LECTURE NOTES LAW AND ECONOMICS (41-240) M. Charette, Department of Economics University of Windsor

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "LECTURE NOTES LAW AND ECONOMICS (41-240) M. Charette, Department of Economics University of Windsor"

Transcription

1 Crime 1 LECTURE NOTES LAW AND ECONOMICS (41-240) M. Charette, Department of Economics University of Windsor DISCLAIMER: These lecture notes are being made available for the convenience of students enrolled in , Winter They represent a first go at this part of the course in Law and Economics. It is anticipated that these notes will undergo many subsequent revisions. In their current form they are essentially unedited. Any comments, criticisms or suggestions are welcomed. Return to the home page for information on contacting the author. These notes follow the general outline and, to a lesser extent, the content of Law and Economics 3rd ed., Cooter, Robert and Thomas Ulen, Addison Wesley, New York NOTE: In what follows, text depicted in small type represents a reminder to the author and should be ignored by the reader. THE FOLLOWING NOTES HAVE NOT BEEN PROOFED PART F-I The Economic Theory of Crime and Punishment There are two fundamental question which must be answered: 1. What acts should the state punish? 2. To what extent should a given act be punished? Why are theses issues not simply handled as part of tort law? Historically they largely were handled as part of the common law of crimes

2 Crime 2 I. The Traditional Theory of Criminal Law The common law of crime has been replaced by criminal statutes. It has been codified. This codified criminal law embodies the traditional theory of criminal law which includes the following: 1. Intended wrongs (crimes) versus accidental wrongs (torts - some not all) 2. Public nature of harm in addition to the private nature of a tort. 3. The plaintiff is the estate not a private individual 4. The standard of proof is higher in a criminal as opposed to civil action. 5. A guilty defendant is punished, as opposed to simply making restitution. Broadly, the traditional theory is based on the simple notion that if someone does something wrong and they are found guilty, they should be punished and they should be punished in proportion to the seriousness of their crime. The traditional theory focuses on the individual and the act. NOTE: Economic theory focuses on societal welfare (takes the perspective of society as a whole - utilitarian ). An act should be made a criminal act if doing so enhances social welfare. An act should be punished to the extent that it maximizes social welfare. A. Criminal Intent Accidental harm vs. intentional harm mens rea - a guilty mind see Figure 11.1 B. Public Harm and Public Prosecution

3 Crime 3 Property, contract and tort law generally (but not always) deal with private - harm imposed by one individual on another. In criminal law more of the harm is of a public nature. A murderer kills his/her victim but also cause a general increase in fear and loss of a sense of security for all members of society. 1. This public nature of criminal acts is why in criminal law the plaintiff is the the crown in Canada, as opposed to the specific person harmed in the criminal act (victim). In civil law the victim is always the plaintiff. 2. The notion that criminal acts harm the general public allows for the possibility of victimless crimes (drugs, gambling, prostitution). Even though the parties to these transaction enjoy mutual gains (and economic theory would as a result find no basis for them being classified as crimes). The traditional theory argues that there are victims - society as a whole - whose peace and security is threatened. 3. What if someone attempts to harm another but fails. There are no loses, no actual injury, no basis for a tort. But traditional theory argues that the attempt to harm causes a fear and loss of security so that the attempt should be punished, even if it failed. C. Standard of Proof Standards of proof Civil case - preponderance of the evidence (plaintiff is more convincing than the defendant - just tip the scales of justice) - 51% Criminal case - beyond a reasonable doubt (clear and convincing evidence) - 90%/95%/99%? Why? (from traditional theory) 1. convicting an innocent person seems worse than letting a guilty person go free (Type II and Type I error). 2. The prosecution in a criminal matter can bring the full force of the state (prosecutor/police/etc.) and all its resources down on the defendant. The heavier burden of proof helps to offset this advantage.

4 Crime 4 D. Punishment Punishment: 1. Incarceration (jail) 2. Restriction of movements (bail terms, house arrest, etc.) 3. Fines 4. Corporal punishment - beatings, mutilation, death Recall compensation in civil law aims to restore the victim to his/her previous level of wellbeing. Punishment in criminal law is intended to harm the injurer but without making the victim better off. (There is some very slow movement in this area.) Punishment and compensation might be substitutes or both be imposed. Perfect compensation: a sum of money that makes the injured indifferent to having suffered the injury or not having suffered the injury. Perfect disgorgement: a sum of money that makes the injurer indifferent to having caused the injury or not having caused the injury. In criminal law, monetary punishment (fines) are intended to be a sum of money that makes the potential injurer prefer not causing an injury- intended to remove whatever incentive the potential injurer has to commit the crime. II. An Economic Theory of Crime and Punishment Problems with the traditional theory

5 Crime 5 - does not provided a model of predictive behaviour. - does not provided a clear objective for criminal law (stop people from doing bad things??) In what follows: - distinguish between civil vs. criminal prosecutions - predictive model of criminal behaviour - propose a clear objective for criminal law (Surprise Surprise - minimize the social costs of crime). A. Inadequacy of Tort Law and the Necessity of Criminal Law If civil suits could cause the potential injurers to internalize the total social cost of their actions, then criminal law would be unnecessary. Why cannot civil suits do this? 1. inherent limitations of compensation - losing a leg, being killed, being abused? We can make civil awards that provide potential injurers with the incentives not to take unreasonable but we cannot really define a sum of money that provides perfect compensation. Criminal punishment is intended to deter intentional harms not compensate for them. How much would you pay to lose an eye or a child? This makes no sense. The victim cannot really considered these questions in terms of indifference. Even if the victim could conceive of a level of perfect compensation, we could never really know what that compensation was. There are no markets for legs, eyes, children, emotional stability, etc. The problem of preference revelation. A thief steals your perfectly efficient artificial leg/ an assaulter causes you to loses your real leg. What s the difference with respect to compensation. 2. What about the wide range of crimes for which perfect compensation is possible, can we dispense with criminal law? NO. Rights versus interests

6 Crime 6 Law of trespass protects interest in property but does not grant an absolute right to property. A person can trespass in an emergency but must pay compensation. At times we will want to protect rights not interests 3. Perfect compensation might not be able to deter so that punishment becomes necessary. Thief steals a $30,000 car gets caught five minutes later and must return the car and pay $100 for the victim s time and out-of-pocket expenses - perfect compensation Not good enough, the victim is returned to her former level of well-being but the thief is not deterred from committing further thefts. Why not? What if there was a 20% chance that the thief would have escaped? Expected value to the thief of stealing the car: 0.2($30,000) + 0.8($0 - $100) = $6,000 - $80 = $5,920 Internalization for torts versus deterrence for crimes If - perfect compensation not possible (in principle or practice) - desire to protect rights not interests - enforcement errors will occur then punishment is necessary. Psychological commitment and punishment: deterrence. The stronger the psychological commitment to the act the greater the required deliberate act versus accident deliberate act versus spontaneous act (pre-meditation) repeated crime vs. first offence This is not the case for simple internalization of the costs of an act, the injurers state of mind does not really matter they will pay whatever is required to compensate the victim.

7 Crime 7 B. Rational Crime Rational Amoral Person someone who carefully considers the means to achieve an illegal goal without restraint by quilt of morality. Do you ever act as a rational immoral person?? IN THIS SECTION YOU SHOULD BE THINKING ABOUT SOME PARTICULAR CRIME OR CRIMINAL ACT (a particular theft, embezzlement, price fixing scheme, fraud, etc.) AND SOME PARTICULAR INDIVIDUAL CONTEMPLATING THE CRIMINAL ACT. See Figures 11.2 to 11.4 The following should be noted: - Perfect Disgorgement is a term we saw in Contract law. It implies returning the exact amount that was mis-appropriated. (You steal $100, get caught and your punishment is to pay back the $100.) - Will perfect disgorgement act to deter a rational criminal? Only if it is 100% certain that he/she will be caught and convicted. So the answer is no. - If there is less than a 100% chance of being convicted, then the punishment if caught (must be greater than the value of the crime. All of this can be set out more formally as follows: Let x be the seriousness of the criminal act (say amount embezzled) y(x) p(x) f(x) be the expected net benefit to the criminal of committing the criminal act (the take or benefit to the criminal less any out-of-pocket expenses such as burglar tools, get-away car, fees for accountants, publicists payoffs to officials, up-front money, the discount on the value of goods charged by the fence, the cost of laundering the profits, etc.) be the probability of being caught be the punishment (fine, prison sentence, etc.) if caught Then, the expected profit from the criminal act (net take less the expected cost of punishment) is given by, y(x) - p(x)f(x)

8 Crime 8 where, y > 0 increases as the seriousness of the crime increases p > 0 the more serious the crime the more resources (police, auditors, prosecutors, courts, prisons, parole officers, etc.) society will devote to catching, convicting and punishing the criminal y > 0 the more serious the crime the harsher the punishment From the criminal s perspective he/she should equate the marginal benefits of the crime to the marginal costs of being caught and punished. This is done if the following condition holds, y (x) = p (x)f(x) + p(x)f (x) where y (x) p (x)f(x) p(x)f (x) is the increase in the benefit of the crime as x increases is the increase in the prob. of being caught and convicted as x increases (multiplied by the punishment if caught) is the punishment if caught multiplied by the increase in the increase in severity of punishment as x increases Note in Figure 11.3 in your text the above condition yields a negative return [y(x) < p(x)f(x)], so the crime is not committed. In Figure 11.4 the condition holds at a point for which the expected return [y(x) > p(x)f(x)], so the crime is committed. From Society s perspective, how to deter crime (lower crime rates)? 1. Decrease y(x), the net returns to a given criminal act. Make crime more costly for the criminal to undertake (higher fences, more complicated alarm systems, more secure safes, more complicate financial reporting systems). In general make the criminal work harder for his/her reward. 2. Increase p(x) by increasing the number and efficiency (equipment, training, etc.) of police, auditors and prosecutors. Give police, auditors, prosecutors more political/legal power to investigate and prosecute suspected criminals. (devote more resources and give up some personal freedoms of all citizens). 3. Increase f(x), the punishment if caught (higher fines, longer sentences, etc.) In general this requires more resources (prisons, etc.) since fines are not enough in any cases (poor criminals, really

9 Crime 9 big crimes). Consider the following and how the above model explains/predicts the impact on criminal activity: 1. Can a thief give good title? In Canada if you buy a stolen good, without knowing it is stolen, and it is found to be stolen you must give it back. In Europe, if you buy a stolen good, without knowing that it is stolen, and it is found to be stolen, you need not give it back. What effect do these alternative rules have on the expected value of theft? 2. In response to recent terrorists attacks, North American government have attempted to decrease y(x) and increase p(x). That is they have tried to decrease the returns from terrorism and increase the probability of terrorists being caught and convicted. In what ways have you personally paid some of the costs of the attempt to decease terrorism? 3. Does poverty cause crime; yes and no. Poverty does not generally cause tax fraud, price fixing or major financial frauds. Poverty (a downturn in the level of economic activity or a skewed distribution of wealth - very poor people living among very rich people) might lead to more theft, muggings, embezzlements, etc. If you think more carefully about y(x), the net benefit that a given criminal gets from a given crime, then it is clear that in general, the opportunity cost of criminal activity falls as other more legitimate economic options deteriorate (the economy goes into a downturn, you lose your job, the relative returns from crime increase). What disparities in income - a group of rich people living next to a group of poor people? Why would relatively wealthy groups be suspicious of (paranoid about) travelling poor people - Gypsies (What is the PC term ROMS?)? You must be very careful about how you pose and answer this question. Does poverty, or unemployment cause people to be bad, become less moral? This is not what the above model implies, rather, it implies that as economic conditions deteriorate, we might expect that some relative prices (wages) began to change and crime becomes a relatively more profitable activity. Can wealth cause crime? Are some crimes positively related to income? 4. More police should lead to less crime but so do more efficient courts (quicker and more certain conviction) and longer prison sentences. What does the above model imply about the allocation of a fixed criminal/justice budget across police, courts and prison? 5. Why is it that local police forces apparently waste their time on public education programs encouraging crime prevention for braking and entering, theft from autos, muggings, etc. but when one of these crimes actually occurs they wont really do much? Continue on with examples

10 Crime 10 First Law of Deterrence - increase pf What about irrational individuals? - consider Mental Institutions, rats (from textbook), children Ignorant individuals? In general the above model makes provides a very good formal framework within which a discussion of crime can take place. It provides qualitative (if not somewhat obvious) predictions concerning the incentives and dis-incentives associated with criminal acts. BUT what is really important are the quantitative answers [More police should lead to less crime but so do more efficient courts (quicker and more certain conviction) and longer prison sentences. Should resources be transferred from courts and prisons to police?] Criminals generally have incomplete information concerning y(x), p(x) and f(x). But so does everyone else when they make an economic decision. Criminals are likely not risk neutral. Non-monetary rewards and punishments can easily be allowed for. Recall y(x) should be thought of as the net reward of the crime (excluding punishment). All sorts of costs and rewards can be included - productivity (basic skills, experience, networking...) - disutility (shame, guilt, family reputation...) - opportunity costs (employment, reputation, future employment, career...) parole repeat offenders and level of punishment??

ANY THEORY OF crime must answer two questions: What acts should be

ANY THEORY OF crime must answer two questions: What acts should be Chapter 11 AN ECONOMIC THEORY OF CRIME AND PUNISHMENT The true measure of crimes is the harm done to society. Cesare Beccaria, ON CRIMES AND PUNISHMENT 64 (1764) ANY THEORY OF crime must answer two questions:

More information

Urban Crime. Economics 312 Martin Farnham

Urban Crime. Economics 312 Martin Farnham Urban Crime Economics 312 Martin Farnham Introduction Why do we care about urban crime? Crime tends to be concentrated in center city Characteristic of impoverished areas; likely both a cause and consequence

More information

WHEN IS THE PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE STANDARD OPTIMAL?

WHEN IS THE PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE STANDARD OPTIMAL? Copenhagen Business School Solbjerg Plads 3 DK -2000 Frederiksberg LEFIC WORKING PAPER 2002-07 WHEN IS THE PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE STANDARD OPTIMAL? Henrik Lando www.cbs.dk/lefic When is the Preponderance

More information

The Cost-Benefit Analysis of Crime*

The Cost-Benefit Analysis of Crime* The Cost-Benefit Analysis of Crime* The Scope of Criminal Penalties There are over 4,450 criminal offenses in the United States Code. About 300,000 federal regulations that are enforced with criminal penalties.

More information

CRIMINAL OFFENCES. Chapter 9

CRIMINAL OFFENCES. Chapter 9 CRIMINAL OFFENCES Chapter 9 LEVELS OF OFFENCES In the Canadian legal system we have three levels of criminal offences. Summary Conviction Offences Indictable Offences Hybrid Offences LEVELS OF OFFENCES:

More information

Econ 522 Review 3: Tort Law, Criminal Law, and the Legal Process

Econ 522 Review 3: Tort Law, Criminal Law, and the Legal Process Econ 522 Review 3: Tort Law, Criminal Law, and the Legal Process Spring 2014 This document is by no means comprehensive, but instead serves as a rough guide to the material we have discussed on tort law,

More information

Civil Law is known as Private Law. Regulates disputes between individuals; between parties; and between individuals and parties.

Civil Law is known as Private Law. Regulates disputes between individuals; between parties; and between individuals and parties. Civil Disputes Civil Law is known as Private Law. Regulates disputes between individuals; between parties; and between individuals and parties. The main purpose of Civil Law is to compensate victims. Civil

More information

THE CRIMINAL EQUATION

THE CRIMINAL EQUATION THE CRIMINAL EQUATION Actus Reus + Mens Rea = CRIME Actus Reus Latin for guilty act This simply means the physical act of committing a crime 1 Mens Rea Latin for guilty In the Criminal Code you will find

More information

ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE GENERAL ASPECTS OF CRIMINAL LAW. Name: Period: Row:

ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE GENERAL ASPECTS OF CRIMINAL LAW. Name: Period: Row: ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE GENERAL ASPECTS OF CRIMINAL LAW Name: Period: Row: I. INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL LAW A. Understanding the complexities of criminal law 1. The justice system in the United States

More information

The HIDDEN COST Of Proving Your Innocence

The HIDDEN COST Of Proving Your Innocence The HIDDEN COST Of Proving Your Innocence Law-abiding citizens use guns to defend themselves against criminals as many as 2.5 million times every year, or about 6,850 times per day. This means that each

More information

Sentencing and the Correctional System. Chapter 11

Sentencing and the Correctional System. Chapter 11 Sentencing and the Correctional System Chapter 11 1 Once a person has been found guilty of committing a crime, the judge imposes a sentence, or punishment. Generally, the goals of sentencing are to punish

More information

CSE 3482 Introduction to Computer Security. Law & Ethics

CSE 3482 Introduction to Computer Security. Law & Ethics CSE 3482 Introduction to Computer Security Law & Ethics Instructor: N. Vlajic, Winter 2017 Learning Objectives Upon completion of this material, you should be able to: Differentiate between law and ethics.

More information

Victim / Witness Handbook. Table of Contents

Victim / Witness Handbook. Table of Contents Victim / Witness Handbook Table of Contents A few words about the Criminal Justice System Arrest Warrants Subpoenas Misdemeanors & Felonies General Sessions Court Arraignment at General Sessions Court

More information

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW PROBATION IN NEBRASKA WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW If you are convicted of a criminal offense in the State of Nebraska you may be sentenced to serve a period of time on probation in addition to, or in lieu of,

More information

Conditional Sentences in Manitoba: A Prisoner in Your Own Home

Conditional Sentences in Manitoba: A Prisoner in Your Own Home Conditional Sentences in Manitoba: A Prisoner in Your Own Home JEFFREY J. GINDIN * I. INTRODUCTION P rior to September of 1996, when a judge sentenced an accused to a jail sentence, he or she was immediately

More information

Chapter 4. Criminal Law and Procedure

Chapter 4. Criminal Law and Procedure Chapter 4 Criminal Law and Procedure Section 1 Criminal Law GOALS Understand the 3 elements that make up a criminal act Classify crimes according to the severity of their potential sentences Identify the

More information

Introduction to Criminal Law

Introduction to Criminal Law Introduction to Criminal Law CHAPTER CONTENTS Introduction 2 Crimes versus Civil Wrongs 2 Types of Criminal Offences 3 General Principles of Criminal Law 4 Accessories and Parties to Crimes 5 Attempted

More information

Catching up with crime and sentencing. Catching up with crime and sentencing

Catching up with crime and sentencing. Catching up with crime and sentencing Booklet Catching up with crime and sentencing Catching up with crime and sentencing Improving public attitudes to the Criminal Justice System: The impact of information What do do we we know about crime?

More information

Unit One Introduction to law

Unit One Introduction to law Unit One Introduction to law GCSE Law Year 10 Mrs Fyfe 2011-2012 1 adapted from GCSE Law by J Martin What is law? It is difficult to give a short simple answer to this question. There is no generally agreed

More information

English as a Second Language Podcast ESL Podcast Legal Problems

English as a Second Language Podcast   ESL Podcast Legal Problems GLOSSARY to be arrested to be taken to jail, usually by the police, for breaking the law * The police arrested two women for robbing a bank. to be charged to be blamed or held responsible for committing

More information

The Criminal Court System. Law 521 Chapter Seven

The Criminal Court System. Law 521 Chapter Seven The Criminal Court System Law 521 Chapter Seven The Feds make criminal law and procedure. Criminal Court Structure Provinces responsible for organizing, administering, and maintaining the criminal court

More information

Business Law Chapter 9 Handout

Business Law Chapter 9 Handout Major Differences: 2 Felonies Serious crimes, punishable by Death or prison for more than one (1) year. Misdemeanors Non-serious (petty) crimes punishable by jail for less than one(1) year and/or by fines.

More information

2/21/2011 AMERICAN CORRECTIONS 9 TH EDITION. Three elements:

2/21/2011 AMERICAN CORRECTIONS 9 TH EDITION. Three elements: AMERICAN CORRECTIONS 9 TH EDITION Chapter Four The Punishment of Offenders Learning Objectives 1. Understand the goals of punishment. 2. Be familiar with the different forms of the criminal sanction. 3.

More information

Texas Law & Due Process (Chapter 10) Dr. Michael Sullivan. Texas State Government GOVT

Texas Law & Due Process (Chapter 10) Dr. Michael Sullivan. Texas State Government GOVT Texas Law & Due Process (Chapter 10) Dr. Michael Sullivan Texas State Government GOVT 2306 192 AGENDA 1. Current Events 2. Due Process of Law 2018 Elections: General Land Office https://www.facebook.com/pg/miguelsuazo

More information

Charlotte-Mecklenburg 2015 Criminal Justice System Public Perceptions Study Quantitative Report

Charlotte-Mecklenburg 2015 Criminal Justice System Public Perceptions Study Quantitative Report 15105-D John J Delaney Drive Suite 325 Charlotte, NC 28277 www.voccii.com Charlotte-Mecklenburg Criminal Justice System Public Perceptions Study Quantitative Report Prepared by Voccii, LLC REVISED December

More information

Law 12 Substantive Assignments Reading Booklet

Law 12 Substantive Assignments Reading Booklet Law 12 Substantive Assignments Reading Booklet Reading # 1: Police and the Law Training and Qualifications Police officers have to go through both physical and academic training to become members of the

More information

Criminal Law Fact Sheet

Criminal Law Fact Sheet What is criminal law? Murder, fraud, drugs, sex, robbery, drink driving stories of people committing crimes fills the news headlines every single day. It is an area of law which captures the imagination

More information

EXPLAINING THE COURTS AN INFORMATION BOOKLET

EXPLAINING THE COURTS AN INFORMATION BOOKLET EXPLAINING THE COURTS AN INFORMATION BOOKLET AT SOME STAGE IN OUR LIVES, EVERY ONE OF US IS LIKELY TO HAVE TO GO TO COURT FOR ONE REASON OR ANOTHER. WE MIGHT BE ASKED TO SIT ON A JURY OR TO GIVE EVIDENCE

More information

The court process CONSUMER GUIDE. How the criminal justice system works. FROM ATTORNEY GENERAL JEREMIAH W. (JAY) NIXON

The court process CONSUMER GUIDE. How the criminal justice system works. FROM ATTORNEY GENERAL JEREMIAH W. (JAY) NIXON The court process How the criminal justice system works. CONSUMER GUIDE FROM ATTORNEY GENERAL JEREMIAH W. (JAY) NIXON Inside The process Arrest and complaint Preliminary hearing Grand jury Arraignment

More information

Chapter 10 The Criminal Law and Business. Below is a table that highlights the differences between civil law and criminal law:

Chapter 10 The Criminal Law and Business. Below is a table that highlights the differences between civil law and criminal law: Chapter 10 The Criminal Law and Business Below is a table that highlights the differences between civil law and criminal law: Crime a wrong against society proclaimed in a statute and, if committed, punishable

More information

4. What is private law? 3. What are laws? 1. Review all terms in chapters: 1, 2, 4, 5,6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, What is the purpose of Law?

4. What is private law? 3. What are laws? 1. Review all terms in chapters: 1, 2, 4, 5,6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, What is the purpose of Law? 1. Review all terms in chapters: 1, 2, 4, 5,6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14 2. What is the purpose of Law? Laws reflect the values and beliefs of a society. A rule enforced by government 3. What are laws? 1)Set

More information

This document sets out the most seriously flawed statements, and corrects each of them for the record.

This document sets out the most seriously flawed statements, and corrects each of them for the record. To: Anchorage Assembly Members From: Greg Razo, Chair, Alaska Criminal Justice Commission Date: October 9, 2017 Re: Response to criticisms/factual errors regarding S.B. 91 I hope you will take a moment

More information

Notes as to NAAUSA response to GAO questions regarding restitution.

Notes as to NAAUSA response to GAO questions regarding restitution. Notes as to NAAUSA response to GAO questions regarding restitution. 101419: GAO Study of the U.S. Courts Authority to Award Restitution Questions for: National Association of Assistant U.S. Attorneys (NAAUSA)

More information

Unions Tasmania Tasmanian Branch of the ACTU

Unions Tasmania Tasmanian Branch of the ACTU Unions Tasmania Tasmanian Branch of the ACTU Industrial Manslaughter Response to Issues Paper No.9 Criminal Liability of Organisations Unions Tasmania As a matter of policy Unions Tasmania says Where a

More information

Justice Green s decision is a sophisticated engagement with some of the issues raised last class about the moral justification of punishment.

Justice Green s decision is a sophisticated engagement with some of the issues raised last class about the moral justification of punishment. PHL271 Handout 9: Sentencing and Restorative Justice We re going to deepen our understanding of the problems surrounding legal punishment by closely examining a recent sentencing decision handed down in

More information

Chapter 13 Topics in the Economics of Crime and Punishment

Chapter 13 Topics in the Economics of Crime and Punishment Chapter 13 Topics in the Economics of Crime and Punishment I. Crime in the United States 1/143 people in prison in 2005 (1/100 adults in 2008) 93 percent of all prisoners are male 60 percent of those in

More information

FINAL EXAMINATION DIRECTIONS: Write your answers on the ANSWER SHEET provided.

FINAL EXAMINATION DIRECTIONS: Write your answers on the ANSWER SHEET provided. FINAL EXAMINATION DIRECTIONS: Write your answers on the ANSWER SHEET provided. DO NOT MARK ON THIS TEST 1. The security guard/proprietary private security officer s role BEFORE a violation has been committed

More information

HID Headlights Victim Precaution No Vest 8% 3% Vest 5% 1%

HID Headlights Victim Precaution No Vest 8% 3% Vest 5% 1% Econ 522 Economics of Law, Spring 2017 Dan Quint Homework 4 Torts, the Legal Process, and Criminal Law Due at midnight on Thursday, April 27 via Learn@UW QUESTION 1 BILATERAL PRECAUTION Consider the following

More information

MULTI CHOICE QUESTIONS EVI301-A

MULTI CHOICE QUESTIONS EVI301-A MULTI CHOICE QUESTIONS EVI301-A 2010 Second Semester Assignment 1 Question 1 If the current South African law does not provide a solution to an evidentiary problem, our courts will first of all search

More information

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA PRETRIAL SERVICES AGENCY

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA PRETRIAL SERVICES AGENCY DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA PRETRIAL SERVICES AGENCY Processing Arrestees in the District of Columbia A Brief Overview This handout is intended to provide a brief overview of how an adult who has been arrested

More information

Identifying Chronic Offenders

Identifying Chronic Offenders 1 Identifying Chronic Offenders SUMMARY About 5 percent of offenders were responsible for 19 percent of the criminal convictions in Minnesota over the last four years, including 37 percent of the convictions

More information

Chapter 4-1 Criminal Law

Chapter 4-1 Criminal Law Chapter 4-1 Criminal Law Crime A punishable offense against society Before anyone can be convicted of a crime, three elements usually must be proved at trial. 3 Elements of a crime: 1. A duty to do or

More information

Example 8.2 The Economics of Terrorism: Externalities and Strategic Interaction

Example 8.2 The Economics of Terrorism: Externalities and Strategic Interaction Example 8.2 The Economics of Terrorism: Externalities and Strategic Interaction ECONOMIC APPROACHES TO TERRORISM: AN OVERVIEW Terrorism would appear to be a subject for military experts and political scientists,

More information

Key Facts and Figures from the Criminal Justice System 2009/2010. March 2011

Key Facts and Figures from the Criminal Justice System 2009/2010. March 2011 Key Facts and Figures from the Criminal Justice System 2009/2010 March 2011 Produced by: Matrix Evidence Ltd This booklet has been produced by Matrix Evidence Ltd. These statistics have been complied according

More information

Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 No 92

Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 No 92 New South Wales Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 No 92 Summary of contents Part 1 Preliminary Part 2 Penalties that may be imposed Division 1 General Division 2 Alternatives to full-time detention

More information

Judicial Branch. Why this is important What do I do if I m arrested? What are my rights? What happens in court?

Judicial Branch. Why this is important What do I do if I m arrested? What are my rights? What happens in court? Judicial Branch Why this is important What do I do if I m arrested? What are my rights? What happens in court? What could happen if I am found guilty? What do I do if I think my rights are being violated?

More information

Making Justice Work. Factsheet: Mandatory Sentencing

Making Justice Work. Factsheet: Mandatory Sentencing Making Justice Work Factsheet: Mandatory Sentencing What is mandatory sentencing? Normally the court has discretion to decide what sentence it will impose on a person convicted of a criminal offence. This

More information

WAYS A CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY 8CAN HELP YOUR CASE

WAYS A CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY 8CAN HELP YOUR CASE WAYS A CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY 8CAN HELP YOUR CASE You or a loved one was arrested for a crime in Texas. What happens next? The first step is hiring a qualified, experienced defense attorney. It s often

More information

20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates

20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates 20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates CANDIDATE: KATHY JENNINGS (D) The Coalition for Smart Justice is committed to cutting the number of prisoners in Delaware in half and eliminating racial

More information

1. The location or site where a criminal offence has taken place is called a(n)?

1. The location or site where a criminal offence has taken place is called a(n)? Canadian Law 2204 Criminal Law and he Criminal Trial Process Unit 2 Test Multiple Choice Name: { / 85} 1. The location or site where a criminal offence has taken place is called a(n)? death trap investigative

More information

Victim Protection in Criminal Proceedings Legislation: A pan-european Comparison"

Victim Protection in Criminal Proceedings Legislation: A pan-european Comparison Victim Protection in Criminal Proceedings Legislation: A pan-european Comparison" Country Report: Sweden Author: Martin Sunnqvist 1 The questions in the Guidelines are answered briefly as follows below,

More information

FAIRNESS VERSUS WELFARE. Louis Kaplow & Steven Shavell. Thesis: Policy Analysis Should Be Based Exclusively on Welfare Economics

FAIRNESS VERSUS WELFARE. Louis Kaplow & Steven Shavell. Thesis: Policy Analysis Should Be Based Exclusively on Welfare Economics FAIRNESS VERSUS WELFARE Louis Kaplow & Steven Shavell Thesis: Policy Analysis Should Be Based Exclusively on Welfare Economics Plan of Book! Define/contrast welfare economics & fairness! Support thesis

More information

Otto von Guericke - University Magdeburg

Otto von Guericke - University Magdeburg Otto von Guericke - University Magdeburg Faculty of Economics and Management Seminar: PD Dr. Roland Kirstein Winter Term 2006/2007 Topic: Can punishment ever be efficient? Name: Anne Kartes Matriculation

More information

The Economics of Crime and Crime Prevention. An act is considered to be a crime either

The Economics of Crime and Crime Prevention. An act is considered to be a crime either The following notes provided by Laura Lamb are intended to complement class lectures. The notes are based on Economic Issues: A Canadian Perspective by C.M. Fellows, G. Flanagan, and S. Shedd (1997) and

More information

Self-defence: What's acceptable under Canadian law?

Self-defence: What's acceptable under Canadian law? Self-defence: What's acceptable under Canadian law? Lawyers explain how to protect yourself under the Canadian Criminal code Andrew Pinsent, CBC News May 12, 2012 The Supreme Court of Canada is seen in

More information

Aggravating factors APPENDIX 2. Summary

Aggravating factors APPENDIX 2. Summary APPENDIX 2 Aggravating factors Summary This guideline deals with those factors that may not be specifically identified in the applicable offencebased guideline, but may still be relevant to sentence depending

More information

Chapter 6 Sentencing and Corrections

Chapter 6 Sentencing and Corrections Chapter 6 Sentencing and Corrections Chapter Objectives Describe the different philosophies of punishment (goals of sentencing). Understand the sentencing process from plea bargaining to conviction. Describe

More information

Criminal Law. Protect people and property Maintain order Preserve standards of public decency

Criminal Law. Protect people and property Maintain order Preserve standards of public decency A Crime is any action or omission of an act that is prohibited and punishable by law. There are four conditions in which an action or omission becomes a crime: The act is considered a wrong for society.

More information

Bail Amendment Bill 2012

Bail Amendment Bill 2012 Bail Amendment Bill 2012 4 May 2012 Attorney-General Bail Amendment Bill 2012 PCO15616 (v6.2) Our Ref: ATT395/171 1. I have reviewed this Bill for consistency with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.

More information

LAWS 1001 C. Come to the PASS workshop with your mock exam complete. During the workshop you can work with other students to review your work.

LAWS 1001 C. Come to the PASS workshop with your mock exam complete. During the workshop you can work with other students to review your work. It is most beneficial to you to write this mock midterm UNDER EXAM CONDITIONS. This means: Complete the midterm in 2 hour(s). Work on your own. Keep your notes and textbook closed. Attempt every question.

More information

Criminal Law and Procedure

Criminal Law and Procedure Criminal Law and Procedure Crime: punishable offense against society The legal process for a crime is to protect society as a whole, not just the individual victim(s) Crimes must be carefully defined by

More information

I ve Been Charged With an Offence: What Now?

I ve Been Charged With an Offence: What Now? I ve Been Charged With an Offence: What Now? Getting a Lawyer If the police have charged you with a criminal, drug or Youth Criminal Justice offence and you have been given a court date down the road:

More information

Appendix 3J Training Memo How a Prosecutor Reads a Domestic Violence Related Police Report

Appendix 3J Training Memo How a Prosecutor Reads a Domestic Violence Related Police Report Appendix 3J Training Memo How a Prosecutor Reads a Domestic Violence Related Police Report Adapted from Domestic Violence: The Law Enforcement Response, a training curriculum from The Domestic Abuse Intervention

More information

20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates

20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates 20 Questions for Delaware Attorney General Candidates CANDIDATE: CHRIS JOHNSON (D) The Coalition for Smart Justice is committed to cutting the number of prisoners in Delaware in half and eliminating racial

More information

The Economics of Crime and Criminal Justice

The Economics of Crime and Criminal Justice The Economics of Crime and Criminal Justice Trends, Causes, and Implications for Reform Aaron Hedlund University of Missouri National Trends in Crime and Incarceration Prison admissions up nearly 400%

More information

The Criminal Justice System: From Charges to Sentencing

The Criminal Justice System: From Charges to Sentencing The Criminal Justice System: From Charges to Sentencing The Key Principles The aim the system is to protect and to regulate society, to punish offenders and to offer rehabilitation; The Government, through

More information

Chapter 4. Justice and the Law. Justice vs. Law. David Hume. Justice does not dictate a perfect world, but one in which people live up

Chapter 4. Justice and the Law. Justice vs. Law. David Hume. Justice does not dictate a perfect world, but one in which people live up Chapter 4 Justice and the Law Justice vs. Law Law & Justice are very different. Law is often defined as the administration of justice. Law may result in judgments that many feel are unjust Justice: Is

More information

CALIFORNIA THEFT CRIMES UNDERSTANDING THE OFFENSES AND PENALTIES

CALIFORNIA THEFT CRIMES UNDERSTANDING THE OFFENSES AND PENALTIES CALIFORNIA THEFT CRIMES UNDERSTANDING THE OFFENSES AND PENALTIES Understanding the Various Theft Offenses And the Corresponding Penalties Is Important If You Have Been Charged with One DOMENIC J. LOMBARDO

More information

Criminal Law and Construction Accidents Bill C - 45 Amendments to the Criminal Code Finally Applied

Criminal Law and Construction Accidents Bill C - 45 Amendments to the Criminal Code Finally Applied Criminal Law and Construction Accidents Bill C - 45 Amendments to the Criminal Code Finally Applied Prepared for the Canadian Bar Association 2012 National Construction Law Conference J David Eaton Q.C.

More information

Introduction to Sentencing and Corrections

Introduction to Sentencing and Corrections Introduction to Sentencing and Corrections Traditional Objectives of Sentencing retribution, segregation, rehabilitation, and deterrence. Political Perspectives on Sentencing Left Left Wing Wing focus

More information

SENTENCING AND PROPORTIONALITY. LTC Harms Japan 2017

SENTENCING AND PROPORTIONALITY. LTC Harms Japan 2017 SENTENCING AND PROPORTIONALITY LTC Harms Japan 2017 TRIPS obligation Member countries have to provide for remedies for counterfeiting and piracy, which must include imprisonment and/or monetary fines,

More information

Evaluate the Effectiveness of Lay People in the Courts

Evaluate the Effectiveness of Lay People in the Courts Evaluate the Effectiveness of Lay People in the Courts Throughout this section of my assignment I will evaluate the effectiveness of Lay people within the courts. Throughout the United Kingdom Lay Magistrates

More information

Police Process. Definition of Police Corruption. Definition of Police Corruption. Cost of Police Corruption (cont.) Cost of Police Corruption

Police Process. Definition of Police Corruption. Definition of Police Corruption. Cost of Police Corruption (cont.) Cost of Police Corruption Police Process Outline for the lecture Dae-Hoon Kwak Michigan State University CJ 335 Summer 2006 Lecture 15 Police Corruption Define police corruption Identify various types of police corruption Explain

More information

Chapter 4 Types of Evidence

Chapter 4 Types of Evidence Chapter 4 Types of Evidence Circumstantial evidence is a very tricky thing. It may seem to point very straight to one thing, but if you shift your own point of view a little, you may find it pointing in

More information

Law & Economics Lecture 1: Basic Notions & Concepts

Law & Economics Lecture 1: Basic Notions & Concepts I. What is law and economics? Law & Economics Lecture 1: Basic Notions & Concepts Law and economics, a.k.a. economic analysis of law, is a branch of economics that uses the tools of economic theory to

More information

The emotional reaction to 490 Tamil

The emotional reaction to 490 Tamil COMMENTARY THE SUN SEA TAMIL MASS REFUGEE CLAIM: AN OPPORTUNITY FOR NEEDED REFORMS By Scott Newark Executive Summary The emotional reaction to 490 Tamil refugee seekers arriving on the MV Sun Sea should

More information

Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević G10, room 6/I, Tue 14:15-15:15. Session 3, 16 Oct 2018

Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević G10, room 6/I, Tue 14:15-15:15.   Session 3, 16 Oct 2018 Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević G10, room 6/I, Tue 14:15-15:15 e-mail: miljen.matijasevic@gmail.com Session 3, 16 Oct 2018 Criminal Law, part 1 1. What does criminal law involve? 2. What is actus reus and

More information

CRIMINAL LITIGATION PRE-COURSE MATERIALS

CRIMINAL LITIGATION PRE-COURSE MATERIALS Legal Practice Course 2014-2015 CRIMINAL LITIGATION PRE-COURSE MATERIALS Copyright Bristol Institute of Legal Practice, UWE AN INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL LITIGATION 1. Introduction: You will be studying

More information

Occasional Paper No 34 - August 1998

Occasional Paper No 34 - August 1998 CHANGING PARADIGMS IN POLICING The Significance of Community Policing for the Governance of Security Clifford Shearing, Community Peace Programme, School of Government, University of the Western Cape,

More information

RECOVERING THE PROCEEDS OF FRAUD

RECOVERING THE PROCEEDS OF FRAUD RECOVERING THE PROCEEDS OF FRAUD World Headquarters the gregor building 716 West Ave Austin, TX 78701-2727 USA PART ONE: THE LAW IN A FRAUD RECOVERY CASE I. LEGAL CAUSES OF ACTION IN GENERAL A fraud victim

More information

Landmark Case MANDATORY MINIMUM SENTENCE FOR MURDER R. v. LATIMER

Landmark Case MANDATORY MINIMUM SENTENCE FOR MURDER R. v. LATIMER Landmark Case MANDATORY MINIMUM SENTENCE FOR MURDER R. v. LATIMER Prepared for the Ontario Justice Education Network by a Law Student from Pro Bono Students Canada R. v. Latimer (2001) Facts Tracy Latimer

More information

The parole deal was conceived to describe the situation whereby innocent life sentenced

The parole deal was conceived to describe the situation whereby innocent life sentenced Naughton, M. (2005) The emergence of PPMI: Progressing Prisoners Maintaining Innocence The Life Line: By lifers for Lifers at HMP Garth. August/September. The parole deal was conceived to describe the

More information

Criminal Justice: A Brief Introduction Twelfth Edition

Criminal Justice: A Brief Introduction Twelfth Edition Criminal Justice: A Brief Introduction Twelfth Edition Chapter 3 Criminal Law The Nature and Purpose of Law (1 of 2) Law A rule of conduct, generally found enacted in the form of a statute, that proscribes

More information

1. The Human Rights Act 1998 was passed by which of the following bodies?

1. The Human Rights Act 1998 was passed by which of the following bodies? 1. The Human Rights Act 1998 was passed by which of the following bodies? A. The UK Parliament. B. The Scottish Assembly. C. The European Court of Human Rights. D. The European Union. 2. There are several

More information

Course Court Systems and Practices. Unit X Pre-trial

Course Court Systems and Practices. Unit X Pre-trial Course Court Systems and Practices Unit X Pre-trial Essential Question What happens to a case between the time a person is arrested and the time they have their trial? TEKS 130.296(c) (1)(G) (4)(B)(E)

More information

Contents. Introduction xvi. Unit 1: Our Legal Heritage 9. How to Use This Book xvi. How to Get the Most from This Course 2

Contents. Introduction xvi. Unit 1: Our Legal Heritage 9. How to Use This Book xvi. How to Get the Most from This Course 2 Contents Table of Cases ix Table of Statutes xiii Acknowledgements xv Introduction xvi How to Use This Book xvi How to Get the Most from This Course 2 Researching Legal Concepts 2 Making Notes 2 Studying

More information

Sentencing Guidelines, Judicial Discretion, And Social Values

Sentencing Guidelines, Judicial Discretion, And Social Values University of Connecticut DigitalCommons@UConn Economics Working Papers Department of Economics September 2004 Sentencing Guidelines, Judicial Discretion, And Social Values Thomas J. Miceli University

More information

VICTIM/WITNESS ASSISTANCE GUIDE RIGHTS AND SERVICES AVAILABLE TO VICTIMS OF CRIME IN PENNSYLVANIA NOTES INCIDENT INVESTIGATION INFORMATION

VICTIM/WITNESS ASSISTANCE GUIDE RIGHTS AND SERVICES AVAILABLE TO VICTIMS OF CRIME IN PENNSYLVANIA NOTES INCIDENT INVESTIGATION INFORMATION NOTES VICTIM/WITNESS ASSISTANCE GUIDE RIGHTS AND SERVICES AVAILABLE TO VICTIMS OF CRIME IN PENNSYLVANIA INCIDENT INVESTIGATION INFORMATION Incident No. Date: Nature of Incident: Investigator: Badge No.

More information

BUSINESS LAW. Chapter 8 Criminal Law and Cyber Crimes

BUSINESS LAW. Chapter 8 Criminal Law and Cyber Crimes BUSINESS LAW Chapter 8 Criminal Law and Cyber Crimes Learning Objectives List and describe the essential elements of a crime. Describe criminal procedure, including arrest, indictment, arraignment, and

More information

S G C. Reduction in Sentence. for a Guilty Plea. Definitive Guideline. Sentencing Guidelines Council

S G C. Reduction in Sentence. for a Guilty Plea. Definitive Guideline. Sentencing Guidelines Council S G C Sentencing Guidelines Council Reduction in Sentence for a Guilty Plea Definitive Guideline Revised 2007 FOREWORD One of the first guidelines to be issued by the Sentencing Guidelines Council related

More information

To obtain additional copies of this document, or to ask how to contact Victim Services in your area, contact:

To obtain additional copies of this document, or to ask how to contact Victim Services in your area, contact: October 2013 To obtain additional copies of this document, or to ask how to contact Victim Services in your area, contact: Victims Services Policy and Program Development Branch Alberta Justice and Solicitor

More information

Inspectors OSPRE Part 1 Statistics - Crime

Inspectors OSPRE Part 1 Statistics - Crime Inspectors OSPRE Part 1 Statistics - Crime Topic 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Probability Ratings 1 Question 5 Questions 4 Questions 3 Questions 3 Questions 3.2 Questions Child abduction Child Abduction x

More information

Police Process. Lecture 12 Lecture 12. Kwak Michigan State University CJ 335 Summer Police Discretion

Police Process. Lecture 12 Lecture 12. Kwak Michigan State University CJ 335 Summer Police Discretion Police Process Dae-Hoon Kwak Michigan State University CJ 335 Summer 2006 Lecture 12 Lecture 12 Police Discretion 1 Outline for the lecture Define police officer use of discretion Explain the sources of

More information

THE QUEEN TOKO MARCUS PEARSON. Guilty SENTENCE OF MACKENZIE J

THE QUEEN TOKO MARCUS PEARSON. Guilty SENTENCE OF MACKENZIE J IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY CRI-2004-070-4342 THE QUEEN 0 V TOKO MARCUS PEARSON Charges: Pleas: Counsel: Sentence: I. Burglary 2. Injuring with intent to cause grievous bodily harm

More information

On the Alleged Disproportionate Sentencing of Cartel Managers

On the Alleged Disproportionate Sentencing of Cartel Managers CPI s Cartel Column Presents: On the Alleged Disproportionate Sentencing of Cartel Managers By John M. Connor (Professor Emeritus, Purdue University) August 2016 Introduction In a recent Commentary, four

More information

3.9 TYPES OF OFFENCES. CLU3M Criminal Law

3.9 TYPES OF OFFENCES. CLU3M Criminal Law 3.9 TYPES OF OFFENCES CLU3M Criminal Law Summary Conviction Offences Minor offences with less severe penalties $2000 and/or 6 months in prison Dealt with quickly and simply- no jury only a judge Accused

More information

Standards. SSCG21 The student will describe the causes and effects of criminal activity.

Standards. SSCG21 The student will describe the causes and effects of criminal activity. Criminal Activity Standards SSCG21 The student will describe the causes and effects of criminal activity. Examine the nature and causes of crimes. Explain the effects criminal acts have on their intended

More information

Sources of Law. Example: U.S. Postal Service. The Constitution. The United States Code. Code of Federal Regulations. (Judicial Precedent) Court Cases

Sources of Law. Example: U.S. Postal Service. The Constitution. The United States Code. Code of Federal Regulations. (Judicial Precedent) Court Cases Example: U.S. Postal Service The Constitution Gives Congress the power to: Establish Post Offices and post roads Make all laws that are necessary and proper for executing this task The United States Code

More information

ACID ATTACKS AND OFFENSIVE WEAPONS Home Office Consultation Response

ACID ATTACKS AND OFFENSIVE WEAPONS Home Office Consultation Response ACID ATTACKS AND OFFENSIVE WEAPONS Home Office Consultation Response December 2017 Introduction The Centre for Social Justice Criminal Justice Unit Response to the Home Office consultation on new legislation

More information

Have you ever been a victim or a witness to a crime? If so, you may be entitled to certain rights under Louisiana's Crime Victim Bill of Rights.

Have you ever been a victim or a witness to a crime? If so, you may be entitled to certain rights under Louisiana's Crime Victim Bill of Rights. VICTIMS RIGHTS Have you ever been a victim or a witness to a crime? If so, you may be entitled to certain rights under Louisiana's Crime Victim Bill of Rights. As a victim or designated family member of

More information