The Quality of Lawyer Consultation: What constitutes enough legal advice?
|
|
- Everett Hudson
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 The Quality of Lawyer Consultation: What constitutes enough legal advice? Part 1: R. v. Osmond (2007) BCCA 1 (the short version) by Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. I. Overview This is the first part of a research series that reviews complex, contradicting right to counsel procedures centered on the British Columbia Court of Appeal decision in R. v. Osmond (2007). This paper includes a brief version of the actual case. The complete version of the Osmond decision will be explained in Part 2. Although the Osmond decision is binding only in British Columbia, it is persuasive in other provinces. The 5 key points of the case are: A 13 year-old girl was beaten to death. DNA evidence linked the accused to the crime scene. The accused was arrested and informed of his right to counsel. Legal Aid was contacted and a Legal Aid lawyer gave him advice in less than 5 minutes. The accused confessed. The BCCA excluded the confession because: the Legal Aid advice was insufficient, constituting a sec. 10(b) Charter violation The Osmond decision relates to a continuum of cases explained in this article. II. Commentary Keep in mind when you read this series that: i. the accused person confessed to beating a 13-year old girl to death. ii. DNA evidence linked the accused person to the crime scene. iii. the police followed the right to counsel procedures that existed at the time. Regardless, you will realize, as you read, that the victim is forgotten. The fact that the accused confessed to beating a 13-year old girl, the focus of the decision is on the inadequate quality of legal advice given to the suspect. The legal consultation took less than 5 minutes to communicate. Somehow, the police were expected to know that the advice was inadequate even though the lawyer-client communication is privileged. This decision is an outrage. The decision cannot be defended intellectually and morally for three reasons: i. courts make up rules after the fact, not before. In this case, the police did what they were supposed to do. They informed the accused of the Brydges component of the right to counsel and they allowed the suspect to exercise the Brydges component. However, the British Columbia Court of Appeal 1 R. v. Osmond (2007) B.C.C.A. 470 (CanLII).
2 said the quality of the Legal Aid advice was not up to par because the accused was unsophisticated. If the police are supposed to monitor the quality of legal consultation given to a suspect, then Parliament should clearly legislate those rules and actually print them into section 10(b) Charter. A clear rulebook is needed before an expected performance. The operative word is clear. ii. The inconsistent application of sec. 24(2) Charter has reached a critical stage. In Canada, the potential admissibility of evidence is completely unpredictable because of the extremely diverse methodology used in applying sec. 24(2) Charter. iii. The Osmond decision creates a changing multi-tiered set of police obligations regarding how to inform and exercise the right to counsel procedures. Police obligations vary according to what the suspect knows and what the suspect has done. The BCCA expects the right to counsel procedure to be dependent on the combined effect of: (a) the accused person s level of sophistication (b) the actual quality of the legal advice given to the accused, and (c) the severity of the offence. This expectation has absolutely no air of reality. Expecting the police to determine the quality of the legal advice given to a suspect is absurd because it creates an unrealistic legal advice disclosure dual-obligation: i) First, the suspect would have to disclose the legal advice to the police. Assuming this were to happen, by what standard would the police judge the advice adequate or not? There is no concrete definition of adequate legal advice in law. ii) Secondly, what if the suspect refuses to disclose the privileged communication? How exactly should the police determine the actual content? Are they obliged to question the suspect to extract the information and also evaluate the suspect s level of sophistication? Is there a sophistication test that police can use on a suspect? III. The Continuum The Osmond decision fits within the following continuum of 10 case law rules: R. v. Black (1989) SCC 2 Rule #1:. it is improper for a court to speculate about the type of legal advice which would have been given had the accused actually succeeded in contacting counsel after the charge was changed. Translation: A judge cannot conclude about: a. the quality of legal advice b. what might have been advised instead of what was advised Judges have to stick to what was, not what could have been. 2 R. v. Black (1989) 50 C.C.C. (3d) 1 (S.C.C.)
3 R. v. Ekman (2000) BCCA 3 & R. v. Griffin (2005) Q.C.C.S. 4 (Rule #2 & #3): Rule #2: After an arrested person has consulted with a lawyer and invokes the right to silence, the police are allowed to: (i) question him, and (ii) persuade him to change his mind and to confess. Translation: After a lawyer advises an arrested person to not talk to the police, the police may still question the arrested person and try to change his mind. A lawyer s advice to a client to remain silent does not prohibit an interrogation. Rule #3: An accused does not have an absolute right to the presence of counsel at a police interrogation. However, an accused does have the right to choose not to speak to the police in the absence of counsel. Translation: Does an adult offender have the right to have a lawyer present during a custodial interrogation? No. There are 2 types of interrogation environments; custodial interrogation, where the suspect is under arrest; non-custodial interrogation by consent the suspect is not detained. He is free to leave at any time during the interrogation. Offenders are classified by age: adult (18 years and older) and young offender (12-17 years). The right to have a lawyer present during custodial interrogation differs for young offenders. They have the right to decide whether a lawyer will be present young offenders are the decision-makers regarding the issue of a lawyer s presence. R. v. Osmond (2007) BCCA 5 : Rule #4: Inadequate legal aid advice to an unsophisticated person arrested for murder constitutes a sec. 10(b) Charter violation. In the Osmond case, this violation was severe enough to exclude the accused s confession of beating a 13 year-old girl to death. R. v. Willier (2008) ABCA 6 : (Rules #5 - #9) Rule #5: The police do not have a duty, or ability, to monitor the quality of [legal] advice received by a detained person in any particular case. Translation: The Alberta Court of Appeal disagrees with the BCCA s decision in Osmond. Rule #6: The police s responsibilities on arrest do not vary depending on the tactical abilities of, or the strategy adopted by the detained person. If a tactical maneuver by the accused (e.g., feigning no reason to consult counsel) does not work, that does not entitle him to start over and try another approach (e.g., arguing that his right to counsel has been violated). 3 R. v. Ekman (2000) 146 C.C.C. (3d) 346 (B.C.C.A.). 4 R. v. Griffin (2005) Q C C.S (CanLII). 5 Supra note R. v. Willier (2008) A.B.C.A. 126 (CanLII).
4 Translation: a. The Alberta Court of Appeal again disagrees with the BCCA s decision in Osmond. b. the police obligation regarding the right to counsel procedure are the same in every case. They do not change depending on the accused s level of sophistication. Rule #7: Confessions should not be excluded because of systemic problems. Translation: Confessions should not be inadmissible if a provincial Legal Aid system does not work properly. A province s failure to have a properly working Legal Aid system should not result in the exclusion of confessions. Rule #8: Overwhelming case law says the police are entitled to outmanoeuvre an arrested person, even to the point of lying to him. Translation: Interrogation strategies are broad and wide-ranging, not narrow and restricted. Rule #9: confession. An interrogation that is not a fair contest does not exclude a Translation: It is not unlawful for the police to be smarter than the accused. If the interrogation is one-sided in favour of the police, the lack of intellectual competition by the accused does not exclude a confession. R. v. Sinclair (2008) BCCA 7 : Rule #10: If an arrested person calls Legal Aid and receives advice during a four minute consultation, there must be evidence proving that Legal Aid lawyer told the accused anything different from what another lawyer later advised. An inference, without evidence, that the accused did not get proper advice from Legal Aid will not constitute a sec. 10(b) Charter violation. An inference unsupported by any evidence that the accused would have been given different advice by another lawyer does not constitute a sec. 10(b) Charter violation. Translation: Another court disagreed with the Osmond decision. Concrete evidence is needed to prove that legal advice was insufficient. Inference alone is not enough to prove inadequate legal advice. IV. Part 1 Conclusion Part 1 summarized the 10 case law rules that relate to the issue of adequate legal advice. Part 2 will explain the full Osmond decision with respect to what constitutes adequate legal advise. Also contained in Part 2 in a literature review of case law relevant to right to silence and the right to legal advise, beginning with Hebert (1990). 7 R. v. Sinclair (2008) B.C.C.A. 127 (CanLII).
5 Questions and comments are invited. The author, Gino Arcaro, may be contacted electronically at
No free trade of constitutional rights. Canada will not adopt the American rulebook on Miranda Rights.
Oct. 8, 2010 Landmark Decision Day Part 1 by Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. No free trade of constitutional rights. Canada will not adopt the American rulebook on Miranda Rights. On Oct. 8, 2010, the Supreme
More informationRelationship between Polygraph, Right to Counsel, and Confessions: R. v. Chalmers (2009) 1 Ontario Court of Appeal By Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc.
Relationship between Polygraph, Right to Counsel, and Confessions: R. v. Chalmers (2009) 1 Ontario Court of Appeal By Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. I. The polygraph paradox A polygraph test is both part of
More informationYoung offender confessions: right versus required. R. v. S.S. (2007) Ont. C.A. 1. By Gino Arcaro B.Sc., M.Ed
Young offender confessions: right versus required R. v. S.S. (2007) Ont. C.A. 1 By Gino Arcaro B.Sc., M.Ed I. Sec. 146(2)(b)(iv) and sec. 146(6) YCJA Among the numerous controversies surrounding young
More informationProsper Warning: Part 2. R. v. Weeseekase(2007) 1. By Gino Arcaro B.Sc., M.Ed. I. Executive Summary
Prosper Warning: Part 2 R. v. Weeseekase(2007) 1 By Gino Arcaro B.Sc., M.Ed. I. Executive Summary This is the second of a two-part series on the application of the Prosper Warning in cases where an arrested
More informationThe Quality of Lawyer Consultation: What constitutes enough legal advice?
The Quality of Lawyer Consultation: What constitutes enough legal advice? Part 2: R. v. Osmond (2007) BCCA 1 (the long version) by Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. I. The short version Part 1 explained, briefly,
More informationPreparation and Planning: Interviewers are taught to properly prepare and plan for the interview and formulate aims and objectives.
In 1984 Britain introduced the Police and Criminal Evidence Act of 1984 (PACE) and the Codes of Practice for police officers which eventually resulted in a set of national guidelines on interviewing both
More informationInvestigative Negligence. Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Services Board (2007)
Investigative Negligence Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Services Board (2007) By Gino Arcaro M.Ed., B.Sc. Niagara College Coordinator Police Foundations Program I. Commentary Part 1 Every police
More informationSelected Developments in Criminal Law. Prof. Vanessa MacDonnell
Selected Developments in Criminal Law and Evidence 2010 2011 Prof. Vanessa MacDonnell Selected Developments in Criminal Law & Evidence: Overview SCC clarified the nature and scope of the s. 10(b) right
More informationI WANT MY LAWYER : RIGHT TO COUNSEL DURING A CUSTODIAL INTERVIEW
I WANT MY LAWYER : RIGHT TO COUNSEL DURING A CUSTODIAL INTERVIEW These materials were prepared by Megan Street, Crown Counsel, Vancouver, BC, for the CBA National Criminal Justice Conference, Seven, Eight,
More informationSAN DIEGO POLICE DEPARTMENT PROCEDURE
SAN DIEGO POLICE DEPARTMENT PROCEDURE DATE: MARCH 1, 2013 NUMBER: SUBJECT: RELATED POLICY: ORIGINATING DIVISION: 4.03 LEGAL ADMONITION PROCEDURES N/A INVESTIGATIONS II NEW PROCEDURE: PROCEDURAL CHANGE:
More informationSECTION 8 UNREASONABLE SEARCH & SEIZURE
SECTION 8 UNREASONABLE SEARCH & SEIZURE : Did X violate Y s section 8 rights when they searched? : Section 8 states that everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure. The
More informationAlberta (Attorney General) v. Krushell, 2003 ABQB 252 Date: Action No
Alberta (Attorney General) v. Krushell, 2003 ABQB 252 Date: 20030318 Action No. 0203 19075 IN THE COURT OF QUEEN'S BENCH OF ALBERTA JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF EDMONTON IN THE MATTER OF the Freedom of Information
More informationOntario Justice Education Network
1 Ontario Justice Education Network Section 10 of the Charter Section 10 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms states: Everyone has the right on arrest or detention (a) (b) to be informed promptly
More informationPolice interviews. Role of the Responsible Adult or Independent Person
Police interviews Role of the Responsible Adult or Independent Person Role of the Responsible Adult or Independent Person at police interviews with a child or young person (under 18) This fact sheet is
More informationDecision adopted by the Committee at its fifty-second session, 28 April 23 May Sergei Kirsanov (not represented by counsel)
United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment Distr.: General 19 June 2014 CAT/C/52/D/478/2011 Original: English Committee against Torture Communication
More informationOrder F11-23 BRITISH COLUMBIA LOTTERY CORPORATION. Michael McEvoy, Adjudicator. August 22, 2011
Order F11-23 BRITISH COLUMBIA LOTTERY CORPORATION Michael McEvoy, Adjudicator August 22, 2011 Quicklaw Cite: [2011] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 29 CanLII Cite: 2011 BCIPC No. 29 Document URL: http://www.oipc.bc.ca/orders/2011/orderf11-23.pdf
More informationOrder F10-01 GREATER VANCOUVER REGIONAL DISTRICT. Michael McEvoy, Adjudicator. January 7, 2010
Order F10-01 GREATER VANCOUVER REGIONAL DISTRICT Michael McEvoy, Adjudicator January 7, 2010 Quicklaw Cite: [2010] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 1 CanLII Cite: 2010 BCIPC 1 Document URL: http://www.oipc.bc.ca/orders/2010/orderf10-01.pdf
More informationModule 1: Fundamentals of Law
Module 1: Fundamentals of Law Section 1.1: The Nature of Law Lesson 1.1A: Law: Definition and Purposes Lesson 1.1B: The Relationship Between Laws and Morals Lesson 1.1C: Important Legal Terms Section 1.2:
More informationThe learner can: 1.1 Explain the requirements of a lawful arrest.
Unit 11 Title: Criminal Litigation Level: 3 Credit Value: 7 Learning outcomes The learner will: 1 Understand the powers of the police to arrest and detain a person for the purpose of investigating a criminal
More informationSection 810. This booklet explains the 810 process, what your rights are and how to get legal help.
INFORMATION FOR FEDERAL PRISONERS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA Section 810 The Criminal Code of Canada allows a judge or justice of the peace to require you to enter into a recognizance (like a peace bond) if there
More informationCRIMINAL LAW PROFESSIONAL STANDARD #2
CRIMINAL LAW PROFESSIONAL STANDARD #2 NAME OF STANDARD A GUILTY PLEA Brief Description of Standard: A standard on the steps to be taken by counsel before entering a guilty plea on behalf of a client. Committee
More informationDr Vicky Kemp Visiting Scholar University of Nottingham
Dr Vicky Kemp Visiting Scholar University of Nottingham From Suspect to Trial: The aphorism that trial starts at the police station is now more true than ever... It is not only what the suspect does say,
More informationSUPREME COURT OF CANADA. CITATION: R. v. Punko, 2012 SCC 39 DATE: DOCKET: 34135, 34193
SUPREME COURT OF CANADA CITATION: R. v. Punko, 2012 SCC 39 DATE: 20120720 DOCKET: 34135, 34193 BETWEEN: AND BETWEEN: John Virgil Punko Appellant and Her Majesty The Queen Respondent Randall Richard Potts
More informationCHAPTER TWO: YOUTH JUSTICE
CHAPTER TWO: YOUTH JUSTICE TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER TWO: YOUTH JUSTICE... 1 I. INTRODUCTION... 1 A. LSLAP AND YOUTH JUSTICE... 1 B. HISTORY OF LEGISLATIVE CHANGES... 1 II. GOVERNING LEGISLATION AND RESOURCES...
More informationPolice Station Advice Advising on Silence
6873 Crim Practitioners Guide 13/1/06 3:55 pm Page 1 Police Station Advice Advising on Silence by Professor Ed Cape on behalf of the Law Society Criminal Law Committee Criminal Practitioners Newsletter
More informationSUPREME COURT OF CANADA
SUPREME COURT OF CANADA CITATION: R. v. Willier, 2010 SCC 37 DATE: 20101008 DOCKET: 32769 BETWEEN: Stanley James Willier Appellant and Her Majesty The Queen Respondent - and - Attorney General of Ontario,
More informationServices for Albertans
Services for Albertans 2 Vision An Alberta where everyone can access justice and achieve fair and lasting resolutions to their legal issues. Mission We are a leader in the provision of quality, efficient
More informationOrder F14-57 OFFICE OF THE POLICE COMPLAINT COMMISSIONER. Ross Alexander Adjudicator. December 23, 2014
Order F14-57 OFFICE OF THE POLICE COMPLAINT COMMISSIONER Ross Alexander Adjudicator December 23, 2014 CanLII Cite: 2014 BCIPC 61 Quicklaw Cite: [2014] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 61 Summary: A journalist requested
More informationThe learner can: 1.1 Explain the requirements of a lawful arrest.
Unit 11 Title: Criminal Litigation Level: 3 Credit Value: 7 Learning outcomes The learner will: 1 Understand the powers of the police to arrest and detain a person for the purpose of investigating a criminal
More informationOFFICE OF THE INFORMATION & PRIVACY COMMISSIONER for Prince Edward Island. Order No. FI Re: Department of Communities, Land, and Environment
OFFICE OF THE INFORMATION & PRIVACY COMMISSIONER for Prince Edward Island Order No. FI-16-004 Re: Department of Communities, Land, and Environment Prince Edward Island Information and Privacy Commissioner
More informationGiving Legal Advice at Police Stations: Practical Pointers
Giving Legal Advice at Police Stations: Practical Pointers November 2010 For further information contact Jodie Blackstock, Senior Legal Officer Email: jblackstock@justice.org.uk Tel: 020 7762 6436 JUSTICE,
More informationSUPREME COURT OF CANADA
SUPREME COURT OF CANADA CITATION: R. v. Sinclair, 2010 SCC 35 DATE: 20101008 DOCKET: 32537 BETWEEN: Trent Terrence Sinclair Appellant and Her Majesty The Queen Respondent - and - Attorney General of Ontario,
More informationThe learner can: 1.1 Explain the requirements of a lawful arrest.
Unit 11 Title: Criminal Litigation Level: 3 Credit Value: 7 Learning outcomes The learner will: 1 Understand the powers of the police to arrest and detain a person for the purpose of investigating a criminal
More informationLevels of Police in Canada
Chapter 8 Levels of Police in Canada The Federal police force of Canada is the Royal Canadian Mounted Police which was formed in 1873 as the Northwest Mounted Police. The RCMP serves as provincial police
More informationIN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA Citation: British Columbia (Ministry of Justice) v. Maddock, 2015 BCSC 746 Date: 20150423 Docket: 14-3365 Registry: Victoria In the matter of the decisions of the
More informationYou re Nicked! UK Police Powers Compared. Laura Gillespie
You re Nicked! UK Police Powers Compared Laura Gillespie SCENARIO Builders Ltd is a construction firm operating across the UK. A large construction project is underway. It s an exciting job. John Smith,
More informationPolicy of the Provincial Court of British Columbia
Information Regarding Bans on Publication Policy Effective Date: Policy Code: February 28, 2011 ACC-3 Scope of Application: Applies to Provincial Court of proceedings. Purpose of Policy To provide a general
More informationIf you wish to understand it further, please consult my more detailed and articulated analysis.
Greetings! and thank you for consulting my legal self-defence kit. Print a copy It is free of charge, but it comes with instructions and warnings and advice. Equipment required: a printer with paper, a
More informationWhen should members of the Canadian Forces (CF) retain private legal counsel, and how should such counsel be employed?
When should members of the Canadian Forces (CF) retain private legal counsel, and how should such counsel be employed? Lieutenant-Colonel (retired) Rory Fowler, CD, BComm, LL.B., LL.M. Cunningham, Swan,
More informationReport A August 17, Legal Aid Commission of Newfoundland and Labrador
eport A-2018-019 August 17, 2018 Legal Aid Commission of Newfoundland and Labrador Summary: The Applicant requested from the Legal Aid Commission invoices and details of payments to lawyers from the private
More informationACCESS TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE Divergent Trends in the Legal Profession DISCLOSURE REVISITED
ACCESS TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE Divergent Trends in the Legal Profession November 29, 2002 DISCLOSURE REVISITED Faculty: Anne Malick, Q.C. Speaking Notes Access to Solicitor/Client Privilegd Information-McClure
More informationChapter SECTION OPENER / CLOSER: INSERT BOOK COVER ART. Section 2.1 A Dual Court System
Chapter 2 SECTION OPENER / CLOSER: INSERT BOOK COVER ART Section 2.1 Chapter 2 A Dual The Court Court System System Section 2.1 Section 2.2 Trial Procedures Why It s Important Learning the structure of
More informationOrder F13-01 MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND MINISTRY OF CITIZENS SERVICES AND OPEN GOVERNMENT. Michael McEvoy, Assistant Commissioner.
Order F13-01 MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND MINISTRY OF CITIZENS SERVICES AND OPEN GOVERNMENT Quicklaw Cite: [2013] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 1 CanLII Cite: 2013 BCIPC No. 1 Michael McEvoy, Assistant Commissioner January
More informationOrder F17-46 UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA. Celia Francis Adjudicator. October 19, 2017
Order F17-46 UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA Celia Francis Adjudicator October 19, 2017 CanLII Cite: 2017 BCIPC 51 Quicklaw Cite: [2017] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 51 Summary: An applicant requested access to her
More informationMOZAMBIQUE SUBMISSION TO THE UNITED NATIONS COMMITTEE AGAINST TORTURE
MOZAMBIQUE SUBMISSION TO THE UNITED NATIONS COMMITTEE AGAINST TORTURE 51ST SESSION OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMITTEE AGAINST TORTURE (28 OCTOBER 22 NOVEMBER 2013) Amnesty International Publications First
More informationTable of Contents. CON-1 (Mental Disorder) (2013-3)
Table of Contents 1 INTRODUCTION... 1-1 1.1 HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE... 1-1 (a) Pre-1992 Amendments... 1-1 (b) The Reform Movement... 1-4 (c) The Swain Decision... 1-6 (d) The 1992 Amendments: Part XX.1
More informationHearsay confessions: probative value and prejudicial effect
Hearsay confessions: probative value and prejudicial effect Don Mathias Barrister, Auckland Hearsay confessions In order to raise a reasonable doubt about the accused s guilt, the defence may seek to call
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, UNPUBLISHED June 24, 2008 v No. 277652 Wayne Circuit Court SHELLY ANDRE BROOKS, LC No. 06-010881-01 Defendant-Appellant.
More informationThe Law Commission BAIL AND THE HUMAN RIGHTS ACT 1998 GUIDANCE FOR BAIL DECISION-TAKERS AND THEIR ADVISERS. (LAW COM No 269)
The Law Commission BAIL AND THE HUMAN RIGHTS ACT 1998 (LAW COM No 269) GUIDANCE FOR BAIL DECISION-TAKERS AND THEIR ADVISERS GUIDANCE FOR BAIL DECISION-TAKERS AND THEIR ADVISERS General principles applicable
More informationLEGAL RIGHTS - CRIMINAL - Right Against Self-Incrimination
IV. CONCLUDING OBSERVATIONS ICCPR United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, ICCPR, A/50/40 vol. I (1995) 72 at paras. 424 and 432. Paragraph 424 It is noted with concern that the provisions
More information3:00 A.M. THE MAGISTRATE THE JUVENILE THE STATEMENT KEEPING IT LEGAL
THE MAGISTRATE THE JUVENILE THE STATEMENT KEEPING IT LEGAL Kameron D. Johnson E:mail Kameron.johnson@co.travis.tx.us Presented by Ursula Hall, Judge, City of Houston 3:00 A.M. Who are Magistrates? U.S.
More informationAccountability, Independence and Consultation Director of Military Prosecutions Policy Directive
Accountability, Independence and Consultation Director of Military Prosecutions Policy Directive Directive #: 010/00 Original Date: 15 Mar 00 Subject: Accountability, Independence and Consultation Cross
More informationDocument references: Prior decisions - Special Rapporteur s rule 91 decision, dated 28 December 1992 (not issued in document form)
HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE Kulomin v. Hungary Communication No. 521/1992 16 March 1994 CCPR/C/50/D/521/1992 * ADMISSIBILITY Submitted by: Vladimir Kulomin Alleged victim: The author State party: Hungary Date
More informationPolice Newsletter, July 2015
1. Supreme Court of Canada rules on the constitutionality of warrantless cell phone and other digital device search and privacy. 2. On March 30, 2015, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled police officers
More informationINDEX. A Access and correction requests, see also Access to and correction of personal information. .. Part 8 of the Act, 110
INDEX The commentary entries in the index are referenced to page number. The legislation entries in the index are referenced to the section numbers of specific Acts and Regulations. Where the references
More informationHIP POCKET GUIDE TO SEARCHES AND INSPECTIONS OF VESSELS IN CANADA
HIP POCKET GUIDE TO SEARCHES AND INSPECTIONS Prepared by: Brad M. Caldwell Caldwell & Co. 401-815 Hornby Street Vancouver, B.C. V6Z 2E6 Tele: 604 689 8894 bcaldwell@admiraltylaw.com An abridged version
More informationA digest of twenty one (21) significant US Supreme Court decisions interpreting Miranda
From Miranda v. Arizona to Howes v. Fields A digest of twenty one (21) significant US Supreme Court decisions interpreting Miranda (1968 2012) In Miranda v. Arizona, the US Supreme Court rendered one of
More informationCriminal Pre-Trial Conference Pilot Project Evaluation Report
Criminal Pre-Trial Conference Pilot Project Evaluation Report January 18, 2012 The current members of the Criminal Law Sub-Committee are: Madam Justice Holmes (Chair) Associate Chief Justice Cullen Mr.
More informationThe Code. for Crown Prosecutors
The Code for Crown Prosecutors January 2013 Introduction 1.1 The Code for Crown Prosecutors (the Code) is issued by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) under section 10 of the Prosecution of Offences
More informationYOU VE been CHARGED. with a CRIME What YOU. NEED to KNOW
YOU VE been CHARGED with a CRIME What YOU NEED to KNOW 1 This booklet is intended to provide general information only. If you require specific legal advice, please consult the appropriate legislation or
More informationConflicts Of Interest
Conflicts Of Interest Dan MacDonald November 8, 2012 Today s Agenda What is the legal test that governs external counsel in analyzing conflicts of interest? Duty of Loyalty Three key SCC decisions and
More informationInternational Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
United Nations CCPR/C/100/D/1346/2005 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Distr.: Restricted * 28 October 2010 Original: English Human Rights Committee One hundredth session 11 to 29 October
More informationOrder F Ministry of Justice. Hamish Flanagan Adjudicator. March 18, 2015
Order F15-12 Ministry of Justice Hamish Flanagan Adjudicator March 18, 2015 CanLII Cite: 2015 BCIPC 12 Quicklaw Cite: [2015] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 12 Summary: The applicant requested records from the Ministry
More informationSUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Bruhm, 2018 NSSC 295. v. Austin James Douglas Bruhm. Voir Dire Decision
SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA Citation: R. v. Bruhm, 2018 NSSC 295 Date: 20181121 Docket: CRBW473972 Registry: Bridgewater Between: Her Majesty the Queen v. Austin James Douglas Bruhm Restriction on Publication
More informationINDEX. A Access and correction requests, see also Access to and correction of personal information. .. Part 8 of the Act, 115
INDEX The commentary entries in the index are referenced to page number. The legislation entries in the index are referenced to the section numbers of specific Acts and Regulations. Where the references
More informationCitation: R. v. R.C. (P.) Date: PESCTD 22 Docket: GSC Registry: Charlottetown
Citation: R. v. R.C. (P.) Date: 2000308 2000 PESCTD 22 Docket: GSC-17475 Registry: Charlottetown BETWEEN: AND: PROVINCE OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND IN THE SUPREME COURT - TRIAL DIVISION HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
More informationREVIEW REPORT FI December 29, 2015 Department of Finance
Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for Nova Scotia Report of the Commissioner (Review Officer) Catherine Tully REVIEW REPORT FI-13-28 December 29, 2015 Department of Finance Summary: The
More informationCivil Law is known as Private Law. Regulates disputes between individuals; between parties; and between individuals and parties.
Civil Disputes Civil Law is known as Private Law. Regulates disputes between individuals; between parties; and between individuals and parties. The main purpose of Civil Law is to compensate victims. Civil
More informationOrder F17-29 LAW SOCIETY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA. Celia Francis Adjudicator. May 11, 2017
Order F17-29 LAW SOCIETY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA Celia Francis Adjudicator May 11, 2017 CanLII Cite: 2017 BCIPC 31 Quicklaw Cite: [2017] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 31 Summary: An applicant requested access to records
More informationThe Interrogation Trilogy and the Protections for Interrogated Suspects in Canadian Law
The Supreme Court Law Review: Osgoode s Annual Constitutional Cases Conference Volume 54 (2011) Article 11 The Interrogation Trilogy and the Protections for Interrogated Suspects in Canadian Law Lisa Dufraimont
More informationIN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO. v. NO. 29,570. APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF LEA COUNTY Gary L. Clingman, District Judge
0 0 This memorandum opinion was not selected for publication in the New Mexico Reports. Please see Rule -0 NMRA for restrictions on the citation of unpublished memorandum opinions. Please also note that
More information"SOME THOUGHTS ON GUILTY PLEAS AND SENTENCING"
"SOME THOUGHTS ON GUILTY PLEAS AND SENTENCING" ( ( )',~- These materials were prepared by Patrick Reis, of Saskatchewan Legal Aid Commission (Regina Rural Office) Regina, Saskatchewan for thesaskatchewan
More informationIN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS * CUYAHOGA COUNTY, OHTO. The indictment
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS * CUYAHOGA COUNTY, OHTO THE STATE OF OHIO, Plaintiff, :VS- JAMES SPARKS-HENDERSON Defendant. ) ) JUDGE JOHN P. O'DONNELL ) ) JUDGMENT ENTRY DENYING ) THE DEFENDANT S ) MOTION
More informationNational Policing Position Statement: Pre-Interview Briefings. With Legal Advisers and Information to be Supplied to Unrepresented Detainees
National Policing Position Statement: Pre-Interview Briefings With Legal Advisers and Information to be Supplied to Unrepresented Detainees National Investigative Interviewing Strategic Steering Group
More informationMULTI CHOICE QUESTIONS EVI301-A
MULTI CHOICE QUESTIONS EVI301-A 2010 Second Semester Assignment 1 Question 1 If the current South African law does not provide a solution to an evidentiary problem, our courts will first of all search
More informationYouth Criminal Justice Act
Page 1 of 92 Youth Criminal Justice Act ( 2002, c. 1 ) Disclaimer: These documents are not the official versions (more). Act current to September 3rd, 2008 Attention: See coming into force provision and
More informationMANDATORY MINIMUM SENTENCES: HANDCUFFING THE PRISONER OR THE JUDGE?
MANDATORY MINIMUM SENTENCES: HANDCUFFING THE PRISONER OR THE JUDGE?.THE CANADIAN EXPERIENCE SO FAR American Judges Association, Annual Educational Conference October 7, 2014 Las Vegas, Nevada Judge Catherine
More informationIN THE YOUTH COURT AT AUCKLAND CRN: [2017] NZYC 375. NEW ZEALAND POLICE Prosecutor. H C Young Person
NOTE: NO PUBLICATION OF A REPORT OF THIS PROCEEDING IS PERMITTED UNDER S 438 OF THE CHILDREN, YOUNG PERSONS, AND THEIR FAMILIES ACT 1989, EXCEPT WITH THE LEAVE OF THE COURT THAT HEARD THE PROCEEDINGS,
More informationMEMORANDUM TO COUNCIL
MEMORANDUM TO COUNCIL From: Lawrence Rubin Date: March 23, 2018 Subject: Professional Standards (Criminal) Committee Standard No. 3: Defence Obligations Regarding Disclosure FOR: APPROVAL INTRODUCTION
More informationCCPR/C/101/D/1517/2006
United Nations International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights CCPR/C/101/D/1517/2006 Distr.: Restricted * 28 April 2011 Original: English Human Rights Committee One hundredth and first session 14
More informationA review of laws and policies to prevent and remedy violence against children in police and pre-trial detention in Bangladesh
A review of laws and policies to prevent and remedy violence against children in police and pre-trial detention in Bangladesh Summary Report 1. INTRODUCTION Violence against children who are deprived of
More informationOFFICE OF THE INFORMATION & PRIVACY COMMISSIONER for Prince Edward Island. Order No. FI Re: Department of Communities, Land and Environment
OFFICE OF THE INFORMATION & PRIVACY COMMISSIONER for Prince Edward Island Order No. FI-17-011 Re: Department of Communities, Land and Environment July 13, 2017 Prince Edward Island Information and Privacy
More informationOrder F16-44 BC CORONERS SERVICE. Celia Francis Adjudicator. September 21, 2016
Order F16-44 BC CORONERS SERVICE Celia Francis Adjudicator September 21, 2016 CanLII Cite: 2016 BCIPC 48 Quicklaw Cite: [2016] B.C.I.P.C.D. No. 48 Summary: An applicant requested access to records of communications
More informationWitness protection program: The repentant experience in Québec, Canada *
Witness protection program: The repentant experience in Québec, Canada * The witness protection program Quebec, is part of a broader process that, as a rule, provides for the use of repentant witnesses
More informationTo provide a continuum of innovative and cost effective legal services for people in need throughout Alberta.
To provide a continuum of innovative and cost effective legal services for people in need throughout Alberta. Effective on Certificates Issued on or after November 1, 2009 Table of Contents Introduction...1
More informationCROSS AND TAPPER ON EVIDENCE
CROSS AND TAPPER ON EVIDENCE Twelfth edition COLIN TAPPER, MA, BCL Emeritus Professor of Law, University of Oxford OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS CONTENTS Preface to the 12th edition v Extractfrom the preface
More informationIN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA JUNIOR JOSEPH, ) ) Appellee/Petitioner, ) ) 5th DCA Case No. 5D09-1356 ) ) Supreme Court Case No. SC11-179 STATE OF FLORIDA,) ) Appellant/Respondent. ) ) APPEAL
More informationSubmissions to the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration
Submissions to the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration By Justice for Children and Youth Regarding Bill C-6 An Act to Amend the Citizenship Act 8 April 2016 About Justice for Children and
More informationThe Charter of Rights and Freedoms Part of our written constitution
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms Part of our written constitution The text for this document was taken from the Youth Guide to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms - English Edition published
More informationIN BRIEF SECTION 1 OF THE CHARTER AND THE OAKES TEST
THE CHARTER AND THE OAKES TEST Learning Objectives To establish the importance of s. 1 in both ensuring and limiting our rights. To introduce students to the Oakes test and its important role in Canadian
More informationAMNESTY INTERNATIONAL
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL SRI LANKA @PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION AFFECTING FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS January 1991 SUMMARY AI INDEX: ASA 37/01/91 DISTR: SC/CO The Government of Sri Lanka has published
More informationADULT CRIMINAL COURT STATISTICS, 1999/00
Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 85-002-XIE Vol. 21 no. 2 ADULT CRIMINAL COURT STATISTICS, 1999/00 by Liisa Pent 1 HIGHLIGHTS In the fiscal year 1999/00, adult criminal courts in 9 provinces and territories
More informationRoster Lawyers Tariff of Fees
Roster Lawyers Tariff of Fees December 7, 2015 Schedule 2 Roster Lawyers Tariff of Fees Table of Contents 1. Criminal Certificates 20 2. Criminal Appeal Certificates 27 3. Civil Certificates 30 4. Administrative
More informationONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN: COURT FILE No.: District Municipality of Muskoka #07-354 Citation: R. v. Andrews, 2008 ONCJ 599 ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN AND DANNY ANDREWS Before Justice Wm. G. Beatty Heard
More informationSEARCH & SEIZURE IN CANADA. A comprehensive guide on gun owners rights and obligations. including case law reviews edition
SEARCH & SEIZURE IN CANADA A comprehensive guide on gun owners rights and obligations including case law reviews 2018 edition INVESTIGATIVE TECHNIQUES OF POLICE OFFICERS The police use their powers in
More informationDelegations will find in the Annex a note by Belgium, France, Ireland, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom relating to the proposed Directive.
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 22 September 2011 14495/11 Interinstitutional File: 2011/0154 (COD) DROIPEN 99 COPEN 232 CODEC 1492 NOTE from : to : No. Prop. : No. Prev. doc. : Subject : General
More informationCriminal Law Guidebook Second Edition Chapter 3: The Criminal Justice System and Criminal Procedure
The following is a suggested solution to the problem question on page 69. It represents an answer of an above average standard. The ILAC approach to problem-solving as set out in the How to Answer Questions
More informationConvention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
UNITED NATIONS CAT Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment COMMITTEE AGAINST TORTURE Fortieth session 28 April 16 May 2008 Distr. GENERAL 8 April 2008 Original:
More informationThis section covers coordination of services between agencies and the youth correctional system. STANDARDS
Child and Family Services PROGRAM STANDARDS MANUAL Section: 701 Effective: Oct 1/88 Revised: Sep 20/99 Page: 1 Subject: SERVICES TO YOUNG OFFENDERS This section covers coordination of services between
More informationSay What?! A Review of Recent U.S. Supreme Court 5 th Amendment Self-incrimination Case Law
Say What?! A Review of Recent U.S. Supreme Court 5 th Amendment Self-incrimination Case Law POPPI RITACCO Attorney Advisor / Senior Instructor State and Local Training Division Federal Law Enforcement
More information