 0 f ~h i 1 0 ~ 0 J ~'. V '- JV I.:I - 1 'J ' t i t }-<.: i 1 world the Ai '.: 1 1:-'.1. ; (i.l. 1 e d ~.~ e t j 1 i I' n t r. j i1c i 1..1~ ~ '" 11 d have very similar py~clira1 (c :.qu(j ces, he adds: "... t.he rnaxirin! linciple T.'ould le;.ad to 1.( «_. 'le t;,nselupnces if t~e T c>r'd.i. e ~. eh that t:-ty [thc' je c-on.~..ue1c('s] n..ally CliffE' d". '1 '1 ~i (y~c~ (nt ~ith llrow is that I think the world is in f~(t 0 CC'1 c:-t i t..:..t- ( d that t:-tcse two principles do have very difft..;u,1t ). c ( l (...l.,fa 4 '_ s i '1 ". e ; :1""1t s. (IT} J f '.;s r, <...,.,,.!, 1 f J.) t.. ( «j- I i 1 3,.,.J... 1 j t-,,
4 l pp ) But we do agree on the main point, viz. on the conditional statement that, if such differences.exist, then they all speak very strongly against the maximln principle. In my opinion, if this criticism is valid, then it completely disqualifies Rawls's theory as a serjous competitpr to utilit2rian theory. (Why should anybody choose a theory that often does much würse, and never does any better, than utilitarian theory does?) For this reason, I find it rather unfortunate that Rawls's paper does not even try to answer this criticism at all. To be sure, the maximin principle does have its valuable uses, and we ~ust be grateful to Rawls for calling our attention to it. E\en if it eannot ~rrve as a b?sic principle of j~ral the01y, -- - _.- it ean be used as a piineiple of ~~proxijnate vdlidity in practie~l ~plieationsl ~,ueh as the theory of optimal inevme distribution er of optimal tixation. In ~ueh arplications, its rplative independence of dctailed interppj"sonal utility eolt~?arions, and of the aetual mathematical furm of ~eople's von Neumann-Morgenstern utility functions for money, is an important advantage, and can be fr'uitfully exploited in economic studies [cf. Arrow, op. cit., p. 259]. Of course, from the point of view of a utilitarian observer, the l~ ~ults of a study of, e~g~, optimal ineome tax rates, } - ~('(on tre mc...ri'dnl'h'ineiple,,,;i1lhave only approxirtate valil'ily. For example, if the study finds that, owing to the dis{ ;entive effeet of very high ~arginal tax rates, the ~1Iginal ineome tax for the highest inc('"e giou) ~:.lld }-,e (~ay) 50 I r ee'1t, then a utilit?rianobf.lc}:td1{ fll1-" ti'1.slx t; t "d(lrtai'1lyl~.!iq.2!lore th.:'l'1:0 LA~r <,t.;1r. """'('(1, re ( n it,fer t'.;;t, if the!:t rj had been La ~(,d on the ä\lt"i Je ut i 1 i ty pi L eir1 e instead of the mayi;'1in I i ({ i le, t~ln t"e T ':, (J{ 21 tr:..xlate at the top \'0,1d pc.lr;:ps 0t Vt l.y r, ueh lower. (Sensitivity analysis may,-"en e, '",,1e us t0 c!"1..': ',ate the aetual p -ereentage poi nts by "hich stl'dü s
5 'ould based on the maximin principle are likely to overestimate the optimal tax rates for various incrnne groups.) It is regrettable that Rawls has ever made the untenable claim that he is proposing a moral theory superior to utilitcric:} theory. This claim can only obscure the practical merits of ~he maximin principle as an e?sily appjicable postulate of appro,imate validity. These practical merits of course do not in any way provide a reason for abandoning utilitarian moral philosophy. (Basic philosophical principles must be exactly right, and not merely approximately right.) But they do provide a reason, even for a utilitarian moral philosopher, to use the n~ximin princ~ple as an admissible approximation in many cases. Had Rawls only made this more modest, but much more realistic, claim for the maximin principle,few ppople '. have contradicted hirn. One thing that all of us must heve Iparned in the last fifty years is the fact that we must never cor~it ourselves seliously to I.,(}~lprinciplcs or political ido1<'gies that are bound to lead to morally utterly ~'~J~ policies fn)!1\ time to time - - however great the advcntages of these principles or ideologies may be in terms of administrative convenience, ease of application, and readier understandability.
6 Norking Pal~rs Nr. 1 Carl Christian von Weizsäcker: The Political Economy of Stability in Western Countries, - The Wicksell Lectures - Stockholm, 2nd and 4th May, 1972, published at Almquist and Wiksell, Stockholm Carl Christian von Weizsäcker: "(j lf~rn Capital Theory and the CCilceptof Fxploitation, July 1972, l'ublished in :~yklos, j'ay "'ir. Nr. Nr. 3 Carl rhri tian von PP:i2: 'kl.er: A ~~W T(chn'cal Progrt.ss Function (1962), August Carl Christi an von \'ieizs.'icker: Long Term Global Optimization in Educational Planning. A Sir1ple F>:0i'1I'.1e, Septen'ber Carl Christian von Weizsäcker: '"nt f>r e'1erationell e Einkomrnensvel. teil ung: Finfache )eispiele 7ür \'~irkui1lje'n steuerlic,er '1C!ßnah,..:n und {"ijr (He cl-"'" -'le St('h-r~trl1k.tL1r, C('io'er 1S72, I.Jbli..1-I'd in,'(,3 l'q)ti.te(~t>r "IJtE.il.j~tl, J'e, G.poTT1baC'h, 9. Fr.ey, B. ('.,;h"n (cds.), 'nibil~j::..n Carl Christian von Weizsäcker: ~~r. 7 Yenneth Arrow's ContriLution to Ecenomic ScienC'E's, r"ovl. bt r 1972, lubli~ lj.:d in S"erli~hJOllu''''l of i-'l (,,0- rnigs, Velo 74, r~rl ChI',,,t i <.1."1'1 <7'-'1..,.-, i '1 ; 1 '1,"',., \.. 11.')li d i,1..; c l.y 1}71, T("lIlal, T" 'i d' ; 1 'tr 1./1.. 71, 8 Reinhard Selten: A Si p'ple Horiel of Ir1perfect Competi tion, \Alhere 4 are 1', <'1 'Ld 6 bre "1eny, FC'bn'ery 1973, published in Inter- ',1 Je:, 'I cf (' e 'l"':~',l'y, D" ' '.:>r "j. 10 r. ~, vf Y 1~11. t' 1 J 'n, 1 r. 11 t,d,.1,',1 «'"'!h J.g: ;"y i",trr-t'd,~fjl1... l' 'r HCt:S, July 1973.
7 - 2 - Nr. 12 Nr. 13 Nr. 14 Nr. 15 Carl Christina von Weizsäcker: Grenzen der traditionellen Globalsteuerung, October 1973, published in Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik Carl Christian von Weizsäcker: Reply to Mrs. Robinson, Morishima and Wolfstetter, November Carl Christian von Keizsäcker: Substituion Along the Time Axis (preliminary version), February John C. Harsanyi: The Tr~'cing procedure: A Bayesian Approach to Defining a Solution for n-person Noncoo~erative Games, Part I, May Nr. 16 Jnhn C. I'cl 5 "1yi : '.1;'e Tl 8t':i.T9 rll(u~,'.r(':a r:>'l ' a Sol t; on [,)r 11 ~,;r'>un :'c ( C~l '. a y n 1.1 ro~lh to r~li~e r s, "'tfi ing p, 1 t 1 T, Nr. 17 C"oLn ),n ('~, Tl: Pl:O(~t'1 Li, 1,' <pm,,d :!c',,:t ~(s ;'i,'.,jlju 'I:;; Ü-Ltels n('is in Ta' an: fko~c~ctlische Unter~uchung und Proynose, ~1ay Reinhard Selten: l~r. 19 The Crain Store Pra1ox, July Cerl C'listicn von T';ei2.~;-:(;k('r: Politi~~l Li~its of Traditional stabilization Policy, J~re '"',(inha~j Selten: Bargai'Ü'1g tl;:3.er IncOJlplete Infor;atiC'n - :\ ;'\. Ti ca 1 Fx IpIe, July ~'1'. 21 r (T"yi: ';,']y o a '~ (~...l 1':;/4., 1 1 )< c ~ U 1 +. r '...,...) (. > J. -! '1 lii..y? - "r. '2 1..i 1 :,~ r',,' L L ~G tee 1,'"'.;1 s 's l' r ln y, l T\...1Y
Chapter 1: Duties of Local Lodge Officers
Chapter 1: Duties of Local Lodge Officers This first section of the guide deals with the main duties of local lodge officers as set forth in the IAM Constitution. The IAM Constitution designates the president,
More informationJohn Rawls: Crit ical Assessment s of Leading. leading political philosophers. Chand ran Kukathas. Routledge (2002) London School of Economics
John Rawls: critical assessments of leading political philosophers. John Rawls: Crit ical Assessment s of Leading Polit ical Philosophers Chandran Kukathas (ed.) Routledge (2002) Authors Chand ran Kukathas
More informationmg Doc 1076 Filed 09/07/18 Entered 09/07/18 12:17:22 Main Document Pg 1 of 10
Pg 1 of 10 M AR TIN LIP TON H E RB ER T M. W AC H T EL L P AU L VIZ C A R R ONDO, J R. TR E VO R S. N O RW I TZ BEN M. GE R M AN A AN D R EW J. N U S SB A U M 51 W E S T 52ND S T R E E T N E W Y O R K,
More informationthe record of the Board of Canvassers filed in my office this 26 1 h
STATE OF IDAHO COUNTY OF CASSIA I, Joseph W. Larsen, County Clerk of said county and state, do hereby certify that the attached is a full, true and complete copy of the abstract of votes for the candidates
More informationECON 4270 Distributive Justice Lecture 4: Rawls and liberal equality
ECON 4270 Distributive Justice Lecture 4: Rawls and liberal equality Hilde Bojer www.folk.uio.no/hbojer hbojer@econ.uio.no February 16, 2011 Economics and welfarism Rawls: liberal equality Rawls: a Kantian
More informationCase 2:18-cv JFC Document 1-1 Filed 04/25/18 Page 2 of 35
Case 2:18-cv-00532-JFC Document 1-1 Filed 04/25/18 Page 1 of 35 Exhibit "A" Case 2:18-cv-00532-JFC Document 1-1 Filed 04/25/18 Page 2 of 35 Case 2:18-cv-00532-JFC Document 1-1 Filed 04/25/18 Page 3 of
More informationAGENDA MEMORANDUM. Item #12. Meeting Date: September 16, 2014
Item #12 Meeting Date: September 16, 2014 AGENDA MEMORANDUM To: From: Title: Honorable Mayor and Members of Town Council Jason Reynolds, Current Planning Manager, Development Services Resolution No. 2014-83:
More information~M~c. f. tl A Commissioner, etc. THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF VAUGHAN. Todd Coles Deputy City Clerk, City of Vaughan A Commissioner. etc.
NULOOK DEVELOPMENTS NC. THE CORPORATON OF THE CTY OF VAUGHAN N THE MATTER OF Section 34, Subsections (18) and (19) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.p.13, BARBARA A. MCEWAN, of the City of Toronto, make
More informationfcnm fcnm cover a wide range of issues, including, inter alia: Non-discrimination Promotion of effective equality
Wh at i s t he F r ame wo w ork rk C o nv ve en f or th e Pr P rot ote ec ct tion io n of N at io i on n al Mi n nor or iiti t ie es s? Th e p pr r o v isio n s of the Framework veon cover a wide range
More informationLevel 2 Offenses. Cheating/Plagarism (CT) Student Conference (CO) Student Conference (CO) Student Conference (CO) Student Conference (CO)
Level 1 Offenses Computer Mischief (CV1) (Minor) Warning (WI) >>>>>>> 45 Min. Detention (IS1) Half Day ISS (HD) ISS Full Day (IS) Dress Code Violation (DC) Warning (WI) (Step 0, Dress Code Letter sent
More informationUNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS
2000-03 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS JOHN NASH AND THE ANALYSIS OF STRATEGIC BEHAVIOR BY VINCENT P. CRAWFORD DISCUSSION PAPER 2000-03 JANUARY 2000 John Nash and the Analysis
More informationTHE CAPABILITY APPROACH AS A HUMAN DEVELOPMENT PARADIGM AND ITS CRITIQUES
THE CAPABILITY APPROACH AS A HUMAN DEVELOPMENT PARADIGM AND ITS CRITIQUES Nuno Martins Faculty of Economics and Management, Portuguese Catholic University, Porto, Portugal Keywords: capability approach,
More informationLecture 2: Normative theories of social and fiscal justice in historical perspective (check on line for updated versions)
Public Economics: Tax & Transfer Policies (Master PPD & APE, Paris School of Economics) Thomas Piketty Academic year 2016-2017 Lecture 2: Normative theories of social and fiscal justice in historical perspective
More informationCAMPAIGN TREASURER' S REPORT SUMMARY. 5) Report Identifiers. Monetary Expenditures. Transfers to Office Account $ 8) Other Distributions 10)
) Tom Keller Name 2) 707 Algonquin Dr. Address (number and street) Clearwater, FL 33755 CAMPAIGN TREASURER' S REPORT SUMMARY Check here if address has changed 4) Check appropriate box(es): p Candidate
More informationAP Comparative Government and Politics
2018 AP Comparative Government and Politics Sample Student Responses and Scoring Commentary Inside: Free Response Question 1 RR Scoring Guideline RR Student Samples RR Scoring Commentary College Board,
More informationo INITIAL REGISTRATION - I/We qualified as a lobbyist on r,...)
CITY CLERK'S OFFICE LOBBYIST INITIAL/ANNUAL REGISTRATION REPORT INSTRUCTIONS: Complete and return this form, along with your payment, to: FEES DUE: Initial/Annual Registration - $452.00 per Registrant
More informationLAURENCE DE BAUCHE. VULNERABILITY IN EUROPEAN LAW ON ASYLUM : A CONCEPTUALIZATION UNDER CONSTRUCTION Study on réception conditions for asylum seekers
LAURENCE DE BAUCHE VULNERABILITY IN EUROPEAN LAW ON ASYLUM : A CONCEPTUALIZATION UNDER CONSTRUCTION Study on réception conditions for asylum seekers LA VULNÉRABILITÉ EN DROIT EUROPÉEN DE L'ASILE : UNE
More informationORDINANCE NO. 14,173
ORDINANCE NO. 14,173 AN ORDINANCE amend Municipal Code City Des Moines, Iowa, 2000, adopted by Ordinance No. 13,827, passed June 5, 2000, by amending Section 94-321 relating fees f private construction
More informationBoy Scout Troop 883 PLC Meeting Plan
Boy Scout Troop 883 PLC Meeting Plan Date: /13dr---7/24/1? Leader Activity Description Opening and Call to Order Roll Call and Reading of the Log : 1st A: N./. 2nd A: V Splody Bang: / \/' : V QM: Reading
More informationComplaint Filed: September 2, 2016 Trial Date: None Set. Case 2:16-cv SB Document 9 Filed 12/30/16 Page 1 of 7
Case :-cv-0-sb Docment Filed /0/ Page of Mary-Alice Coleman (SBN: Dianne Schambrg (SBN: 00 LAW OFFICES OF MARY-ALICE COLEMAN, P.C. Kennedy Place, Site Davis, California Telephone:.. Facsimile:.0.00 Attorneys
More informationState of Florida TASK FORCE ON CITIZEN SAFETY AND PROTECTION Comments. Completion of personal information is optional. Street
~~ask Force on ~CITIZEN SAFETY "Jnd PROTECTION State of Florida TASK FORCE ON CITIZEN SAFETY AND PROTECTION Completion of personal information is optional. DATE: j /...- I 0 ' I z.. '. PLEASE PRINT (7.
More informationAppellate Briefs of the Future
Appellate Briefs of the Future Blake Hawthorne Don Cruse IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS 44444444444444444444 Misc. Docket No. 10-9065 44444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444
More informationylaws of ral ealth lorida he na e of the corporation shall be ral ealth lorida, hereinafter so eti es referred to as the Corporation Principal Office
ylaws of ral ealth lorida CL a e he na e of the corporation shall be ral ealth lorida, hereinafter so eti es referred to as the Corporation CL Principal Office rincipal ffice he principal office and place
More informationl!!y fat her was one of the few Democrats in
SEPTEMBER 29, 1967 l!!y fat her was one of the few Democrats in Huron, South Dakota. My mot her was not one of the other Democrats. My fat her once told me: "Hubert, that wonderful lady deserves your love
More informationTHE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF BRAMPTON BY-LAW Number. A By-law to authorize the execution of a Cessation of Charge.
THE CORPORATON OF THE CTY OF BRAMPTON BYLAW 22876 Number A Bylaw to authorize the execution of a Cessation of Charge. WHEREAS it is deemed necessary to enter into and execute a Cessation of Charge; NOW
More informationFIRST AMENDMENT TO INTERLOCAL CONTRACT. Between DOUGLAS COUNTY, NEVADA. And CITY OF SOUTH LAKE TAHOE, CALIFORNIA
AYYKUVED AYK1L 1/, ZU14 11r;M WZa BOCC FIRST AMENDMENT TO INTERLOCAL CONTRACT Between DOUGLAS COUNTY, NEVADA And CITY OF SOUTH LAKE TAHOE, CALIFORNIA WHEREAS, Douglas County is a political subdivision
More informationTHE CORPORATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF WOOLWICH BY-LAW NUMBER A BY-LAW FOR THE IMPOSITION OF DEVELOPMENT CHARGE
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWNSHIP OF WOOLWICH BY-LAW NUMBER 33-2014 A BY-LAW FOR THE IMPOSITION OF DEVELOPMENT CHARGE WHEREAS the Township of Woolwich will experience growth through development and redevelopment;
More informationConflicts of Interest
Conflicts of Interest You Can t Be Everyone s Best Friend or Their Lawyer, Either Claude E. Ducloux Attorney At Law Board Certified Texas Board of Legal Specialization Civil Trial Law Civil Appellate Law
More informationThe Burger Court Opinion Writing Database
The Burger Court Opinion Writing Database Paris Adult Theatre I v. Slaton 413 U.S. 49 (1973) Paul J. Wahlbeck, George Washington University James F. Spriggs, II, Washington University Forrest Maltzman,
More informationT he Subst ance of Polit ics
The substance of politics. T he Subst ance of Polit ics A. Appadorai Oxford University Press India (2001) Abstract This is a well-integrated and comprehensive textbook of political science primarily meant
More informationmentioned only as to be done next month but no budget action taken at this meeting.
RHC Meeting Date: 4-11-18 Time: 6:00pm Location: 825 Lounge Minutes Minutes recorded by Diona Symester Let residents grab food then start at 6:10 Warm welcome- by JJ Li ntroduction eboard: President -
More informationCase 0:17-cr BB Document 125 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/23/2018 Page 1 of 5 UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
Case 0:17-cr-60022-BB Document 125 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/23/2018 Page 1 of 5 UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA CASE NO. 17-60022-CR-BLOOM UNITED STATES O F AM ERICA V. ESTEBAN
More information- L iq uor to in to xica ted cus tomers - R e mo va l o f l iq u o r fr o m p r e mis e s
Legislation Excerpts This appendix contains excerpts from the Alberta Gaming and Liquor Act (GLA), Alberta Gaming and Liquor Regulation (GLR), and the Alberta Gaming and Liquor Commission Licensee Handbook,
More informationen de teeomonenchlion AL e Xonoretaa
440 (4 de ezealkie en 25th July,, _T. /90 4, gie.)ent.- Q5704 Alimmelera e/a McBride. ehgtfessi.) GX. Green. eg en de teeomonenchlion AL e Xonoretaa The Minister of Mines. an,/ eingq yetoviision4 gxydrt
More informationALLETE, INC. BOARD OF DIRECTORS EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE CHARTER
Approved by the ALLETE Board of Directors on July 26, 2017 ALLETE, INC. BOARD OF DIRECTORS EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE CHARTER Purposes of Committee The pu rposes of the Execu tive Compensation Committee
More informationI For additional employers, use a second form and attach to original_
Full Lobb ist Permanent Business Business While Lobb in State Last \) f.."n l S Pursuant to the Lobbyist Registration Act of the of Albuquerque, the undersigned hereby registers as a Lobbyist and states
More informationConstitutional Law: Arizona Gun Rights
Constitutional Law: Arizona Gun Rights Presented by: Attorney Howard Dworman AttorneysForFreedom.com 3185 S. Price Road, Chandler, Arizona 85248 480-755- 7110 Contact@AttorneysForFreedom.com Exper i en
More informationIN THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA. THiRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT DECISION AND ORDER
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA ALASKA DEMOCRATIC PARTY, THiRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT vs. Plaintiff, GAIL FENUMIAI, in hcr official capacity as DIRECTOR OF THE DIVISION OF ELECTIONS; and STATE
More informationSECOND SUPERSEDING ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE. WHEREAS, the United states having filed a civil complaint on
:KJ\M':eSK:ec CV2-18.wpd UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - against - JASON VALE, Defendant. x Docket No. CR-O2-466(S-2)
More informationFIRST AMENDMENT TO ANNEXATION AGREEMe:NT. THIS FIRST AMENDMENT TO ANNEXATION AGREEMENT ("Amendment") is made and
, \ ')QeJ2 &tiz1-- _at J 6wwd- FRST AMENDMENT TO ANNEXATON AGREEMe:NT THS FRST AMENDMENT TO ANNEXATON AGREEMENT (Amendment) is made and entered into this 16 th day of May, 25 by and among Horizons Acquisition
More informationExperimental Computational Philosophy: shedding new lights on (old) philosophical debates
Experimental Computational Philosophy: shedding new lights on (old) philosophical debates Vincent Wiegel and Jan van den Berg 1 Abstract. Philosophy can benefit from experiments performed in a laboratory
More informationTHE POLICY CONSEQUENCES OF POLARIZATION: EVIDENCE FROM STATE REDISTRIBUTIVE POLICY
THE POLICY CONSEQUENCES OF POLARIZATION: EVIDENCE FROM STATE REDISTRIBUTIVE POLICY Elizabeth Rigby George Washington University Gerald Wright Indiana University Prepared for presentation at the Conference
More informationˆ Ø Ø Ø ØŒ Ø Ø Ø Ø Â Ø Ø. Ø ØŒØ Â ØªØ Ø . Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Š . Ø Ø
F R N R PH NT R N TT N R PH f th F D R L N L F R N ND T HN L n r t d f r b r ( n v r t f l f rn, n D n 20 2 0 2 :02 T http: hdl.h ndl.n t 202. 0 2 06 6 88 "F r t n f th nd f r â v r n n h p d th p r t
More informationBRIAN M. BARNARD USB /I 0215 JAMES L. HARRIS, Jr. USB I 8204 UTAH LEGAL CLINIC Attorneys for PLAINTIFF Cooperating Attorneys for UTAH CIVI L RIGHT!;; 6- LIBERTIES FOUNDATION, INC. 214 East Fifth South
More informationCAS Justice, Democracy, and Global Affairs
PA R T- T IME DEGR EE PROG RAM C A S JU ST ICE, DEM OCR ACY, AND GLOBAL AF FAIRS I N STITU TE OF PHILOSOPH Y / UNIVE RS IT Y OF BE RN ( SWITZERLAND) CAS Justice, Democracy, and Global Affairs CAS Justice,
More informationCAPITOL BOULEVARD REVISITED NASHVILLE CIVIC DESIGN CENTER
CAPITOL BOULEVARD REVISITED NASHVILLE CIVIC DESIGN CENTER ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS The Capitol Boulevard Study was conducted in May of 2002 by the following Nashville Civic Design Center Staff:
More informationCERTIFICATE IN ANTI HUMAN TRAFFICKING (CAHT) Term-End Examination. December,
No. of Printed Pages : 6 I BLE-032 CERTIFICATE IN ANTI HUMAN TRAFFICKING (CAHT) Term-End Examination December, 2015 450 BLE-032 : LAW POLICIES AND INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSE TO HUMAN TRAFFICKING Time : 3 hours
More informationA representation theorem for minmax regret policies
Artificial Intelligence 171 (2007) 19 24 Research note www.elsevier.com/locate/artint A representation theorem for minmax regret policies Sanjiang Li a,b a State Key Laboratory of Intelligent Technology
More informationMaximin equilibrium. Mehmet ISMAIL. March, This version: June, 2014
Maximin equilibrium Mehmet ISMAIL March, 2014. This version: June, 2014 Abstract We introduce a new theory of games which extends von Neumann s theory of zero-sum games to nonzero-sum games by incorporating
More informationRules of the Prosecuting Attorneys Council of Georgia
Rules of the Prosecuting Attorneys Council of Georgia Chapter 5 Preemployment Drug Testing Part 1 Pre-employment Drug Testing 1. Authority. These rules have been adopted by the Prosecuting Attorneys' Council
More informationProposed Rule(s) Filing Form
Department of State Division of Publications 312 Rosa L. Parks Avenue, 8th Floor SnodgrassfTN Tower Nashville, TN 37243 Phone: 615-741-2650 Email: publica!ions.lnformation@tn.gov J~-1 Fo::::::::~:.:ta-te~
More information~Wr ---- dfib ~ay /S-/ --+_..10. Lp: -2 S ~ j:?.. /. /:J- /77. CL/rl. t{cem,
'n:lfte GU:\E l.i:
More informationGame Theory -RE-S-O-N-A-N-C-E--I-J-U-IY ~~ ~- 1. Nash Equilibrium. P GBabu
Game Theory 1. Nash Equilibrium P GBabu This article tries to outline what game theory is all about. It illustrates game theory's fundamental solution concept viz., Nash equilibrium, using various examples.
More informationEntrepreneurs out of necessity : a snapshot
Entrepreneurs out of necessity : a snapshot Markus Poschke McGill University, Montréal QC, Canada H3A2T7 E-mail: markus.poschke@mcgill.ca August 2012 Abstract Entrepreneurs out of necessity as identified
More informationThis document is from the collections at the Dole Archives, University of Kansas ,U~t. , r---..ft_. timtcd. ~tatr.
', r---ft_ Q l BOB 00LE I a KANSAS timtcd,ut \ r f'l - tatrs enatc r TAND ING COM M 1n S AGRICULTU RE NU TRITI ON ANO FORESTRY FINANCE RULES WASHINGTON DC 20510 Febr uary 1, 1985 Mr Larr y Allis on Arch
More informationWORLD SOCIALIST PARTY APPLICATION FOR MEM BER SHIP
WORLD SOCIALIST PARTY APPLICATION FOR MEM BER SHIP The World Socialist Party Party of the of the United United States, States, as a as com a pan com ion pan party ion within party within the World the
More informationAn Ordinance entitled, "AN ORDINANCE to amend the Municipal Code of the City of Des
Roll Call Number Agenda Item Number 3> Date October 8, 218 An Ordinance entitled, "AN ORDINANCE to amend the Municipal Code of the City of Des Moines, Iowa, 2, apted by Ordinance No. 13,827, passed June
More informationAP United States Government and Politics
2018 AP United States Government and Politics Sample Student Responses and Scoring Commentary Inside: Free Response Question 4 RR Scoring Guideline RR Student Samples RR Scoring Commentary College Board,
More informationFiserv Solutions, Inc. v XL Specialty Ins. Co NY Slip Op 33330(U) January 4, 2012 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /09
Fiserv Solutions, Inc. v XL Specialty Ins. Co. 2012 NY Slip Op 33330(U) January 4, 2012 Supreme Court, Ne York County Docket Number: 601096/09 Judge: Melvin L. Scheitzer Cases posted ith a "30000" identifier,
More informationAPPLICATION LOCATIONS JUNE 2015
APPLICATION LOCATIONS JUNE 2015 34 23 19 TTO OW WN N O O FF TT E EC CU UM MS SE E TOW N OF LAKESOR E 8 8 WA LKER RD Y LAND RD LD EN RD _ ^ OL 11 S/S 14th Concession Rd B-20-15 & A-17-15 13T CO NCE SSIO
More informationLIST OF CERTIFIED CANDIDATES. Municipal Elections Act, 1996 s.11.1(4) NOTICE is hereby given to the Municipal Electors of the
LIST OF CERTIFIED CANDIDATES Municipal Elections Act, 1996 s.11.1(4) NOTICE is hereby given to the Municipal Electors of the Regional of York That during the period commencing on May 1, 2018 and completed
More information(67686) Mathematical Foundations of AI June 18, Lecture 6
(67686) Mathematical Foundations of AI June 18, 2008 Lecturer: Ariel D. Procaccia Lecture 6 Scribe: Ezra Resnick & Ariel Imber 1 Introduction: Social choice theory Thus far in the course, we have dealt
More informationGames With Incomplete Information A Nobel Lecture by John Harsanyi
Games With Incomplete Information A by John Harsanyi Sujit Prakash Gujar Course: Topics in Game Theory Course Instructor : Prof Y Narahari November 11, 2008 Sujit Prakash Gujar (CSA, IISc) Games With Incomplete
More information1 Filer ID ( Ethics Commission Filers) 2 Total pages filed: II S Col I ee n R. Date Ree. k- k. re pate Filed ( I 16b. ID(yez, r
CANDIDATE / OFFICEHOLDER FORM C/ OH CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORT COVER SHEET PG 1 The C/ OH Instruction Guide explains how to complete this form. 1 Filer ID ( Ethics Commission Filers) 2 Total pages filed:
More informationMehmet Ismail. Maximin equilibrium RM/14/037
Mehmet Ismail Maximin equilibrium RM/14/037 Maximin equilibrium Mehmet ISMAIL First version March, 2014. This version: October, 2014 Abstract We introduce a new concept which extends von Neumann and Morgenstern
More informationNASSAU COUNTY ALAM, 8,2002. Plaintiffs Memorandum of Law was submitted on November. and Defendant s Memorandum was submitted on November
-MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER Present: SUPREME COURT - STATE OF NEW YORK NASSAU COUNTY HON. MERYL J. BERKOWITZ, Acting Justice BARBARETTA SINDACATO, INC. D/b/a LACUCINA ITALIANA and THOMAS D. MORAN, Plaintiff(s),
More informationMojica v Metro-North Commuter Railroad Co NY Slip Op 32542(U) October 10, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2011 Judge:
Mojica v Metro-North Commuter Railroad Co. 2013 NY Slip Op 32542(U) October 10, 2013 Sup Ct, Ne York County Docket Number: 109805/2011 Judge: Kathryn E. Freed Cases posted ith a "30000" identifier, i.e.,
More informationBaturone v Gracie Square Hosp NY Slip Op 33433(U) September 26, 2012 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: /2012 Judge: Anil C.
Baturone v Gracie Square Hosp. 2012 NY Slip Op 33433(U) September 26, 2012 Sup Ct, Ne York County Docket Number: 100091/2012 Judge: Anil C. Singh Cases posted ith a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip
More informationFrom Article at GetOutOfDebt.org
Case 5:11-cv-00988-C Document 1 Filed 09/06/1 1 Page 1 of 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA (1)HAROLD M I L H ISLER, husband, and ( 2)ELIZABETH MILH I SLER, wife, individually
More informationFU=- Iq,t"".r;;;:;J h ~e anre~ e JCCe tohu -.FJ c«t- ~lj 1-(yf-(u~Jlt4/i,
- -- ~---'-------- ~f(;rj1/ a.dtj/ij~~) fa the.. ll7fp",te-z /tj-;!d~r;d.,,( rl,e... (2.) / fi -1! te. 1,6., I/ f'1//''jt'e'l) f.tcr,..., o~'z.!3'206iel... j w/,rc4 r V/.( y I /Pe a,:,{c!4eff'ej, /.,.:i
More informationand for the erection and maintenance
.i.' RESOLUTION NO. CIII (103) A RESOLUTION APPROVING AGREEMENT FOR INSTALLATION AND raintnance OF TRAFFIC SIGNALS AT INTERSECTION OF WILSONVILLE ROAD AND BOONES FERRY ROAD HHEREAS, the City of Hilsonville,
More informationEEOC v. Zale Corporation
Cornell University ILR School DigitalCommons@ILR Consent Decrees Labor and Employment Law Program --0 Judge John W. Sedwick Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/condec
More informationELECTION AND CAMPAIGN RULES Boston Teachers Union Local 66
ELECTION AND CAMPAIGN RULES Boston Teachers Union Local 66 1. Constitution and Bylaws The nomination and election of Boston Teachers Union (BTU) Local 66, President, Vice- President, Secretary-Treasurer,
More informationThe Social Legitimacy of Targeted Welfare Attitudes towards welfare deservingness
The Social Legitimacy of Targeted Welfare Attitudes towards welfare deservingness Wim van Oorschot Centre for Sociological Research University of Leuven Belgium ESPAnet-Israel Annual Conference 22 Februari
More informationStero v Laasko 2007 NY Slip Op 34513(U) April 12, 2007 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: /06 Judge: Joan B. Carey Cases posted with
Stero v Laasko 2007 NY Slip Op 34513(U) April 12, 2007 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 111583/06 Judge: Joan B. Carey Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip Op 30001(U),
More informationOrigin. What Every Notary Should Know. Richard Alexander Gwinnett County Clerk of Superior Court. L aw re n c e v ille, G A Ju n e 2 0,
Origin W h y A re D o c u m e n ts N o ta riz e d? 2018GeorgiaSuperior Court Clerks CooperativeAuthority 2018GeorgiaSuperior Court Clerks CooperativeAuthority What Every Notary Should Know Richard Alexander
More informationThe freely given consent and the bundling provision under the GDPR
Bojana Kostic and Emmanuel Vargas Penagos 1,2 The freely given consent and the bundling provision under the GDPR Under European data protection law, consent of the data subject is one of the six grounds
More informationReview of Christian List and Philip Pettit s Group agency: the possibility, design, and status of corporate agents
Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics, Volume 4, Issue 2, Autumn 2011, pp. 117-122. http://ejpe.org/pdf/4-2-br-8.pdf Review of Christian List and Philip Pettit s Group agency: the possibility, design,
More informationCAMPAIGN TREASURER' S REPORT SUMMARY. 5) Report Identifiers. Election Report. Monetary. Transfers to. Office Account.
CAMPAIGN TREASURER' S REPORT SUMMARY ) Tom Keller OFFICE USE ONLY Name 2) 707 Algonquin Dr. Address ( number and street) Clearwater, FL 33755 Check here if address has changed 3) ID : 4) Check appropriate
More informationFILED: KINGS COUNTY CLERK 03/27/ :49 PM INDEX NO. 3189/2016 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 69 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 03/27/2018
FILED KINGS COUNTY CLERK 03/27/2018 0449 PM INDEX NO. 3189/2016 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 69 RECEIVED NYSCEF 03/27/2018 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF KINGS ------------------------------------------------------------------------
More informationBASAVARAJA & DILEEP Chartered Accountants. E-moil . The company has also. "the Act "
BASAVARAJA & DILEEP Chartered Accountants 1287/68 "NANDI' 4lh Cross, Ashoknogor (5 Cross, N.R Colony), BSK lst Stoge Bongolore - 560 050 Office :080-26618143 Mobile 98453 30800, 98440 06543 E-moil bodill234@gmoil.conr
More informationS. ll IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
TH CONGRESS ST SESSION S. ll To amend the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act to authorize an extension of exclusivity periods for certain drugs that are approved for a new indication for a rare disease
More informationHOFSTRA JAW REVIEW SYMPOSIUM: THE IMPLICATIONS OF SOCIAL CHOICE THEORY FOR LEGAL DECISIONMAKING INTRODUCTION: THE SOCIAL CHOICE PERSPECTIVE
HOFSTRA JAW REVIEW Volume 9, No. 5 Summer 1981 SYMPOSIUM: THE IMPLICATIONS OF SOCIAL CHOICE THEORY FOR LEGAL DECISIONMAKING INTRODUCTION: THE SOCIAL CHOICE PERSPECTIVE Kenneth J. Arrow* One of the major
More informationReligion, Law and Education: Tensions and Perspectives
Jan de Groof, Georgia du Plessis and Maria Smirnova (Eds.) This book provides an encompassing analysis of the position of religion in education in several countries across the globe. It first analyses the
More informationORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the zoning ordinances of the City of Dallas by permitting the following
122128 ORDNANCE NO. 28746 An ordinance amending the zoning ordinances of the City of Dallas by permitting the following property. which is presently zoned as an R-7.5(A) Single Family District: BENG Lot
More informationOn Migration, Migration Costs, and Wage Differentials: Reply
On Migration, Migration Costs, and Wage Differentials: Reply By Richard J.Cebula, Atlanta, Georgia Kohn [11] recently has offered a critique of an earlier paper by myself published in this journal [1].
More informationConstitutional Design and Political Communication
Constitutional Design and Political Communication Dimitrios Xefteris International Doctorate in Economic Analysis Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona December 13, 2008 Dimitrios Xefteris (XXXIII S.A.E.)
More informationGame-Theoretic Remarks on Gibbard's Libertarian Social Choice Functions
Economic Staff Paper Series Economics 1980 Game-Theoretic Remarks on Gibbard's Libertarian Social Choice Functions Roy Gardner Iowa State University Follow this and additional works at: http://lib.dr.iastate.edu/econ_las_staffpapers
More informationCONFERENCE WORK PAPER. BY: Mrs. Bessie Smith. The first time I heard abo ut "maximum feasible participation " of the poor,
CONFERENCE WORK PAPER BY: Mrs. Bessie Smith 1. FIRST IMPRESSION: The first time I heard abo ut "maximum feasible participation " of the poor, was when I attended the first meetin g of Area Board 3 in Mar
More informationDefinition: Institution public system of rules which defines offices and positions with their rights and duties, powers and immunities p.
RAWLS Project: to interpret the initial situation, formulate principles of choice, and then establish which principles should be adopted. The principles of justice provide an assignment of fundamental
More informationNOTICE OF DECISION CONSENTS
~f'vaughan COMMTTEE OF ADJUSTMENT 2141 Major Mackenzie Drive, Vaughan, ON L6A 1T1 Phone: (905)832-8585 Fax: (905)832-8535 NOTCE OF DECSON CONSENTS FLE NUMBER: B037/16 APPLCANT: PROPERTY: ZONNG: PURPOSE:
More informationCRIME ARTICLE: FIT FOR TRIAL?
CRIME ARTICLE: FIT FOR TRIAL? Parliament and the courts have developed a process of identifying when defendants are unfit to stand trial in the Crown Court to allow accommodations to be made to the court
More informationSTATE OF TEXAS Records Retention Schedule
1Page 300 of 307 APPENDIX EXPLANATION OF FIELDS Records Series Item Number Records series item numbers are assigned by the State and Local Records Management Division of the Texas State Library and Archives
More informationil\ ~~~ C If I CJ ~NEP/1 ~~J.-u ~ vtz :1 ~ ~~kth -~~~ ot ~t.ya. - ~L-V ~~c:ry~ ~\s c.o..se SttW\S r>ecembe& 1975 Conference ~~e~~~~.
PJ/gg 12-l-7r:: ( C If I CJ ~ vtz :1 ~~~ ~NEP/1 ~~J.-u ~ ~~kth - ~L-V ~~c:ry~ -~~~ "-...- PRELIMINARY MEMORANDUM ~ N.B. ~\s c.o..se SttW\S r>ecembe& 1975 Conference a.. uo-j ~~, List 3, Sheet 2 ~1e~lrve
More informationCase 1:16-cr FAM Document 98 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2016 Page 1 of 6 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
Case 1:16-cr-20010-FAM Document 98 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2016 Page 1 of 6 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA VS. FERNANDO M ENDEZ VILLAM IL, a/k/a ufernando M endez,'' Defendant. / UNITED STATES DISTRICT
More informationFOREIGN JUDGMENTS (RECIPROCAL ENFORCEMENT)
CAP. 10. CYPRUS FOREIGN JUDGMENTS (RECIPROCAL ENFORCEMENT) CHAPTER 10 OF THE LAWS 1959 EDITION l l
More informationInstitutional Interplay and Global Environmental Change
and Global Environmental Change State of the Art and Perspectives for Future Research SENSE PhD Summer School 2008, Amsterdam, 25 August 2008 Sebastian Oberthür Vrije Universiteit Brussel Contents 1. Introduction:
More informationADDRF.SS OF RETIRI!l'G GOVERNOR Al.rD FR!:SIDffiT-ueCT titafikll U b.elano R60 C5EVELT
1 ADDRF.SS OF RETIRI!l'G GOVERNOR Al.rD FR!:SIDffiT-ueCT titafikll U b.elano R60 C5EVELT ).. "' J'J On teklnr l ~eve of you my fri ends, my ne i ghbors.!!:dd my!laaociatee, pfter four years in Alb8ny,
More informationORDINANCE NUMBER
ORDINANCE NUMBER 9293-124 AN ORDINANCE TO REPEAL THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF URBANA, ILLINOIS AND TO RE-ADOPT A COMPREHENSIVE AMENDMENT TO THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF URBANA, ILLINOIS (Plan
More informationJOHN CHARLES HARSANYI. by John A. Weymark. Working Paper No. 06-W07. March 2006 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY NASHVILLE, TN 37235
JOHN CHARLES HARSANYI by John A. Weymark Working Paper No. 06-W07 March 2006 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY NASHVILLE, TN 37235 www.vanderbilt.edu/econ John Charles Harsanyi by John A. Weymark
More information