INTRADEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE. The Honorable Board of Police Commissioners

Transcription

1 INTRADEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE May 24, TO: The Honorable Board of Police Commissioners FROM: Chief of Police SUBJECT: PROCEDURES FOR CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION OF ADULTS AND MINORS - REVISED; PROCEDURES FOR ADMONITION OF CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS PER CALIFORNIA WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS CODE, SECTION MINORS TAKEN INTO CUSTODY - REVISED; AND PROCEDURES FOR QUESTIONING DURING ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATIONS - ESTABLISHED RECOMMENDED ACTION That the Board of Police Commissioners REVIEW and APPROVE the revision to Department Manual Section 4/202.10, Interrogation of Suspects - Admonition of Miranda Rights, and the establishment of Department Manual Section 4/202.20, Interviewing Adult and Juvenile Arrestees for Administrative Investigations. DISCUSSION The attached Special Order amending Department Manual Section 4/ and establishing Section 4/ is submitted for your review and approval. This Order updates and informs Department personnel regarding Department procedures for the custodial interrogation of adult and juvenile suspects and the Admonition of Constitutional Rights for juveniles taken into custody per Section 625 of the California Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC). The Order also establishes new procedures for questioning during administrative investigations. Should you have questions regarding this matter, please contact Mr. Gerald L. Chaleff, Special Assistant for Constitutional Policing, at (213) Respectfully, CHARLIE BECK Chief of Police Attachment

2 OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF POLICE SPECIAL ORDER NO. APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ON SUBJECT: PROCEDURES FOR CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION OF ADULTS AND MINORS - REVISED; PROCEDURES FOR ADMONITION OF CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS PER CALIFORNIA WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS CODE, SECTION MINORS TAKEN INTO CUSTODY - REVISED; AND PROCEDURES FOR QUESTIONING DURING ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATIONS - ESTABLISHED EFFECTIVE: IMMEDIATELY PURPOSE: The purpose of this Order is to update and educate Department personnel on Department procedures for the custodial interrogation of adult and juvenile suspects and the Admonition of Constitutional Rights for juveniles taken into custody per Section 625 of the California Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC). Generally, Department personnel should refrain from conducting custodial interrogations once a suspect in custody unequivocally invokes either the right to silence or the right to an attorney. However, the criminal investigating officer may question a suspect outside of Miranda in cases involving public safety and/or matters unrelated to the crime for which the suspect is in custody, such as crimes in the area, local gang activity, etc. New procedures have been established for questioning during administrative investigations. Miranda and the procedures for custodial interrogations do not apply to persons who are not in custody for a criminal offense. This Order supersedes all other Department directives regarding custodial interrogations if in conflict with the procedures detailed below. Department Manual Section 4/202.10, Interrogation of Suspects - Admonition of Miranda Rights, has been revised to reflect the below procedures. PROCEDURE: I. INTERROGATION OF ADULT AND JUVENILE SUSPECTS FOR CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS. Generally, Department employees should not conduct a custodial interrogation once a suspect in custody unequivocally invokes either the right to silence or the right to an attorney. Note: If the suspect only invokes silence, this does not preclude investigators from seeking a waiver at a later time, as allowed by law.

3 SPECIAL ORDER NO. -2- When a major crime is involved, an officer shall not read the Miranda admonition to a suspect or question a suspect prior to consulting with the investigating officer (I/O) conducting the criminal investigation. Such cases include, but are not limited to, the following: * Homicides; * Crimes against persons resulting in injuries that require hospitalization of the victim; * Crimes, excluding narcotics, that are the responsibility of a specialized detective division (e.g., bank robbery, arson, child abuse, etc.); * Major narcotics cases that require specialized expertise (e.g., methamphetamine labs, etc.); * Felony wants/warrants, including fugitives; and, * Any crimes that require extensive follow-up investigations. For all other crimes, the arresting officer(s) or other assigned employee(s) should attempt to obtain a statement from an in-custody suspect after providing the Miranda admonition, unless otherwise directed by his/her watch commander or commanding officer. Interrogating Officers - Responsibilities. When officers are conducting a custodial interrogation, the following procedures shall be followed: * Officers shall read the Miranda admonition verbatim as delineated in the Officer's Notebook, Form ; Note: Courtroom testimony shall also reflect that the Miranda admonition was read verbatim to the suspect. * Officers shall document the suspect's responses to the Miranda admonition in the appropriate report; * If the suspect does not unequivocally invoke his/her rights to silence and/or an attorney, the I/O shall conduct a non-coercive interrogation; * If the suspect unequivocally invokes his/her rights to silence and/or an attorney at any time during the custodial interrogation, the officer should stop any questioning regarding the crime for which the suspect is in custody; and/or, Exception: An I/O may conduct non-coercive questioning on matters related to public safety, e.g., location of a victim during a kidnapping or medical condition, location of a weapon, etc; or, matters unrelated to the crime for which the suspect is in custody, e.g., crimes in the area, local gang activity, etc.

4 SPECIAL ORDER NO. -3- * Any statements made by the suspect shall be documented in the appropriate report. Note: Officers are not required to wait for a parent or guardian prior to the questioning of a juvenile. However, officers shall ensure that proper Gladys R. procedures are followed when interrogating minors under the age of 14 (Section IV of this Order). II. INTERVIEWING ADULT AND JUVENILE ARRESTEES FOR ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATIONS - ESTABLISHED. Department Manual Section 4/202.20, Interviewing Adult and Juvenile Arrestees for Administrative Investigations, has been established. The criminal investigation shall take precedence over the administrative investigation, e.g., use of force, vehicle pursuit, personnel complaint investigation, etc.; nevertheless, a Department employee conducting an administrative investigation should attempt to interview the suspect for administrative investigations. When conducting a custodial interview of a suspect for an administrative investigation, the following procedures shall be followed: * When a major crime is involved, as identified in Section I above, the administrative I/O shall coordinate with the criminal I/O to conduct the administrative interview. If no major crime is involved, the administrative I/O should proceed, when practical; * Prior to any questioning, the administrative I/O shall determine if the suspect had been read the Miranda admonition and the suspect's responses; * If the suspect had not been read the Miranda admonition, the administrative I/O shall read the Miranda admonition verbatim as delineated in the Officer's Notebook and document the suspect's responses to the Miranda admonition in the appropriate report; * If the suspect does not unequivocally invoke his/her right to silence and/or an attorney, the I/O shall conduct a non-coercive administrative interview; * If the suspect does unequivocally invoke his/her right to silence and/or an attorney, the administrative I/O should advise the suspect that the interview is for a Department administrative investigation, ask the suspect if he/she will answer questions for the administrative investigation, and conduct a non-coercive administrative interview only if the suspect agrees to be interviewed; and,

5 SPECIAL ORDER NO. -4- * The administrative I/0 shall document any statements made by the suspect in the appropriate administrative report or in a Follow-Up Investigation, Form , if the interview occurs after the completion of the initial reports. Note: The report shall include the date and time of the interview, the name of the person(s) interviewed and the name of the Department employee who conducted the interview. The report shall also include when the statements were given, e.g., after the Miranda admonition, after the administrative interview advisement, etc. This report shall be provided to the criminal I/0 and shall list the original crime/arrest Division of Records number as a related report. III. ADVISEMENT OF CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS PER WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS CODE MINORS. When an officer takes a person under the age of 18 (minor) into temporary custody for a 601 or 602 WIC offense and does not intend to interrogate the minor for a 601/602 WIC offense, the officer shall advise the minor as follows: * You have the right to remain silent; * Anything you say may be used against you in court; * You have the right to the presence of an attorney before and during any questioning; * If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you, free of charge, before any questioning, if you want. The officer shall not ascertain if the minor understands his rights and shall not seek a waiver. The 625 advisement may be given anytime during the period that the minor is in police custody. Officers should be aware of the Six-Hour Rule when conducting the interrogation of a minor in custody. Note: Providing the Miranda admonition for interrogation purposes will fulfill the 625 WIC requirement. An advisement per 625 WIC shall be given in, but is not limited to, the following situations: * Any minor taken into temporary custody/arrested by the Los Angeles Police Department on a 602 WIC offense where investigative responsibility lies with another division or police agency;

6 SPECIAL ORDER NO. -5- * Any minor arrested on a 601/602 WIC warrant or 602 WIC offense, wherein the investigator assigned to that case would be unable to interrogate the minor prior to the expiration of the Six-Hour Rule; and, * Any minor detained on a 601/602 offense who is not booked but is placed in handcuffs, placed in the back of a police vehicle, transported by a police officer, or placed in some other situation that would indicate a restraint on the freedom of movement of such degree associated with a formal arrest. Documentation. The officer shall document in the narrative portion of the arrest report, "The minor was advised per 625 WIC." If the minor was detained and issued a Non-Traffic Notice to Appear, Form , "625 WIC" shall be printed on the bottom left-hand corner of the narrative portion of the citation. If the minor was detained and no formal arrest was made nor a citation was issued, then the 625 WIC admonition may be documented on the Daily Field Activities Report, Form ; Sergeant's Daily Report, Form ; Watch Commander's Daily Report, Form ; or, in the investigating officer's Detective Case Tracking System (DCTS) notes. IV. GLADYS R. ADMONITION. When a minor under the age of 14 years is suspected of committing a crime, and the officer plans on interrogating the minor, the minor's section of the Gladys R. questionnaire shall be completed after the Miranda admonition has been given, but before the questioning begins. The parent, guardian, or other responsible adult section may be completed anytime prior to filing the case with the District Attorney's office. The purpose of the Gladys R. questionnaire is to assist the District Attorney's office in proving that the minor understood the wrongfulness of his/her act. Every effort should be made to locate and interview the parent, guardian or other responsible adult having contact with the minor to complete their section of the Gladys R. questionnaire prior to filing a criminal case with the District Attorney's office. If a parent or guardian refuses to be interviewed or cooperate, and no other responsible adult having contact with the minor can be located and/or refuses to be interviewed, the word "Refused" should be written next to the parent/guardian name on the form, and the

7 SPECIAL ORDER NO. -6- circumstances surrounding the refusal shall be documented on a Follow-up Investigation report. A copy of the Follow-up Investigation report shall be submitted to the District Attorney's office at the time of filing. Note: A Gladys R. questionnaire is not required if the minor is only being admonished per 625 WIC. V. DOCUMENTATION OF CUSTODIAL AND NON-CUSTODIAL INTERROGATION - ADULTS AND JUVENILES. Custodial interrogations, or any statement that requires a signature, should be documented on the Investigative Action/Statement Form, Form Non-custodial statements should be documented on a Continuation Sheet, Form , or a blank sheet of paper. Note: Officers shall refer to the General Reporting Instructions, Field Notebook Divider, Form , for directions on completing Investigative Action/ Statement Forms. AMENDMENTS: This Order amends Section 4/ and adds Section 4/ to the Department Manual. MONITORING RESPONSIBILITY: All commanding officers shall have monitoring responsibility for this directive. AUDIT RESPONSIBILITY: The Commanding Officer, Internal Audits and Inspections Division, shall review this directive and determine whether an audit or inspection shall be conducted in accordance with Department Manual Section 0/ CHARLIE BECK Chief of Police DISTRIBUTION "D"