Participating Societies: SURVEY RESPONSES. Q1. Responder - Distribution. Representatives of 93 countries were invited to participate

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Participating Societies: SURVEY RESPONSES. Q1. Responder - Distribution. Representatives of 93 countries were invited to participate"

Cordelia York
6 years ago
Views:

Representatives of 9 countries were invited to participate CURRENT SITUATION OF TRAINING PROGRAMS IN AUDIOLOGY AND PHONIATRICS A GLOBAL ONLINE SURVEY STATISTICAL DATA Uniklinik, RWTH Aachen

Neighbours 101 Individuals, 90 Countries, Worldwide Christiane Neuschaefer-Rube, RWTH Aachen University 201 Participating Societies: ORL-UEMS UEP 72 Individuals, 20 Countries, Europe & Middle East

Responders in total (including 20 from ), representing 8 countries 61 received questionnaires (6 exclusions caused by failed transmission) 17 (2%) responders, 1 countries In addition, we received

1 Representatives of 9 countries were invited to participate CURRENT SITUATION OF TRAINING PROGRAMS IN AUDIOLOGY AND PHONIATRICS A GLOBAL ONLINE SURVEY STATISTICAL DATA Uniklinik, RWTH Aachen Christiane Neuschaefer-Rube, 201 Christiane Neuschaefer-Rube, Clinic of Phoniatrics, Pedaudiology & Communication Disorders, RWTH Aachen University 87 Individuals, Countries, European Union & their Neighbours 101 Individuals, 90 Countries, Worldwide Christiane Neuschaefer-Rube, RWTH Aachen University 201 Participating Societies: ORL-UEMS UEP 72 Individuals, 20 Countries, Europe & Middle East SURVEY RESPONSES 25 (25%) responders, 16 countries 19 (22%) responders, 17 countries Christiane Neuschaefer-Rube, RWTH Aachen University 201 Survey represents : Reference Date: 1th May, Responders in total (including 20 from ), representing 8 countries 61 received questionnaires (6 exclusions caused by failed transmission) 17 (2%) responders, 1 countries In addition, we received mail answers without questionnaire from other countries Q1. Responder - Distribution 1 North- and South-America: Brazil 5 29 Europe: Albania...Malta...U.K. Africa and Middle East: AUS (Namibia), Egypt, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, South Africa Asia: India, Japan, Vietnam Oceania: no response The colors of the map represent data of the most recent census by country, source of map: wikimedia commons 0 1

2 Q1. Responder - Distribution Albania Austria Belgium Croatia Cyprus Czech Republic ( RP) Denmark (2 RP) Estonia France Germany ( RP) Greece Hungary (2 RP) Ireland Italy 29 countries of Europe And Mails from Russia, Finland and Luxembourg Latvia Lithuania Malta Moldova (2 RP) Netherlands Norway Poland Portugal Slovakia Slovenia Spain (5 RP) Sweden ( RP) Switzerland ( RP) Turkey (2 RP) United Kingdom The colors of the map represent data of the most recent census by country, source of map: wikimedia commons Q2. THE RESPONDER ARE WORKING IN THE FOLLOWING (SUB-) SPECIALTIES Audiology Broncho-Esoph Facial Plastic... General Otolaryng Head & Neck Surg Laryngology Maxillofacial Surg Neurotology Otology Pedaudiologie Pediatric Otolaryn Phoniatrics Phonosurgery Vestibulology Vocology, N=20 UEMS, N=17 UEP, N=17 6 Q-1. Within the study of human medicine in your country... Q-2. Within the study of human medicine in your country... Responses: (N RP =55; N CY =8) ORL is... an obligatory subject 8 RP (87%) CY (89%) a selective subject 2 RP (%) 2 CY (5%) an elective subject 2 RP (%) 2 CY (5%) X no subject at all 0 RP 0 CY Responses: (N RP =55; N CY =8) (Ped)Audiology is... an obligatory subject 7 RP (1%) 7 CY (18%) a selective subject 6 RP (11%) 5 CY (1%) an elective subject 9 RP (16%) 7 CY (18%) no subject at all 25 RP (5%) 22 CY (58%) N RP = Number of Responder N CY = Number of Countries 2

3 Q-. Within the study of human medicine in your country... Phoniatrics is... Responses: (N RP =55; N CY =8) an obligatory subject 6 RP (11%) 6 CY (16%) a selective subject 6 RP (11%) 5 CY (1%) an elective subject 10 RP (18%) 8 CY (21%) no subject at all 29 RP (5%) 2 CY (6%) Q. (Ped)Audiology in your country is... (N RP =20) (N RP =5; N CY =7) 19 RP (5%) 17 CY (5%) 19 RP (5%) 12 CY (2%) 7 RP (1%) 6 CY (16%) RP (5%) CY (8%) 10 RP (18%) 10 CY (26%) Q5. Phoniatrics in your country is... X X (N RP=20) (N RP=55; N CY=8) 15 RP (27%) 1 CY (7%) 0 20 RP (6%) 1 CY (%) 0 9 RP (16%) 7 CY (18%) RP (7%) CY (11%) 8 RP (15%) 8 CY (21%) 2 RP (%) 2 CY (5%) 10 RP (18%) 7 CY (18%) Q7. Does audiology training in your country follow a defined program/curriculum documented by a logbook? Yes No There is no specialized audiology training in my country UEMS: Yes: 2 countries: Belgium, Brazil, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, France, Germany, Hungary, India, Ireland, Latvia, Moldova, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. No: 7 countries: Albania, AUS, Czech Republic, Italy, Japan, Spain, Turkey There is no training...: 11 countries: Austria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Greece, Lithuania, Malta, Nigeria, Spain, Sweden, Vietnam

Slovenia, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. No: 6 countries: Austria, India, Italy, Japan, Spain, Sweden Q8.

4 Q10. Does phoniatric training in your country follow a defined program/curriculum documented by a logbook? Yes No There is no specialized phoniatric training in my country UEMS: Yes: 16 countries: Albania, Croatia, Czech Republic, Egypt, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Norway, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. No: 6 countries: Austria, India, Italy, Japan, Spain, Sweden Q8. How many institutions participate in the (postgraduate) audiology training in your country? (N RP =18) (N RP=; N CY=) Albania, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Greece, Lithuania, Nigeria, Vietnam Brazil, Croatia, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Moldova, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Hungary, Netherlands, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey France, Italy, Norway, Turkey Germany, India AUS, Japan, Spain There is no training... : 10 countries: Brazil, Cyprus, Estonia, Greece, Latvia, Lithuania, Moldova, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Vietnam Q11. How many institutions participate in the (postgraduate) phoniatric training in your country? (N=15) (N RP=; N CY=1) Q12. What official state approved body or ministry regulates the postgraduate training in audiology and/or phoniatrics in your country? Brazil, Cyprus, Greece, Lithuania, Moldova, Netherlands, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Vietnam UEMS-Responses (N RP=18) Albania, Austria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, India, Latvia, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, 20 RP (6%) 1 CY (7%) France, Hungary, Italy, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland Germany Egypt, Norway, U.K. 5 RP (9%) 5 CY (1%) 10 RP (18%) 8 CY (21%) 9 RP (16%) 9 CY (2%) 1 RP (2%) 1 CY (%) Japan 6 RP (11%) 5 CY (1%) (N RP=51; N CY=7)

5 Q1. The postgraduate training structure in your country is organized... -Responses UEMS-Responses (N RP=16) (N RP=51; N CY=6) (N RP=5; N CY=8) RP (62%) 2 CY (6%) X Croatia, Germany (Phoniatrics), Poland, Vietnam 9 RP (16%) 7 CY (18%) 5 RP (9%) 5 CY (1%) RP (5%) CY (8%) Austria, Japan Ireland, Malta Brazil, Egypt, Estonia, India, Lithuania Albania, Hungary, Latvia, Moldova, Spain, Turkey Belgium, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany (ORL), Greece, Hungary, Italy, Netherlands, Nigeria, Norway, Portugal, Saudi Arabia, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland AUS, U.K. Q15. How many additional years following training in ORL are required for subspecialty approval? Audiology (Answered: 1, Skipped: 2) <1 year: Czech Republic, Denmark, Ireland, Sweden, Switzerland 2 years: Croatia, Hungary, Moldova, Spain, Sweden years: Poland Pedaudiology (Answered: 11, Skipped: ) <1 year: Czech Republic, Ireland, Sweden, Switzerland 2 years: Croatia, Hungary, Moldova years: Germany Otology/Neurootology (Answered: 5, Skipped: 50) <1 year: Switzerland 2 years: Brazil, Croatia, Hungary, Ireland Vestibulology (Answered: 7, Skipped: 8) <1 year: Brazil, Ireland, Sweden, Switzerland 2 years: Croatia, Hungary, Sweden Q16. How many additional years following training in ORL are required for subspecialty approval? Phoniatrics (Answered: 19, Skipped: 6) <1 year: Hungary, Ireland 2 years: Austria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Sweden, Switzerland years: Czech Republic, Germany, Poland, Slovakia, Sweden years: Hungary 5 years: Czech Republic, Switzerland Laryngology (Answered:, Skipped: 52) <1 year: Ireland, Switzerland years: Hungary Phonosurgery (Answered: 5, Skipped: 50) Vocology (Answered: 2, Skipped: 5) <1 year: Ireland years: Hungary <1 year: Ireland, Sweden, Switzerland 2 years: Croatia years: Hungary 5

6 Q17. What are the legal requirements to be allowed to work as an approved ORL specialist in your country (multiple answers allowed)? Q18. What are the legal requirements to be allowed to work as an approved audiologist in your country (multiple answers allowed)? (N=20) (N=16) 25 RP (5%) 18 CY (7%) 7 RP (1%) 5 CY (1%) RP (62%) 25 CY (66%) 16 RP (29%) 12 CY (2%) 5 RP (9%) 5 CY (1%) 29 RP (5%) 2 CY (6%) 15 RP (27%) 12 CY (2%) 0 RP 0 CY 1 RP (2%) 12 CY (2%) (N RP =52) (N CY =6) 9 RP (16%) 7 CY (18%) (N RP =2) (N CY =1) Q19. What are the legal requirements to be allowed to work as an approved phoniatrician in your country (multiple answers allowed)? (N=16) 15 RP (27%) 10 CY (26%) 6 RP (11%) CY (11%) YES: 20 RP (6%) 17 CY (5%) NO: 28 RP (51%) 20 CY (5%) (N RP =8) (N CY =) 20 RP (6%) 12 CY (2%) 9 RP (16%) 9 CY (2%) 1 RP (2%) 11 CY (29%) YES: 18 RP (%) 1 CY (%) NO: 0 RP (55%) 2 CY (6%) (N RP =2) (N CY =28) (N RP =8) (N CY =) 6

7 Q2-1. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the treatment of organic voice disorders? : (N RP=51) (N CY=5) 18 General Otolaryngology: Albania, AUS, Brazil, Czech Republic, Denmark, Germany, India, Latvia, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Nigeria, Norway, Poland, South Africa, Spain, Turkey, Vietnam 11 Laryngology: Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Japan, Lithuania, Portugal, Sweden 6 Phoniatrics: Croatia, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland Phonosurgery: Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovenia, Spain Logopedics/SLP: Ireland, Sweden, U.K. Q2-2. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the treatment of non-organic voice disorders? : (N RP=51) (N CY=5) 15 Logopedics/SLP: AUS, Brazil, Denmark, Estonia, India, Ireland, Malta, Netherlands, Nigeria, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. 1 Phoniatrics: Croatia, Czech Republic, Egypt, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Moldova, Poland, Saudi Arabia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland Laryngology: Belgium, Japan, Lithuania, Portugal General Otolaryngology: Norway, Spain, Turkey 1 Linguistics: Vietnam ; Neurology: Albania Q2-. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the treatment of occupational voice disorders? : (N RP=51) (N CY=5) 1 Phoniatrics: Croatia, Czech Republic, Egypt, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Moldova, Poland, Saudi Arabia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland 1 Logopedics/SLP: AUS, Belgium, Brazil, Denmark, Estonia, Ireland, Malta, Netherlands, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, U.K. 8 General Otolaryngology: Albania, India, Lithuania, Nigeria, Norway, Spain, Turkey, Vietnam 2 Laryngology: Japan, Portugal Q25-. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the medical treatment of dysphagia? : (N 12 RP=9) (N CY=) Logopedics/SLP: AUS, Brazil, Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Malta, Netherlands, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Switzerland, U.K. 10 Phoniatrics: Egypt, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Poland, Saudi Arabia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland 9 General Otolarynologist: Albania, Czech Republic, Denmark, India, Moldova, Nigeria, Norway, Spain, Turkey Neurology: Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania Broncho-Esophagology: Japan, Sweden; General Medicine: Vietnam; Head & Neck Surgery: Moldova; Laryngology: Belgium; Linguistics: Ireland; Pediatric Otolaryngology: Switzerland 7

8 Q26-. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the medical treatment of inner ear disease? : (N RP=52) (N CY=6) 21 Audiology: AUS, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Estonia, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Poland, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, U.K. 1 General Otolarynologist: AUS, Czech Republic, Germany, Greece, India, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Netherlands, Nigeria, Norway, Spain, Turkey 12 Otology: Albania, Belgium, Brazil, Croatia, Egypt, France, Hungary, Italy, Japan, Saudi Arabia, Spain, Slovakia Neurotology: Portugal, Slovenia, U.K., Vietnam Pedaudiology: Germany; Phoniatrics: Hungary Q26-. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the medical treatment of middle ear disease? : (N RP=52) (N CY=6) 19 General Otolaryngologist: AUS, Czech Republic, Germany, Hungary, India, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Nigeria, Norway, Poland, South Africa, Spain, Turkey, Vietnam 1 Otology: Albania, Belgium, Brazil, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Estonia, France, Hungary, Japan, Saudi Arabia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K. 1 Audiology: Switzerland; Neurotology: Portugal Q26-5. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in hearing aid fitting? : (N RP=50) (N CY=6) 2 Audiology: AUS, Belgium, Croatia, Denmark, Egypt, Estonia, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Saudi Arabia, Slovenia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, U.K. 9 General Otolaryngologist: Albania, Germany, Greece, India, Lithuania, Nigeria, Norway, Turkey, Vietnam Otology: France, Spain; Phoniatrics: Czech Republic, Slovakia; Pedaudiology: Germany; Logopedics/SLP: Brazil Q26-1. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the medical treatment of CAPD? : (N RP=50) (N CY=5) 2 Audiology: AUS, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Estonia, France, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Poland, Saudi Arabia, Slovenia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, U.K. General Otolarynologist: Greece, Nigeria, Norway, Vietnam; Neurotology: Latvia, Lithuania, Portugal, Otolaryngic Pathology Neurology: India, Moldova, Spain; Otology: Belgium, Brazil, Slovakia Pedaudiology: Germany, Hungary, Switzerland Phoniatrics: Czech Republic, Spain 8

9 Q26-2. Which (sub-)specialty is most often involved in the medical treatment of Auditory Synaptopathy/ Neuropathy? : (N RP=51) (N CY=5) 21 Audiology: AUS, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Egypt, Estonia, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Malta, Moldova, Netherlands, Poland, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, U.K. 6 General Otolarynologist: Czech Republic, Germany, Greece, Lithuania, Nigeria, Norway Neurotology: France, India, Portugal, Spain, Slovenia, Vietnam Otology: Belgium, Brazil, Slovakia, Sweden Pedaudiology: Germany, Latvia; Phoniatrics: Czech Republic, Spain; Pediatric Otolaryngology: Hungary Q29. What would you prefer as the most appropriate denomination of audiology, phoniatrics etc. considering their expert knowledge? (N RP =19 subspecialty superspecialty hyperspecialty (N RP =55; N CY =8) RP 27 CY 15 RP 12 CY RP CY As time has gone Thank you, for your attention Acknowledgements: We thank all participants of, UEMS and UEP and especially their board members who supported the distribution of our request 9

European patent filings

Annual Report 07 - European patent filings European patent filings Total filings This graph shows the geographic origin of the European patent filings. This is determined by the country of residence of