SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Grants & Denials List GRANTS APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT. Nashville.

Transcription

1 SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS Grants & Denials List AMENDED - Monday, November 18, 2013 GRANTS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville NONE Knoxville Samuel E. Foster et al. v. Walter William Chiles, III, M.D. et al. E SC-R11-CV Knox County Circuit Judge Dale C. Workman No Susano, J., Vacated Granted: Application of Walter William Chiles, III, M.D., Knoxville Urology Clinic, P.C., Gordon Lee Collins, M.D., Anesthesia Medical Alliance of East P.C., Covenant Health and Parkwest Medical Center (Order Filed ; copy attached) Page 1 of 23

2 State of v. Gwendolyn Hagerman E SC-R11-CD Sullivan County Criminal Judge Robert H. Montgomery, Jr. No. S57, 179 Tipton, J., Granted: Application of Gwendolyn Hagerman (Order Filed ; copy attached) Edward Thomas Kendrick, III v. State of E SC-R11-PC Hamilton County Criminal Judge Don W. Poole No Bivins, J., Reversed Granted: Application of State of (Order Filed ; copy attached) Larry Sneed v. The City of Red Bank, E SC-R11-CV Hamilton County Circuit Chancellor Jeffrey M. Atherton No. 12C1164 McClarty, J., Reversed Motion Granted: Application of Larry Sneed Motion to file amicus brief Granted (Order Filed ; copy attached) Andrew Spencer v. Norfolk Southern Railway Company E SC-R11-CV Hamilton County Circuit Judge Ward Jeffrey Hollingsworth No. 10C1029 Swiney, J., Vacated Granted: Application of Norfolk Southern Railway Company (Order Filed ; copy attached) Jackson State of v. Marlo Davis W SC-R11-CD Judge W. Mark Ward No Thomas, J., Granted: Application of Marlo Davis (Order Filed ; copy attached) State of v. Broderick Devonte Fayne W SC-R11-CD Tipton County Circuit Judge Joseph A. Walker, III No Glenn, J., Granted: Application of Broderick Devonte Fayne (Order Filed ; copy attached) Page 2 of 23

3 SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS AMENDED - Monday, November 18, 2013 DENIALS STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTY TRIAL JUDGE TRIAL COURT NO. APPELLATE JUDGE JUDGMENT NATURE OF APPEAL ACTION Nashville Gregory Anderson D/B/A ABC Painting Company v. The Metropolitan Development and Housing Authority M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Carol L. McCoy No III Cottrell, P.J. M.S., Denied: Application of Gregory Anderson D/B/A ABC Painting Company Shelvy Antwon Baker v. State of M SC-R11-PC Judge Cheryl A. Blackburn No A-112 Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Shelvy Antwon Baker Jerome Sidney Barrett v. State of M SC-R11-CO Judge Steve R. Dozier No. 2007D3201 Smith, J., Denied - Application of Jerome Sidney Barrett (Order filed ) Rosalyn L. Caffey v. Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, et al. M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Judge Russell T. Perkins No IV Dinkins, J., Denied - Application of Rosalyn L. Caffey; Granted - Motion to Correct Clerical and Form Errors of Rosalyn L. Caffey Page 3 of 23

4 State of v. Colby Terrell Black M SC-R11-CD Giles County Circuit Judge Stella Hargrove Nos , 13632, Page, J., Denied: Application of Colby Terrell Black Fonda Blair v. Rutherford County Board of Education, Et Al M SC-R11-CV Rutherford County Chancery Judge Timothy L. Easter No. 10CV698 Dinkins, J., in part, Reversed in part, Remanded Denied: Application of Fonda Blair State of v. Michael D. Boone M SC-R11-CD Judge Steve Dozier No A-266 Wedemeyer, J., Denied: Application of Michael D. Boone Michael Timothy Brown v. Janine Biache Brown M SC-R11-CV Maury County Chancery Judge Jim T. Hamilton No Dinkins, J., Denied: Application of Janine Biache Brown Inez Bryson v. Department of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Carol L. McCoy No II Dinkins, J., Denied: Application of Inez Bryson State of v. Robert Jason Burdick M SC-R11-CD Williamson County Circuit Judge Timothy L. Easter No. II-CR Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Robert Jason Burdick Jonathan Duane Christy v. Mitchell B. Dugan, Administrator Ad Litem of the Estate of Laura Antoinette Long, Deceased M SC-R11-CV Dickson County Circuit Judge Robert Burch No. 22CC2011CV40 Dinkins, J., Denied: Application of Jonathan Duane Christy Page 4 of 23

5 City of South Pittsburg, v. James C. Hailey & Co. Et Al M SC-R11-CV Marion County Circuit Judge J. Curtis Smith No Dinkins, J., Reversed Denied: Application of Bituminous Casualty Corp. State of v. Marcus Terrell Church M SC-R11-CD Judge J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. No A-583 Woodall, J., Tipton, P. J., Concurring Opinion; Denied: Application of Marcus Terrell Church Williams, J., Concurring Opinion State of v. Darius Dix M SC-R11-CD Montgomery County Circuit Judge John H. Gasaway, III No Smith, J., Denied - Application of Darius Dix (Order filed ) State of v. Raina Fisher M CCA-R11-CD Maury County Circuit Judge Robert Lee Holloway, Jr. No CR Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Raina Fisher State of v. Trinidad Martinez Flores M SC-R11-CD Judge Seth Norman No C-2341 Woodall, J., Denied: Application of Trinidad Martinez Flores Dismissed- Pro Se Application of Trinidad Martinez Flores Page 5 of 23

6 Martha L. Patlan-Cano v. State of M SC-R11-PC Judge Steve R. Dozier No D-3184 Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Martha L. Patlan- Cano State of v. Kyle Ronald Fencl M SC-R11-CD Judge Steve Dozier No. 2011A8 Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Kyle Ronald Fencl State of v. Gerald Branden Fitzpatrick M SC-R11-CD Judge Monte Watkins No D-3267 Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Gerald Branden Fitzpatrick (Order Filed ) H. G. Hill Realty Company, LLC. v. Re/Max Carriage House Inc., et al. M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Judge Russell T. Perkins No IV Stafford, J., Denied: Application of Robert L. Wood, Jr. Timothy L. Jefferson v. State of M SC-R11-PC Judge Cheryl A. Blackburn No. 200D1954 Wedemeyer, J., Denied Denied - Application of Timothy L. Jefferson (Order filed ) Russell Jensen v. State of M SC-R11-HC Wayne County Circuit Judge Jim T. Hamilton No Wedemeyer, J., Denied: Application of Russell Jensen Geret Jessee Johnston v. Susan Harwell Johnston M SC-R11-CV Maury County Chancery Judge Robert Lee Holloway, Jr. No Kirby, J., Reversed Denied - Application of Geret Jessee Johnston (Order filed ) Page 6 of 23

7 State of v. Brandon L. Kirk M SC-R11-CD Robertson County Circuit Judge Michael R. Jones No. 2010CR668, 2010CR670 Thomas, J., Denied: Application of Brandon L. Kirk Motion for appointment of counsel is denied. V. Theresa Manning, et al. v. Hendersonville Hospital Corporation d/b/a Hendersonville Medical Center, et al. M SC-R10-CV Sumner County Circuit Judge C. L. Rogers No. 2013CV213 Per Curiam Denied Denied: Application of Joseph Mangoun State of ex rel. Herbert S. Moncier v. Nancy S. Jones et al. M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Carol L. McCoy No Clement, J., in Part; Reversed in Part Denied - Application of Herbert S. Moncier Herbert S. Moncier v. Board of Professional Responsibility of the Supreme of M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Chancellor Russell T. Perkins No Bennett, J., Denied - Application of Herbert S. Moncier State of ex rel. Herbert S. Moncier v. Nancy S. Jones et al. M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Judge Hamilton Gayden No. 12C502 Dinkins, J., Denied - Application of Herbert S. Moncier Herbert S. Moncier v. Hearing Panel of the Board of Professional Responsibility M SC-R11-CV Knox County Chancery Chancellor John F. Weaver No Bennett, J., Denied - Application of Herbert S. Moncier (Order filed ) Chauncey Moore v. State of M SC-R11-PC Judge Cheryl Blackburn No. 2009A539 Smith, J., Denied: Application of Chauncey Moore Page 7 of 23

8 Adedamola O. Oni M.D. v. Department of Health, et al. M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Judge Russell T. Perkins No IV Bennett, J., in Part, Reversed in Part Denied: Application of Adedamola O. Oni Linda Alexander Owens v. James Emery Owens M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Circuit Judge Philip E. Smith No. 03D535 Cottrell, J., in Part, Reversed in Part Denied - Application of Linda Alexander Owens (Order filed ) State of v. William Patrick Peebles M SC-R11-CD Judge Steve R. Dozier No A-829 Smith, J., Denied: Application of William Patrick Peebles Daniel E. Pottebaum, Sr. v. State of M SC-R11-PC Judge Cheryl A. Blackburn No. 2002C1808 Thomas, J., Denied - Application of Daniel E. Pottebaum, Sr. (Order filed ) State of, on relation of the Board of Regents, Austin Peay State University for and on behalf of said Department v. University Landing Partners, LLC, a Limited Liability Company and Montgomery County, M SC-R10-CV Montgomery County Circuit Judge Ross H. Hicks No. MCCCCVCN Per Curiam Rule 10 Denied Rule 10 Denied: Application of University Landing Partners, LLC In Re Utility Management Review Board v. The Commissioners of the Powell- Clinch Utility District M SC-R11-CV Davidson County Chancery Judge Russell T. Perkins No IV Farmer, J., in Part; Modified in Part Denied - Application of Commissioners of the Powell-Clinch Utility District (Order filed ) Page 8 of 23

9 Earl Vantrease, Jr. v. State of M SC-R11-HC Hickman County Circuit Judge Robbie Beal No. 12CV43 Wedemeyer, J.; Smith, J., Denied: Application of Earl Vantrease, Jr. State of v. Clifton Williams, Jr. M SC-R11-CD Rutherford County Circuit Judge David M. Bragg No. F65511 Summers, Sr.J., Denied - Application of Clifton Williams, Jr. (Order filed ) Knoxville State of, Ex Rel Paul Allen, Et Al v. The City of Newport, E SC-R11-CV Cocke County Chancery Chancellor Telford Forgety No McClarty, J., Reversed Denied: Application of The City of Newport, Antonio J. Beasley, Sr. V. State of E SC-R11-PC Hamilton County Criminal Judge Rebecca J. Stern Nos , , , , , , Ogle, J. Witt, Jr., J Thomas, Jr., J Appeal Dismissed Denied: Application of Antonio J. Beasley, Sr. (Order Filed ) Patrick Devin Camp v. State of E SC-R11-PC Sullivan County Criminal Judge Robert H. Montgomery, Jr. No. C57, 818 Thomas, Jr., J., Denied: Application of Patrick Camp (Order Filed ) State of v. Ralph Byrd Cooper, Jr. E SC-R11-CD Anderson County Circuit Judge Donald Elledge No. A3CR0059 Woodall, J., Denied: Application of Ralph Byrd Cooper, Jr. Page 9 of 23

10 Jerry W. Dickerson v. David Sexton, Warden E SC-R11-HC Johnson County Circuit Judge R. Lynn W. Brown No Tipton, J., Denied: Application of State of v. Jaron Lee Goodson E SC-R11-CD Blount County Circuit Judge Tammy Harrington No. C20245 Williams, J., Denied: Application of Jaron Lee Goodson Harold Holloway v. David Sexton E SC-R11-HC Johnson County Circuit Judge Lynn W. Brown No Woodall, J., Denied: Application of Harold Holloway (Order Filed ) Bassam Issa v. Jack Benson, Sr. E SC-R11-CV Hamilton County Circuit Judge Marie Williams No. 12C283 Swiney, J., Denied: Application of Bassam Issa State of v. Raynella Dossett Leath E SC-R11-CD Knox County Criminal Judge Richard Baumgartner No Thomas, J., Denied: Application of Raynella Dossett Leath Jesse R. Miltier v. Bank of America, N. A. E SC-R11-CV Carter County Circuit Judge Thomas J. Seeley, Jr. No. C9814 McClarty, J., Denied: Application of Thomas E. Cowan, Jr. (Order Filed ) State of v. Quincy D. Moutry E SC-R11-CD Knox County Criminal Judge Jon Kerry Blackwood No Thomas, J., Denied: Application of Quincy D. Moutry Page 10 of 23

11 Sabra Elaine Ellis O Daniel v. Rusty Wade O Daniel E SC-R11-CV Hamilton County Chancery Judge Jeffrey M. Atherton No Susano, P.J., Reversed in Part, in Part, Case Remanded for further proceedings Denied: Application of Rusty Wade O Daniel Daylon D. Roberts v. David Sexton, Warden E SC-R11-HC Johnson County Circuit Judge Lynn W. Brown No Page, J., Denied: Application of Daylon D. Roberts James R. Sterchi, JR. V. L. Basil Savard E SC-R9-CV Bradley County Circuit Judge Lawrence H. Puckett No. V Susano, Jr., P.J. Swiney, J Frierson, II, JJ, J Rule 9 Application Denied Denied: Application of L. Basil Savard (Order Filed ) Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. V. W. Phillip Reed, Et Al. E SC-R11-CV Blount County Chancery Judge Telford E. Forgety No Swiney, J.,, Remanded Denied: Application of W. Phillip Reed Jerry Orlando Weaver v. State of E SC-R11-PC Anderson County Circuit Judge Donald R. Elledge No. B0C00843 Wedemeyer, J., Denied: Application of Jerry Orlando Weaver Lori K. Wilhoit, Et Al. v. Joshua Andrew Rogers, Et Al. E SC-R11-CV Washington County Circuit Judge Thomas J. Seeley, Jr. No Frierson, J., in part, Reversed in part, Remanded Denied: Application of Englewood Lawn & Landscape, LLC, and Joshua Andrew Rogers Page 11 of 23

12 Jackson State of v. Eric Bledsoe W SC-R11-CD Judge Chris Craft No Bivins, J., Denied: Application of Eric Bledsoe State of v. Tyrone Bohanna W SC-R11-CD Judge Lee Coffee No Smith, J., Denied: Application of Tyrone Bohanna Jerry Brock v. Jerry Lester, Warden W SC-R11-HC Lauderdale County Circuit Judge Joe Walker No Williams, J., (Rule 20) Denied: Application of Jerry Brock William T. Bryant v. State of W SC-R11-CO Obion County Circuit Judge William B. Acree, Jr. No. CC-12-CR-57 Ogle, J., Denied: Application of William T. Bryant State of v. Charlie Burks W SC-R11-CD Judge Lee V. Coffee Nos. B & B Page, J., Appeal Dismissed Denied: Application of Charlie Burks George Campbell, Jr. V. State of W SC-R11-CO Judge James C. Beasley, Jr. No Smith, J., Denied: Application of George Campbell, Jr. State of v. Casey Colbert W SC-R11-CD Judge James Lammey No , Bivins, J., in part, Reversed in part Denied: Application of Casey Colbert Page 12 of 23

13 Jordan Aston Danelz v. John Gayden, M.D. W SC-R11-JV Shelby County Juvenile Judge Curtis S. Person, Jr. Special Judge Dan H. Michael No. N6141 Kirby, J., Reversed in part, vacated in part and remanded Denied: Application of John Gayden, M.D. Kenneth E. Diggs v. DNA Diagnostic Center Et Al W SC-R11-CV Shelby County Chancery Chancellor Walter L. Evans No. CH Kirby, J., Denied: Application of Kenneth Diggs Denied Eight motions filed between September 9, 2013 and October 7, 2013 Pearlie Mae Dunigan, Ex Rel. Grover Dunigan v. State of W SC-R11-CV Claims Commission Judge Nancy Miller-Herron No Highers, J., Denied: Application of Pearlie Mae Dunigan State of v. Roy Demond Duncan W SC-R11-CD Madison County Circuit Judge Roy B. Morgan, Jr. No Woodall, J., in part, Reversed in part Denied: Application of Roy Demond Duncan Sarah Patricia Emanuele v. Joshua David Scritchfield W SC-R11-JV Shelby County Juvenile Judge Curtis S. Person, Jr. No. Y1079 Kirby, J., in part, Vacated in part Denied: Application of Sarah Patricia Emanuele (Order Filed ) State of v. Michael Allen Gibbs W SC-R11-CD Haywood County Circuit Judge Clayburn L. Peeples No 6458A Thomas, J., Reversed in Part Denied: Application of Michael Allen Gibbs State of v. Lashun Gray W SC-R11-CD Judge James M. Lammey, Jr. No Tipton, P.J., in part; Reversed in part Denied: Application of Lashun Gray Page 13 of 23

14 State of v. Andre Harris W SC-R11-CD Judge Lee V. Coffee No Page, J., Denied: Application of Andre Harris State of v. Jay Earl Haynes W SC-R11-CD Dyer County Circuit Judge Lee Moore No. 09-CR-288 Smith, J., Denied: Application of Jay Earl Haynes State of v. Warren Hildred W SC-R11-CD Judge Paula Skahan No Witt, Jr., J. Denied: Application of Warren Hildred State of v. Kenneth D. Hubanks W SC-R11-CD Hardin County Circuit Judge Creed McGinley No Wedemeyer, J., Denied: Application of Kenneth D. Hubanks Reginald D. Hughes v. Dwight Barbee, Warden W SC-R11-HC Lauderdale County Circuit Judge Joseph Walker No 6586 Woodall, J., Denied: Application of Reginald D. Hughes State of v. James Eric Hurd W SC-R11-CD Madison County Circuit Judge Roy B. Morgan, Jr. No Williams, J., Denied: Application of James Eric Hurd Vershawn McCoy v. State of W SC-R11-PC Judge John Fowlkes, Jr. No Smith, J., Denied - Application of Vershawn McCoy (Order filed ) State of v. Herman McKinley W SC-R11-CD Judge Lee Coffee No Williams, J., Denied: Application of Herman McKinley Page 14 of 23

15 Pervis Tyrone Payne v. State of W SC-R11-PD Judge J. Robert Carter No. P9594 McMullen, J., Denied Denied: Application of Pervis Tyrone Payne (Order filed ) Gerald Sanford v. State of W SC-R11-PC Judge Paula Skahan No Glenn, J., Denied - Application of Gerald Sanford (Order filed ) Michael L. Smith v. State of W SC-R11-HC Lake County Circuit Judge Lee Moore, Jr. No. 11-CR-9640 Woodall, J., Denied: Application of Michael L. Smith State of v. Darquan Swift W SC-R11-CD Judge W. Mark Ward No Page, J., Denied: Application of Darquan Swift State of v. Don Maurice Taylor W SC-R11-CD Gibson County Circuit Judge Clayburn L. Peeples No Ogle, J., Denied: Application of Don Maurice Taylor State of v. Demario Darnell Thompson W SC-R11-CD Madison County Circuit Judge Donald H. Allen No Tipton, P.J., Denied: Application of Demario Darnell Thompson Jerome Wall v. State of W SC-R11-PC Judge J. Robert Carter, Jr. No , Page, J., Dismissed Denied: Application of Jerome Wall Page 15 of 23

16 Clayton Ward v. Illinois Central Railroad Company W SC-R11-CV Shelby County Circuit Judge Jerry Stokes No. CT Stafford, J., Reversed & Remanded Denied: Application of Illinois Central Railroad Company State of v. Lee Weaver, Jr. W SC-R11-CD Hardin County Circuit Judge C. Creed McGinley No Smith, J., Denied - Application of Lee Weaver, Jr. (Order filed ) Jeremy Young v. State of W SC-R11-PC Judge W. Otis Higgs, Jr. No Thomas, J., Denied: Application of Jeremy Young Page 16 of 23

17 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE SAMUEL E. FOSTER ET AL. v. WALTER WILLIAM CHILES, III, M.D. ET AL. Circuit for Knox County No No. E SC-R11-CV- Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Walter William Chiles, III, M.D., Knoxville Urology Clinic, P.C., Gordon Lee Collins, M.D., Anesthesia Medical Alliance of East, P.C., Covenant Health and Parkwest Medical Center, and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 17 of 23

18 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE STATE OF TENNESSEE v. GWENDOLYN HAGERMAN Criminal for Sullivan County No. S57,179 No. E SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of Gwendolyn Hagerman s application for permission to appeal and the record before us, the application is granted and the case is remanded to the of Criminal Appeals with direction to order the parties to supplement the appellate record with the victim s Department of Children s Services records, which were sealed and filed with the trial court, and to reconsider the case in light of the supplemented appellate record. PER CURIAM Page 18 of 23

19 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE EDWARD THOMAS KENDRICK, III v. STATE OF TENNESSEE Criminal for Hamilton County No No. E SC-R11-PC - Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of the State of and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 19 of 23

20 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE LARRY SNEED v. THE CITY OF RED BANK, TENNESSEE Circuit for Hamilton County No. 12C1164 No. E SC-R11-CV - Filed November 12, 2013 ORDER The Employment Lawyers Association s motion to file an amicus brief is granted. Upon consideration of the Tenn. R. App. P. 11 application for permission to appeal filed on behalf of Larry Sneed, the amicus brief in support of the application, and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 20 of 23

21 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE ANDREW SPENCER v. NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY Circuit for Hamilton County No. 10C1029 No. E SC-R11-CV - Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Norfolk Southern Railway Company and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 21 of 23

22 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT JACKSON STATE OF TENNESSEE v. MARLO DAVIS Criminal for Shelby County No No. W SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of Marlo Davis application for permission to appeal and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 22 of 23

23 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE AT JACKSON STATE OF TENNESSEE v. BRODERICK DEVONTE FAYNE Circuit for Tipton County No No. W SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013 ORDER Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Broderick Devonte Fayne and the record before us, the application is granted. The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of briefing. PER CURIAM Page 23 of 23