6^^^.^L ^'RI^^^^DU. ...:. ^ ^^ 6cm -su^.^aaka ^^ ^^ ^. ... ou 6 _!..^... W 1 ier,:::...: a... _...: ... ^.^.:...,...,,... 8 :.^ ...,^,

Transcription

1 ,, /,3,lnp y G f,'! 1,r %,r>r, F4 6L : fs ou 6 _! W 1 ier,::: : a r ;,,,,, - :, :: :,r, -- -, -, yi,, :_-- t; :: :,,, 8 : J3 _,,, _ : c,_ rs :- _: % ;,, _ :,,,_ :_: _,,,,, - a Avi ;,:,, _ : 6cm -suaaka,, - :: _ `h ':Si :f r, "\c: : Q't ;'i iltt [ " y _-_,, _ 7 : ' '_ f C r? /,?,c! 1 _ niqiiir _d rrucrlirviiccru:vtur/u!!r//ztrr,r ror 'ar 3a 3iAi//rtirc[ri : -_, S Z i 4 pf p 4y ::,, - Li i 9fu 3r i r _,, : _ -: _ -::: Y::: //, _:- _ -,-_,:- :::_-, :,, :-:_-_ _ ::: 6 % _ Er' S + i ly 0 14 _: 'RIDU -_ :- -- :_, -- -::_ -- ::_ :i,, _

2 , pir :,,n _,::: :: :: `,,,,,,,,, 1! " b'l :, _ y,,,i6 5, L R::ia `?c Q :C :,,I C t,:c,',!,,,,,a w,_,: :, ::,:, : :::::, :,,: { A ::,:,, :,,,,,,,,_ :,, ; 3,,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,,,,, :, :,, _:_,,, G -: :,, /Jr'E-,,l2,,, - ' ',lv fl/y :,:_:,,,,,,,,,,,,, O y _ jya,,: -, _,,_:,,, _: _,,, : - 3d,, g,, _,_ " :,,,,,,,: t! l a0 : _:,_ :,_ : i,, : `7 i

3 ,s,-, : - id + 4>P, c ;ra :::::3 d," J 4a `:-1 Y,!y f s,tl Is ` r,,:,,, LS,,yg } b $ + S?P:rr :::: -- 4:Fs,,y - L,, t ` s, fi :: ',:,:, ' o, -A - A,: C-0 :,, :: `,,,, :`?,,,, f t?i,'t7 a g 41Cj,;, L_:::::, 8 5 : # -, _, ` d- 6-6PAE:G` \`Gr,`! '' 3 YTla1 ''""dt "9l CJ f'l ' r' - ' ` 3f L t_ f? l : tj 11 :-;,`s7,,':, l c, c A r _:: _ : :: _ tl CJf04vrtC a y 4 S y r> Y'-q 1{;\ t\ / l:f3f\ ( y # p -:-- i : :-,:, pf 1F, t -- Y`",, l {" ij - P `fi''"' T A 1 ' ' d G1 1f R, f Y : '' ito d`c-l gl a t E P - ',-0S? ', ` j,j J Y"4+pia' ' " ' ` "s- ys W :_ 4i }, f 5 {p i3 A + -- ':, U' i,, ': l_,: a ::_ i ki'co Li`-J :, - ` -,-, S - ij + ::: _,

4 ,,, :::: _ ' p`s,r -E c{:,'+3`cn-::` \Y "- '5,,ti,:, : - :e, :', M(YeeJAt2 4t XFA 2 C)t;,_,;? r_r 4,,,- ` 3 '`:g 't,>i::'"-f:: _' ': m `" i ': a!, '' <, ','C :,,,,,4,V,ti : :a, _ % ` -ry :!%S, '! }a ;' f l:- 9>, ',::c,; a'c ir 'v," -- 11,, 'L% a,o'"_4; -_::- ' -C::;HL1t:?'::::,i:'_:yfG;t'''-,,i3+'',: a,i1 01A FEIAJIt!,_f:,C 3p: 7E: t U : aloi,`an:r )M,i,_ pi So?:N,a _ ; 1V ' Iti _, Y -: : xf ;, ;, _ :: V\1 ";;`::::i :, C ' ' ' _ 0-4 S, C $'en `G:'" _ Cs re " r r,' r, ` vi T e- Ar A OvO CA - i f 01I), ;,IS,o! ecar -' -=' : \ ;, : 9, e '! e, 663 " I : -:,,:

5 4' 1 9{; k,,,,_,:, j,a,, ::: ::: :i-,:, ' w,t-,,:, ,,, - -c,,:x, :, - _- :,,,,,,», cy,,,: S _, r yf jy {p { _p,3> y y y :;,Y,-, :_j i,,, :, t1 _: '4!L,tt /,,e,r,f, : ::,,,,, :: s t g y a y_ -:::,,, :,- 4?,,+l ya;a-j,,,,: :, :, - -,:, :, - 1,:,_ 3 p,ry! {,ib a : :,,,,, :: ::, : : :!, ;,,, u V ` 6t3 w,r' F, i i_ (L :, Q!'lJ ir 4:: -I P r T!w ij : _ "' `%,,,,,,,, ; :o,,,,: At-ACi,,, v F L,,, S r + :,,,,, _,- :,,-: cs-d,,,,, f'r p 1 1 'AQr _dyzyk1>"r: ` :,:`_:_,,, N : ::,,, :,, :,,,,,:,,: u - `e,,i!1,,:s e, ju,'-ctrss; :,:, _, -:; 9: ` :: 1 P1 ts i= - 1 a d `," Tf, ' f Ca J,9,t:1v :,

6 -,- --f,,:- s \ " :::, - : q,i,,, :,,,, :,ts?y `, -,? : ::, - : : -, f,,3 a _'-, r # 4r+ak";;, y!,e:ir±, }4s' ' 1"?,:t, :,`n,';-:`, la,+' r`'f, - ( '`n,y,;,,,,, s a ar " { _ C ` 3 N: T k 0 6 An:, 6 tl 'v_ t 7 Y - i VLy 5 1,,,: : : { ` rd!z) curne i' :,i - y- -Gr -e '+Tm=ejq,a 3,- M Cv : & i?: s 1: i' : O,f' 5k '-- -: L i'1 ` -,- : }e,,,,: y, i i,",r,j 3`$ $" - s"r v_ -, - -, t,( 1-6:,": R,2:ti, -: -,d - - : "Ex -_- :,,, /,,,,r f, / 1, F T _,;: Z _ I 4 r _,, : _- _ - _ ` " - \ G, ' "v u '`,/'a, L:' b /, P c 3,,'`_ Z { (,,: F / ' M / : ::: Y :: -- ( :: `, -- :: : 9 'ff!r, :::: ' _:

7 4 F$ { {, iy _, '`,J,,! Sc ;5!6?7D,3J a/ e, L 'S3 AY:,,, S: -;,L::R,!-'' ::, k,,, yi,,, y Y,,,--_,, r,, ::,,,,,, _ - : F1J 1 % {kt l, -( ls S : 3 r w, {,,, h,, -, ;oi,65/,vrl: x:f:dc' ::%,, _ ' AeNt,t t ',I t,4:4! a <,, / pp p y :,,!d'''?,,t 119ar:)Y,w,: `; _l ` 9 t,;5};41*,tl,ih,'sr/9 ;iv 4,,, 5-LF,3:1,, 'F? 11fiG s'6j"131-;90's 1 Av,, al, `J H 4 CA r,, / B Y r R,,id 8 j ;,:,C, _,,, t 1,,, ; : r? lnle,,;', ize :,:,,, A_m j' J,,?, : :: yy,, +n:k!, L : :r, : :,f'/b :;:ta : 9, :,, _:, j / p Z,,Fj,'s-,, a,, ;,;,, t t s _::< --:,:,,:,,;: :t :: :, : :I:i:`" ` 1,": :: :, > _ :

8 _ - : :: : ::: `,, > ::: : _ : :a C eq C i; f--: '` s c sp,: E'` ec :,' G g a, 1 : { j` b : l ;:1 1f, ' ' _s _ : : :,, : A"?te` tt% " ar:--::i'=f ef br 0t&-,j,tl-d _:,,Vr'6 e ry 0 W$,, _ - I - ` R, 4k P - ` _ - :, _ : _,: ::::

9 _,,,,_, (/J'D ppp! a(/yt" 7 :: - ',-,, -,--,, _: :,::,, -, w,, 3"` y,fjy, y t,ps _ 4,!:5 : _:_',, r,7y,4:'4:4±3 lrr:,,,63, a"" 3:,: q,, Vs : _ -- :,:, a,,,,:, :,:, : :,,,:,,, -,,,, :, s :: : : _,,:,,, :!e -,ia! - :?- :? v- -,[:F: '- :- 3:`s:--i,:, a!r` C' 1i',, :A a-, 5- ;, a,:; :;, > : :-d:- :, a f3: :" c :,,,;:;,, _t', r,,,i f -: -, p+(y, / 3 ---,,-,,, _,, :,,- _,,, ', ;C Sqe?!"!,-,:l,yA Y,,+ f,: ',,, I3"`` `, Y f 1,f' ',,? p / q,,,_,,,,, 'F, :r':'-:: af,,, '`V!`i' _,'p ṛb ad!vyj(, j V? 14;ls,;:;:4,,:w1 -,-: :::,,, :, -:,,:,,,, _,, _ : _ "_, u j : ', `,` `,,:,, : :_ ::,?,s'- - :`,` ac;,,d CeJb,: _- ::, :

10 , y:: -: 6i''Lts a,nl:: s/ :,,AfJ''v,?::,, 1,,,, t {,rf! ; Y V",i:,4!, ;r? 3 v! 1'", :,,,,5 :-, $ 4! r : :,,,,:,, --,,,,sci3 i$fo"t t; 4 :,,, toad A ci i'ṣ :::,, :_,:_,,,,, _,;, :, S,n :,: _ :,, : t 1:! :: :,,,, :, :,, S ::' t,,,f,:-,: :_,, _: _ ;! :,5,-J b,,:,, :,,,','i,,,,,,,,,, _ :: -,;;,, ':, 5 i $ "",,,,-,,,,,_, 5 +:: +:L : J:: 5, r,: -,,,,,,,, d ;,:--,,,,::,,,,, ::_ : : -,:,5,,,+s+rf, f-3,;1,,1, 1 ;, A,S " : ` f-,,:: : : :,,,?,,, +,,, +: r,,,,,,a 's,,,,,,,: :_:,? k,,,:,_,,, : :,: s ` - -,,,, :,:,,, : 'F:,,o,, _ :, i,:,,_ W : 4 lp,_!,,: : :,lj R -'r r, 3:,C,,, e : _,,:;, :, s;, -:, x`:: -:,r ::, ' i: a t! r ` C f y C, : t,, -, f :', ` f J h, l :! J 3 y/y :,, h F 1 :::1, f f r i, SS : S : :, f 3,: : :,-,, :: f J i, f (,: j S w r c k r!' r ' '3'C rr 1 - i,,,,,,,,,,,_ :,_ - : :,:,: ::: F_,, L,,- c :, - p i,,,:, _,,,,,, _,, t,:p,,:f, _,, : F 1 " f,,,, :,, 1,, : : y x,, :,,»s,,,-::' i t! e: : _ : ;,,,,: {:,: ` z,,,,,, ::::,, s::, -:,1,: v,:, :, _,,,, :,,,,:,,, :,,,: -:y _,, _,:,-

11 ::::, _; " _, S f, :,` 4f A " "',,, %s,,,,, :::,,,,,: -:,::, - _, _:e, 1,:, ::::,y, ::,:,,,,-,:::: _,,, : a9 s ro C< _,, ---- _ - ' _" 11"S"S, :: ::c c,,_ co,;o :_:_S _;;, :, er-t, :,,?, 1 'c-,} - sj?«r,, Y F 3 P21 f?,ti r,}?,, _ ' :::: :,,,, '-- :: g 52Y A41 denn1fermak1 NotaryPubElc, Stateof Ohio emrdad itt Ashtabula County f o yv My tcommission Expires April 25; 2Qi7 _ : ;a;, -

12 Cuyahoga County Clerk of Courts - Case Docket Page 1 of 2 Pririt CASE INFORMATION CA STATE OF OHIO vs HAKEEM SULTAANA Filing Date Side TypeDescription Image 11/05/2014 N/A MO Pro se appellant's judicial notice pertaining to Ohio Supreme Court case no /05/2014 N/A MO Motion by appellant, pro se, "to follow Stave v Crosby 1987 Ohio App Lexis 7761 pertaining to verdict form issue" 11/04/2014 Al EV APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED, 10/29/2014 N/A JE Motion by Appellant to extend time to file assignments of error and brief is granted to November 4, 2014 No further extension will be considered Notice issued 10/29/2014 N/A JE Motion by appellant, pro se, to vacate/reconsider this court order denying ; appellant's stay request is denied Notice issued 10/29/2014 N/A JE Motion by appellant, pro se, to add additional support to appellant's reconsideration motion is denied Notice issued = 10/28/2014 Al MO MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE BRIEF = 10/28/2014 N/A MO Motion by appellant, pro se, to vacate/reconsider this court order denying = appellant's stay request? n!28/2n1a p`i, ': v,cti " a,,i Fr; :se, to adci additioral support to appellant`s = reconsideration motion = 10/27/2014 N/A JE Motion by Appellant, pro se, for reconsideration, or as an alternative, transfer appellant's amended brief and authorities to appeal number is denied Notice issued 10/23/2014 N/A JE Motion by appelfant, pro se, to stay until trial court furnish/release/deliver verdict forms and PSI report is denied Notice issued 10/23/2014 N/A MO "For record 'Void Arrest Warrant Up Affidavitfiled by pro se = appellant = 10/23/2014 N/A MO Motion by Appellant, pro se, for reconsideration, or as an alternative, transfer appellant's amended brief and authorities to appeal number /22/2014 N/A MO Motion by appellant, pro se, to stay until trial court furnish/release/deliver verdict forms and PSI report 09/02/2014 N/A JE Motion by Appellant to extend time to file assignments of error and brief is granted to October 29, 2014 No further extension will be considered Notice = issued 08/28/2014 Al MO MOTION FOR MOTION TO EXTEND THE DEADLINE FOR FILING BRIEF 08/13/2014 N/A JE Motion by appellant, pro se, to amend notice of appeal with lower trial court 7/30/14 journal entry; with request to supplement the record with appellant's = 7/9/14 lower trial court filing is denied Notice issued 08/13/2014 N/A JE Motion by appellant, pro se, to supplement the record is denied Notice issued 08/13/2014 N/A JE Motion by appellant, pro se, "to take into consideration the 3/6/14 unlawful arrest warrant, that created a void 3/10/14 order from special proceeding = which was a final appealable order pursuant to RC , when - appeal bond is sought" is denied Notice issued 08/06/2014 N/A MO MOTION BY APPELLANT, PRO SE, TO AMEND NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH LOWER TRIAL COURT 7/30/14 JOURNAL ENTRY; WITH REQUEST TO Case?nformation_Docketaspx?q=5r7rkrmlVlIi 11/7/2014

13 Cuyahoga County Clerk of Courts - Case Docket Page 2 of 2 07/16/2014 Al EV 07/16/2014 N/A JE 07/16/2014 N/A JE 07/16/2014 N/A NT 07/15/2014 N/A MO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD WITH APPELLANT'S 7/9/14 LOWER TRIAL COURT FILING TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS FILED BY APPELLANT 18 VOLS AND I BOX OF EXHIBITS Motion by appellant, pro se, "for public defender to furnish appellant a copy of entire record" is denied Notice issued Motion by Appellant, pro se, for appointment of the office of the Public Defender is granted Motion to allow for extension of time to meet all deadlines is granted in part, appellant's brief is due August 29, 2014 Notice issued Record on appeal filed and notice issued to all parties Motion by appellant, pro se, to supplement the record = 07/15/2014 N/A MO Motion by appellant, pro se, "for public defender to furnish appellant a copy of = entire record" _ 07/10/2014 Al EV ORIGINAL PAPERS FILED BY TRIAL COURT ON SH 25 07/10/2014 N/A JE Application by Appellant's counsel for assigned counsel fees fiked by Edward M Heindel is granted in the amount of $33500 Notice issued 07/09/2014 N/A MO Application by Appellant's counsel for assigned counsel fees filed by Edward M Heindel 07/09/2014 N/A MO Copy of correspondence sent to Judge Peter Corrigan, et al 07/09/2014 N/A MO Copy of motion filed in United States District Court for the Northen District of Ohio 07/09/2014 N/A MO Judicial notice filed by pro se appellant 07/09/2014 N/A MO 07/07/2014 N/A MO 06/24/2014 N/A JE Motion by Appellant, pro se, to appoint new counsel Motion by appellant, pro se, "to take into consideration the 3/6/14 unlawful arrest warrant, that created a void 3/10/14 order from special proceeding %n%hich was a fira" appealable order purusant to RC , when appeal bond is sought" Motion by appellant's counsel, Edward M Heindel, for leave to withdraw as counsel is granted for good cause shown Appellant Hakeem Sultaana may represent himself pro se He shall comply with all Appellate and Local Appellate rules The record is due July 16, 2014 Attorney Edward M Heindel shall file his fee bill within 30 days of this entry Notice issued 06/19/2014 Al MO MOTION FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW 06/06/2014 Al EV NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED FROM COMMON PLEAS CRIMINAL BRANCH COURT, CASE # CR WITH JOURNAL ENTRY, PRAECIPE, DOCKETING STATEMENT AND DOCKET SHEET 06/06/2014 Al SF LEGAL RESEARCH 06/06/2014 Al SF COMPUTER FEE 06/06/2014 Al SF CLERK'S FEE 06/06/2014 Al SF COURT OF APPEALS SPECIAL PROJECTS 06/06/2014 Al SF LEGAL NEWS 06/06/2014 Al AF POVERTY AFFIDAVIT, FILED 06/06/2014 N/A SF CASE INITIATED: NOTICE OF APPEAL, PRAECIPE, DOCKETING STATEMENT Only the official court records available from the Cuyahoga County Clerk of Courts, available in person, should be relied upon as accurate and current For questions/comments please click here Copyright O 2014 PROWARE All Rights Reserved m El u Docketaspx?q=5r7rkrmMIi 11/7/2014

14 1987 Ohio App LEXIS 7761 No C July 1, 1987, Decided Editorial Information: Prior History Criminal Appeal from Hamilton County Municipal Court Appeal Dismissed Trial No 86CRB-1818A Disposition: Appelal dismissed Counsel Richard A Castellini, City Solictor, Terrence R Cosgroe, Esq,, and Kevin O Donovan, Esq, for Plaintiff-Appellee Timothy A Smith, Esq, for Defendant-Appellant Judges: KLUSMEEIER, PJ, SHANNON and HILDERBRANT, JJ Opinion PER CURIAM This cause came on to be heard upon the appeal, the transcript of the docket, journal entries and original papers from the Hamilton County Municipal Court, the transcript of the proceedings, the argument of plaintiff-appellee's counsel, defendant-appellant having failed to appear either personally or through counsel We do not reach the two assigned errors -- ineffective assistance of counsel and the conviction being against the manifest weight of the evidence -- because the appeal is dismissed for a lack of fundament to support the sentence imposed by the trial court The record before us lacks the jury's the jury's verdict form A verdict must be in writing, signed by the jurors, and returned to the judge in open court Crim R 31(A) When it is received by tlie court, "the verdict must be immediately entered in full upon the minutes" RC The verdict form is required to be filed in the criminal appearance docket by the clerk Crim R 55(A) The jury's verdict in the record guarantees there will be no doubt as to what specific crime the defendant was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt Therefore, the purported entry sentencing the defendant-appellant is a nullity As such we must dismiss this appeal for lack of a final appealable order App R 4(B); State v Woods (Apr 17, 1985), Hamilton App No C , unreported

15 Casc No: STATE OF i`' --!10 VS HAKEEM S U LTAA NA Firs(-C;ass Mail U S Postage Paid Lleveland, OH Permit tjc 1962 C_,- Y i _ n _ Motion by ap- -',n«, pro se, ro ; s ay un;; : t :i COu-t forms and F'ri r'dpor:!s denied E 'u >Y' -- K ',i All M 3KA: of E ghth Appellate District _ r _:, - acesie, ave 'id, 5 -iu zi 1 ' J (216) Da:e: 10127,'2014 TO:,U TAANA 2T,5 S AVG" BELDON ROAD GR:-\FTON, CFi c tac ; fd 9 - f 3dI _,