SHOW ME YOUR PAPERS: A CONTENT ANALYSIS OF BARRIERS OF ANTI-IMMIGRATION LEGISLATION IN THE UNITED STATES. Meghan Dillon

Transcription

1 SHOW ME YOUR PAPERS: A CONTENT ANALYSIS OF BARRIERS OF ANTI-IMMIGRATION LEGISLATION IN THE UNITED STATES Meghan Dillon

2 Research Question How has the implementation and creation of antiimmigration laws created barriers for immigrants?

3 Thesis There is a progression in the amount of restrictions and barriers placed upon immigrant individuals in the United States with the development of each new piece anti-immigration legislation.

4 Literature Review SB 1070 And Copycat Legislation Trends, Barriers And Reduction Of Equal Opportunities Mexican Immigration to the United States: A Case Study

5 SB 1070 And Copycat Legislation Work together to discourage and deter the unlawful entry and presence of aliens and economic activity by persons unlawfully present in the United States (SB 1070, 2000) Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee and Texas (Lacayo, 2011) June 9 th, 2011 House Bill 56 was signed into law in Alabama (HB 56, 2011)

6 Trends, Barriers And Reduction Of Equal Opportunities Environment of racial profiling, encouraged statesanctioned discrimination and discrimination in schools based off of perceived ethnicity has arisen and attendance has decreased (NILC, 2012) Making or attempting to make business transactions with Alabama government officials a felony and also includes a school enrollment provision and a contract provision that makes contracts void if the other party is undocumented; three provisions not required in the earlier SB 1070 (NILC, 2012)

7 Mexican Immigration to the United States: A Case Study Estimated six million of Mexican immigrants were undocumented, representing around fifty six percent of the ten million undocumented immigrants in the United States at that time (Hanson, 2006) In the process of rediscovering the Mexicodiaspora affinity, observers have often overstated the political significance and intensity of the transborder connection and at times even romanticized the strength of the cultural bond (Shain, 2000)

8 Theory: The Critical Race Theory Scholars interested in studying and transforming the relationship among race, racism, and power (Delgado, 2006) An immigrant s race and social class plays a role in influencing anti-immigrant laws and policy-making due to popular misconceptions about immigrant individuals and specific racial groups. Questions claims of the current legal system and argues claims are a camouflage for the self-interest, power, and privilege of dominant groups in U.S. society (Solórzano, 1997) Policy recommendations generated from the focus on assimilation [to] maintain the status quo, ignore White privilege, and set the agenda to disadvantage racialized groups further (Romero, 2008)

9 Methodology Content Analysis Manifest and Latent coding Sample SB 1070 and SB 1070 style legislation Visited each state s government website to obtain copy of bills Arranged chronologically and randomly selected 7 of 15 bills Coding Opening coding

10 Findings Immigrant Identity Frequency of negative descriptions Immigration Status Acceptable vs. unacceptable immigration Basis For Profiling Race, color, national origin and the extent allowed Creation Of Barriers Education, employment verification, healthcare services and public benefits

11 Immigrant Identity Legal, illegal, unauthorized and unlawful used to depict a negative or positive identity Use of word illegal 51times in HB 56 of 66 total appearances Use of word legal 1 time in HB 87 of 12 total appearances The more frequently that the word alien was used, the more frequently negative descriptions were also used also the case in Arizona s SB 1070, Oklahoma s SB 908, Florida s HB 7809 and South Carolina s S 20 The way the identity of immigrants was described shaped overall kind of terminology used within the bills

12 Immigration Status Acceptable vs. unacceptable immigration Acceptable - US citizen, foreign national, permanent resident or resident alien Reference to United States government authorization Unacceptable - illegal alien, unauthorized alien, unlawful alien, illegal persons, etc Use of words and terms to describe and define unwanted immigration and/or persons

13 Basis For Profiling Use of race, color, religion or national origin as a means for identifying undocumented immigrants Appeared in 7 of 8 bills analyzed and 4 of 4 passed bills HB 738 (2/17/2011) was mentioned 1 out of 11 times and accounted for 4% of total references to race, color, religion or national origin where as HB 56 (6/9/2011) was mentioned 8 out of 14 times and accounted for 33% of total appearances

14 Creation Of Barriers Education, employment verification, healthcare services and public benefits Only HB 56 (6/9/2011) passed restrictions in all four areas 7 of 8 laws expressed need for employment verification Creation of barriers for US citizens

15 Discussion Societal patterns Use of labels to characterize individuals often to evoke emotions and compel action Labels frequently used to portray minority individuals in a negative light Role appearance plays in determining facts about individuals Profiling is allowed but only within specified extent Weaknesses/Strength Future for immigrants/immigration