Transcription

1 Case Summary Case No CA O H, Cet al. vs. JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MDet al. Related Case Information Related Cases 2004-CP O (Civil Action) Parties Converted Financial Data CONVERSION CA - Malpractice - Case Type: Medical Date Filed: 02/09/2004 Location: Div 34 Judicial Kest, John Marshall Officer: Uniform CA001202A001OX Case Number: Lead Attorneys Defendant JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD FJ Sep ROBERT J NESMITH, Esquire Retained (W) Defendant ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC FJ Sep ROBERT J NESMITH, Esquire Retained (W) Defendant RANDALL B WHITNEY MD bk JOSEPH P MENELLO, Esquire Retained (W) Plaintiff H, C

2 Plaintiff STALLEY, DOUGLAS B JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ, Esquire Trustee THE CENTER FOR SPECIAL NEEDS TRUST ADMINISTRATION Docket List DISPOSITIONS 05/17/2005 Order Denying 11/22/2005 Order Denying 02/06/2006 Order Denying 02/10/2006 Order Granting 02/15/2006 Order Granting 07/24/2006 Order Granting 09/20/2006 Final Judgment Retained (W) 06/23/2010 Suggestion of Bankruptcy (Judicial Officer: Turner, Thomas A) Comment (3:09-bk-10170) 07/20/2010 Notice of Dropping Party (Judicial Officer: Turner, Thomas A) 07/22/2011 Final Judgment (Judicial Officer: Kest, John Marshall) Comment ($18,000, sent to rec 7/26) 07/22/2011 Final Judgment (Judicial Officer: Kest, John Marshall) Comment ($18,737, sent to rec 7/26) OTHER EVENTS AND HEARINGS 02/09/2004 Initial Judge Assigned Initial Judge Assigned INITIAL JUDGE ASSIGNED GRINCEWICZ, D E 34 02/09/2004 Complaint Complaint COMPLAINT FILED 02/09/2004 Civil Cover Sheet Civil Cover Sheet CIVIL COVER SHEET FILED 02/09/2004 Summons Issued Summons Issued SUMMONS ISSUED (3) (ORIG TO ATTY) 02/24/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 02/24/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories

3 Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTFS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES 02/24/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO DEFT RANDALL B WHITNEY MD 02/24/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTFS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES 02/24/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO DEFT JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 02/24/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTFS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES 03/03/2004 Acceptance of Service Acceptance of Service ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE FOR DEFTS 03/16/2004 Answer & Affirmative Defenses Answer & Affirmative Defenses ANSWER & AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES 03/16/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFTS 03/16/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO DOUGLAS STALLEY 03/29/2004 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) Notice of Taking Deposition NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO OF CAROL HOWARD 10:00 AM 04/02/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER 04/02/2004 Petition/Motion to Strike Petition/Motion to Strike PLTF MOTION TO STRIKE FIFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE 04/02/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO RANDALL WHITNEY MD 04/02/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD 04/06/2004 Reply to Affirmative Defenses Reply to Affirmative Defenses PLTFS REPLY TO DEFTS ANSWER & AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES 04/06/2004 Motion to Amend Motion to Amend DEFTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND ANSWER 04/15/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce ORLANDO WOMENS RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE

4 04/15/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PENDERGRAFT RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 04/15/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce WHITNEY RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 05/05/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories PLTFS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 05/11/2004 Notice Notice NOTICE OF VACATION OF DEFT'S ATTY 05/13/2004 Motion to Withdraw Motion to Withdraw MOTION FOR WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL 05/13/2004 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF RECORD PICK UP 06/03 10 DEPONENTS M-05/11 05/25/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories PLTF NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 05/25/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PLTF RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 05/26/2004 Request for Copies Request for Copies PLTF REQUEST FOR COPIES 05/28/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTFS SUPPLEMENTAL REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFTS 06/04/2004 Motion to Amend Motion to Amend PLTF MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT 06/04/2004 Certificate Certificate CERTIFICATE OF NON-OBJECTION OF NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTY (10) 06/07/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 06/07/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 06/09/2004 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing PLTF NOTICE OF FILING ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 06/09/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE SERVICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES TO RANDALL B WHITNEY MD 06/09/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE SERVICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES TO ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 06/11/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories

5 Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTFS NOTICE OF SERVING INSURANCE INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 06/11/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES PROPOUNDED TO DEFT JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 06/11/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVING ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES PROPOUNDED TO DEFT RANDALL B WHITNEY MD 06/14/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 06/22/2004 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING EXPARTE 07/23/ :00 A.M. 06/24/2004 Amended Notice of Hearing Amended Notice of Hearing AMENDED NOTICE EX PARTE HEARING 07/29/ :00 A.M. 06/29/2004 Notice of Compliance Notice of Compliance DEFTS JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV & ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE W/COPIES (7) 07/02/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PLTF SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 07/12/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories ORLANDO WOMENS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 07/12/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories ORLANDO WOMENS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES 07/14/2004 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DEFT ORLANDO WORMENS CENTER INC NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO SUPOLEMENTAL INTERROG 07/14/2004 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) Notice of Taking Deposition NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION OF JOEL FRASURE 8/12 10:00 AM 07/19/2004 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel STALLEY MOTION TO COMPEL 07/20/2004 Order Granting Motion to Amend Order Granting Motion to Amend ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT 07/20/2004 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JENNIFER FERNANDEZ 07/22/2004 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel PLTF THIRD MOTION TO COMPEL

6 07/22/2004 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel PLTF SECOND MOTION TO COMPEL 07/22/2004 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel PLTF FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL 07/23/2004 Hearing Exparte (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) 07/27/2004 Notice Cancellation of Hearing Notice of Cancellation of Hearing NOTICE CANCELLATION OF HEARING 7/29 9:00 AM 07/27/2004 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING [09/08/2004] 03:00 P.M. 07/29/2004 Amended Notice of Exparte Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale) 07/30/2004 Answer & Affirmative Defenses Answer & Affirmative Defenses ANSWER & AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO AMENDED COMPLAINT BY RANDALL B WHITNE Y MD JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 08/18/2004 Petition/Motion to Strike Petition/Motion to Strike MOTION TO STRIKE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES 08/18/2004 Petition/Motion to Strike Petition/Motion to Strike MOTION TO STRIKE AND/OR REPLY AND AVOIDANCE TO ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO AMENDED COMPLAINT 08/20/2004 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO WHITNEY, PENDERGRAFT AND ORLANDO WOMENS 08/25/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF RANDALL WHITNEY MD ON 1:00 08/30/2004 Notice Notice WHITNEY, PENDERGRAFT & ORLANDO NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE 09/08/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF TANYA SEVERANCE ON 1:00 W/ATTACHMENTS 09/08/2004 Hearing (3:00 PM) (Judicial Officers Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale, Turner, Thomas A) 09/10/2004 Notice Cancellation of Hearing Notice of Cancellation of Hearing NOTICE CANCELLATION OF HEARING 3:00 09/13/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DAVELA CLERVEAU ON 12:30 09/13/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF JANET RAINER ON 10:30

7 09/17/2004 Notice Notice NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES BY RANDALL B WHITNEY MD J AMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 09/23/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC TANAY SEVERANCE ON 1:00 09/23/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC JANET RAINER ON 10:30 09/23/2004 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC DAVELA CLERVEAU ON 12:30 09/30/2004 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DAVELA CLERVEAU ON 09 12:30 10/07/2004 Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned to Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM DEPOSITION SERVED JANET RAINER 10/11/2004 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC AND JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 10/18/2004 Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned to Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM DEPO UNSERVED DAVELA CLERVEAU ISSUED BY ATTY 11/10/2004 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PENDERGRAFT AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 11/10/2004 Per the Court: Free PENDERGRAFT AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER PRIVILEGE LOG 01/07/2005 Motion Motion MOTION TO SEAL COURT FILE AND/OR REMOVE ITEMS FROM COURT FILE DOUGLAS STALLEY 01/10/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 01/11/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING EXPARTE 9:00 02/01/2005 Letter Letter LETTER FILED FROM ATTORNEY JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ 02/01/2005 Order Order ORDER DIRECTING CLERK TO REMOVE FROM THE COURT FILE CH MEDICAL RECORDS ATTACHED TO DEFTS RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE DATED 4/15/04 AND DESTROY THEM **MEDICAL RECORDS OF CH WERE DESTROYED ON 2/3/05 -- SEE RECEIPT** 02/02/2005 Response to Request to Produce

8 Response to Request to Produce ORLANDO WOMEN RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 02/03/2005 Receipt Receipt RECEIPT --FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF CH'S MEDICAL RECORDS ATTACHED TO DEFTS RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE DATED 4/15/04-- PER ORDER DATED 2/1/05 02/17/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING [05/02/2005] 11:15 A.M. 02/18/2005 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel STALLEY MOTION TO COMPEL 04/29/2005 Motion Motion MOTION FOR IN CAMERA INSPECTION OF AND TO COMPEL ITEMS IDENTIFIED IN DEFT PRIVILEGE LOG FILED BY DOUGLAS STALLEY 04/29/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF JANET RAINER 04/29/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF TANYA SEVERANCE 04/29/2005 Notice for Trial Notice for Trial NOTICE FOR TRIAL (JURY) (NO SASE) 04/29/2005 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF TANYA SEVERANCE (FILED IN DEPO FOLDER) (NEED ORDER AND SEAL FEE) 04/29/2005 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF JANET RAINER UNDER SEAL (FILED IN DEPO FOLDER) **SEE CLERKS NOTES** 05/02/2005 Hearing (11:15 AM) (Judicial Officers Evans, Robert M, Turner, Thomas A) 05/06/2005 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) Notice of Taking Deposition NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION OF JAMES PENDEGRAFT 05/10/2005 Objection Objection DEFTS RANDALL B WHITNEY MD, JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD, ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC OBJECTION TO PLTFS NOTICE FOR TRIAL 05/17/2005 Order Denying Order Denying ORDER DENYING DEFTS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 05/23/2005 Per the Court: Free SEALED ENVELOPE FILED (FROM JUDGE GRINCEWICZ) 06/01/2005 Letter Letter LETTER FILED FROM ATTORNEY JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ 06/01/2005 Order Granting Motion to Compel Order Granting Motion to Compel ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO COMPEL 06/07/2005 Order for Jury Trial Order for Jury Trial NOTICE/ORDER TRIAL JURY 9:00 & PRETRIAL 10:00 06/10/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC

9 OF JAMES PENDEGRAFT MD ON 1:00 WITH ATTACHMENTS 06/13/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce JAMES PENDERGRAFT AND ORLANDO WOMENS SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO DOUGLAS REQUEST TO PRODUCE 06/16/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING EXPARTE 06/23/ :00 A.M. 06/16/2005 Notice of Conflict Notice of Conflict DEFTS NOTICE OF CONFLICT 06/16/2005 Per the Court: Free PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY EXPERT LIST 06/16/2005 Interrogatories Interrogatories EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 06/16/2005 Interrogatories Interrogatories EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 06/16/2005 Interrogatories Interrogatories EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 06/16/2005 Interrogatories Interrogatories EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO RANDALL B WHITNEY MD 06/23/2005 Hearing Exparte (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale) 06/28/2005 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories DEFTS JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD, ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC & RANDALL B WHITNEY MD NOTICE OF SERVING EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO PLTF 06/28/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce DEFTS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO PLTF 06/29/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce DOUGLAS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO ORLANDO WOMENS 06/30/2005 Per the Court: Free DEFTS RANDALL B WHITNEY MD, JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IB MD & ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE 07/15/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DEFTS RANDALL B WHITNEY MD & JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 07/27/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES TO PLTFS EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD 07/27/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF

10 ANSWERS TO PLTFS EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 07/27/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO PLTFS EXPERT INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT RANDALL B WHITNEY MD 08/15/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF MARY SPIELVOGAL 11:00 AM 08/15/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories NOT OF SERVING PLTFS ANSWERS TO DEFTS EXPERT WITNESS INTERROGATORIES 08/15/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY RESPONSES TO DEFTS REQUEST TO PRODUCE 08/15/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOT OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM 8/31 TURIYA 1:00; PATTI 2:00; DEVELA 3:00 PM 08/18/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF SHARON GRIFFIN MD 1:00 PM 08/18/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF FREDERICK RAFFA PHD 2:00 PM 08/18/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF PAUL GATEWOOD MD 10:00 AM 08/19/2005 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF RECORD PICK UP 2 DEPONENTS 9/24 MAILED 8/17 08/19/2005 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF RECORD PICK UP 18 DEPONENTS 9/24 MAILED 8/17 08/29/2005 Request for Copies Request for Copies PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY REQUEST FOR COPIES (18) 09/01/2005 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF DEPOSITION *TURIYA VELEZ, PATTI FULOP, MARY SPI EVIVOGEL, DAVELA CLERVEAU, 08/31/ /01/2005 Per the Court: Free DEFENDANTS'NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF EXPERT DAVID GRIMES 09/02/2005 Request for Copies Request for Copies PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY REQUEST FOR COPIES (2) 09/09/2005 Certificate of No Objection Certificate of No Objection CERTIFICATE OF NO OBJECTION TO NON

11 PARTIES 09/09/2005 Certificate of No Objection Certificate of No Objection CERTIFICATE OF NO OBJECTION TO NON PARTIES 09/09/2005 Motion Motion MOTION TO BIFURCATE TRIAL AND FOR PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY FILED BY JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD, ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER AND RANDALL WHITNEY MD 09/09/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF JOHN MCKAY PHD ON 10:00 09/13/2005 Motion for Summary Judgment Motion For Summary Judgment MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT W/ATTACHMENTS BY JAMES S PENDERGRA FT IV MD 09/15/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV 09/15/2005 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF JAEMS PENDERGRAFT IV 09/15/2005 Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned to Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM FOR DEPO SERVED DAVELA CLERVEAU ISSUED BY ATTY 09/15/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING [11/07/2005] 11:00 A.M. 09/16/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING [11/07/2005] 11:30 A.M. 09/21/2005 Deposition Deposition VIDEOTAPED DEPO OF RANDALL B WHITNEY MD W/ATTACHED EXHIBITS (FILED ON DEPO DESK) 09/21/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF RANDALL B WHITNEY MD UNDER SEAL (FILED ON DEPO DESK) **SEE CLERKS NOTES** 09/21/2005 Order Order ORDER SETTING MEDIATION CONFERENCE 10:00 AM 09/26/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DR JOGI PATTISAPU 11/10 2:00 PM 10/05/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC DR JOGI PATTISAPU ON 2:00 10/05/2005 Motion to Quash Motion to Quash MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA BY AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION 10/10/2005 Exhibit List Exhibit List STALLEY AMENDED EXPERT LIST 10/14/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION

12 DUCES TECUM OF DR DAVID AUERBACH ON 2:00 10/19/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF SHARON GRIFFIN MD 11/30 1:00 PM 10/19/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF FREDERICK RAFFA PHD 12/6 2:00 PM 10/25/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DOUGLAS STALLEY 10/27/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DOUGLAS STALLEY 10/27/2005 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DOUGLAS STALLEY 10/27/2005 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY RURAL METRO AMBULANCE 12/8 MAILED 10/24 10/28/2005 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF 11/03/2005 Motion Motion DEFTS MOTION TO RELEASE RECORDS FOR IN CAMERA INSPECTION 11/04/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO CAROL HOWARD 11/04/2005 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF CAROL HOWARD 5/12/04 (DEPO FOLDER) 11/07/2005 Objection Objection PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO DEFENDANT NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTY 11/07/2005 Response Response PLTFS RESPONSE & MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFTS MOTION TO BIFURCATE TRIAL & FOR PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY 11/07/2005 Hearing (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) 11/07/2005 Hearing (11:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) 11/08/2005 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference ORDER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE 05/02/ :00 A.M. 11/08/2005 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference ORDER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE 04/25/ :00 A.M. 11/09/2005 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference ORDER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE 04/25/ :00 A.M. 11/10/2005 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING ORLANDO WOMEN'S CENTER INC'S INFORMED CONSENT FORMS WITH PATIENT NAME REDACTED

13 11/14/2005 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DR JOGI PATTISAPU, 11/10/05, 2:00 11/14/2005 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DR DAVID AUERBACH, 11/29/05, 2:00 11/14/2005 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF JOHN MCKAY 12/7/05, 10:00 11/14/2005 Notice for Trial Notice for Trial NOTICE FOR TRIAL (JURY) (NO SASE) 11/15/2005 Notice of Compliance Notice of Compliance DEFTS NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH NOTICE FOR REQUEST FOR COPIES 11/17/2005 Notice of Conflict Notice of Conflict DEFT JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD/ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC AND RANDALL B WHITNEY MD NOTICE OF CONFLICT 11/21/2005 Exhibit List Exhibit List STALLEY AMENDED EXPERT LIST 11/22/2005 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JENNIFER FERNANDEZ 11/22/2005 Order Denying Order Denying ORDER DENYING DEFTS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT 11/23/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 11/28/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 11/30/2005 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference AMENDED ORDER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE 04/17/ :00 P.M. 12/02/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 12/02/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S NOTICE OF SERVICE OF UNVERIFIED RESPONSES TO SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES 12/02/2005 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING * 02/07/ :30 A.M. 12/12/2005 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S NOTICE

14 OF SERVICE OF VERIFIED RESPONSES TO SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES 12/16/2005 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S AMENDED RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 12/22/2005 Witness List Witness List DEFTS RANDALL B WHITNEY MD/JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE 12/30/2005 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DR JAY PLOTKIN, 2/7/06, 1:00 01/02/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC PAUL GATEWOOD MD ON 1:00 01/02/2006 Order of Jury Trial (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) 01/03/2006 Letter Letter LETTER FILED FROM ATTORNEY JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ 01/03/2006 Order Order AMENDED ORDER SETTING MEDIATION CONFERENCE 2:00 PM 01/05/2006 Notice of Compliance Notice of Compliance DEFT JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD /ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC AND RANDALL B WHITNEY MD NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH PLTF REQUEST FOR COPIES 01/18/2006 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF PAUL GATEWOOD, MD, 1/20/06, 1:00 01/19/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY HEALTHEASE OF FLORIDA 3/4 MAILED 1/18 02/02/2006 Notice of Unavailability Notice of Unavailability NOTICE OF NON-AVAILABILITY JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ 3/20-3/24 02/02/2006 Request for Copies Request for Copies DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S REQUEST FOR COPIES 02/06/2006 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JENNIFER FERNANDEZ 02/06/2006 Order Denying Order Denying ORDER DENYING DEFTS MOTION TO BIFURCATE TRIAL & FOR PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY 02/07/2006 Hearing (11:30 AM) (Judicial Officers Glatt, James E, Turner, Thomas A) 02/10/2006 Order Granting Order Granting ORDER GRANTING PLTFS MOTION TO OBTAIN HEARING TRANSCRIPT FROM JUVENILE COURT FILE 02/10/2006 Mediation Report

15 Mediation Report MEDIATION REPORT - ADJOURNED 02/10/2006 Motion Motion PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY MOTION TO OBTAIN HEARING TRANSCRIPT FORM JUVENILE COURT FILE 02/13/2006 Certificate Certificate CERTIFICATE OF NON OBJECTION HEALTHEASE OF FLORIDA INC 02/15/2006 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JOSEPH MENELLO 02/15/2006 Order Granting Order Granting ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO RELEASE RECORDS FOR IN CAMERA INSPECTION 02/21/2006 Order to Seal Document Order to Seal Document ORDER: CONDUCT OF PARENTS WAS NOT A REFUSAL TO FOLLOW MEDICAL RECOMMENDATIONS/ORDER TO SEAL DOCUMENT: TRANSCRIPT OF JUVENILE HEARING **SEALED & PLACED ON CIVIL RETENTION SHELF-SEALED FILES 4/21/06** 02/21/2006 Per the Court: Free TRANSCRIPT OF JUVENILE HEARING **SEALED & PLACED ON CIVIL RETENTION SHELF-SEALED FILES 4/21/06** 02/22/2006 Mediation Report Mediation Report MEDIATION REPORT - IMPASSE 02/27/2006 Motion to Amend Motion to Amend PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT & ADD A CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES 03/02/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING EXPARTE 04/05/ :15 A.M. 03/10/2006 Notice of Service of Proposal for Settlement Notice of Service of Proposal for Settlement DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER NOTICE SERVICE OF PROPOSAL FOR SETTLEMENT 03/16/2006 Notice of Independent Medical Exam Notice of Independent Medical Exam NOTICE OF INDEPENDANT MEDICAL EXAM JORDAN FRASURE ON 10:00 03/27/2006 Order Order AGREED ORDER FOR EXAMINATION OF THE MINOR PLTF 03/30/2006 Notice of Compliance Notice of Compliance NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE 03/31/2006 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) Amended Notice of Taking Deposition SECOND AMENDED NOTICE TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF PAUL GATEWOOD, 3/31/06, 1:00 04/03/2006 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY MOTION TO COMPEL 04/04/2006 Memorandum Memorandum STALLEY SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDA OF LAW AND PROFFER IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT TO ADD PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLAIM

16 04/05/2006 Hearing Exparte (10:15 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Glatt, James E, Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale) 04/06/2006 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference ORDER FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE 08/22/ :00 A.M. 04/06/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING 04/05/2006 AS TO 10:15 AM 04/06/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF PAUL D GATEWOOD, 3/31/06 04/06/2006 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF PAUL D GATEWOOD, 3/31/06, 1:10 WITH ATTACHMENTS 04/06/2006 Motion Motion DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF LAW AND PROFFER IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT TO ADD PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLAIM AND MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF HEARING BY RANDALL B WHITNEY MD JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC A FLORIDA CORPORATION 04/15/2006 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE SERVICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES TO ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER 04/15/2006 Notice Notice STALLEY REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE 04/15/2006 Request to Produce Request to Produce REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO RANDALL WHITNEY MD, JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD AND ORLANDO WOMENS 04/15/2006 Supplemental Interrogatories Supplemental Interrogatories SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD 04/15/2006 Supplemental Interrogatories Supplemental Interrogatories SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES RANDALL WHITNEY MD 04/15/2006 Supplemental Interrogatories Supplemental Interrogatories SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER 04/15/2006 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE SERVICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES RANDALL WHITNEY MD 04/15/2006 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE SERVICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD 04/17/2006 Pre-Trial Conference (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Evans, Robert M) 04/24/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING JAMES D PEDERGRAFT IV MD CONSENT

17 FOR CONTINUANCE 04/25/2006 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JOSEPH MENELLO 04/25/2006 Order for Continuance Order for Continuance ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE 04/25/2006 Pre-Trial Conference (10:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Glatt, James E) 05/04/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM ON 5/30/06 OF PATRICIA FULOP, 10:30 AND TURYIA VELEZ, TO FOLLOW 05/04/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING CONSENT FOR CONTINUANCE SIGNED BY JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 05/04/2006 Per the Court: Free CONSENT FOR CONTINUANCE 05/15/2006 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DEFT WHITNEYS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIE 05/15/2006 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DEFT PENDERGRAFTS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS SUPPLEMEENTAL INTERROGATORIES 05/15/2006 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DEFTS RESPONSE TO REQUEST TO PRODUCE 05/15/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum DEFTS AMENDED NTS TAK DEPO DUC TEC OF PAUL GATEWOOD MD ON 10:00 05/15/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DR JAY PLOTKIN 6/29 1:00PM 06/09/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING EXPARTE 07/20/ :30 P.M. 06/13/2006 Request to Produce Request to Produce DEFENDANTS SUPPLEMENTAL EXPERT REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO PLAINTIFF 06/13/2006 Motion to Shorten Time Motion to Shorten Time DEFTS MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME 06/15/2006 Request to Produce Request to Produce FIFTH REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DOUGLAS B STALLEY 06/15/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY 10 DAYS, 9 DEPONENTS, MAILED 6/13/06 06/15/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF TURYIA VELEZ, 6/19/06, 10:00 06/20/2006 Motion for Summary Judgment

18 Motion For Summary Judgment DEFTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT & SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW 06/29/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING * 07/20/ :30 P.M. 06/29/2006 Request for Copies Request for Copies STALLEY REQUEST FOR COPIES FROM NON PARTIES 06/30/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY 10 DAYS, CITY OF ORLANDO FIRE DEPT, MAILED 6/28/06 06/30/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY 10 DAYS, TAMPA FIRE RESCUE, MAILED 6/28/06 07/03/2006 Certificate of No Objection Certificate of No Objection CERTIFICATE OF NO OBJECTION 07/03/2006 Request to Produce Request to Produce DEFTS SIXTH REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO PLTF 07/07/2006 Objection Objection DEFTS OBJECTIONS TO PLTFS NOTICES OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTY TAMPA FIRE RESCUE & CITY OF ORLANDO FIRE DEPARTMENT 07/10/2006 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RESPONSE TO 6TH REQUEST TO PRODUCE 07/10/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV, ORLANDO WOMEN'S CENTER INC AND RANDALL B WHITNEY'S NOTICE OF FILING DEPO TRANSCRIPT OF PAUL D GATEWOOD, TAKEN 6/12/06 07/10/2006 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF PAUL D GATEWOOD, 6/12/06, 10:00 WITH EXHIBITS 07/11/2006 Amended Notice of Hearing Amended Notice of Hearing AMENDED NOTICE EX PARTE HEARING 07/20/ :30 P.M. 07/11/2006 Motion to Compel Motion to Compel PLTFS DOUGLAS B STALLEY AS GUARDIAN OF THE PROPERTY OF J.F. AN INCAPACITATED MINOR MOTION TO COMPEL OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, FOR SANCTIONS WITH ATTACHED EXHIBITS 07/11/2006 Request to Produce Request to Produce PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 07/11/2006 Notice of Service Notice of Service PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY NOTICE OF SERVING PLTFS RESPONSE TO DEFTS SUPPLEMENTAL EXPERT REQUEST TO PRODUCE 07/13/2006 Response to Request to Produce Response to Request to Produce DOUGLAS B STALLEY'S NOTICE OF SERVING RESPONSE TO FIFTH REQUEST TO PRODUCE

19 07/14/2006 Deposition Deposition DEPOSITION OF TURIYA VELEZ 07/14/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY UCP HOLLOWAY CENTER 10 DAYS MAILED 7/13 07/14/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING DEPO OF TURIYA VELEZ 07/17/2006 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTF NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PUNITIVE DAMAGES INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD 07/17/2006 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories PLTF NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PUNITIVE DAMAGES INTERROGATORIES TO DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC 07/18/2006 Response Response DEFTS RESPONSE AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO PLTF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT AND ADD A CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES 07/19/2006 Notice Notice NOTICE OF SERVING PLTF SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO DEFT REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO PLTF DOUGLAS B STALLEY 07/19/2006 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DEFT JAMES S PENDEGRAFT IV MD NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO PUNITIVE DAMAGES INTERROGATORIES 07/19/2006 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories DEFT ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO PUNITIVE DAMAGES INTERROGATORIES 07/20/2006 Amended Notice of Exparte Hearing (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officers Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale, Turner, Thomas A) 07/20/2006 Hearing (2:30 PM) (Judicial Officers Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale, Turner, Thomas A) 07/20/2006 Hearing Exparte (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officers Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale, Turner, Thomas A) 07/24/2006 Letter Letter LETTER FILED FROM ATTORNEY JOSEPH P MENELLO 07/24/2006 Order Granting Order Granting ORDER GRANTING DEFT MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 07/25/2006 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum NOTICE OF TAKING DEPO DUCES TECUM OF WILLIAM P EGHERMAN MD 10:30 AM 07/27/2006 Motion for Protective Order Motion for Protective Order DEFTS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER

20 REGARDING THE DEPO OF WILLIAM P EGHERMAN MD 07/31/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING * 08/08/ :00 A.M. 08/08/2006 Notice Notice NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF HEARING FOR 8/8/06 AT 11AM 08/08/2006 Amended Complaint Amended Complaint SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL 08/08/2006 Hearing (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Glatt, James E) 08/09/2006 Subpoena for Deposition Returned Subpoena for Deposition Returned SUBPOENA FOR DEPOSITION SERVED UCP HOLLOWAY CENTER ISSUED BY ATTY 08/10/2006 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition Notice of Cancellation of Deposition NOTICE CANCELLATION OF VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM WILLIAM P EGHERMAN MD 8/15 10:30 AM 08/15/2006 Motion to Dismiss Motion to Dismiss DEFTS RANDALL B WHITNEY MD; JAMES SCOTT PENDERGRAFT IV MD & ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC MOTION TO DISMISS PLTFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT & DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL W/ATTACHMENTS (UNSIGNED) 08/22/2006 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing NOTICE OF HEARING * 09/20/ :00 P.M. 08/22/2006 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing NOTICE OF FILING TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS BY JAMES S PENDERGRAFT IV MD 08/22/2006 Transcript of Proceedings Transcript of Proceedings TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS HELD ON JULY /22/2006 Pre-Trial Conference (10:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Glatt, James E) 09/06/2006 Notice of Production of Non-Party Notice of Production of Non-Party NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON PARTY FLORIDA DEPT OF HEALTH 09/12/2006 Objection Objection DEFTS OBJECTION TO PLTFS NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTY (FLORIDA DEPT OF HEALTH) 09/20/2006 Order of Dismissal Order of Dismissal ORDER GRANTING DEFTS MOTION TO DISMISS PLTFS 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT 09/20/2006 Final Judgment Final Judgment FINAL JUDGMENT - BY JUDGE PLTFS TAKE NOTHING & DEFTS JAMES PENDERGRAFT IV MD, RANDALL WHITNEY MD, ORLANDO WOMENS CENTER INC SHALL GO HENCE WITHOUT DAY 09/20/2006 Memorandum in Opposition Memorandum in Opposition PLTFS' MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFTS' MOTION TO DISMISS

21 09/20/2006 Hearing (3:00 PM) (Judicial Officers Turner, Thomas A, Notice of Sale, Notice of Sale) 09/27/2006 Motion to Tax Costs Motion to Tax Costs DEFENDANTS'MOTION TO TAX COSTS 09/27/2006 Motion to Tax Costs Motion to Tax Costs DEFENDANTS'MOTION TO TAX COSTS 09/27/2006 Case Reopened Close on Re-Open Main #10 ***Case Reopened***Close on Re-Open Maintain #10*** ****CASE RE- OPENED****CLOSE ON RE-OPEN MAINT #10** 10/12/2006 Notice of Appeal Notice of Appeal NOTICE OF APPEAL 10/24/2006 Acknowledgment Acknowledgment ACKNOWLEDGMENT NOTICE OF APPEAL 5D /21/2006 Order Order DCA ORDER OF REFERRAL TO MEDIAITON 12/27/2006 Directions to Clerk Directions to Clerk DIRECTIONS TO THE CLERK 01/12/2007 Order Order ORDER FROM DCA RE: UNSUCCESSFUL MEDIATION 02/16/2007 Copies of Appeal Index Mailed Copies of Appeal Index Mailed COPIES OF APPEAL INDEX MAILED 04/12/2007 Notice of Appeal Notice of Appeal AMENDED NOTICE OF APPEAL 04/17/2007 Record on Appeal Mailed Record on Appeal Mailed RECORD ON APPEAL MAILED 05/07/2007 DCA Order DCA Order DCA ORDER TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD BY 5/23/07 05/10/2007 Directions to Clerk Directions to Clerk SUPPLEMENTAL DIRECTIONS TO THE CLERK 05/10/2007 Transcript of Proceedings Transcript of Proceedings COPY OF TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS (9/20/06) 05/14/2007 Copies of Appeal Index Mailed Copies of Appeal Index Mailed COPIES OF SUPPLEMENTAL APPEAL INDEX MAILED 05/14/2007 Directions to Clerk Directions to Clerk SUPPLEMENTAL DIRECTIONS TO THE CLERK 05/15/2007 Notice of Filing Notice of Filing PLTFS' NOTICE OF FILING HEARING TRANSCRIPT WITH TRANSCRIPT ATTACHED 05/21/2007 Record on Appeal Mailed Record on Appeal Mailed SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ON APPEAL MAILED 08/20/2008 Mandate Reversed & Remanded Filed and Recorded Mandate Reversed & Remanded Filed and Recorded MANDATE REVERSED & REMANDED (5D ) 09/11/2008 Motion for Case Management Conference Motion for Case Management Conference PLAINTIFF'S MOTION CASE

22 MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 10/10/2008 Notice for Trial Notice for Trial NOTICE FOR TRIAL (JURY) (NO SASE) 11/17/2008 Supreme Court Supreme Court SUPREME COURT / DETERMINED THAT IT SHOULD DECLINE TO ACCEPT JURISDICTION / PETITION FOR REVIEW IS DENIED / NO MOTION FOR REHEARING WILL BE ENTERTAINED (SC )(5D ) 11/26/2008 Notice for Trial Notice for Trial NOTICE FOR TRIAL 11/26/2008 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference UNIFORM ORDER SETTING CASE FOR NON-JURY TRIAL ON 9:30AM AND PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE 04/27/ :30 A.M. AND MATTERS TO BE COMPLETED 12/05/2008 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Notice of Service of Interrogatories NOTICE OF SERVING SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES TO PLTF 01/08/2009 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF HEARING * 02/26/ :30 P.M. 01/08/2009 Memorandum of Law Memorandum of Law PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF LAW AND EVIDENTIARY PROFFER IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT TO ADD PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLAIM 02/17/2009 Amended Notice of Hearing Amended Notice of Hearing PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING 02/26/09 13:30 02/19/2009 Letter Letter LETTER TO JUDGE FROM JENNIFER GENTRY FERNANDEZ 02/19/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 02/19/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 02/19/2009 Amended Notice of Hearing 02/20/2009 Response in Opposition to AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW 02/24/2009 Objection to Interrogatories 02/24/2009 Objection to Interrogatories 02/26/2009 Motion (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) Evidentiary Hearing / Case Management Parties Present Result: Taken under Advisement 02/26/2009 Notice of Conflict 02/26/2009 Amended Notice of Hearing 02/26/2009 Memorandum of Law 02/26/2009 Response AND MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT 02/26/2009 Exhibits in Support of

23 RESPONSE AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT 02/26/2009 Motion MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT AND ADD A CLALIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES 02/27/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 02/27/2009 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum 02/27/2009 Letter 03/02/2009 Letter From Clerk Requesting Reopen Fee MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT AND ADD A CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES 03/04/2009 Minutes Hearing 03/05/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) UPDATED OF CAROL L HOWARD 9:00 AM 03/05/2009 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum OF SHARON B GRIFFIN 12:00 PM 03/13/2009 Notice to Produce 03/16/2009 Subpoena Returned for production to non-party served 03/16/2009 Letter SECOND REQUEST 03/16/2009 Disclosure of Experts 03/18/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) Third 03/23/2009 Subpoena Duces Tecum for Deposition Returned Served 03/31/2009 Notice of Compliance 04/06/2009 Affidavit of Service 04/06/2009 Affidavit of Service 04/13/2009 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum 04/14/2009 Letter 04/14/2009 Motion for Continuance of trial 04/14/2009 Order Continuing Trial 04/15/2009 Order Continuing Trial 04/16/2009 Correspondence hearing index of materials 04/16/2009 Letter 04/16/2009 Order Granting Motion to Amend COMPLAINT 04/20/2009 Notice of Service punitive damages interro. to deft james scott pendergraft 04/20/2009 Notice of Service pltf's punitive damages interro to deft orlando women's center 04/22/2009 Motion for Rehearing AND MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION OF PLTFS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT 05/08/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s)

24 Fourth notice 05/12/2009 Answer to Amended Complaint/Petition Third Amended 05/18/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 05/18/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 05/26/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) FIFTH 05/28/2009 Subpoena Returned Served City of Orlando Fire Department 06/01/2009 Notice of Hearing 06/01/2009 Affidavit of Service served Cirty of Orlando Fire Department 06/01/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 06/12/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 06/12/2009 Petition/Motion to Strike 06/16/2009 Notice of Conflict 06/18/2009 Notice of Compliance 06/22/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 06/22/2009 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum SECOND 06/30/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 07/07/2009 Letter 07/07/2009 Motion to Compel Discovery AMENDED 07/08/2009 Objection 07/16/2009 Notice of Unavailability 07/24/2009 Notice of Hearing 1015am 08/06/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 08/06/2009 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 08/06/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 08/06/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 08/07/2009 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 08/07/2009 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 08/14/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 08/14/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 08/17/2009 Subpoena Returned Served Served to Christine Chacon 08/28/2009 Motion to Compel RENEWED 09/10/2009 Hearing (10:15 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) plf motion to compel Parties Present Result: Ordered 09/11/2009 Notice of Production of Non-Party 09/14/2009 Court Minutes

25 motion to compel 09/14/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 09/14/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Amended 09/14/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories Amended 09/14/2009 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 09/14/2009 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 09/17/2009 Letter 09/17/2009 Order on Motion to compel discovery 09/23/2009 Request to Produce 09/23/2009 Request to Produce 09/28/2009 Certificate of No Objection 10/09/2009 Notice of Conflict AMENDED 10/12/2009 Motion to Bifurcate THE PUNITIVE DAMAGES CLAIM 10/16/2009 Request for Copies 10/21/2009 Notice of Conflict Second Amended 10/23/2009 Response to Request to Produce 10/23/2009 Witness List Second Amended 10/23/2009 Motion to Compel AMENDED AND RENEWED 10/26/2009 Notice of Hearing 1/5/2010 at 2 pm 10/26/2009 Witness List 3rd amended expert 10/26/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 10/27/2009 Response to Request to Produce 10/27/2009 Response to Request to Produce 10/27/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 10/27/2009 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 10/29/2009 Notice of Hearing 2:00 PM 10/29/2009 Motion to Compel 11/02/2009 Notice Cancellation of Hearing 2:00 PM 11/06/2009 Order Setting Pre-Trial Conference 10:30am 11/06/2009 Notice of Compliance 11/16/2009 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) DUCES TECUM 11/19/2009 Returned Mail

26 11/23/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 11/23/2009 Witness disclosure 11/23/2009 Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 12/01/2009 Notice of Taking(s) Deposition Duces Tecum 12/02/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 12/02/2009 Request to Produce 12/07/2009 Exhibit List 12/07/2009 Witness List 12/07/2009 Witness and Exhibit List AMENDED 12/07/2009 Witness and Exhibit List 12/15/2009 Notice of Production of Non-Party 12/17/2009 Notice OF EXAMINATION 12/21/2009 Objection 12/21/2009 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 12/29/2009 Motion to Compel amended 12/29/2009 Amended Notice of Hearing 1/5/2010 at 200pm 12/29/2009 Notice of Hearing 2:00 PM 01/05/2010 Hearing (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) Parties Present Result: Ordered 01/05/2010 Minutes Hearing 01/06/2010 Notice of Hearing 2:00 pm 01/06/2010 Notice of Filing 01/06/2010 Notice amended notice of examination of pltf as to time only 01/06/2010 Motion for Continuance 01/06/2010 Deposition of Sharon Griffin 01/07/2010 Hearing (10:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) 01/08/2010 Objection to deft's amended notice 01/08/2010 Petition/Motion to Strike 01/08/2010 Notice of Independent Medical Exam Second Amended 01/11/2010 Order Compelling rule examination 01/11/2010 Letter 01/12/2010 Certificate of No Objection

27 01/14/2010 Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 01/15/2010 Notice of Production of Non-Party 01/15/2010 Notice of Service of Interrogatories 01/20/2010 Answer to Interrogatories 01/20/2010 Answer to Interrogatories 01/20/2010 Affidavit as to existence of written protocols 01/20/2010 Notice of Filing 01/21/2010 Notice of Filing 01/21/2010 Notice of Filing 01/25/2010 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 01/25/2010 Letter 01/25/2010 Letter 01/25/2010 Notice of Hearing 2:00 pm 01/25/2010 Notice of Filing 01/25/2010 Order Granting Motion to Compel (amended and renewed) 01/25/2010 Order Granting Motion to Compel 01/25/2010 Motion to reconsider deft's motion for continuance and motion to determine sufficiency of deft's response to court-ordered punitive damages discovery and for sanctions 01/26/2010 CANCELED Hearing (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Turner, Thomas A) Cancelled 01/26/2010 Letter 01/26/2010 Order for Continuance Granted 01/28/2010 Notice Cancellation of Hearing 1/26/10 at 2:00 pm 02/03/2010 Certificate of No Objection 02/09/2010 Affidavit 02/09/2010 Objection to Interrogatories 02/09/2010 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 02/09/2010 Notice of Filing affidavit of Nicholas E Christin 02/18/2010 Amended Notice of Taking Deposition(s) 02/22/2010 Uniform Order Setting Case for Jury/Pretrial 7/20/10 10am 02/24/2010 Status Hearing (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Kest, John Marshall) Parties Present Result: Hearing Held 02/24/2010 Court Minutes 02/26/2010 Notice of Conflict second amended 02/26/2010 Notice of Filing original exhibits to the deposition, and transcripts. with attachments.