FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/31/ :07 PM

Transcription

1 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/31/ :07 PM INDEX NO /2015 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 94 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/31/2016 Kueker & Bruh, LLP Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street ~ESPO e: \...y1lj\'6 C E.fE.f\E "e.c\~\..\'\ Bill Number Bill Date Fees Billed Disb Billed Total Billed Pay Date Payments Adjustments Balance Due /06/2015 $1, $0.00 $1, /09/2015 $1, $0.00 $ /04/2015 $3, $ $4, /09/2015 $4, $0.00 $ /05/2015 $8, $ $8, /09/2015 $8, $0.00 $ /05/2015 $10, $ $11, /12/2016 $11, $0.00 $ /04/2015 $2, $ $3, /12/2016 $3, $0.00 $ /08/2016 $0.00 $16.18 $ /12/2016 $16.18 $0.00 $ /03/2016 $ $0.40 $ /12/2016 $ $0.00 $ /04/2016 $11, $37.30 $11, /12/2016 $4, ($7,851.17) $ /05/2016 $3, $1.80 $3, $0.00 ($3,638.80) $ /05/2016 $8, $ $9, $0.00 $0.00 $9, /06/2016 $2, $69.39 $2, $0.00 $0.00 $2, /06/2016 $5, $ $5, $0.00 $0.00 $5, Total $60, $2, $62, $33, ($11,489.97) $17, Fee Historv Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount 06/19/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Review and analyze case. Conversation with Shogik Oganisyan. 06/22/2015 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Received and reviewed file; Lease; Petition; Stipulation; Notice of Default; online research re company info, alternate service address. 06/22/2015 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Prepared Complaint. 8/03/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Review of documentation obtained in file in preparation of drafting summons and complaint; legal research; outlined summons and complaint. 8/04/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Continued draft of summons and complaint against tenant and guarantor. 8/05/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Completed draft of summons and complaint. 8/05/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Received instructions from Gregg Kurlander; Phone call with client; Sent correspondence to client via facsimile; Prepared casefile. 8/19/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Discussion with client. Conversation with Gregg Kurlander. 8/19/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $80.00 Revision of Verification of Summons and Complaint; Prepared riday, July 08, /12

2 Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street Fee Historv Date Employee/ Description Hours Rate Amount Pleadings for purchase of index number and for service and filing. 08/19/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $43.50 Made edits to verification page of summons and complaint; delivered same to client via facsimile. 8/20/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Revision of Summons and Complaint to include claim for newly issued water bill. 8/20/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Received and notarized signed verification page from client; advise attorney of same; Prepared litigation covers for summons and complaint; Made revisions to summons and complaint; Electronically filed summons and complaint; phone call with electronic filing clerk; Prepared multiple copies of summons and complaint to be served on defendants. 8/24/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 1.30 $85.00 $ Flat fee for service of Summons upon Pui Y. Ho at 250 East 39th Street. (bad address) 8/25/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 1.30 $85.00 $0.00 Served Summons and Complaint upon Amber Japanese and Ho. (first attempt) 8/26/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 0.80 $85.00 $0.00 Served Summons and Complaint upon Amber Japanses and Ho. (second attempt) 8/27/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 1.20 $85.00 $ Completed service of Summons and Complaint upon Amber Japanses and Pui Y. Ho. 8/28/2015 Rhoden, Curtis DAD $85.00 $34.00 Prepared mailing to complete service of Summons and Complaint. 8/28/2015 McCarthy, Peter J. DAD $ $58.00 Assisted with preparing additional copies of summons and complaint for service via certified mail; Prepared certified mailings. 9/01/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 1.30 $85.00 $ Prepared Affidavit of Service for Summons and Complaint. 9/02/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 0.80 $85.00 $68.00 Completed Affidavit of Service for Summons and Complaint. 9/08/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $43.50 Made edits and revisions to affidavit of service of summons and verified complaint. 9/17/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Discussion with client. Conversation with Phil Widlanski. Litigation strategy with Gregg Kurlander. riday, July 08, /12

3 Columbus Avenue a/kla 65 West 70th Street Fee Historv Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount 9/17/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $80.00 Telephone conference with opposing counsel (Eric Li) re: consent to extend time to answer. 9/18/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Draft responsive to opposing counsel's request for extension of time to interpose answer and response to offer of settlement. 9/25/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Review incoming pleading. 9/25/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Receipt, review and analysis of Defendants' answer; meeting with A. Kueker to discuss litigation strategy and summary judgment; began outlining motion for summary judgment. 9/25/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Provide attorneys of copies of electronically filed answer with affirmative defenses and counterclaims. 9/29/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Legal research regarding mitigation of damages. 9/29/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $3, Preparation of summary judgment motion (Research, file review; outlining; compilation of exhibits, etc.) 9/30/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $2, Draft affirmation in support of summary judgment; legal research pertaining to and specific to striking each of the twenty one defenses raised by the Defendants. 0/01/2015 Rhoden, Curtis 2.30 $85.00 $ Obtained records from Dept. of Building. 0/05/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Began preparation of summary judgment motion. 0/07/2015 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Litigation strategy with Gregg Kurlander. 0/07/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Continued draft of affirmation in support of summary judgment. 0/09/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Arranged for the retrieval of the so-ordered stipulation of settlement for Gregg Kurlander. 0/12/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $2, Continued draft of Affirmation and Memorandum of Law. 0/12/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Assisted Gregg Kurlander with drafting summary judgment motion riday, July 08, /12

4 Kueker & Bruh, llp Columbus Avenue a/kla 65 West 70th Street fee History Date Employee/ Description Hours Rate Amount by providing clauses of defendant's answer. 10/13/2015 King, James M $85.00 $ Had Post Trial Stipulation of Settlement sent up to Judge to be So- Ordered. 10/14/2015 Kucker, Alan D $ $ Finalize affidavit. 10/14/2015 King, James M $85.00 $ Obtained So-Ordered Post Trial Stipulation from court. 10/14/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Draft affidavit of client in support of summary judgment motion. 10/14/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Received instructions from Gregg Kurlander; converted exhibits A through I into electronic format in preparation for electronic filing; stored each exhibit individually into electronic case file; prepared (3) copies of exhibits A through I to assemble motion for summary Judgment; prepared litigation covers for summary judgment motion; sent affidavit to client for signature via facsimile. 10/19/2015 Kucker, Alan D $ $ Discussion with client. 10/19/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Continue Draft of motion 10/27/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Completed Draft of Summary Judgment Motion 10/29/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Assisted Gregg Kurlander with drafting reply to counterclaims. 10/30/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Completion of Memorandum of Law; Prepared papers for efiling 11/03/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Draft Response and Defenses to Counterclaims. 11/03/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Prepared verified reply to counterclaims to be sent to client via facsimile. 11/13/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Preparation of papers for e-filing and service on opposing counsel. 11/13/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Prepared request for judicial intervention; electronically converted notice of motion, affirmation, memorandum of law, affidavit and verified answer to counterclaims in preparation for electronic filing; made additional copies of each document. 11/16/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $80.00 Friday, July 08, /12

5 Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street Fee History Date Employee/ Description Hours Rate Amount Review and edit Request for Judicial Intervention. 11/16/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Prepared commercial division request for judicial intervention; served verified reply to counterclaims via first class mail; prepared affidavit of service for verified reply to counterclaims; made edit to notice of motion page; electronically filed notice of motion with annexed affirmation, affidavit, memorandum of law, exhibits and request for judicial intervention; velabound (3) copies of notice of motion with annexed documents; prepared litigation covers for notice of motion and verified reply to counterclaims. 11/17/2015 McCarthy, Peter J $ $58.00 Served opposing counsel with notice of motion via first class mail; drafted affidavit service and electronically filed affidavit of service. 11/19/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $80.00 Telephone conference with opposing counsel re: proposed briefing schedule. 11/20/2015 Kucker, Alan D $ $ Litigation strategy with Gregg Kurlander. 11/25/2015 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $40.00 Prepared stipulation. 01/26/2016 King, James M $85.00 $85.00 Submitted Notice of Motion to E-File Clerk in NY Supreme Court. 01/26/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Arranged with court clerk to file notice of motion with e-filing clerk. 02/01/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Review and analysis of Defendant's cross motion; legal research; outlined opposition and reply. 02/02/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Draft opposition. 02/03/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Correspondence with P. McCarthy and court reporter from prior nonpayment trial to ascertain whether there was testimony in the trial by Defendant Pui Yan Ho in which she testified to her relationship to Amber Japanese Restaurant Inc.(lnformation required for opposition to cross motion). 02/04/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $2, Outline opposition papers to Defendant's cross and reply to Defendant's opposition. 02/05/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Continued preparation of opposition papers to Defendant's crossmotion. Friday, July 08, /12

6 .' Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street Kueker & Bruh, LLP Fee History Date Employee/ Description Hours Rate Amount 02/05/2016 McCarthy, Peter J. 020 $ $29.00 Assisted Gregg Kurlander by providing electronic copies of caserelated documentation. 02/08/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $1, Draft opposition to Defendants' Cross motion and opposition papers. 02/09/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $2, Continued and completed opposition and reply papers; prepared documents for efiling and reviewed file in preparation of court appearance. 02/09/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $72.50 Prepared multiple copies of opposition to cross-motion and reply with exhibits; prepared litigation covers; scanned opposition papers and exhibits individually into electronic casefile; electronically filed opposition papers with exhibits. 02/10/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Submission of moving papers in Room /16/2016 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Legal research regarding updated research on application security. 03/07/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ exchange between Judge's law clerk and opposing counsel re: scheduling of argument of Plaintiffs motion for summary judgment. 03/07/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $40.00 Receipt and review from Judge's law clerk. Draft response to same. 03/07/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $40.00 Receipt of argument date via from court; sent responsive confirming argument on March 29 at 11:00 am 03/28/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.35 $ $ Correspondence to and from opposing counsel; phone calls to and from opposing counsel. 03/28/2016 Kurlander, Gregg R $ $ Coordination of alternate argument date with Court Law Clerk, Opposing Counsel; N. Winiarsky and J. Marino. 03/30/2016 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Legal research regarding merger clause and corporate capacity. 03/30/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /30/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 5.25 $ $2, Friday, July 08, /12

7 Columbus Avenue a/kla 65 West 70th Street Fee History Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount Review motions; extensive research in preparation for oral argument. 03/30/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $29.00 Assisted Nativ Winiarsky with arranging for the retrieval of legal research from law library. 03/31/2016 Rhoden, Curtis 0.80 $85.00 $68.00 Ordered records from Law Library. 03/31/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Followup with court clerk regarding retrieval of legal research for Nativ Winiarsky. 04/01/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 2.50 $ $1, Research and preparation for oral argument. 04/01/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Assisted Nativ Winiarsky by providing copies of case law; assembled and organized file folders per Nativ Winiarsky's instructions. 04/04/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 3.25 $ $1, Review of cases; documents; preparation for oral argument. 04/04/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Assisted Nativ Winiarsky with legal research and preparing for court appearance. 04/05/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 4.50 $ $1, Preparation for oral argument; oral argument; court appearance. 04/06/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 1.00 $ $ Review billings; phone call to opposing counsel; correspondence to opposing counsel; review transcript; phone call to stenographer; review motion for purposes of proposed order; outline order for Shogik. 04/06/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.75 $ $ Review and edit order. 04/06/2016 King, James M $85.00 $76.50 Obtained transcript of trial from court reporters at Ny Supreme Ct. 04/06/2016 Young, Valerie M $ $29.00 Contacted court reporter to order transcript from court appearance dated 4/5/ /06/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Discussion with N. Winiarsky re draft of proposed order; began drafting proposed order. 04/07/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.75 $ $ Review and edit order. Friday, July DB, /12

8 : Kueker & Bruh, LLP Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street Fee History Date Employee/ Description Hours Rate Amount 04/07/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Received instructions from Nativ Winiarsky regarding redaction of documents. 04/07/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Drafted proposed order; discussion with N.Winiarsky; phone call to court. 04/08/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $80.00 Phone call to court part clerk reosettlement of order. 04/14/2016 Kueker, Alan D $ $ Legal research regarding guarantor's location. 04/14/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $80.00 Phone call to court reoshort form order; correspondence. 04/20/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $80.00 Numerous phone calls to court reo short form order. 04/21/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /25/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /26/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /26/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Prepared stipulation to settle transcript; phone call to court clerk & opposing counsel. 04/27/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /27/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 1.20 $ $ Research statutes regarding proposed orders and settlement of transcript; edit stipulation; phone calls to and from opposing counsel; correspondence to and from opposing counsel. 05/02/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ correspondence with opposing counsel. 05/04/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ correspondence with opposing counsel. 05/05/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.35 $ $ Correspondence to and from opposing counsel; phone calls to and from client; review and edit proposed order. 05/05/2016 King, James M $85.00 $76.50 Obtained trial transcript from Supreme Ct, Court Reporters. 05/05/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Friday, July 08, /12

9 'j Kueker & Bruh, LLP Columbus Avenue a/kja 65 West 70th Street Fee Historv Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount Drafted notice of settlement; correspondence with opposing counsel; phone call with opposing counsel; correspondence with court reporter; phone call with part clerk; assembled notice of settlement, proposed order, settlement of transcript and transcript for e-filing and court submission. 05/06/2016 Biamby, Tamara 0.40 $ $58.00 Prepared litigation covers and assembled notice of settlement. 05/06/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.50 $ $ Phone calls to and from opposing counsel; correspondence to and from opposing counsel. 05/06/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Correspondence to opposing counsel enclosing settlement. 05/06/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $80.00 Efiled notice of settlement of order; instructions to paralegal reo service. 05/09/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $40.00 E-filed documents online. 05/10/2016 King, James M $85.00 $93.50 Filed Notice of Settlement with Proposed Order. 05/11/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 1.50 $ $ Phone calls and from opposing counsel; review of from opposing counsel seeking to explain why judgment amount should be amended; review affidavit and determination of judgment amount. 05/16/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.35 $ $ Review and edit correspondence to court and review affidavit from opposing counsel. 05/16/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $80.00 Received and reviewed proposed counter-order. 05/16/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $40.00 Phone call from opposing counsel. 05/16/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Drafted two letters to the judge in opposition to defendants' proposed counter-order; converted documents to pdf format for e- filing; e-filed documents. 06/02/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /03/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /03/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Friday, July 08, /12

10 Columbus Avenue a/kla 65 West 70th Street Fee Historv Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount Drafted correspondence attorney. to judge; phone conversation with court 06/06/2016 King, James M $85.00 $85.00 Delivered documents to Judge Ramos chambers. 06/07/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.10 $ $ /07/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $14.50 Provided copy of case-related documentation to Nativ Winiarsky. 06/07/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Reviewed correspondence from court & signed order; prepared notice of entry; efiled notice of entry; instructions to paralegal. 06/08/2016 Biamby, Tamara 0.30 $ $43.50 Prepared litigation covers and assembled notice of entry along with confirmation notice. 06/08/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Phone conversation with court clerk; phone conversation with court referee's office; researched online for special referee information sheet and instructions regarding filing for referee. 06/15/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ 0.20 $ $ /15/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ correspondence with referee. 06/15/2016 Oganisyan, Shogik S $ $ Prepared and submitted application for referee; phone call with opposing counsel; correspondence with referee; phone call to court clerk; prepared judgment for filing. 06/16/2016 Biamby, Tamara 0.30 $ $43.50 Prepared litigation covers and assembled judgment. 06/17/2016 Rhoden, Curtis 1.30 $85.00 $ Attempted to entered Judgment. (to be resubmitted on 9/19/2016/returned Judgment to attorney, first attempt) 06/21/2016 Rhoden, Curtis 1.30 $85.00 $ Attempted to entered judgment. (second attempt) 06/22/2016 McCarthy, Peter J $ $ Received instructions from Nativ Winiarsky; printed out from electronic courts database, opposing counsel's motion, affirmation, memorandum of law and exhibits 1-19; velabound motion and memorandum of law. 06/24/2016 Rhoden, Curtis 0.80 $85.00 $68.00 Checked status of Judgment. Friday, July 08, /12

11 Columbus Avenue a/k/a 65 West 70th Street Fee History Date Employeel Description Hours Rate Amount 06/24/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ Review motion for reargument and renewal; correspondence to client; call to client; research re: CPLR 2221 and for reargument based upon miscalculation $ $1, /30/2016 Winiarsky, Nativ Research and draft of opposition to motion to reargue $ $2, Total Fees $ $60,497.0 Disbursement History Date Description Amount 08/20/ /28/ /28/ /28/ /28/ /31/ /31/ /31/ /01/ /01/ /30/ /30/ /30/ /01/ /01/ /31/ /31/ /31/ /31/ /31/ /31/ /01/ /06/ /16/ /17/ /30/2015 Court Fee Postage Postage Postage Postage Copy Lexis-Nexis Lexis-Nexis Copy Certified Copy Building Deed Lexis-Nexis Copy Copy Lexis-Nexis Request Judicial Intervention Court Fee Postage $ $4.87 $4.87 $1.35 $1.35 $25.00 $31.40 $4.20 $44.33 $10.68 $45.40 $5.00 $1.00 $8.00 $85.40 $38.20 $1.40 $53.80 $0.60 $24.90 $0.20 $ $95.00 $45.00 $1.35 $19.40 Friday, July 08, /12

12 Columbus Avenue a/kla 65 West 70th Street Disbursement Historv Date Description Amount 11/30/2015 Copy $ /30/2015 $ /01/2015 Lexis-Nexis $ /31/2016 Copy $ /29/2016 $ /29/2016 Copy $ /29/2016 $ /31/2016 $ /31/2016 Copy $ /01/2016 Lexis-Nexis $ /01/2016 Miscellaneous $ /06/2016 Stenographer's Fee $ /30/2016 $ /30/2016 $ /30/2016 Copy $ /30/2016 $ /01/2016 Lexis-Nexis $ /06/2016 Postage $ /31/2016 $ /31/2016 Copy $ /31/2016 $ /01/2016 Lexis-Nexis $ /30/2016 $ /30/2016 Copy $ /30/2016 $0.50 Total $2, Friday, July 08, /12