Out of Its Comfort Zone: Indonesia and the South China Sea
|
|
- Gabriella Kelley
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Out of Its Comfort Zone: Indonesia and the South China Sea Ristian Atriandi Supriyanto Asia Policy, Number 21, January 2016, pp (Article) Published by National Bureau of Asian Research DOI: For additional information about this article Access provided by Kathmandu Model College (5 Feb :11 GMT)
2 roundtable non-claimant perspectives on the south china sea Out of Its Comfort Zone: Indonesia and the South China Sea Ristian Atriandi Supriyanto During a visit to Tokyo in 2015, Indonesia s president Joko Widodo publicly rejected China s so-called nine-dash or U-shaped line claim in the South China Sea. Yet shortly thereafter in Beijing, he also agreed with Chinese president Xi Jinping that Indonesia s global maritime fulcrum (poros maritim dunia) concept is complementary to China s 21st Century Maritime Silk Road. 1 Widodo s statements give the impression that Indonesia is conveying a conflicting message to China, expressing concern about the U-shaped line while simultaneously trying to cultivate a closer economic relationship through maritime cooperation. This approach appears to reflect a hedging strategy that Indonesia and other Southeast Asian nations take in both accommodating and confronting China s rise at the same time. 2 In the long run, however, Indonesia could face a fork in the road where it will be unable to have closer cooperation with China while concurrently resisting intimidation and coercion whenever and wherever China attempts to impose the U-shaped line. This essay examines Indonesia s perspective as a non-claimant state on the South China Sea disputes. The first section discusses Indonesia s interests in the South China Sea. The essay then considers the relevance of Indonesia s status as a non-claimant state for its role in the disputes and assesses the implications of the South China Sea disputes for Indonesia s relationships with China and the United States. Finally, the conclusion discusses the future that Indonesia envisages for the South China Sea. ristian atriandi supriyanto is an Indonesian Presidential PhD Scholar with the Strategic and Defence Studies Centre at the Australian National University. He can be reached at <ristian.supriyanto@anu.edu.au>. 1 Kanupriya Kapoor and Linda Sieg, Indonesian President Says China s Main Claim in South China Sea Has No Legal Basis, Reuters, March 23, 2015 u and Joint Statement on Strengthening Comprehensive Strategic Partnership between the People s Republic of China and the Republic of Indonesia, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People s Republic of China, March 26, 2015 u 2 Cheng-Chwee Kuik, Malaysia s Balancing Act, New York Times, December 6, 2015 u [ 21 ]
3 asia policy What Is at Stake? The territorial disputes in the South China Sea place Indonesia s interests at stake, namely the security of the resource-rich Natuna Islands, the sanctity of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the security of sea lines of communication, and nonalignment vis-à-vis the major powers. The security of the Natuna Islands is Indonesia s immediate concern in the South China Sea. China has never claimed the islands, yet neither has it clarified to Indonesian policymakers the meaning of the U-shaped line. Indonesia rejects the U-shaped line and claims to have neither territorial nor boundary disputes with China. 3 However, Indonesia is increasingly concerned with the potential spillover effects of conflict between China and other claimants as a result of Beijing s assertive enforcement of the U-shaped line. The Natuna Islands are scattered across over 100,000 square miles of ocean more than ten times the size of their total land area and only 27 out of the 154 islands are inhabited, with a total population of around 76,000 people. 4 Despite the lack of infrastructure, the Natuna Islands are one of Indonesia s richest regencies in offshore natural resources. Fisheries are estimated to yield a potential of 500,000 tons annually, but in reality the locals manage to haul in only a third of it through traditional methods. Chinese fishermen continually venture south into the fishing grounds around the islands, escorted by Chinese government fishery patrol vessels. A number of incidents have occurred between these vessels and Indonesian maritime authorities while the latter were trying to apprehend illegal Chinese fishermen, including one threatening encounter in which a Chinese government vessel trained its guns on an Indonesian patrol boat. 5 Beneath the seabed also lie vast energy resources. Located within the purported overlap of the U-shaped line, the East Natuna block (block D-Alpha) is estimated to contain one of the world s largest gas reserves at around 46 trillion cubic feet. Indonesia s oil and gas company, Pertamina, in partnerships with U.S.-based ExxonMobil, France s Total SA, 3 Randy Faby and Ben Blanchard, Indonesia Asks China to Clarify South China Sea Claims, Reuters, November 12, 2015 u N0T10KK #FpxvFikQ4V2vr8eB Ristian Atriandi Supriyanto, Indonesia s Natuna Islands: Next Flashpoint in the South China Sea? S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), RSIS Commentary, no. 033, February 16, 2015 u 5 Scott Bentley, Shaping the Narrative: New Chinese Documentary Revisits Indonesia and the South China Sea, Australian Strategic Policy Institute, Strategist, February 26, 2014 u org.au/shaping-the-narrative-new-chinese-documentary-revisits-indonesia-and-the-south-china-sea. [ 22 ]
4 roundtable non-claimant perspectives on the south china sea and Thailand s PTT Public Company Limited, plans to begin production in Additionally, Pertamina holds some shares in the offshore blocks near Vietnam in the Nam Con Son Basin with PetroVietnam and Petronas that might overlap with the U-shaped line. Chinese insistence on the U-shaped line also devalues Indonesia s belief in the sanctity of UNCLOS. Jakarta has been consistently advocating for the convention, which recognizes Indonesia as an archipelagic state, so that it may draw straight archipelagic baselines joining the outermost islands and dying reefs of the archipelago. 7 Indonesia s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) boundary north of the Natuna Islands was drawn in this manner. After China published its U-shaped line map again in 2009, Indonesia responded that China s claim clearly lacks international legal basis and is tantamount to upset[ting] the UNCLOS This statement reflects the sentiments of Indonesian diplomats, who consider the U-shaped line only as an illustrative map and not a real map and as incomplete, inaccurate, inconsistent and legally problematic. 9 Apart from undermining UNCLOS, the South China Sea disputes could impede on the security of sea lines of communication. While merchant shipping navigation has not been violated, the growing risk of conflict could increase insurance rates and deter merchant ships from passing through the South China Sea. China might urge ships to provide notification through electronic or other means to its monitoring stations located in Chinesecontrolled artificial features in the area, thus providing indirect recognition of China s sovereignty over the U-shaped line. Moreover, China could insist that commercial flights in and from the region, including Indonesia, comply with an air defense identification zone (ADIZ). These outcomes, albeit unlikely, are not impossible. Indonesia has clearly stated that it would reject a Chinese ADIZ, 10 and it would likewise reject Chinese-imposed reporting for foreign ships passing through the U-shaped line. 6 Amahl Azwar, Govt Looks to Approve East Natuna Bid, Jakarta Post, August 14, 2013 u 7 According to Article 7 of UNCLOS, straight baselines can be drawn only under exceptional circumstances. 8 United Nations, Permanent Mission of the Republic of Indonesia, no. 480/POL-703/VII/10, July 8, 2010 u idn_2010re_mys_vnm_e.pdf. The Indonesian version of this note uses stronger words against China s U-shaped line. 9 Arif Havas Oegroseno, Indonesia, South China Sea and the 11/10/9-dashed lines, Jakarta Post, April 9, 2014 u dashed-lines.html. 10 Esther Teo, South China Sea Air Zone? Complicated, Says Beijing, Straits Times, February 20, 2014 u [ 23 ]
5 asia policy Finally, as tensions in the South China Sea increase, Indonesia s nonalignment vis-à-vis the major powers could be compromised. Indonesia maintains an independent and active (bebas aktif) foreign policy that emphasizes nonalignment. Although this policy eschews formal military alliances with foreign countries, Indonesia cannot remain neutral when international law is violated, especially when the violation occurs right within its front yard. By the same token, while formal military alliances are out of the question, anything short of that is possible. Jakarta wishes to cultivate close ties with both Beijing and Washington, as well as with other major powers, but its order of preference ultimately depends on who is aligned more closely with Indonesia s national interests. Jakarta currently considers Beijing and Washington as both responsible for intensifying tensions in the South China Sea. However, Indonesia can also see that Beijing is a source of anxiety in the views of Southeast Asian claimants and thinks that Washington s policy is largely a reaction to Beijing s provocative behavior. Although it is not in Indonesia s interest to lean on one major power against another, if push comes to shove, external assistance would be necessary, including closer military cooperation with the United States. A Cautious Non-claimant In May 2010, through its UN representative in New York, Indonesia declared that it is not a claimant State to the sovereignty disputes in the South China Sea, and as such Indonesia has played an impartial yet active role in establishing confidence-building measures among the claimant States and creating an atmosphere of peace through a series of workshops on the South China Sea since However, being a non-claimant state connotes a double meaning. On the one hand, Indonesia does not lay claim to the disputed features in the South China Sea (such as the Spratly Islands), nor does it take sides with any claimant states with regard to the territorial disputes therein. On the other hand, Indonesia can attempt to be an honest broker by facilitating confidence-building measures among claimant states to peacefully manage their disputes. Understood in this context, Indonesia s non-claimant status is not equivalent to that of a disinterested party. On the contrary, its non-claimant status creates a comfort zone where Indonesia can avoid being drawn into the fray alongside the claimant states, elevate its diplomatic prestige by offering to be an honest broker to the claimants, 11 United Nations, Permanent Mission of the Republic of Indonesia. [ 24 ]
6 roundtable non-claimant perspectives on the south china sea and reap prospective benefits of closer cooperation with China and the United States. 12 By consistently rejecting the U-shaped line, Indonesia can avoid creating the perception that it has become a claimant state. If it were to acknowledge that overlaps do exist between the U-shaped line and its EEZ, Indonesia would indirectly lend credence to Beijing s claim and undermine its credibility as a non-claimant state. This non-claimant status also allows Indonesia to elevate its diplomatic prestige by offering to facilitate dialogues through a multilateral, consensus-building approach. Indonesia did this in the 1990s by facilitating an informal workshop series to reduce tensions and build confidence among the claimants and other interested parties. More recently, Indonesia has tried to help preserve ASEAN s unity in the face of disagreements over the South China Sea disputes, such as following the 2012 ASEAN Foreign Ministers Meeting in Phnom Penh. This preference for a multilateral, consensus-building approach is also reflected in Indonesia s continuing emphasis on the implementation of the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea and attempts to formulate a code of conduct, rather than on the Philippines unilateral decision to seek international arbitration in The Hague, as the best way to manage the South China Sea disputes. Through such an approach, Indonesia can better showcase its role as an honest broker, while at the same time elevating its diplomatic prestige as ASEAN s primus inter pares now buttressed with President Widodo s maritime diplomacy agenda. In contrast, unilateral approaches, such as the Philippines arbitration decision, are seen as divisive and leave less maneuvering room for Indonesia to play a greater facilitating role. Relationships with China and the United States Indonesia s non-claimants status allows it to avoid the political baggage of territorial disputes when cultivating closer cooperation with China and the United States. Despite its repeated verbal backlash against the U-shaped line claim, Indonesia welcomes growing economic and security cooperation with China. As of September 2015, China is Indonesia s largest trading partner with a total value of around $27.2 billion. 13 Jakarta is interested in 12 Douglas Johnson, Drawn into the Fray: Indonesia s Natuna Islands Meet China s Long Gaze South, Asian Affairs 42, no. 3 (1997): World Trade Organization, Indonesia, September 2015 u WSDBCountryPFView.aspx?Language=S&Country=ID. [ 25 ]
7 asia policy Beijing s investment pledges, especially through the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, to finance large-scale infrastructure projects, such as seaports, that can help achieve President Widodo s maritime agenda. 14 The fanfare surrounding Sino-Indonesian maritime cooperation at times gives the impression that Indonesia is strategically tilting toward China. However, these closer economic ties with China are just another expression of Indonesia s pragmatic policy to finance its cash-strapped infrastructure development. 15 The government reports that in only 7% of Beijing s investments in Indonesia were actually implemented. 16 A similar trend is also found in bilateral security cooperation. Although both countries have announced joint military activities and projects, including special forces and naval exercises, missile development, and surveillance systems, these activities are mainly symbolic and add little substantial value to Indonesia s cooperation with its traditional Western partners, such as the United States and European Union. Instead, Sino-Indonesian security cooperation can be seen as a diplomatic way to showcase Jakarta s nonalignment policy, if not also as a diversionary maneuver to gain more military assistance from the West amid the intensifying Sino-U.S. geopolitical competition. On the other hand, Indonesia remains wary of closer alignment with the United States and other Western countries, lest it be accused of violating its independent and active foreign policy. The United States remains one of Indonesia s top trade and investment partners, and Jakarta has shown interest in joining the U.S.-led Trans Pacific Partnership. Indonesia is also trying to deepen the country s military partnership with the United States and its allies, including in the maritime domain. Growing concern over Chinese maritime assertiveness in the South China Sea has led Jakarta and Washington to conduct military surveillance flights over the Natuna Islands and the surrounding waters and to plan regular submarine engagements 14 Ben Otto, China-Led Bank to Focus on Big-Ticket Projects, Indonesia Says, Wall Street Journal, April 10, 2015 u 15 Rizal Sukma, Insight: Is Indonesia Tilting toward China? Jakarta Post, December 11, 2015 u 16 BKPM Seeks to Boost Investment from China, Indonesian Investment Coordinating Board, March 23, 2015 u +Investment+from+China#.Vnj4UpN973A. [ 26 ]
8 roundtable non-claimant perspectives on the south china sea and operations. 17 In addition, Indonesia is a target recipient country of the U.S.-funded Southeast Asia Maritime Security Initiative that was announced in Such U.S. assistance could help Indonesia develop its nascent coast guard agency to better patrol the country s vast maritime swathes, including waters around the Natuna Islands. However, this development should not be interpreted as a sign of Indonesia s alignment with the United States. If all things stay the same, Indonesia still wishes to see all major powers, especially the United States and China, keep each other in check. Thus, its interests continue to lie in preserving ASEAN unity and centrality against the domination of a single major power. Conclusion: Future Instability Without doubt, the most interesting question is what happens if all things fail to stay the same. In other words, what if the claimant states and interested parties engage in behaviors that make the South China Sea less stable and more prone to conflict? From the moment China revealed its U-shaped line at an Indonesia-facilitated workshop in 1993 until 2010, Indonesia could simultaneously both cultivate closer cooperation with China and reject the U-shaped line. This is the status quo Indonesia wishes to uphold. The strategic ambiguity that China carefully and masterfully maintained in the last two decades helped sustain this status quo. By keeping the U-shaped line from claiming the insular features of the Natuna Islands, China removed the most sensitive of Indonesia s sovereignty concerns. It is becoming clearer, however, that China s ambiguity is more declaratory than actual. Despite this vague stance on the potential overlap between the U-shaped line and Indonesia s EEZ boundary, China s behavior suggests that the line can stretch as far south as Beijing wants. Even if China were to decide to compromise and adjust the southern extremity of the U-shaped line to align with Indonesia s EEZ boundary, Jakarta would still not accept such a move because of the intimidating and coercive nature via which Beijing enforces its claim vis-à-vis the ASEAN claimants, even apart from the illegality of the U-shaped line itself under UNCLOS. 17 Kanupriya Kapoor and Randy Fabi, Indonesia Eyes Regular Navy Exercises with U.S. in South China Sea, Reuters, April 13, 2015 u and Brian Reynolds, Submarine Group 7 Strengthens Ties with the Indonesian Submarine Force, Submarine Force Pacific, April 20, 2015 u submarine-group-7-strengthens-ties-with-the-indonesian-submarine-force. [ 27 ]
9 asia policy As China increasingly finds the status quo untenable, Indonesia grows more convinced that the South China Sea is becoming unstable. The former chief of the Indonesian Armed Forces, General Moeldoko, felt dismayed with the U-shaped line and pledged that the Indonesian National Defence Forces would strengthen their presence in Natuna. 18 This would include a greater deployment of naval and air assets for combat and surveillance purposes. Indonesia s top security minister and former senior adviser to President Widodo, Luhut Pandjaitan, has even threatened to take China to an international court if it continues to assert its U-shaped line, which has the potential to affect the security of the Natuna Islands. 19 Unlike in the past, when it had to rely more on diplomatic overtures, China can now utilize its naval and law-enforcement capabilities to impose its territorial claims. The recent fortification and militarization of features claimed by China has created anxiety in Indonesia, not just because of their proximity to the Natuna Islands, but also because Chinese activities could destabilize the situation further and increase the risk of conflict, with real consequences for Indonesia s interests. It appears that the sooner Indonesia begins contemplating a life out of its comfort zone, the better it can brace for this future instability. 18 Moeldoko, China s Dismaying New Claims in the South China Sea, Wall Street Journal, April 24, 2014 u 19 Sara Schonhardt and Ben Otto, Indonesia Invokes International Tribunal in South China Sea Dispute, Wall Street Journal, November 12, 2015 u indonesia-invokes-international-tribunal-in-south-china-sea-dispute [ 28 ]
This document is downloaded from DR-NTU, Nanyang Technological University Library, Singapore.
This document is downloaded from DR-NTU, Nanyang Technological University Library, Singapore. Title Who governs the South China Sea? Author(s) Rosenberg, David Citation Rosenberg, D. (2016). Who governs
More informationSouth China Sea- An Insight
South China Sea- An Insight Historical Background China laid claim to the South China Sea (SCS) back in 1947. It demarcated its claims with a U-shaped line made up of eleven dashes on a map, covering most
More informationHARMUN Chair Report. The Question of the South China Sea. Head Chair -William Harding
HARMUN Chair Report The Question of the South China Sea Head Chair -William Harding will_harding@student.aishk.edu.hk Introduction Placed in between the Taiwan Strait and the Straits of Malacca Straits
More informationGeopolitics, International Law and the South China Sea
THE TRILATERAL COMMISSION 2012 Tokyo Plenary Meeting Okura Hotel, 21-22 April 2012 EAST ASIA I: GEOPOLITICS OF THE SOUTH CHINA SEA SATURDAY 21 APRIL 2012, ASCOT HALL, B2F, SOUTH WING Geopolitics, International
More informationSouth China Sea: Realpolitik Trumps International Law
South China Sea: Realpolitik Trumps International Law Emeritus Professor Carlyle A. Thayer Presentation to East Asian Economy and Society, Institut für Ostasienwissenschaften Universität Wien Vienna, November
More information12 August 2012, Yeosu EXPO, Republic of Korea. Session I I Asia and UNCLOS: Progress, Practice and Problems
2012 Yeosu International Conference Commemorating the 30 th Anniversary of the Opening for Signature of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 12 August 2012, Yeosu EXPO, Republic of Korea
More informationDefinition of key terms
Committee: Security Council Issue title: Terriotorial disputes over the South China Sea Submitted by: Stuart Verkek, Deputy President of Security Council Edited by: Kamilla Tóth, President of the General
More informationI. Background: An Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) is an area of water a certain distance off the coast where countries have sovereign rights to
South China Seas Edison Novice Committee I. Background: An Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) is an area of water a certain distance off the coast where countries have sovereign rights to economic ventures
More informationConference Summary: Revisiting and Innovating Maritime Security Order in the Asia-Pacific. Nanjing, China November 2-4, 2016
Conference Summary: Revisiting and Innovating Maritime Security Order in the Asia-Pacific Nanjing, China November 2-4, 2016 Introduction An international selection of scholars from Asia and North America
More informationAssessing China s Land Reclamation in the South China Sea
Assessing China s Land Reclamation in the South China Sea By Sukjoon Yoon / Issue Briefings, 4 / 2015 China s unprecedented land reclamation projects have emerged as one of its key strategies in the South
More informationCommittee Introduction. Background Information
Committee: Disarmament and International Security (DISEC) Agenda: Peaceful yet effective solutions to the territorial disputes in the South China Sea Written by: 정윤철, 박진원 Committee Introduction The Disarmament
More informationGame Changer in the Maritime Disputes
www.rsis.edu.sg No. 180 18 July 2016 RSIS Commentary is a platform to provide timely and, where appropriate, policy-relevant commentary and analysis of topical issues and contemporary developments. The
More informationHearing on the U.S. Rebalance to Asia
March 30, 2016 Prepared statement by Sheila A. Smith Senior Fellow for Japan Studies, Council on Foreign Relations Before the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission Hearing on the U.S. Rebalance
More informationThe South China Sea Territorial Disputes in ASEAN-China Relations Aileen S.P. Baviera, University of the Philippines
The South China Sea Territorial Disputes in ASEAN-China Relations Aileen S.P. Baviera, University of the Philippines Recent events call attention to the territorial disputes in the South China Sea as a
More informationTara Davenport Research Fellow Centre for International Law
Maritime Security in Southeast Asia: Maritime Governance Session 3 Provisional Arrangements of a Practical Nature: Problems and Prospects in Southeast Asia Tara Davenport Research Fellow Centre for International
More informationEast Asian Maritime Disputes and U.S. Interests. Presentation by Michael McDevitt
East Asian Maritime Disputes and U.S. Interests Presentation by Michael McDevitt Worlds top ports by total cargo 2012 1. Shanghai, China (ECS) 744 million tons 2. Singapore (SCS) 537.6 3. Tianjin, China
More informationProspects for the Code of Conduct in the South China Sea after Hague decision
Prospects for the Code of Conduct in the South China Sea after Hague decision by Richard Q. Turcsányi, PhD. On 12 July 2016, the Permanent Arbitration Court in The Hague issued the final decision in the
More informationRemarks by. H.E. Le Luong Minh. Secretary-General of ASEAN High-Level International Workshop 2015:
Remarks by H.E. Le Luong Minh Secretary-General of ASEAN High-Level International Workshop 2015: Managing South China Sea Conflict from ASEAN Perspective 26 June 2015, Hotel Borobudur, Jakarta ----------------------
More informationPhilippines U.S. pawn in its looming clash with China?
POWER FEUDS IN THE SCS (WPS): Prospects of Dispute Settlement between Philippines & China Philippines U.S. pawn in its looming clash with China? Political Science Week, UP Manila Dec. 04, 2012 By Center
More informationRecent Developments in the South China Sea: Reclamation, Navigation and Arbitration
Recent Developments in the South China Sea: Reclamation, Navigation and Arbitration EIAS Briefing Seminar 16 June 2016 The South China Sea, through which USD 5.3 trillion worth of maritime trade passes
More informationASEAN & the South China Sea Disputes
Asian Studies Centre, St Antony s College University of Oxford China Centre 19-20 October 2017 Session V, Friday 20 th, 11.15-12.45 ASEAN & the South China Sea Disputes Robert Beckman Head, Ocean Law and
More informationDisputed Areas in the South China Sea
Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam The 5 th International Workshop The South China Sea: Cooperation for Regional Security and Development 10-12 November, 2013, Hanoi, Viet Nam Vietnam Lawyers Association Disputed
More informationCoalition Building in ASEAN. Orlando S. Mercado, PhD
Coalition Building in ASEAN Orlando S. Mercado, PhD OUTLINE Present issues concerning ASEAN (focus on South China Sea issue) ASEAN Way evolution, changes, current mechanisms ASEAN Way: a stumbling block
More informationand the role of Japan
1 Prospect for change in the maritime security situation in Asia and the role of Japan Maritime Security in Southeast and Southwest Asia IIPS International Conference Dec.11-13, 2001 ANA Hotel, Tokyo Masahiro
More informationYan YAN, National Institute for South China Sea Studies, China. Draft Paper --Not for citation and circulation
The 10 th CSCAP General Conference Confidence Building in the Asia Pacific: The Security Architecture of the 21 st Century October 21-23, 2015 Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia Yan YAN, National Institute for South
More informationChina s Response to the Permanent Court of Arbitration s Ruling on the South China Sea
China s Response to the Permanent Court of Arbitration s Ruling on the South China Sea Shinji Yamaguchi Regional Studies Department, National Institute for Defense Studies The decision awarded to the Philippines
More informationChinese Reactions to Japan s Defence White Paper
Chinese Reactions to Japan s Defence White Paper Pranamita Baruah On 2 August 2011, Japanese Diet (Parliament) approved the 37 th Defence White Paper titled Defense of Japan 2011. In analysing the security
More informationThe Habibie Center, Jakarta July 26, 2016
THE HABIBIE CENTER DISCUSSION REPORT No. 25/July2016 th 36 TALKING ASEAN Post-Tribunal s Ruling South China Sea Dispute The Habibie Center, Jakarta July 26, 2016 INTRODUCTION JAKARTA On Tuesday, 26 July
More informationDiplomatic Coordination. Bonji Ohara The Tokyo Foundation. Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1-3, 2015
Diplomatic Coordination Bonji Ohara The Tokyo Foundation Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1-3, 2015 Introduction Asian governments and security establishments presume that the United States
More informationCan the COC Establish a Framework for a Cooperative Mechanism in the South China Sea? Robert Beckman
9 th South China Sea International Conference: Cooperation for Regional Security & Development 27-28 Nov 2017, Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam Session 7: Panel Discussion: Code of Conduct (COC): Substance and
More informationIntroduction East Asia in 2014
Introduction East Asia in 2014 The year 2014 in East Asia was a year of growing risks to security that could lead to serious unforeseen incidents or armed confrontations. Among the contributing factors
More informationThe Nomocracy Pursuit of the Maritime Silk Road On Legal Guarantee of State s Marine Rights and Interests
Journal of Shipping and Ocean Engineering 6 (2016) 123-128 doi 10.17265/2159-5879/2016.02.007 D DAVID PUBLISHING The Nomocracy Pursuit of the Maritime Silk Road On Legal Guarantee of State s Marine Rights
More informationAssessing the ASEAN-China Framework for the Code of Conduct for the South China Sea
RESEARCHERS AT ISEAS YUSOF ISHAK INSTITUTE ANALYSE CURRENT EVENTS Singapore 8 August 2017 Assessing the ASEAN-China Framework for the Code of Conduct for the South China Sea Ian Storey* EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
More informationThe Belt and Road Initiative: The China-Philippines relation in the South China Sea beyond the Arbitration
The Belt and Road Initiative: The China-Philippines relation in the South China Sea beyond the Arbitration Professor Vasco Becker-Weinberg Faculty of Law of the Universidade NOVA de Lisboa The Belt and
More informationp o l i c y q & a An Australian Perspective on U.S. Rebalancing toward Asia
p o l i c y q & a AN INTERVIEW WITH RORY MEDCALF An Australian Perspective on U.S. Rebalancing toward Asia By SAR AH SER IZAWA Published: April 30, 2012 Earlier this month, U.S. Marines arrived in Australia
More information2018 Legal Committee Background Guide
2018 Legal Committee Background Guide The University of Notre Dame Model United Nations Conference February 2-4, 2018 Dear Delegates, I wish you a warm welcome to the second annual NDMUN. I am absolutely
More informationTo summarize, the details of the article that is of interest to us are as follows:
From: natalie@isis.org.my To: rarogers@um.edu.my CC: rroy75@hotmail.com Subject: ASEAN Newsletter Date: Thu, 22 Nov 2012 16:21:17 +0800 Dear Mr. Roy Anthony Rogers, I hope this email finds you well. As
More informationMilitarization of the South China Sea
PASMUN VII 2016 GENERAL ASSEMBLY FIRST COMMITTEE DISARMAMENT & INTERNATIONAL SECURITY Militarization of the South China Sea Chair - Jessie Wu Pacific American School Model United Nations VII Annual Session
More informationThe Legal Regime Governing Passage on Routes used for International Navigation through Indonesian Waters. Robert Beckman
42 nd Annual Conference of the Center for Oceans Law & Policy Cooperation and Engagement in the Asia Pacific Region Beijing, China, 24-26 May 2018 Panel 4: Straits Governance The Legal Regime Governing
More informationContents. Preface... iii. List of Abbreviations...xi. Executive Summary...1. Introduction East Asia in
Preface... iii List of Abbreviations...xi Executive Summary...1 Introduction East Asia in 2013...27 Chapter 1 Japan: New Development of National Security Policy...37 1. Establishment of the NSC and Formulation
More informationGUIDELINES FOR REGIONAL MARITIME COOPERATION
MEMORANDUM 4 GUIDELINES FOR REGIONAL MARITIME COOPERATION Introduction This document puts forward the proposed Guidelines for Regional maritime Cooperation which have been developed by the maritime Cooperation
More informationWhat a Nixed Energy Project Reveals About Vietnam s South China Sea Calculus
Vietnamese protesters hold national flags and an anti-china banner during a rally near the Chinese Embassy in Seoul, South Korea, July 24, 2016 (AP photo by Ahn Young-joon). What a Nixed Energy Project
More informationCounteracting Chinese Hegemony in the South China Sea
Perspective Counteracting Chinese Hegemony in the South China Sea Matthew Baker August 2012 Key Facts The South China Sea potentially holds vast Natural Gas reserves: The EIA estimates that total gas resources
More informationStrategic & Defence Studies Centre ANU College of Asia & the Pacific The Australian National University
The CENTRE of GRAVITY Series The US Pivot to Asia and Implications for Australia Robert S Ross Professor, Boston College and Associate, Harvard University March 2013 Strategic & Defence Studies Centre
More informationThe Philippines Criticizes China
The Philippines Criticizes China Feb. 24, 2017 The honeymoon phase of the Philippines opening to China is over. By Jacob L. Shapiro China s commerce minister canceled a planned trip to the Philippines
More informationUnit 3 (under construction) Law of the Sea
Unit 3 (under construction) Law of the Sea Law of the Sea, branch of international law concerned with public order at sea. Much of this law is codified in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the
More informationhe Historical Context of Australia s Political and Legal Strategy in th...
Posted on March 8, 2014 In 1974, with the prospect of an Indonesian annexation of Timor on the horizon, Australia faced an important question: would Australia receive more favorable access to the gas and
More informationTHE EUROPEAN UNION S PRINCIPLED NEUTRALITY ON THE EAST CHINA SEA
SIPRI Policy Brief February 2015 THE EUROPEAN UNION S PRINCIPLED NEUTRALITY ON THE EAST CHINA SEA mathieu duchâtel and fleur huijskens INTRODUCTION 1 The European Union (EU) is widely perceived as a marginal
More informationThailand s Contribution to the Regional Security By Captain Chusak Chupaitoon
Thailand s Contribution to the Regional Security By Captain Chusak Chupaitoon Introduction The 9/11 incident and the bombing at Bali on 12 October 2002 shook the world community and sharpened it with the
More informationSome legal aspects of the drilling rig incident in the South China Sea in
China. 6 Vietnam asserted that the locations were within Vietnam s exclusive Some legal aspects of the drilling rig incident in the South China Sea in 2014 1 Pham Lan Dung 2 1. The positioning of the drilling
More informationasia responds to its rising powers
strategic asia 2011 12 asia responds to its rising powers China and India Edited by Ashley J. Tellis, Travis Tanner, and Jessica Keough Australia Grand Stakes: Australia s Future between China and India
More informationJapan s Position as a Maritime Nation
Prepared for the IIPS Symposium on Japan s Position as a Maritime Nation 16 17 October 2007 Tokyo Session 1 Tuesday, 16 October 2007 Maintaining Maritime Security and Building a Multilateral Cooperation
More informationPolitical Implications of Maritime Security in Asia and on ASEAN-EU Interregional Relations: Inhibiting and Enabling Factors
Political Implications of Maritime Security in Asia and on ASEAN-EU Interregional Relations: Inhibiting and Enabling Factors Changing Realities of Regional Security. Political and Economic Perspectives
More informationMARITIME BOUNDARY DISPUTES AMONG ASEAN MEMBER COUNTRIES: COULD ASEAN DO SOMETHING? Amrih Jinangkung
MARITIME BOUNDARY DISPUTES AMONG ASEAN MEMBER COUNTRIES: COULD ASEAN DO SOMETHING? Amrih Jinangkung Background Cambodia Thailand dispute is an example of how a longstanding unresolved boundary dispute
More informationCrowded Waters in Southeast Asia
Crowded Waters in Southeast Asia June 23, 2017 Jihadism in Marawi is actually a good thing for U.S. strategy in Asia. By Phillip Orchard Cooperation among Southeast Asian states has never come easy, but
More informationINTERNATIONAL TERRITORIAL DISPUTES AND CONFRONTATIONS IN THE SOUTH CHINA SEA FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE
INTERNATIONAL TERRITORIAL DISPUTES AND CONFRONTATIONS IN THE SOUTH CHINA SEA FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE Yurika ISHII (Dr.) National Defense Academy of Japan eureka@nda.ac.jp INTRODUCTION (1) Q: What is the
More informationInternational Conference on Maritime Challenges and Market Opportunities August 28, 2017
International Conference on Maritime Challenges and Market Opportunities August 28, 2017 John A. Burgess, Professor of Practice Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy A Tale of Two Seas The Arctic and the
More informationOverview East Asia in 2010
Overview East Asia in 2010 East Asia in 2010 1. Rising Tensions in the Korean Peninsula Two sets of military actions by the Democratic People s Republic of Korea (DPRK or North Korea) heightened North-South
More informationGeneral NC Vij Vivekananda International Foundation. Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1-3, 2015
Asia-Pacific Security Structure Defence Cooperation: Operation and Industry General NC Vij Vivekananda International Foundation Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1-3, 2015 India has been
More informationASEAN s Search for Neutrality in the South China Sea
Asian Journal of Peacebuilding Vol. 2 No. 1 (2014): 61-77 Research Article ASEAN s Search for Neutrality in the South China Sea Ralf Emmers This article seeks to make a contribution to the existing literature
More informationTHE SOUTH CHINA SEA DISPUTE: SIMULATING THE NEXT GLOBAL CONFLICT. A Case Study by. Yeju Choi Kennesaw State University
THE SOUTH CHINA SEA DISPUTE: SIMULATING THE NEXT GLOBAL CONFLICT A Case Study by Yeju Choi Kennesaw State University Case Study #1217-05 PKSOI TRENDS GLOBALCASE STUDY SERIES DISCLAIMER: The views expressed
More information17TH ASIA SECURITY SUMMIT THE IISS SHANGRI-LA DIALOGUE FIRST PLENARY SESSION US LEADERSHIP AND THE CHALLENGES OF INDO- PACIFIC SECURITY
17TH ASIA SECURITY SUMMIT THE IISS SHANGRI-LA DIALOGUE FIRST PLENARY SESSION US LEADERSHIP AND THE CHALLENGES OF INDO- PACIFIC SECURITY SATURDAY 2 JUNE 2018 JAMES MATTIS, SECRETARY OF DEFENSE, UNITED STATES
More informationOpening Remarks. Dewi Fortuna Anwar The Habibie Center. Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1 3, 2015
Opening Remarks Dewi Fortuna Anwar The Habibie Center Quad-Plus Dialogue Denpasar, Indonesia February 1 3, 2015 Distinguished Delegates, Ladies and Gentlemen, It is with great pleasure that I welcome you
More informationMaritime Security in Southeast Asia: Issues and Perspectives
Maritime Security in Southeast Asia: Issues and Perspectives Frances Lai In today s Southeast Asia we are witnessing the emergence of a post cold war order. The region is so diverse in history, culture,
More informationASEAN and the South China Sea Dispute
ASEAN and the South China Sea Dispute Baladas Ghoshal Distinguished Fellow, Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies Introduction The main thrust of this paper is to look at ASEAN s approach towards the
More informationBasic Maritime Zones. Scope. Maritime Zones. Internal Waters (UNCLOS Art. 8) Territorial Sea and Contiguous Zone
Basic Maritime Zones Dr Sam Bateman (University of Wollongong, Australia) Scope Territorial Sea and Contiguous Zone Territorial sea baselines Innocent passage Exclusive Economic Zones Rights and duties
More informationChina and Freedom of Navigation in South China Sea: The Context of International Tribunal s Verdict
China and Freedom of Navigation in South China Sea: The Context of International Tribunal s Verdict Author: Gurpreet S Khurana* Date: 19 July 2016 On 12 July 2016, the Tribunal constituted at the Permanent
More informationIS THIS THE TIME TO SEEK A REGIONAL INCIDENTS-AT-SEA AGREEMENT?
CSS STRATEGIC BACKGROUND PAPER 13/ 2013 THE SEARCH FOR MARITIME SECURITY IN THE ASIA PACIFIC: SOME IMPORTANT QUESTIONS INTRODUCTION Tensions have risen in recent months in both the South China Sea and
More informationCompetition and maritime disputes over fishing resources intensify in Asia Pacific
Competition and maritime disputes over fishing resources intensify in Asia Pacific [Content preview Subscribe to Jane s Intelligence Review for full article] Overfishing and illegal fishing are depleting
More informationThe South China Sea: Examining Security and Cooperation
The South China Sea: Examining Security and Cooperation Shirin Naseer Senior Research Analyst Contents Introduction... 2 The Xiangshan Forum... 4 Obstacles to Security: Differing Perspectives... 6 Building
More informationFROM STRATEGIC AMBIGUITY TO STRATEGIC PERSUASION IS CHINA COMING TO GRIPS WITH THE US NEW ROLE IN ASIA?
Analysis No. 191, July 2013 FROM STRATEGIC AMBIGUITY TO STRATEGIC PERSUASION IS CHINA COMING TO GRIPS WITH THE US NEW ROLE IN ASIA? Bernt Berger While the US is seeking a way of rebalancing China in East
More informationCHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST. Host: Paul Haenle Guest: Robert Ross
CHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST Host: Paul Haenle Guest: Robert Ross Episode 88: Are China s New Naval Capabilities a Game Changer? June 19, 2017 Haenle: Bob Ross, thank you very much for being with us today
More informationAssessing China s South China Sea Policy,
Assessing China s South China Sea Policy, 2009-2015 ZHANG Feng* This paper identifies three phases of China s South China Sea policy since 2009: reactive assertiveness from 2009 to 2011, forceful response
More informationTHE NEXT CHAPTER IN US-ASIAN RELATIONS: WHAT TO EXPECT FROM THE PACIFIC
THE NEXT CHAPTER IN US-ASIAN RELATIONS: WHAT TO EXPECT FROM THE PACIFIC Interview with Michael H. Fuchs Michael H. Fuchs is a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress and a senior policy advisor
More informationASEAN Cooperation in Maritime Security Focusing on the ASEAN Ministers Meeting in August 2017
ASEAN Cooperation in Maritime Security Focusing on the ASEAN Ministers Meeting in August 2017 Tomotaka Shoji Head, America, Europe, and Russia Division, Regional Studies Department The Association of Southeast
More informationPolicy Recommendation for South Korea s Middle Power Diplomacy: Maritime Security Policy
Policy Recommendation for South Korea s Middle Power Diplomacy: Maritime Security Policy Min Gyo Koo Seoul National University March 2015 EAI MPDI Policy Recommendation Working Paper Knowledge-Net for
More informationASEAN and Regional Security
BÜßT D m & h ü I P 1 Kl @ iy Kl D W 1 fi @ I TTP STRATEGIC FORUM INSTITUTE FOB NATIONAL STRATEGIC STUDIES Number 85, October 1996 Conclusions ASEAN and Regional Security by Patrick M. Cronin and Emily
More informationThe Quadrilateral Security Dialogue: An Alignment of Policies for Common Benefit Ambassador Anil Wadhwa Vivekananda International Foundation
The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue: An Alignment of Policies for Common Benefit Ambassador Anil Wadhwa Vivekananda International Foundation Quad-Plus Dialogue Tokyo, Japan March 4-6, 2018 The Quadrilateral
More informationThe Growth of the Chinese Military
The Growth of the Chinese Military An Interview with Dennis Wilder The Journal sat down with Dennis Wilder to hear his views on recent developments within the Chinese military including the modernization
More informationVietnam s First Maritime Boundary Agreement
74 Articles Section Vietnam s First Maritime Boundary Agreement Nguyen Hong Trao Introduction On 9 August 1997, in Bangkok, the Foreign Minister of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam (SRV), His Excellency
More informationCICP Policy Brief No. 8
CICP Policy Briefs are intended to provide a rather in depth analysis of domestic and regional issues relevant to Cambodia. The views of the authors are their own and do not represent the official position
More informationRegional Security: From TAC to ARF
Regional Security: From TAC to ARF Min Shu School of International Liberal Studies Waseda University 4 Dec 2017 IR of Southeast Asia 1 Outline of the lecture Sovereignty and regional security Territorial
More informationThe Law of the Sea Convention
The Law of the Sea Convention The Convention remains a key piece of unfinished treaty business for the United States. Past Administrations (Republican and Democratic), the U.S. military, and relevant industry
More informationAssessing Responses to the Arbitral Tribunal s Ruling on the South China Sea
RESEARCHERS AT ISEAS YUSOF ISHAK INSTITUTE ANALYSE CURRENT EVENTS Singapore 28 July 2016 Assessing Responses to the Arbitral Tribunal s Ruling on the South China Sea Ian Storey* EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Arbitral
More informationRemarks by Mr Sumio Kusaka, Ambassador of Japan Japan-U.S.-Australia relations and the Indo-Pacific Symposium Perth USAsia Centre
Remarks by Mr Sumio Kusaka, Ambassador of Japan Japan-U.S.-Australia relations and the Indo-Pacific Symposium Perth USAsia Centre Thursday 1 March 2018 Ladies and gentlemen, I am honoured to be here with
More informationChina-Southeast Asia Connectivity: Opportunities and Challenges for the Maritime Silk Road
China-Southeast Asia Connectivity: Opportunities and Challenges for the Maritime Silk Road Connectivity is a shared interest for China and Southeast Asia, and the Maritime Silk Road (MSR) represents part
More informationLine Between Cooperative Good Neighbor and Uncompromising Foreign Policy: China s Diplomacy Under the Xi Jinping Administration
Line Between Cooperative Good Neighbor and Uncompromising Foreign Policy: China s Diplomacy Under the Xi Jinping Administration Kawashima Shin, Ph.D. Associate Professor, Department of International Relations,
More informationTHE ROLE OF ASEAN LAW ASSOCIATION IN FOSTERING RELATIONSHIP & STRENGTHENING COOPERATION BETWEEN ASEAN COUNTRIES IN EXERCISING LEGAL ENFORCEMENT
THE ROLE OF ASEAN LAW ASSOCIATION IN FOSTERING RELATIONSHIP & STRENGTHENING COOPERATION BETWEEN ASEAN COUNTRIES IN EXERCISING LEGAL ENFORCEMENT By: Prof. O.C. Kaligis 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. FOREWORD...3
More informationJoint Statement of the 16th ASEAN-China Summit on Commemoration of the 10th Anniversary of the ASEAN-China Strategic Partnership
Joint Statement of the 16 th ASEAN-China Summit on Commemoration of the 10 th Anniversary of the ASEAN-China Strategic Partnership ----------------------------------- WE, the Heads of State/Government
More informationconnecting the dots: japan s strategy to ensure security and economic growth
connecting the dots: japan s strategy to ensure security and economic growth July 2015 ASIA PROGRAM During the final decade of the Cold War, China, Japan, and the United States formed a pseudo alliance
More informationThe Aspiration for Asia-Europe Connectivity. Fu Ying. At Singapore-China Business Forum. Singapore, 27 July 2015
Final The Aspiration for Asia-Europe Connectivity Fu Ying At Singapore-China Business Forum Singapore, 27 July 2015 It s my great pleasure to be invited to speak at the Singapore-China Business Forum.
More informationStrategic Developments in East Asia: the East Asian Summit. Jusuf Wanandi Vice Chair, Board of Trustees, CSIS Foundation
Strategic Developments in East Asia: the East Asian Summit Jusuf Wanandi Vice Chair, Board of Trustees, CSIS Foundation Economic development in East Asia started 40 years ago, when Japan s economy developed
More informationASEAN ANALYSIS: ASEAN-India relations a linchpin in rebalancing Asia
ASEAN ANALYSIS: ASEAN-India relations a linchpin in rebalancing Asia By Ernest Z. Bower and Prashanth Parameswaran www.aseanaffairs.com Can India Transition from Looking East to Acting East with ASEAN
More informationTESTIMONY OF ADMIRAL ROBERT PAPP COMMANDANT, U.S. COAST GUARD ON ACCESSION TO THE 1982 LAW OF THE SEA CONVENTION
Commandant United States Coast Guard 2100 Second Street, S.W. Washington, DC 20593-0001 Staff Symbol: CG-0921 Phone: (202) 372-3500 FAX: (202) 372-2311 TESTIMONY OF ADMIRAL ROBERT PAPP COMMANDANT, U.S.
More informationMore engagement with ASEAN is Australia's best hedge in Asia
More engagement with ASEAN is Australia's best hedge in Asia By Geoff Raby Australian Financial Review, 29 July 2018 Link: https://www.afr.com/news/politics/world/more-engagement-with-asean-isaustralias-best-hedge-in-asia-20180729-h139zg
More informationChinese Behaviour in the South China Sea: An Offensive and Defensive Realist Case Study
Chinese Behaviour in the South China Sea: An Offensive and Defensive Realist Case Study Name Student number Email Supervisor Fleur Slenter S2096765 f.s.j.slenter@umail.leidenuniv.nl Michiel Foulon Words
More informationThe 21st Century Maritime Silk Road and China-Malaysia Relations
The 21st Century Maritime Silk Road and China-Malaysia Relations by Mr Shahriman Lockman Senior Analyst, Institute of Strategic and International Studies (ISIS) Malaysia shahriman@isis.org.my Dialogue
More informationPLENARY SESSION TWO Monday, 30 May 2011
PS 2(b) PLENARY SESSION TWO Monday, 30 May 2011 China: Less Charm, More Offensive China is a Big Country, Other Countries are Small Countries : Analyzing the Facts of Power Asymmetry by Aileen S. P. BAVIERA
More informationBeijing Unveils New Strategy for ASEAN China Relations The Jamestown Foundation Prashanth Parameswaran
Beijing Unveils New Strategy for ASEAN China Relations The Jamestown Foundation Prashanth Parameswaran Earlier this month, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang embarked on highprofile trips
More informationI. Is Military Survey a kind of Marine Scientific Research?
On Dissection of Disputes Between China and the United States over Military Activities in Exclusive Economic Zone by the Law of the Sea Jin Yongming (Institute of Law, Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences,
More information