Protecting Immigrant Families Campaign Public Charge Threats 101

Transcription

1 Protecting Immigrant Families Campaign Public Charge Threats 101 Campaign Call: March 29, 2018 CAMPAIGN CO-CHAIRS: NATIONAL IMMIGRATION LAW CENTER CENTER FOR LAW AND SOCIAL POLICY

2 I heard that the President wants to punish immigrants who use public benefits like Food Stamps! I heard even if their kids use anything! What is going on?

3 AGENDA I. Introduction II. Overview of Public Charge III.Recent Changes to the Foreign Affairs Manual (FAM) IV.Up Next: Notice of Public Rulemaking (NPRM) V.Messaging and Fighting Back VI.Protecting Immigrant Families Campaign VII.Next Steps

4 WHAT IS PUBLIC CHARGE?

5 5 BACKGROUND: PUBLIC CHARGE Public Charge is a term used in immigration law to refer to a person who is likely to become dependent on the government for financial and material support. An immigrant who is deemed likely to become a public charge may be denied admission to the U.S. or lawful permanent resident status.

6 WHEN IS PUBLIC CHARGE ASSESSED? A public charge assessment is made: When a person applies to enter the U.S. or Applies to adjust status to become a Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR), NOT when applying to become a U.S. citizen

7 7 PUBLIC CHARGE FACTORS The Public Charge determination is based on assessment of all relevant factors. The law requires immigration agents to consider an applicant s: Age Health Family status Financial status Education and skills Affidavit of support

8 WHAT BENEFITS ARE CONSIDERED? Agents are permitted to consider other relevant factors. Under current policy, only two types of public benefits may be considered: 1.Cash assistance for income maintenance 2.Institutionalization for long-term care

9 9 THINGS TO KEEP IN MIND Certain immigrants, including refugees, asylees, survivors of trafficking, domestic violence and other serious crimes, and others are not subject to the public charge test. The decision is forward-looking and can t be based only on what happened in the past. No single factor determines whether a person is likely to become a public charge. All relevant factors must be considered.

10 RECENT CHANGES: FOREIGN AFFAIRS MANUAL (FAM)

11 FOREIGN AFFAIRS MANUAL (FAM) CHANGES Officials in U.S. embassies and consulates abroad use the FAM to make decisions about whether to grant non U.S. citizens permission to enter the U.S. Major changes published on January 3, Receipt of non-cash benefits may be considered as part of totality of circumstances test Shifts focus from sponsor to applicant and applicant s family members Too early to know how changes will be implemented by each U.S. Embassy or Consular office. NOTE: ONLY impacts people seeking to enter the U.S. from abroad

12 PUBLIC CHARGE: NOTICE OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING (NPRM)

13 13 PUBLIC CHARGE PROPOSED RULE LEAKED DRAFTS

14 14 PUBLIC CHARGE PROPOSED RULE LAW passed by Congress, signed by the president REGULATION adopted by agency, after public comment POLICY adopted by agency Important parts of the law cannot be changed by regulation: Public charge is NOT a factor when applying for citizenship The balance of factors has to be considered Some categories of immigrants are exempt

15 15 DRAFT PROPOSED RULE: CONTENT DHS/USCIS allowed to consider a much broader array of services and benefits in the public charge determination. Leaked draft includes: Health programs like non-emergency Medicaid, CHIP and ACA Marketplace subsidies/tax credits Nutrition programs like SNAP and WIC Housing assistance Energy assistance (LIHEAP) Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) Benefits received by dependents including citizen children may be considered

16 DRAFT PROPOSED RULE: CONTENT Certain benefits likely EXEMPT from consideration in the public charge determination including: Earned benefits connected to work or military service (SSDI, veteran s benefits, unemployment, worker s comp) Medicare Emergency and disaster assistance Government student loans K-12 Education benefits, including Head Start

17 DRAFT PROPOSED RULE: CONTENT Rule not retroactive Noncash benefits used before a public charge rule is finalized are not likely to be used as a factor in a public charge determination for an individual or family member. Certain heavily weighted factors Positive Includes having income and assets of at least 250 FPL Negative Includes receiving public benefits in the past 36 months

18 18 EXAMPLE: ANGIE Angie is a 32 year old single mother with four children. She wants to become a lawful permanent resident (green card holder) Recently completed her nursing degree and is working for a hospital Sister sponsored her to come to the US US Citizen Kids received Medicaid and SNAP (Food Stamps) while she was in school

19 19 EXAMPLE: ANGIE Negative factors Supports a large family Children received Medicaid and SNAP Positive Factors Working age Good health Has a job Skills are in demand Has a sponsor

20 20 PROPOSED RULE: TIMELINE 1 USCIS finalizes draft rule Draft goes to Office of Management and Budget 2 Proposed rule published in Federal Register 3 Opportunity for Public Comment 4 Final rule published 5

21 PUBLIC CHARGE: MESSAGING AND FIGHTING BACK

22 22 PUBLIC MESSAGING UNDEMOCRATIC end-run around Congress Rewrites our national immigration narrative and undermines American values of hard work and opportunity Current laws ALREADY bar immigrant access to benefits Bad for public health and our economy Forces parents to decide between obtaining a permanent immigration status or providing for children Harms CHILDREN and future generations

23 23 MESSAGING TO IMMIGRANT FAMILIES MESSAGING TO FAMILIES The rules for immigrants who apply for a green card in the U.S. (who are not processed abroad) have not changed. Receipt of non-cash public benefits for which you are eligible currently are not considered when you obtain a green card in the U.S. Many families are not subject to public charge Public charge test considers totality of the circumstances. -- Families need to make individual determinations based on their situation. -- Using health care and nutrition benefits can help you be stronger, healthier and less likely to be dependent on the government For individuals currently receiving public assistance, there may be no advantage to terminating benefits at this time.

24 24 STRATEGIES TO RESPOND BEFORE the Proposed Rule is Published Educate your networks to fight the chilling effect and prepare them to fight back (draft s and info sheets available!) Talk to policymakers and urge them to oppose changes Map out coalitions and groups you can work with to fight back Identify individuals who may be willing to share their story publicly AFTER the Proposed Rule is Published Join efforts to submit public comments: organizational and individual Educate and advise immigrant families

25 STORY GATHERING WHY: We want to work with individuals and families to help them tell their stories for public education, to inform advocacy materials, and to highlight the harm of the proposed rule to elected officials, agency staff, and media outlets. HOW: send a short to Kat Lundie at lundie@nilc.org with the subject line Protecting Immigrant Families Story. Please provide the following information: First name of the person whose story would be shared; their city, state, and address (if available); and a phone number at which we can contact you or the person for follow-up. Why access to public programs or benefits is essential to this individual and/or their family. A brief summary of the family s immigration story

26 PROTECTING IMMIGRANT FAMILIES, ADVANCING OUR FUTURE: THE CAMPAIGN

27 THE PROTECTING IMMIGRANT FAMILIES CAMPAIGN Brings leading advocates from multiple sectors together to defend against threats to immigrant families access to core health, nutrition and economic supports, and also to lay the foundation for future gains.

28 MANY LEVELS OF INVOLVEMENT Vestibulum cogue Co-Chairs and Steering Committee Sector Leads, Active Members and Workgroups Lorem ipsum congue empus Allies General Public

29 WORKGROUPS AND SECTOR LEADS Federal Advocacy Policy and Legal Analysis Research Communication Education and Mobilization

30 GET INVOLVED! Campaign Resources: Sign up for Campaign listserv: For organizations: to join Campaign as an active member and participate in working groups:

31 31 WRAP UP Public charge changes are coming Important to spread the word and prepare to push back without creating mass panic. Remember: this is just a preliminary draft! Materials available Stay tuned for more updates and resources

32 32 QUESTIONS Please add your questions to the chat box! We will follow up on all questions submitted, even if we are not able to answer them during the call.